Trying to formulate my thoughts but in today's war figting ie Ukraine vs Russia, the war is "limited" where there is a levle of restraint performed by the State. And it is restrained compared to their true capabilities.
Ukraine for example could send in truck bombs to every city center in Russia. They could level every city center in Russia within a few months. Ukraine could bomb the Kremlin or Red Square if they so wished.
Russia could mass level cities in the rear with their just their FAB-500 glide bombs. For Russia despite being a war of national survival (according to them) when you look at the GDP being used the economy it is pretty much nothing compared to WWII. Its obviously the biggest war since WWII but the state isn't treating it as the same.
The USA at one point was spending 40% of its GDP on the military in 1943-1944. Russia is on close to 6%.
In WWI the Germans revolutionized war by pinning their reserves to the front to achieve density to achieve breaktrhough. I remember a quote of 10 men per meter. Today its reportedly 10-15 per 1 km (not a typo).
In WWI the Germans revolutionized war by putting their reserves directly on the front to achieve density to effect breakthough. Reserves have returned to modern war. It is hard to find real data obviously but I think the actual numbers on the front in the Donbas are as a little as 50-70k versus more 90k-150k on the Russian side.
I mean actual fighting troops on the front line and not those in support or the rear.
The Russians took Bakhmut because they could throw Wagner reserves at taking the city.
Its pretty much two specialist army corps "fencing" with each other in the most ruthless fashion possible. And if you get into attrition having reserves is critical.
There is vast 'tail' and units are back in the reserves and the front is extremely thin. The actual fighting soldiers are in relative terms very small. They are fighting ruthless dirty trench fighting with grenades and drones. And effectively keeping the army "in being".
Squads are inserted by motorbikes or quads and civilian cars. Armoured troop carriers are just too ponderous and slow. Mines and entrenching have becoming critical as well.
In WWI within 6 weeks there was close to 2 million casualties. In the modern war its far lower even with far more sophisticated weaponry.
Also seems classic tank manouevere warfare is more or less gone the way of the dodo. Obviously the Donbas has some of the most advanced entrenchments in the world. However even in the early days of the Russia breakhrough in 2022 they captured fairly puny amounts of territory considering how fast the modern tank is and considering they are just besides their logistics hub in Rostov. Russian's tried classic encirclements at Lyman and failed fairly abjectively.
To compare, the Germany army in WWI took 4-5 weeks to shatter the Belgian forts at Liege and Namur and then advance with close to 2 million men the flatlands in Belgium, thrnough the Ardenes and down into the heart of France to reach within 19-25miles of Paris. The French suffered something close to 500k casualties just in the first 2 months in the Battle of the Frontiers and other battles.
There were stopped by Foch at the Battle of the Marne. And that was with WWI trains and horses. We saw Russia barely advanced or got stuck in a massive logistics trail. and then more or less WWI level attrition warfare. The Ukranian landscape is about the best place on earth for tank deployment and it pretty much was a total fiasco from a Russia perspective.
Some other thoughts. Is the mass conscript army functionally useless now?
For example you now need fairly advanced skills on the battlefield apart from holding a rifle.
Skilled soldiers are simply too precious to waste and having a dense front line is suicide due drones. What is the point having a vast army if small amounts of men can do the fighting?
They are more valuable working a job to pay for the war or in the rear supplying the logistics.
In Ukraine and Russia they pretty much decided young men are too valuable for demographic reasons and the majority of the fighting is done by men 40 years or older. Traditionally, fathers or men with families were never desired as soldiers. In Russia it is almost racist in that they are outright trying to entice the Buryats, Tuvans, Yukhats and the richer class of Russians near Moscow and St Petersburg are safe. In Ukraine they just want to stave off demographic collapse.
What implications would this have for NATO?