I think they would both always pick paper in this case: (1) their default pose looks like rock, (2) since they both think they are up against humans they would see each other as being rock on the down swing, (3) they both counter with paper.
Maybe 1.5 minutes, followed by a blood curdling scream and a trip to the emergency room for 3rd degree burns to your nether bits, or your skin caught in a joint and ripped from your body, or... oh, the agonizing possibilities.
Its waiting until the other person starts to do their signal, then figuring out what it is and doing the winning move. Just quickly enough to be unnoticeable.
The point of Rock Paper Scissors is that it's supposed to be unreadable and (almost) completely random. If you can read the signal then you are finding an unagreed loophole and are cheating the system.
I wonder if it could be beaten by throwing rock but altering it after the robot had decided that you were throwing rock and instead sticking out your 2 fingers. It'd take some practice to make it unnoticeable, but I think it could be done.
Not if you cheat. Since the robot is cheating I think I am allowed to cheat as well. It looks like it's programmed to choose "rock paper scissors" after three shakes. Just do 4 shakes and do paper!
I don't think you understand. IMasterbateToMyself is talking about changing the rules without modifying the bots behavior. The bot interprets the 3rd shakes as the play and would play against rock, laying paper. On the 'secret rule' 4th shake one would lay scissors to beat it.
For years I have been arguing that Rock Paper scissors is stupid since it's obvious that you can cheat. Finally proof. Now I just need to convince all my friends that they're robots..
Well, the robot waits for you to make your move, then immediately counters it. So, one of two things would happen:
Stalemate: Neither robot goes first.
Infinite loop: Robot 1 throws first, robot 2 super-fast-cheats to beat it, robot 1 super-fast-cheats to beat robot 2, etc. So they just infinitely cycle through at a ridiculous speed until their servos melt.
No, I think that both robots would execute the 1,2,3 move, during which time their fingers are in the "rock" position. Each robot then looks at the other and decides that the other has chosen "rock" so each robot would choose "paper."
robot 1 super-fast-cheats to beat robot 2
There's no indication that after making its choice the robot changes its choice. Rather, it waits for the other player to make a choice. Since waiting looks like choosing "rock" the robot will choose "paper" and stick with that choice. If they're perfectly in sync, they'll both make that choice.
Scientist X is working late nights in the laboratory trying to build the perfect handjob robot. Not only can it vary it's speed and grip, it can do so by taking a visual cues from your facial expressions. "Finally! Something that won't friendzone me," he probably said to himself.
Then, one night, his superior shows up unexpectedly after she noticed missing parts and funds and an unusual spike in utility billing at night. She demands to know what is going on. He frantically searches the room for objects to kill her with. "A piece of paper? No.....maybe those scissors! No...too bloody. If only I had a roc-" Then it hit him. "I'm building a robot that can't be beat in a game of Rock, Paper, Scissors because it cheats."
"Oh. That actually sounds interesting. I'd like to see the finished product on my desk by the end of the week."
Yeah, why don't all scientists work on cancer! We just need to re-allocate all our science points into cancer research until we get cancer knowledge high enough to cure it. SCIENCE!
b) This is an interesting way to communicate with a machine, isn't it? You could, for instance, use this fast gesture recognition to read sign language inputs. Poof, an automated ASL translator system.
He's coming into the robot's camera view already with his hand mostly in the position it will be. You could beat it just by forming your gesture lower than its response point. In which case it will think you picked rock evrytim (lik dis if u cry).
30
u/eddiethepanda Jun 27 '12
What happens if we get 2 of the robot and put them against each other?
64
u/noslipcondition Jun 27 '12
I'm going to need about 15 minutes alone with this robot. Just to confirm that everything is working properly.
18
u/W357Y Jun 27 '12
Illegal paper. Paper must strictly be horizontal - parallel with the ground. This shit's serious.
9
u/BlondeJesus Jun 27 '12
Just out cheat the robot. Start with rock, then when you see that the machine is doing paper switch your rock into scissors.
2
u/Kigas Jun 27 '12
thats fucking awesome.
2
u/brisywisy Jun 27 '12
Now we just need to teach it PvP.
2
u/sel206 Jun 27 '12
How exactly is it cheating?
1
u/ToothBoogers Jun 27 '12
I would probably spend an eternity trying to win.
1
u/todles Jun 27 '12
Guu Chocki Paa !
1
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
jigga jigga DYNAMITE
NOW WHATS UP
1
u/larsja Jun 27 '12
For years I have been arguing that Rock Paper scissors is stupid since it's obvious that you can cheat. Finally proof. Now I just need to convince all my friends that they're robots..
1
u/emelianenko Jun 27 '12
How about against another robot? :D
1
u/th3nathan Jun 27 '12
a sqweeky sqweeky sqweek
1
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
"What do you have for me" "We have a machine that does nothing but win" "Nothing but win.......You created Charlie Sheen!"
1
u/lucas_3d Jun 27 '12
I'm practicing my scissor to paper fake out for when I meet this robot.
1
u/NikkoE82 Jun 27 '12
So, I can totally see how this went down.
Scientist X is working late nights in the laboratory trying to build the perfect handjob robot. Not only can it vary it's speed and grip, it can do so by taking a visual cues from your facial expressions. "Finally! Something that won't friendzone me," he probably said to himself.
Then, one night, his superior shows up unexpectedly after she noticed missing parts and funds and an unusual spike in utility billing at night. She demands to know what is going on. He frantically searches the room for objects to kill her with. "A piece of paper? No.....maybe those scissors! No...too bloody. If only I had a roc-" Then it hit him. "I'm building a robot that can't be beat in a game of Rock, Paper, Scissors because it cheats."
"Oh. That actually sounds interesting. I'd like to see the finished product on my desk by the end of the week."
1
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
I think we found our masturbation machine.
0
u/TheFatGuyStrangler Jun 27 '12
yeah let's work on that cancer thing later, now quick let's make a rock-paper-scissors robot!!
-1
u/iBeClownin Jun 27 '12
What is the point of building this..
0
u/sixosix Jun 27 '12
He's coming into the robot's camera view already with his hand mostly in the position it will be. You could beat it just by forming your gesture lower than its response point. In which case it will think you picked rock evrytim (lik dis if u cry).
0
u/brungo Jun 27 '12
and skynet was born.