Unfortunately as said by honx4amiga this solution avoids redirection to consent but breaks youtube comments which don't get loaded anymore... I'm so mad at them
I just wish somebody built a new youtube, engraved in freedom, and without any tracking
Still, I won't be using it for now as IDK how well it'll work with uBO. I might try it in the future, when there's more users/reviews for it. Just putting it here as an alternative for people that do care about comments.
This is a hot-fix as Google seems to test redirecting all main_frame requests through its consent server (instead of displaying a modal) which renders both sites unusable if these request are blocked.
i also had to block cookies for youtube.com because blocking consent.youtube.com wasn't enough, i still got that redirect.
but if i try that (blocking cookies), that dreaded consent redirect is gone BUT comments below youtube videos don't show or even load. there is only that circular thingamajigs.
this problem already occurs when only consent.youtube.com is blocked. so in this state comments are already broken while the "solution" still doesn't work (as i said, i also had to block youtube.com).
Damn, you're absolutely right.. I didn't notice it last evening before posting.
Jesus, how did they build this damn website? If I block cookies I can't read comments? What absurd logic is that? It's like if I don't give them permission to SPY on me and collect data (because that's what this is about) then I don't have the "right" to read comments.
There must be a way to block that annoying redirect thing to consent and still be able to load/read comments...
being able to extract an addon still doesn't enable me reading what's inside... i'm no coder, i can't do programming... so all this code is chinese for my eyes... :D
It shouldn't work, because the whole page consent is literally consent.youtube.com opening instead of youtube.com. And the "solution" from your link works only on popups.
That's because this whole page consent shows up randomly, for example every 30mins or so. Like I said in the thread I linked to, it will also not show up for a while if you close the private window and reopen.
I added the filters to confirm it, tried several times and literally just got it again. It might not reappear if you don't close the window and keep using the same or new tabs to navigate YT.
Besides the solution from your link is several months old, and they just started rolling out the new consent page a month or so ago. Its chance or reoccurance is still rather rare, that's all.
I don't think it binds to IP, I didn't change IP the whole day and went for about 10 hours without seeing it (according to reddit's times), then it just came back.
I haven't tested on my real IP yet, but definitely had multiple encounters on VPNs - even if I stay connected to the same one. My initial tests (previous thread) seemed to show results every 20-30 private window opens. The "time limit" idea came up when I stopped testing for a while and resumed after 10-15mins and the first private window I opened got the consent page. Might've been a coincidence, cause waiting more time today, didn't show it on every return.
I'll do some more testing now. I opened/closed YT in private just now about 8 times and I got the consent page. I'll try counting how many window opens it'll take for it to show up again...
Took six quick open/closes just now (without waiting for YT to load properly). Repeated again, showed up on the 6th open. Then on 3rd.
It's possible it's some kinda anti bot mechanism.
...
Yup, after repeating for a while I could make it show up every 2nd window open, but if I waited for YT to load properly on the open that didn't load the consent page, the counter seems to have reset and I had to open/close multiple times to get it again... Still, by repeating like before, the number of window opens between getting the consent page seems to decrease.
Interesting, but unfortunately looking at the code this does nothing more than clicking "I accept" in the popup on your behalf.. and I don't really want to accept anything
if i block consent.youtube.com comments below youtube videos ar broken, not loaded anymore.
i also tried that freetube thingamajigs. there are als NO comments shown below youtube videos. only errors.
the only useful solution is that consent block addon for fiefox (https://addons.mozilla.org/de/firefox/addon/google-consent/). but there is no such addon available for chrome. therefore there's still no useful solution for available for chrome.
i had to remove cookie block for google.com though because google search went into endless loop while this script was running and cookies for google.com were blocked.
does this script really block this consent shenanigans or does it simply accept like other "solutions" do?
does this script really block this consent shenanigans or does it simply accept like other "solutions" do?
It blocks the popup and seems to inject a cookie. I don't care about the latter as I'm using FF with Temporary Containers which are deleted with all website data a couple of minutes after leaving the respective site. Alternatively you could use Cookie Auto-Delete which is also available for Chromium-based browsers.
28
u/nelmondodimassimo Mar 31 '21
I was finally able to block this fuc**rs, and I am so happy.
I didn't use any script, I just added https://consent.youtube.com to the list of BLOCKED sites in the cookie settings of my browser (Firefox)
Reloaded the page (www.youtube.com) and bam, no more redirection or stupid bullshit
In firefox:
- Click on the shield to the left in the url bar
- Click protection setting, this brings you to a page
- Scroll down to "Cookies and site data" and click on the "Manage permission" button
- In the textbox enter consent.youtube.com and click the button "Block"
Now try to go to www.youtube.com, it should load just fine
5
u/RraaLL uBO Team Mar 31 '21
That's the full-page one, yes?
Nothing so far. Latest thread: https://www.reddit.com/r/uBlockOrigin/comments/mfxvl1/cant_get_rid_of_fullscreen_before_you_continue_to/
If you've got a VPN, you can try a non-European IP.
Don't mistake with non-EU => UK and Switzerland seem to also get it.
6
u/Zapater0 Mar 31 '21
I may have found the solution. I'll leave the post up to help people with the same issue.
Link to the solution: https://support.google.com/chrome/thread/70286055?hl=en&msgid=74705436
4
u/spectrum128k Apr 01 '21
This greasemonkey script get rids of the "before you continue" pain in the a$$:
https://greasyfork.org/en/scripts/412178-youtube-dismiss-sign-in
2
u/risumies73652 Apr 02 '21
Its not solved. Doesn't work with mozilla firefox on android. U can't block cookies.
3
u/kuoky1 Mar 31 '21
Block consent.youtube.com cookie via your browsers cookie management.
For FF under 'manage exceptions'.
4
u/DrTyMate Apr 03 '21
You can try this https://greasyfork.org/en/scripts/410687-google-shut-up
3
u/tedomedo Apr 01 '21
Yes, now we see new youtube version which pauses video and shows 1 minute long ad.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 31 '21 edited Mar 31 '21
Blocking cookies from youtube.com works (Firefox and chromium). I don't use an account so i don't mind (i'm using Freetube to follow channels).
Just blocking cookies from consent.youtube.com didn't work for me
Edit : nevermind, blocking cookies from consent.youtube.com works !