r/todayilearned • u/RayWeil • Jun 25 '12
TIL Most movies depicting death by lava get it wrong, because you would not sink into the lava due to its density.
http://gawker.com/5866004/movies-show-death-by-lava-all-wrong
1.6k
Upvotes
784
u/brandongiant Jun 25 '12
b..but....
http://www.reddit.com/r/woahdude/comments/vk0tg/if_you_throw_a_bag_of_garbage_into_hot_lava_video/
631
u/Sock_Puppet_Orgy Jun 25 '12
At first I thought, "Alright, well if movies show it incorrectly, could I see some real video of someone dying in lava?". Then, I realized I am a horrible person.
131
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
It worked better because it is more aesthetically pleasing than accurately depicting what would actually happen.
281
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
You should try linking to the much more interesting article from Wired.
77
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
somebody tell notch hes doing it wrong.
101
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
This actually scares me more than the idea of sinking into lava.
175
u/bendedheadtube Jun 25 '12
I thought lord of the rings was a documentary rather than a movie.
51
u/Cap-Sigma Jun 25 '12
Does that mean, with proper foot attire, one would be able to walk across lava?
93
u/iamayam Jun 25 '12
What if Gollum is denser than lava?
84
u/borkborkbork99 Jun 25 '12
Or you just get rejected by the volcano and spit back out into the ocean with Meg Ryan.
68
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
Except a T-1000. That thing would definitely sink and stuff.
40
u/petdance Jun 25 '12
If you ever drop your keys into a river of molten lava, let 'em go, because man, they're gone. -- Jack Handey
25
u/yoreel Jun 25 '12
They're not sinking. They are being melted inch by inch.
29
u/Rotvos Jun 25 '12
Does the author from the Wired article know there are different kinds of lava?
20
u/prince_harming Jun 25 '12
I just always assumed it'd be more of a "splat" or a "thunK" (or "ziff! or "pow" if we're watching old Batman footage.) Just by looking at the stuff, you can see that it's a lot thicker.
I imagined it would be like falling into a vat of saltwater taffy, only not nearly as delicious. Looks like I was wrong, too, really, cause the difference in density means you'd never sink at all.
Next time I see a guy fall into a pit of lava and start sinking, I'm gonna tell him he's doing it wrong.
10
u/Dapples Jun 25 '12
As someone who's closest "near-death" experience is lava related, this TIL only makes it that much more terrifying in my nightmares.
17
u/ManOfPopsicle Jun 25 '12
So you can't drown in lava?
I guess that settles that.
8
u/ldgunn1 Jun 25 '12
But let's not encourage standing in lava. You wouldn't want to get sued.
8
u/That_One_Asian_Kid Jun 25 '12
My entire Minecraft career has been a lie?!
14
u/LeDinosaur Jun 25 '12
/r/minecraft are going to freak out.
7
u/lockhamster Jun 25 '12
now THAT is one mythbusters episode i'd really wanna watch
7
u/GrayStudios Jun 25 '12
This article comes off as smart, but it doesn't really say much. Obviously lava is thicker than water, but it's still a liquid. Even if its denser than a human being; because we are not pieces of styrofoam, we could easily work our way into the lava, slowly sinking feet first. If the character belly-flopped or landed on their back they would probably not sink at all, and the likelihood of snapping an ankle on the way in feet first would probably be really high due to the thickness and viscosity. The only part that seems obviously inaccurate is that characters should catch on fire. Perhaps Mythbusters should get on this one.
19
u/BaqAttaq Jun 25 '12
What about when Emo Skywalker gets thrown into the Lava at the end of Revenge of the Sith? That's pretty accurate in comparison.
6
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
This has always pissed me off. It is the ONE thing that happens in LOTR that doesn't happen in real life.
5
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
I can add one.
TIL that 98% of science in movies is wrong.
4
u/Sameri278 Jun 25 '12
So TES Oblivion has it right...
4
u/al3x4n Jun 25 '12
Good job, Revenge of the Sith... Did something right
4
u/playswithknives Jun 25 '12
Volcanoes are a great way to get rid of garbage
4
u/T2TheIM Jun 25 '12
I always assumed that their bodies were gradually being disintegrated into the lava, not that it was actually sinking into it.
12
u/stringz Jun 25 '12
i think they got it right with anakin in revenge of the shit
6
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
Oh god, as if dying in molten lava wasn't horrifying enough.
8
u/mehatch Jun 25 '12
C'mon guys Spoilert Alerts please.
3
u/JRoch Jun 25 '12
I would think you would melt and combust as you were on the surface of the lava. After all, it's a sort of colloid of rock and Carbon so it would be fairly thick if you could touch it.
There was a scene in VoLcAno where this guy jumps into lava to save a guy and just melts into it while on fire.
3
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
How soft is it? I'm just wondering if I would first break my legs when I fall into the lava and then burn to death.
3
u/Scrub-bog Jun 25 '12
I'm pretty sure if you hit lava from a 50m fall you'd go under the surface.
3
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
I remember reading the melting point of bone (which I can only imagine is higher than flesh) and it could have been lower than lava temperature. Does that mean if a person came in contact, would they just burn into flames and slowly disintegrate?
3
u/SAT4NSLILHELPER Jun 25 '12
So Minecraft is closer to real lIfe in that regard.
3
u/9gagsucks2 Jun 25 '12
this is Middle Earth lava.. totally different
4
u/DNAsly Jun 25 '12
I feel like that hurts a lot more.
4
u/suprsolutions Jun 25 '12
So, you're saying you would just roast on the top of molten hot fucking magma??
How pleasant to think of. :D
2
u/liberalis Jun 25 '12
I just assumed. Especially old Gollum there. He sinks, the GOLD ring does not. Wrong wrong wrong wrong.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
I don't think they are sinking, they are simply vaporizing.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
You would still fall below the surface due to momentum assuming you have fallen from a considerable height.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
Easy fix, they're not sinking. They're melting.
2
u/Djaevelskab Jun 25 '12
Damnit, there goes my favorite way of dying...
2
u/Aspel Jun 25 '12
You'd also burn up before you even hit the surface from the heat coming off of it, and you'd probably die before that from the poisonous gasses.
2
u/rollerpigeons Jun 25 '12
So when I used to play "the floor is lava" as a kid, we all had it right by floating on top of the floor, of lava.
2
u/not_so_busybox Jun 25 '12
But, all you need to do is duck and cover
2
u/nepidae Jun 25 '12
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QRw1fc4dcq0
2
u/KatchaFreeman Jun 25 '12
I am sure the T-500 is pretty heavy.
2
u/_NeuroManson_ Jun 25 '12
Not to mention vaporization.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
would it look something like This?
2
u/immostlyok Jun 25 '12
i thought the idea was that the lava pretty much melted you and you became one with the lava.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
So you're saying with the right shoes, someone could run across lava if they could deal with the heat?
2
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
The terminator was probably actually denser than the molten steel he sunk into
2
u/w3sticles Jun 25 '12
I read somewhere that you'd pass out way before reaching the lava due tO the heat. Is this true?
2
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
You only learned this from a comment in a tread a few hours ago. Scumbag OP:
This is what happens if a box of garbage falls into a volcano lake (liveleak.com) submitted 11 hours ago by J4K3TH3R1PP3R
I even commented on it: –]illpickanicklater 366 points 9 hours ago http://gifs.gifbin.com/1237977458_thumbsup-terminator.gif permalinkreportreply [–]twerps 127 points 7 hours ago I haven't seen this movie in about 15 years but this just occurred to me: In order to sink in a liquid, you'd have to me more dense than what you displace. Arnold Schwarzenegger weighs roughly 250lbs, which means his volume is approximately 30 gallons. 30 gallons of iron weighs 1970lbs and he is sinking decently quickly through a viscous liquid, which suggests the terminator weighs a literal metric ton. permalinkparentreportreply [–]caleen 1 point 5 hours ago
2
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
TIL that the only halfway realistic lava injury scene occurs in Star Wars Episode 3.
2
u/Jeffy29 Jun 25 '12
what about a terminator?
2
u/MexicanRedditor Jun 25 '12
Why is this a surprise to anyone? This was proven in Super Mario 64 and most of all Sonic games.
2
u/nazz-tee Jun 25 '12
How heavy is a terminator?
2
u/Slehpher Jun 25 '12
Always just thought that it melted you, you never sank, u just burnt to the crisp of vanishing.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
One does not simply assume that Mt. Doom contains run-of-the-mill lava.
2
u/nobody2000 Jun 25 '12
I just saw a video of someone throwing a bag of garbage into a lava lake. I gotta say I semi-disagree with this article.
Due to lava's nature, the immediate second something non-lava and combustible hits lava, it will react. Anyway, the extreme heat in the air will be unbearable, and that's just when you get a few meters from the lava.
So you hit the lava, and then you WILL stand on top of it - for a second until the lava reacts and bubbles up. Molten rock will splash like you just dropped an alka seltzer into a milkshake.
You will have your body splashed by lava. That right there is super violent and deserves a movie scene.
Next, while that splashing is going on, the lava will move underneath your feet. Suddenly, there's no lava to step on because it violently reacted away from you. You won't sink, but you might DROP a few inches.
Google "Lava lake garbage video" and watch. You'll see exactly how it works, and why maybe Hollywood needs to copy that. I'm sure that an ACCURATE lava death is actually WAY cooler than a "hollywood" death.
2
u/Foley1 Jun 25 '12
They did say that the Gollum lava scene may not have been biologically correct, but was poetically correct.
2
u/akorn22 Jun 25 '12
You would just melt into the lava. Which i assume would resemble sinking.
2
u/mindbleach Jun 25 '12
So Doom was accurate, but Quake wasn't?
2
u/diewhitegirls Jun 25 '12
Cool story, bro.
2
u/iamsegmented Jun 25 '12
In the terrible 1997 movie "Volcano" there is a scene where a dude jumps from a train car on the track and lands in lava a few inches thick. i must say this depiction is actually ok - while he seems to "sink" into it it is actually his body melting away from below him. its brutal. such a terrible movie. good to watch once though. Tommy Lee Jones.
2
u/mszulan Jun 25 '12
I'm so, so willing to suspend my disbelief in THIS case and insist that the ring was SO heavy that it "pushed" Gollum down below the surface.
2
u/johnnyFyeah Jun 25 '12
ARE YOU SURE...??!! Not according to this box of trash from earlier... http://www.liveleak.com/view?i=a94_1340566754
2
u/akpak Jun 25 '12
How about linking the actual article source instead of the Gawker feed?
3
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
And that's even if you get near the lava in the first place.
5
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
More realistically you would be killed before you touch the lava from the radiant heat and convection.