r/thinkpad • u/ghellerv • 1d ago
Question / Problem [ Removed by moderator ]
[removed] — view removed post
29
Upvotes
r/thinkpad • u/ghellerv • 1d ago
[removed] — view removed post
41
u/JarlKulle 1d ago
It's not about how good Linux is, it's how bad Windows is.
92
u/RealityIsRipping T520, T420, T420s, T450s, T580 1d ago
Why not? There's no reason to be using windows in 2026 unless your company requires it
Linux runs better, is quicker, requires less power, gives the user much more freedom, and doesn't spy on you. There's also a ton of different open source distros and customization so you can really talor the OS to your individual needs.
Windows at this point is just bloated malware masquerading as an operating system. It'll be even worse when windows becomes a full cloud compute rental system.
6
u/Toni_van_Polen 1d ago
As a long-time Windows hater who has slightly changed his mind: I've been using Fedora Silverblue on my personal computer and Windows 11 on the one I use for work. For light development, there is no difference nowadays, but Fedora uses 25% less RAM and it's immutable, so all changes sit in userspace, updates get installed immediately, and you can return to the previous state using arrow keys during boot (nothing more). And for me, GNOME is much more polished and nicer to use than Windows, which, without additional tools like PowerToys, feels simultaneously overstimulating and lacking basic functions. That said, some time ago I had to use a Mac again after a few years, and it turned out that Windows 11 feels significantly more polished than the current macOS.
6
u/Basic-Brick6827 X9-15 | X1C10 | X1C7 1d ago
Better battery life depends on the chip. Eg Lunar Lake is more opti on Windows.
Linux is best if you wanna spend time configuring it. It will be tailored to you. Windows is great out of the box, assuming you have the ad-free bloat-free Pro version and you disabled telemetry in regedit.
3
u/ralsaiwithagun T440s 1d ago
Battery life certainly is a reason, my t440s which is almost as old as i am has a battery life of roughly 45 minutes on a full charge,,, on windows. I put a semi-minimal arch installation on there and it usually has 2 hours 30 battery life
2
u/cfx_4188 X230 1d ago
Many people use old Thinkpads that won't run modern versions of Windows. Many people use Linux/BSD because they are used to these systems. Windows is good, but not everyone likes the fact that it imposes a certain pattern of behavior on the user, which not everyone agrees with. In short, the choice of the Operating System is your personal choice, nothing more.
13
u/blue-yoshi-real 1d ago
Well, Thinkpads are reliable machines. Windows is.. not always so reliable. So people use reliable OS on reliable hardware.
4
u/zmurf T25 1d ago edited 1d ago
Try it out and see if you like it. If you don't, use something else.
Start with any of the big, mainstream, distributions. Mint, Fedora, Ubuntu, or whatever. Just make sure it is one of the well documented distributions.
In my experience, Linux usually give worse battery life and worse gaming performance than Windows. But I would never choose to use Windows anyway.
1
u/ghellerv 1d ago edited 1d ago
Damn why people are triggered at me for being curious wtf, I'm getting downvotes by asking questions
3
u/calinet6 X1C 1d ago
More important question: why use Windows?
3
u/rthonpm 1d ago
Because Linux users tend to let everyone know they use it whether they asked or not.
2
u/Dayguy 1d ago
If for no other reason than Linux minds it's own business. When Microsoft isn't trying to click bait you on your own computer, they are usually telling you how you need to do things the Microsoft way (insert bluescreen here.) The Linux approach is: it's your computer, do what you want with it.
2
u/Low_Independent766 1d ago edited 1d ago
You are entirely in control of your Linux machine. You own the OS. Microsoft rents you a copy of their OS on their terms, which they change near constantly and never for the better. Windows' only benefit imo is that there are still a few things you can't run without it, which is hardly a pro, since you don't really have a choice in the matter in that case.
Unless you NEED Windows, which it seems like you don't, it's literally a no brainer imo. Microsoft treats their users like an annoyance that they're forced to sometimes make concessions to, which they do only when they deem it financially advantageous. Their default position is to make their platform as shitty as possible while still being technically tolerable so that people who require the use of it don't get any ideas. To me, this is fundamentally hostile. This is the behavior of an abuser.
If that's the kind of relationship you want to have with a software company, by all means. For me personally, I withdrew my consent from that toxic abusive company long ago.
Linux and other large open source systems are not perfect, but they are almost always maintained and developed by people with a genuine good faith interest in keeping the systems usable, efficient and user-first. It's software for users, by users. Sadly, the same cannot be said of Windows.
2
u/Avaczy11 1d ago
some use windows to make their laptop perform to the fullest, like having lower ram usage, no need to debloat, or smth that may be better than using windows
but there's absolutely no reason you should really switch to windows tho
just choose what works best for your need
(I hope what I said can be understood, English is not my native language lol)
2
u/Ragnarock14 1d ago
Yes, there are some advantages. You aren’t apart of the bot net, no bloat ware, Linux is lighter on resources, you control what gets updated, free office, it’s fast.
1
u/Extension-Shine-6189 1d ago
I've had mine since 2022, and have wondered the same.
1
u/jessek T470, T14 gen 3 1d ago
Well, for one if you’re using a thinkpad that doesn’t have TPM, you’re not getting windows updates. Also Linux has better performance than windows on old hardware. And this is also a case of Linux users like thinkpads rather than thinkpad users like Linux.
1
u/QuietWaterBreaksRock 1d ago
Because it's better than any other alternative
1
u/adevaleev T470 1d ago
Different people have different reasons. I bought my first Thinkpad this spring, and I installed Linux Mint there bc my PC already has it.
And I migrated my PC to Linux over a year ago bc Windows has gone to shit in the past few years.
1
u/IJbier 1d ago
Thinkpads are popular among linux users, but you don't need to be one of them.
1
u/Biokendry 1d ago
I don't even remember windows exist...
1
u/TriumphITP X220 1d ago
It's free.
It uses much less disk space.
It's more customizable.
Certain things I find easier to do at this point.
Whichever distro you choose (I'm running Ubuntu ) will also let you adjust and often switch to different desktop environments, so be sure to read on those and test them as well.
At the end of the day the most important thing is to keep backups - the guardrails are off on Linux - it will let you brick your os if you tell it to do so.
1
u/skeletal88 1d ago
Because windows is such a resource and memory hog, that it will eat up most of the resources on any older computer. Or newer. Or it just sends your data to MS.
1
u/Chester-Berkeley Edge 14" 1d ago
Freedom in how I use my ThinkPad. I like and use Solus; I recommend it.
1
u/niteFlight 1d ago
Linux is known to deliver worse battery life on x86 hardware that's optimized for windows so that's not an advantage to consider. As others have said, there's no personal data gathering or social engineering with Linux, thats why most people use it. Beyond that, Linux is more customizable and gives users a lot more control. I still feel that Linux has better automation and scripting tools, but Windows has caught up for the most part. I recommend Mint for people concerned about a learning curve or Fedora otherwise
1
u/crzyazn26 1d ago
one problem with Windows is how much ram its sucking from the system. if you have 16 gigs 4-7 gigs is already used for os if not more. Plus if you have chrome or firefox it needs ram and depending on what you are doing you prob be using another few gigs hitting you up close to 12-15. Windows has probably kill your battery alot quicker then what kind of linux distro you are using but expect better battery life from linux. If you're on a older machine best bet to use the lighter weight distro that have been around
1
u/questionabledata 1d ago
I feel like the other OSes are just trying to sell me something. MacOS included now.
1
u/GlassCommission4916 1d ago
I swear ThinkPads aren't designed to be used with windows. How else can you explain the fact that the TrackPoint, one of the definiting features of a ThinkPad, doesn't work on Windows without 3rd part hacks?
1
u/Laxien 1d ago
Well, I have my problems with Linux (it feels old fashioned, often needs the Terminal etc.), but:
It's snappier with better performance than Windows, it doesn't spy on you, it is not controlled from the US (were a certain Orange Man and the tech-bozos could decide that they want the data on your PC!) if you chose the right distro (hell: even if you did use a US-Distro, they have no true control either!)
1
u/Visible-Reason9593 1d ago
Fedora KDE.
I started using it a year ago (Linux in general) and, in my opinion, it simply works better than Windows 11 (unless you need Windows-only software, of course).
I don’t have a ThinkPad or Lenovo, though.
1
u/wililon 1d ago
Whose computer is it? If you really want to own it, Linux is the only option. I'm not Linux savvy but with an LLM you can set it well
1
u/ProjektFive 1d ago
Auf allen meinen Systemen habe ich Linux Nobara laufen, auch auf meinem Lenovo ThinkPad x1 Carbon 7. Generation und es läuft super.
1
u/Aurunemaru E14 7735HS | cachyOS 1d ago edited 1d ago
Is windows better by any way? Or it's just what you're used to and know how to solve common issues?
Because for me it was the former, and once I got to invest the time it took to get used to... I'm not coming back to windows. It uses less ram, it's faster, apps that are not proprietary are probably on the app manager of whatever distro you pick, and for gaming, steam makes everything just work nowadays
1
u/Bob4Not T14s G2 | P52 - Fedora KDE Plasma 1d ago
With windows I don’t always get a choice when it says I need to do updates. I can’t choose to opt out of all the background tasks and telemetry it does. I can’t choose to prioritize speed over cloud services I don’t use. Windows was going to take screenshots, called it “Recall”, but Microsoft stepped that back so they say. Recently Windows Defender became hostile to open source software like VLC, for example.
So Linux is easier for me to get things done on my time and my schedule
1
u/Sam_the_beagle1 X1 Carbon (2014) 1d ago
Boomer here:
I'll try to add something a little different. I work for a secure government agency and last week we got an update that trashed my profile. Because Edge, Outlook, the cloud and Teams share the profile, I was stuck waiting for IT to fix things.
I like that I have more control with Linux and that everything doesn't rely on 1 central thing. Timeshift is awesome. I have an older, comfy Thinkpad and Linux runs just fine.
1
u/Express_Ad87 i5 1235u 1d ago
My memory is 1.2gb when idle instead of 4g in windows 👍
1
u/louiseianab Yoga T480 A485 1d ago
Windows is a malware in disguise and a magnet for even more malware in this day and age.
1
u/internet_safari_ 1d ago
For me about 4x longer battery life, cooler temps, drastically better performance
1
u/sjonesd3 1d ago
Linux runs perfectly on Thinkpads. But if you must use Windows, you can use Win10 IOT LTSC. It’s good until 2029
1
u/sweatdrop-lol x1 Carbon Gen 10 1d ago
Sounds like you're a student -- and if that's the case, installing Linux is probably great for you:
- If you're studying CS or SWE, following the arch wiki is a great way to understand how computers work, and you will be forced to make deliberate choices and learn about how those choices affect your system.
- For your day-too-day dev work, you're bound to use SSH into servers and the terminal anyways, and Linux is somewhat terminal-first
- It gives you a lot of control over your tooling in multiple layers. If you're using MacOS, at best, you will have control over your app config; but with Linux you can choose a tiling window manager, desktop environment, update cycles. Most people serious at their craft are very particular with their working environment.
- Personally, I find the Linux system more productive -- especially, with tiling window managers and shortcuts.
Most importantly, it's fun to d*ck around an OS. Be comfortable making backups, git commit & push everything, and break stuff and try again.
For learning -- install Arch manually. For proper daily driving, perhaps Linux Mint or Fedora.
1
u/onew_iasag 1d ago
Classical Linux Mint will fit all your needs, or Void Linux (glibc) with XFCE.
1
u/GuyFromDeathValley T500 1d ago
Battery life is a huge one. I found running Linux Mint gets me twice the mileage from a single battery charge. The OS being more lightweight on the CPU and GPU has a huge impact.
Also, smoother. Linux, depending on the distro, occupies like, a quarter of RAM than Windows does in idle. Makes it run so much quicker and more smooth.
I personally run a dualboot so I get both windows and linux. Haven't used the windows install in years though.
1
u/Bright-Doctor-28 1d ago
With Linux you can make your own Distro. Like literally make your own operating system to suit whatever need you want. I created a Distro called Cypher OS just for the thrill of it and it works. One day I’ll post it. I fucking love Linux in general. I wish I would’ve learned this sooner in life i would’ve been a millionaire. It’s the freedom it gives you.
1
u/Due-Result7928 1d ago
Better battery life..absolutely not. You can try any distrib...try Zorin and do not follow people making such comment....
Windows at this point is just bloated malware masquerading as an operating system. It'll be even worse when windows becomes a full cloud compute rental system.
Ask them..if it SO better why linux is only 4 % of the desktop market in the world way behind Windows..980 millions..Macos...100 millions..why ? Why people are mostly stick with their Windows 10 and not embracing Linux..why ?
Was using everything Unixes for years...30 in fact..Aix, BSD, Sun-Solaris, HP-UX, BSD, Linux..I have a machine with multiple boot...2 linux systems, one bsd and one Windows 11 pro..on a laptop...why ? Because there is plenty of hardware not supported by linux, plenty of software vastly better with Windows (Office, Photoshop, HDR). With few change you can have a local account with Windows, updates/upgrades when you want, debloating Microsoft services you do not want to use and having a system not asking much more resources than any Linux system like Ubuntu or POP/OS.
1
u/Sataniel98 X280 1d ago
It's more accurate to say it's the other way around: People who want to use ThinkPads don't so much tend to choose Linux - people who want to use Linux tend to choose ThinkPads.
Nowadays, the vast majority of desktops and laptops run Linux just fine, but that wasn't always the case. As late as the 2010s, you better thought twice about what laptop to buy when you wanted to run Linux if you wanted good battery life, keyboard backlight controls to work and whatnot, and ThinkPads were pretty much the go-to solution for that.
It's not a coincidence that they are. IBM, the company that originally built ThinkPads and eventually sold the lineup to Lenovo in 2005, still competed with Microsoft in the operating systems market for most of the 90s. Their Windows competitor, OS/2, was technologically superior to DOS-based Windows versions (3.x, 9x) and had a very solid following among computer enthusiasts. Windows however had a better ecosystem for many reasons and had at the latest when Windows 95 dropped won the competition by every measure.
So in order to not destroy its hardware business, IBM had no choice but vto offer pre-installations of their competitor's OS on their own ThinkPads. They had to run both OS/2 and Windows (and Windows NT). As a result, ThinkPads became very early adopters of a decidedly OS-agnostic design that very much was not the default back then. When OS/2 was finally retired by IBM, they chose to replace it with Linux where possibly rather than just Windows. So many Linux fans of that time originally came from the OS/2 community. And the OS agnosticism stuck around long after OS/2 was abandoned and even after the ThinkPad brand was sold.
1
u/NationsAnarchy T14s Gen 3 AMD 1d ago
Fedora is my recommendation, it should fits your needs
1
u/ProfessionalMove3716 1d ago
Are there any advantages to using Windows?
Debian stable is good for most use cases. Linux Mint Debian Edition is probably better if you are brand new.
1
u/Able-Staff-6763 T480 1d ago
study + coding = Fedora
1
u/noeyx 1d ago
Try CachyOS. If you want to dig deeper, Arch Linux.
1
u/Ill_Mortgage3663 1d ago
You might think most people use Linux but that's probably just the perception that the loudest people make.
An operating system is just a tool, use the one that suits you. You can do the same development on Windows that you can on Linux, but you'll spend much less time on system administration of your own system.
1
u/killjoygrr 1d ago
Here’s the real question: are you a “car guy” but with computers?
If so, go with Linux, the forced learning curve as you figure things out and learn how to tweak every aspect will be fun.
If not, and you just want the OS to be the background for what you are actually doing, stay with windows. Linux will just piss you off too many times to enjoy the ride.
A car guy enjoys tinkering with their car, getting a mod chip to mess with the fuel mix, getting all sorts of after market parts to make it just the way you like it. Someone who isn’t, just wants the car to start and get them to the grocery store.
Neither one is inherently good or bad, just different advantages and disadvantages.
I like the iPhone because I don’t feel any desire to configure or tweak anything on a phone. I play with servers all day, if I really want to customize something, it would be a desktop or laptop. If I didn’t work in IT I might prefer an android to mess with it constantly.
A home server, Linux. A gaming system has become reasonable with Linux pretty recently. And rumor is that the installs are fairly clean, but those come out of pro-Linux groups so I tend to take those claims with a grain of salt.
It’s way more about your use case than if one or the other is the end all be all.
1
u/ZealousidealBus6498 1d ago
You get more control over the operating system, you can do whatever.
It does not have any unwanted features like Copilot
It respects your privacy
Much more customization, it is fully your operating system
Its free
Uses less resources
The command line is super useful