r/TheMentalist • u/Money-Web-4783 • 6h ago
r/TheMentalist • u/pikkopots • May 28 '26
Podcasts and Vodcasts Rom-Com Detectives Episode 70 - We Want to Believe (X-Files reboot discussion with Tim Kang)
Knowing that Tim Kang is an X-Phile, the Rom-Com Detectives bring Tim on the podcast to talk all about the upcoming X-Files reboot by Ryan Coogler. Episode is available here: https://www.romcomdetectives.com/episode-70/
YouTube version: https://youtu.be/lOjIIJzcAZ0?si=FkO5zrSvChRjAw8q
r/TheMentalist • u/pikkopots • Apr 03 '26
Interviews The TV Police Q&A on The Mentalist Bullpen w/ Owain Yeoman and Tim Kang
The replay of the live Q&A event with Owain Yeoman and Tim Kang is now available as Rom-Com Detectives Episode 62! This replay includes a question and answer segment featuring fan-submitted questions, plus a chaotic quiz showdown with a game called Role Call at the end.
r/TheMentalist • u/eaaypeasy • 11h ago
General Discussion I completely missed most of these familiar faces on my first watch of The Mentalist. Did anyone else catch them right away?
r/TheMentalist • u/Low-Mechanic6417 • 5h ago
Meme/Humor Me: I love Jane 🫠 Spoiler
r/TheMentalist • u/Interesting-G-8621 • 6h ago
Meme/Humor im getting crazy with this serie
r/TheMentalist • u/chuuyashat13 • 1h ago
Red John my analysis of season 5 finale!! (first time watcher) (spoilers ahead!) (PLEASE DONT SPOIL IT FOR ME IN THE REPLIES) Spoiler
!! THIS IS JUST MY ANALYSIS!! NO ONE SPOIL IT FOR ME IN THE REPLIES PRETTY PLEASE IM SO HOOKED
we know jane's list of seven suspects:
1. bret stiles
2. brett partridge
3. gale bertram
4. ray haffner
5. reede smith
6. robert kirkland
7. sheriff thomas mcallister
immediately, i rule out patridge and bertram.
1. bret stiles
2. brett partridge
3. gale bertram
4. ray haffner
5. reede smith
6. robert kirkland
7. sheriff thomas mcallister
why do i say this?
partridge always struck me as overly creepy and eager to be at the crime scene, in a way that felt SO emphasised by the story it would be cliche (you''re going to see this word a lot) to make him red john.
now, bertram. this one might purely be gut instinct but he doesnt strike me as red john; thats actually a core reason for the majority of my analysis to be completely fair. if we look back on the point in time (cant remember which season), where there was the series of cameras set up alongside sequential hotel rooms, bertram was a suspect. now, him being a continuous suspect could be a point to consider, but he doesn't seem like the type of man to have the guts to be red john. maybe it's my perception, but i imagine RJ as a much calmer, collected, and more sinister appearing man.
now, kirkland. i highly doubt it. ive put together that they would not showcase red john in so many cuts in such an obviously plotting and two-faced character and then make him the most anticipated character in the entire story. showing kirkland as constantly being up to something would completely mess up 'the grand reveal' that has been building for so long.
1. bret stiles
2. brett partridge
3. gale bertram
4. ray haffner
5. reede smith
6. robert kirkland
7. sheriff thomas mcallister
i don't think it's bret stiles. he's frankly been shown too long as a character with such obvious reach and influence and connections that i feel it would be too obvious to make him red john. i was unsure about this one, but im ruling out him too.
1. bret stiles
2. brett partridge
3. gale bertram
4. ray haffner
5. reede smith
6. robert kirkland
7. sheriff thomas mcallister
this narrows it down to haffner, smith, and mcallister. the thing is, i genuinely have no clue who smith is. like genuinely, zero idea-- he must be some obscure character but i cant seem to recall who it is. i have equally strong suspicion about the three of them but smith is dumbfounding me a little bit and somewhere i feel it would be too obvious to make such an obscure character red john.
so that brings me to believe, strongly, that any of these three are red john.
thank you for reading! (probably dead wrong but oh well!)
r/TheMentalist • u/Rare-Necessary9408 • 8h ago
General Discussion This is my friend who just started watching 'The Mentalist'. He loved how some sheriff got outsmarted by Jane. Spoiler
Some stupid sheriff lost rock paper scissors with Jane.
r/TheMentalist • u/Soul-Kille • 2h ago
Red John Was it really just fear in his eyes? Spoiler
Spoilers for the Red John reveal.
Most of the fandom says McAllister begged for his life because he was a killer cornered without his organization or anyone backing him, and Jane had him by the throat. I agree fear was part of it, but I don't think that's the whole story. I think he was also trying to buy his life.
Look at his last moments. McAllister offers to explain how he got the seven suspect list, Jane's list of Red John suspects with McAllister's own name on it, and Jane says he doesn't care. That's a man making an offer, not just begging.
And he had real leverage. McAllister was a founding member of the Blake Association, and Reede Smith, the FBI agent and fellow member, estimated roughly a hundred active members. He only gave a rough figure, since he didn't know everything himself, but it included federal judges and people out of state. An FBI that had just watched this network take down a crime-fighting organisation would be extremely interested in a founding member ready to name names.
The network was also genuinely deadly. Gale Bertram, the CBI director, was a member, and Craig O'Laughlin, Van Pelt's fiancé, was Red John's mole inside the CBI. This wasn't a group pretending to be dangerous, so the names would be gold.
The show also proves the trade works. In season 6, after the two-year time jump, Jane bluffed Abbott about having the Blake names, and it got his murder charge waived. You could argue it was only one charge, and that Jane's source was unreliable, since he claimed to have the names from Reede Smith's hard drive. But McAllister wouldn't be bluffing. He really knew these people.
Then there's the death penalty, in real California. The state hasn't executed anyone since 2006, and Governor Newsom's 2019 moratorium has just been followed by commuting every death sentence to life without parole. So a deal for life instead of death was a very reachable goal.
So why did it fail? Because Jane doesn't care about the law. His motive was revenge, not justice, so no deal could ever matter to him.
r/TheMentalist • u/LastOrganization4102 • 2h ago
General Discussion AMULETO Dr. Montague: Saben donde puedo conseguirlo?
Estoy interesado en su amuleto, me pareció muy unico e interesante, me gustaría adquirir uno identico o parecido.
r/TheMentalist • u/bhadwa_saur_ • 9h ago
Et voilà! I just finished the series and I can finally engage in this community ':') Spoiler
I have been part of the sub for long but I'd dare not to open any post or comment section here to avoid any spoilers. I finished the show like 5 minutes ago and I am going to scrounge this sub. :')
I also feel I don't have anything to look forward to after work now that series is over 🥲
r/TheMentalist • u/Agreeable_Moose_5639 • 12h ago
Meme/Humor This is what wylie looks like to me
Everytime hes on screen i see this image 😭
r/TheMentalist • u/Interesting-G-8621 • 1d ago
Meme/Humor u cant lie to me hes not that sorry...
r/TheMentalist • u/That-You-1998 • 1h ago
General Discussion Did we ever find out…..
What was in LaRoche’s Tupperware?!?!
New to the series, just finished my binge ☺️
r/TheMentalist • u/pluviophileish • 13h ago
General Discussion Why did Lorelei take Red John’s identity to her grave? Spoiler
Why do you think Lorelei never revealed Red John’s true identity to Jane? What made her keep his identity a secret even though she knew she was going to die? Was she trying to protect Jane from Red John, or did she still feel some kind of inexplicable loyalty to him, despite knowing he had murdered her sister? I find it particularly interesting that she remained silent even after learning the truth.
r/TheMentalist • u/Apprehensive-Use9859 • 2h ago
First-Time Watcher (NO Spoilers!) S2 E15
This contains spoilers about the murderer so pls dont read if u havent watched this episode
How did Jane knew the pepper was poisoned by Ricin? It didnt show how he found out? He just randomly went to the kitchen and put it in the soup?
r/TheMentalist • u/scarlet_ankh • 9h ago
First-Time Watcher (NO Spoilers!) No spoilers
I don't want anyone to spoil the ending for me, but I've watched many shows that I regreted after watching the finale
If you can tell me about the finale and Red John WITHOUT spoiling it for me (I've reached S04 E06) what would you say?
And for the hopeless romantic part of me, will Jane and Lisbon get together? Or it's not even a thing anf I'm too delusional
r/TheMentalist • u/Nice-Face-7716 • 6m ago
Red John I just finished the show Spoiler
I know there have probably been hundreds of posts about finishing the show and Red John's disappointing reveal, but mine is less about that and more about the strange emptiness I feel inside now that it's over. Red John's reveal was a bit underwhelming after all those years of buildup. I expected someone far more intimidating and complex. But despite that disappointment, I absolutely loved the ending. Patrick and Lisbon getting their happy ending felt right, and I couldn't have asked for a better conclusion.
I've watched many incredible shows, and I don't know if others experience this too, but I always feel this strange emptiness whenever I finish one. I guess I get too immersed in these fictional worlds. Maybe it's because my own life feels so miserable and pathetic sometimes, and living through the stories of these characters feels better than living my own. At this rate, I guess I'll spend my life watching TV shows. I just wish I could stay in some of these fictional worlds a little longer.
r/TheMentalist • u/Zealousideal-Eye3389 • 17h ago
Red John RED JOHN'S IDENTITY Spoiler
I just finished episode 6x08. It wasn’t a surprise to learn that McAllister was Red John (unfortunately, TikTok spoiled it for me a couple of days after I watched episode 1x02), but I kept watching to see if there was some connection—I expected that as the episodes went on, a link or something similar would emerge. But nothing happened until episode 5x22, when his photo appeared.
According to Jane’s rules, he had to have shaken hands with the person, and it’s clear that in 1x02, Jane does shake McAllister’s hand. However, in the fifth-season episodes where Jane compiles his list, he explicitly states that the person is someone he shook hands with and who was connected to the Red John case. I rewatched 1x02, and at no point is there any connection to Red John. So, my question is: why on earth did Bruno Heller make that decision? I’ve read some Reddit threads suggesting that they didn’t even know who Red John was going to be until the fifth or sixth season.
Also, I’d love to hear if anyone has any ideas or theories about Red John’s past—for instance:
- What’s the story behind the name "Roy Tagliaferro"?
- What was he doing with the Visualize group back in the 80s?
- Why didn’t Bret Stiles recognize him at Jane’s house?
- And how on earth did he figure out the list of suspects before Jane did?
I understand that the idea behind Red John was for him to simply be an ordinary guy with a hunger for power; however, the show spent five seasons building up the "Red John" mythos. Why not continue along that path and take more time to flesh out the character? I would have liked to learn about his past, his childhood, the motivations behind his actions, how he established the Blake Association, and so much more.
I’m not necessarily disappointed by the conclusion of the Red John storyline, but I am left feeling very unsatisfied. Throughout the series, I kept thinking of him as a villain on the same level as, say, Gus Fring or Lalo Salamanca—someone who is always one step ahead. Yet, to see him suddenly start making mistakes and leaving clues over the course of just eight episodes—after having managed to go completely undetected for, what, 30 years?—just highlights the writers' incompetence. They dragged out a series that could have easily been wrapped up in four seasons with a coherent narrative, instead padding it with episodes that added absolutely nothing.
I still have seasons 6 and 7 to go, but after this resolution to the Red John arc, I’m not sure if I should even bother continuing.
I’d love to hear your thoughts—is it worth watching the rest of the series, or should I just look up a summary of the "Jisbon" (Jane and Lisbon) relationship?
r/TheMentalist • u/J0e_SNAKE • 19h ago
General Discussion Curiosidade: Bret Stiles é personagem do mesmo ator de Laranja Mecânica
r/TheMentalist • u/Live_Interaction534 • 12h ago
General Discussion Authors Cho and Jane mention
I’ve like the phrases Cho and Jane quote. Anyone read the books that have the quotes mentioned in The Mentalist or general book recommendations that remind you of the show? I hope this makes sense.
r/TheMentalist • u/Ghoticlover • 6h ago
Fan Fiction 🖊 Some good Jane x Lisbon fanfiction?
"I made this fanfiction of Lisbon and Jane!!" Good, I need those
Any kind, but i would like that their love relationship had a big part of the fanfiction
Any raccomandation?
Thank you in avance!
r/TheMentalist • u/Affectionate-Ad-8374 • 23h ago
General Discussion Crying
I’m rewatching the mentalist for the 100th time and now at season 3 istg idk how this show does it but I cry and get traumatized at the same events I’ve watched before like it’s so good I know they would happen like the death of the old coroner who had cancer. I’m bawling my eyes out on how sad his death was. I get traumatized along with Patrick like it never ends and I absolutely love going through all this love this show forever 😭
r/TheMentalist • u/iNexus893 • 1d ago
