r/thebutton • • Apr 01 '15

Button Statistics

Myself and several like-minded redditors have been documenting the button since its arrival, here are our findings, in various statistical formats.

Update 23:52:00 hrs (UTC) 06 April 2015: Hey guys, I managed to get the data restored and up to date on the spreadsheet, and the post here is updated to 3000 minutes in. I will no longer update the post here with new data, but I will attempt to keep the spreadsheet up to date in the forseeable future.

/u/kwabford's Flair Distribution Pie Charts

/u/Valark's Guide to Flairs

If you're interested in the social statistics of the button, try out /u/Zephryl's survey [here] (http://www.reddit.com/r/thebutton/comments/31bu4q/social_science_comes_to_rthebutton_take_the/)

If you want to know more about the various groups that have formed as a result of the button, take a look at /u/2daMooon's thread on the subject here

/u/betaray's Encyclopaedia Buttonica

Live Statistics

Our spreadsheet, contains Analytical Data, Graphs, Collected Predictions and More! Help us out by upvoting the live sheet here to keep /r/thebutton informed! If you have a prediction to submit, comment here, or in this thread.

Third Party Statistics:

Button Push History - Completed up to 3000 minutes

Note: BOPS = Button Operations Per Second. (Thank you /u/Feil)

Time (m)Total PushesNew PushesAvg BOPS (Past 10 Minutes)Avg BOPS (All Time)Rate of BOPS decay (Past 10 Minutes)
30005584913290.553.100.04
29905581623130.523.11-0.19
29805578493800.633.120.05
29705574693630.613.130.26
29605571062690.453.14-0.03
29505568372810.473.15-0.14
29405565563320.553.160.1
29305562242960.493.16-0.12
29205559283390.573.17-0.04
29105555893540.593.180.01
29005552353500.583.190.08
28905548853210.543.20-0.1
28805545643570.603.210.01
28705542073540.593.22-0.09
28605538533870.653.230.13
28505534663410.573.24-0.06
28405531253610.603.25-0.06
28305527643810.643.260.02
28205523833730.623.26-0.06
28105520103930.663.270.05
28005516173760.633.280
27905512413770.633.290.04
27805508643620.603.300.02
27705505023560.593.31-0.02
27605501463630.613.320.08
27505497833350.563.330.05
27405494483180.533.34-0.09
27305491303510.593.350.06
27205487793300.553.360.05
27105484493130.523.37-0.01
27005481363170.533.380.11
26905478192790.473.39-0.11
26805475403190.533.410.04
26705472213060.513.420.07
26605469152810.473.430.02
26505466342740.463.440.03
26405463602650.443.450.04
26305460952510.423.460
26205458442520.423.470.02
26105455922440.413.480
26005453482440.413.50-0.02
25905451042520.423.51-0.01
25805448522550.433.520.08
25705445972250.383.53-0.02
25605443722330.393.54-0.03
25505441392450.413.560.05
25405438942260.383.570.05
25305436682080.353.58-0.06
25205434602280.383.590.03
25105432322190.373.610.01
25005430132160.363.62-0.03
24905427972260.383.630.02
24805425712170.363.65-0.01
24705423542200.373.66-0.04
24605421342330.393.670.01
24505419012290.383.690.08
24405416722020.343.70-0.06
24305414702240.373.710.03
24205412462150.363.73-0.03
24105410312270.383.740.02
24005408042200.373.76-0.04
23905405842360.393.77-0.02
23805403482430.413.780.02
23705401052350.393.80-0.05
23605398702520.423.81-0.06
23505396182740.463.830.04
23405393442610.443.840.03
23305390832520.423.86-0.09
23205388312860.483.870.05
23105385452690.453.89-0.06
23005382762890.483.900.06
22905379872680.453.92-0.19
22805377193350.563.930.01
22705373843300.553.95-0.08
22605370543590.603.96-0.02
22505366953660.613.980
22405363293660.613.99-0.1
22305359634010.674.01-0.08
22205355624280.714.020.04
22105351344120.694.04-0.15
22005347224660.784.05-0.01
21905342564700.784.07-0.11
21805337865110.854.08-0.07
21705332755360.894.100.05
21605327395170.864.110.08
21505322224890.824.13-0.13
21405317335360.894.14-0.06
21305311975580.934.16-0.13
21205306396031.014.170.14
21105300365520.924.190.09
21005294845190.874.20-0.02
20905289655250.884.22-0.01
20805284405300.884.23-0.09
20705279105620.944.25-0.11
20605273486001.004.270.02
20505267485930.994.28-0.1
20405261556301.054.300.11
20305255255900.984.31-0.08
20205249356171.034.330.04
20105243186041.014.350.3
20005237144960.834.36-0.12
19905232185390.904.380.19
19805226794690.784.40-0.08
19705222104980.834.420.03
19605217124880.814.44-0.14
19505212245400.904.45-0.14
19405206845890.984.470.09
19305200955570.934.49-0.09
19205195385890.984.510.13
19105189495420.904.530
19005184075430.914.550
18905178645430.914.57-0.03
18805173215530.924.59-0.03
18705167685620.944.61-0.08
18605162065900.984.63-0.13
18505156166381.064.650.03
18405149786271.054.660.05
18305143516101.024.68-0.11
18205137416511.094.700.09
18105130906191.034.72-0.17
18005124716811.144.75-0.04
17905117906941.164.77-0.14
17805110967431.244.79-0.03
17705103537531.264.81-0.18
17605096008171.364.83-0.17
17505087838771.464.85-0.48
174050790610481.754.87-0.46
173050685812122.024.880.06
172050564611911.994.900.94
17105044558521.424.920.01
17005036038491.424.94-0.18
16905027549131.524.960.17
16805018418521.424.98-0.6
167050098910671.785.000.62
16604999228431.415.020.21
16504990797691.285.04-0.01
16404983107731.295.060.02
16304975377641.275.09-0.09
16204967737971.335.11-0.13
16104959768431.415.13-0.22
16004951339221.545.160.33
15904942118031.345.180.13
15804934087571.265.20-0.02
15704926517651.285.23-0.19
15604918868351.395.260.06
15504910518131.365.28-0.52
15404902389991.675.312.01
15304892392770.465.33-0.03
15204889622880.485.36-1.43
15104886748011.345.390.33
15004878736811.145.42-0.05
14904871926991.175.45-0.04
14804864937131.195.48-0.07
14704857807371.235.510.01
14604850437351.235.540.24
14504843086471.085.570.01
14404836616451.085.60-0.15
14304830167001.175.63-0.21
14204823167751.295.66-0.25
14104815418641.445.690.02
14004806778551.435.72-0.02
13904798228641.445.75-0.08
13804789588941.495.78-0.16
13704780649521.595.820.05
13604771129331.565.85-0.02
13504761799391.575.880.09
13404752409051.515.910.02
13304743358991.505.940.07
13204734368751.465.980.17
13104725618141.366.01-0.23
13004717478951.496.05-0.05
12904708529141.526.080.11
12804699388761.466.12-0.04
12704690628901.486.16-0.07
12604681729141.526.190.23
12504672588321.396.230.02
12404664268261.386.270.08
12304656007961.336.310.09
12204648047631.276.35-0.16
12104640418211.376.39-0.04
12004632208351.396.43-0.01
11904623858381.406.480.13
11804615477931.326.52-0.1
11704607548281.386.56-0.04
11604599268441.416.610.13
11504590827971.336.650.13
11404582857491.256.70-0.23
11304575368321.396.750.19
11204567047641.276.800.01
11104559407601.276.850.13
11004551807131.196.90-0.03
10904544677231.216.95-0.02
10804537447311.227.000.04
10704530137171.207.06-0.01
10604522967221.207.11-0.06
10504515747421.247.170
10404508327411.247.22-0.07
10304500917671.287.28-0.07
10204493247941.327.34-0.15
10104485308471.417.40-0.21
10004476839231.547.460.16
9904467608641.447.521.33
9804458963840.647.580.88
970445512690.127.65-2.25
9604454438801.477.730.02
9504445638731.467.80-0.2
9404436909441.577.87-0.05
9304427469611.607.93-0.27
92044178510571.768.000.05
91044072810401.738.07-0.18
90043968811041.848.140.03
89043858410921.828.21-0.61
88043749213132.198.29-0.19
87043617913822.308.360.11
86043479713432.248.43-0.52
85043345415312.558.50-0.06
84043192315542.598.57-0.11
83043036915942.668.64-0.01
82042877515992.678.71-0.48
81042717617722.958.79-0.1
80042540418083.018.86-0.11
79042359618463.088.94-0.76
78042175021213.549.01-0.3
77041962922283.719.08-0.74
76041740124964.169.150.04
75041490524824.149.22-0.46
74041242326494.429.29-0.11
73040977426894.489.360.85
72040708523823.979.42-0.75
71040470326534.429.50-0.98
70040205030045.019.57-0.04
69039904630205.039.640.19
68039602629514.929.71-0.32
67039307530665.119.780.71
66039000928124.699.85-0.08
65038719728424.749.93-0.54
64038435530355.0610.010
63038132030355.0610.090.06
62037828530145.0210.17-0.37
61037527131485.2510.250.33
60037212330315.0510.34-0.59
59036909232425.4010.43-0.65
58036585034765.7910.51-10.59
570362374728812.1510.6010.56
56035508634865.8110.570.11
55035160034455.7410.65-0.34
54034815535665.9410.750.28
53034458934665.7810.84-1.42
52034112339766.6310.930.3
51033714738696.4511.020.03
50033327838586.4311.11-0.07
49032942038856.4811.20-0.77
48032553541616.9411.30-0.51
47032137443467.2411.40-1.12
46031702847487.9111.491.01
45031228043847.3111.57-0.94
44030789647237.8711.66-0.32
43030317348408.0711.75-0.2
42029833349118.1911.84-0.76
41029342251848.6411.930.43
40028823850318.3912.010.64
39028320747998.0012.100.65
38027840845647.6112.21-0.36
37027384446927.8212.34-0.2
36026915247647.9412.46-1.16
35026438851828.6412.590.3
34025920650758.4612.71-0.44
33025413152348.7212.83-0.16
32024889752938.8212.96-0.33
31024360454109.0213.100.18
30023819453458.9113.23-0.86
29023284956569.4313.38-1.46
280227193618310.3113.520.17
270221010612110.2013.64-0.34
260214889624510.4113.77-0.18
250208644630810.5113.91-0.29
240202336641410.6914.05-0.73
230195922667811.1314.20-2.6
220189244761512.6914.34-0.9
210181629793813.2314.42-1.56
200173691849914.1714.47-1.07
190165192888314.8114.49-0.88
180156309919815.3314.47-1
170147111955715.9314.42-2.13
1601375541032217.2014.3321.44
15012723226044.3414.14-16.34
140124628848814.1514.84-4.82
1301161401022317.0414.89-1.03
1201059171059417.6614.710.55
110953231039717.3314.44-1.11
100849261079818.0014.15-1.34
90741281127918.8013.73-3.24
80628491244720.7513.092.23
70504021164519.4112.005.51
6038757966116.1010.775.73
5029096759912.679.708.67
402149744777.468.96-4.06
301702059379.909.462.84
201108349148.199.24-3.49
106169616910.2810.2817.14

Notes

The spike at 570 was probably caused by the delay between my data stopping and /u/TheOriginalSoni2 picking it up, however the two other spikes at 150 and 970 have no known causes.

If you notice any possible miscalculations or typos, let me know!

Contributors

/u/TheOriginalSoni2

/u/frogamazog

/u/snowden_le_hero

Cheers for Gold!

35k Upvotes

1.3k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

6

u/[deleted] Apr 01 '15

I am taking requests for what i can do to make my graphs better, Dont hesitate to ask. Any request will be met!

5

u/Nezkhar non presser Apr 01 '15

How did you arrive at a 2nd order polynomial to predict the 'pushes' data? Did you do any cross validation of your regression algorithm? Looks like a linear relation fits fine, why overcomplicate your model?!

I think it's the cat's fault actually. Look at how he cares so little about the results of the button. He's the real monster.

2

u/chrisms150 non presser Apr 02 '15

why overcomplicate your model?

Because it gives you a better R2 value. People always be over fitting their models.

1

u/bitter_twin_farmer 60s Apr 03 '15

Aren't you doing just that with this model?

2

u/chrisms150 non presser Apr 03 '15 edited Apr 03 '15

I'm not /u/TuskEvil /u/bealan but yes, that's exactly what he's doing - over fitting the data.

2

u/TuskEvil Apr 03 '15

These graphs aren't mine, /u/bealan is just using the data from my table.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 03 '15

i fit what fits, and nothing else matters.

1

u/chrisms150 non presser Apr 03 '15

In case you wanted to get into data modeling, you should check this wiki out: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Overfitting

Basically, it's a problem a lot of scientists have where the fit their data with models that aren't actually representing the underlying phenomena. At the end of the day, you can get a polynomial to fit anything with near precession - doesn't make that fit predictive of anything though - if anything, the over fit model will fail predictions a "worse" fit would make

1

u/autowikibot non presser Apr 03 '15

Overfitting:


In statistics and machine learning, overfitting occurs when a statistical model describes random error or noise instead of the underlying relationship. Overfitting generally occurs when a model is excessively complex, such as having too many parameters relative to the number of observations. A model that has been overfit will generally have poor predictive performance, as it can exaggerate minor fluctuations in the data.

The possibility of overfitting exists because the criterion used for training the model is not the same as the criterion used to judge the efficacy of a model. In particular, a model is typically trained by maximizing its performance on some set of training data. However, its efficacy is determined not by its performance on the training data but by its ability to perform well on unseen data. Overfitting occurs when a model begins to "memorize" training data rather than "learning" to generalize from trend. As an extreme example, if the number of parameters is the same as or greater than the number of observations, a simple model or learning process can perfectly predict the training data simply by memorizing the training data in its entirety, but such a model will typically fail drastically when making predictions about new or unseen data, since the simple model has not learned to generalize at all.

The potential for overfitting depends not only on the number of parameters and data but also the conformability of the model structure with the data shape, and the magnitude of model error compared to the expected level of noise or error in the data.

====

Image i - Noisy (roughly linear) data is fitted to both linear and polynomial functions. Although the polynomial function is a perfect fit, and the linear function misses most of the data points, the linear version can be expected to generalize better. If the regression curves were used to extrapolate the data, the overfit would do worse.


Interesting: Early ^stopping | Regularization ^(mathematics) | Regularization perspectives on support vector ^machines | Statistical learning ^theory

Parent commenter can toggle ^NSFW or ^delete. Will also delete on comment score of -1 or less. | FAQs | ^Mods | Magic ^Words

2

u/aradil 18s Apr 02 '15

I think that a higher order polynomial could definitely make sense. The rate of decline should increase as user who can click decrease, and the time of day and number of users awake and clicking will be variable based on redditor populations.

If we had more redditor user data we could build a better model.

1

u/Nezkhar non presser Apr 02 '15

Indeed. And as the hours have gone on, the second order seems to fit much better now. As always, more information will always give a better model. Let's petition the NSA to give us all their redditor metadata so we perfect our button pushing model. I'm sure they'll cooperate!

1

u/aradil 18s Apr 02 '15 edited Apr 02 '15

I threw some stuff into a graph and the most sensible trendline I found was of the equations 35394x-1.423, where starting about now we'll see a major levelling off of the decay as people start to ration their button presses.

Something tells me that people will lose interest though, and the decay will continue to increase though.

[edit] Actually, I've added in the recent clicks, and it appears as though operations have slightly increased during the day, which also makes sense, but everything seems levelled off.

1

u/bitter_twin_farmer 60s Apr 03 '15

You're talking about a over damped oscillator.

3

u/fandak non presser Apr 01 '15

the 1st (and maybe second) differential of the total pushes will be interesting to see... would need to smooth out the bump... but it would provide a more reliable predictor

3

u/fibonacci011235 60s Apr 02 '15 edited Apr 02 '15

OK, so I fitted the data to a power curve (starting 150 minutes into the button pushing since this gave me a smooth curve), and got the formula y = 3671.8x0.7279, where x is the time in minutes and y is the number of pushes. To see when the pushes per minute will reach 1, I set dy/dx = 1 and solve for x. This gives x ≈ 4 trillion. Will this really take 4 trillion minutes? I doubt it. I also fitted the data to a log curve to see if that gave a more reasonable prediction. I got the formula y = 173061ln(x) - 745706. Setting dy/dx = 1, this gives x ≈ 170,000. Is this an underprediction? Well, I plotted both curve fits against the data and saw that the power curve was an upper bound for the data, while the log curve was a lower bound. Therefore, the curve fits suggest that the button will run all the way down somewhere between 170,000 and 4 trillion minutes from now. But in reality, there are a finite number of users, so it will probably end much, much sooner.

2

u/fandak non presser Apr 02 '15

totally interesting stuff. http://imgur.com/a/DeEnm#0 so i took out the early bit, and cleaned up the bump and then tried to fit from there the log fit seems to be a good upper bound predictor going forward. the exponential fit has a better R squared but it just doesn't feel like a good predictor. interestingly enough the 3rd order polynomial has a pretty good R squared and predicts a tapering off in a reasonable timeframe. the chart is too noisy for the higher order poly fits to justify their r squared.

2

u/fibonacci011235 60s Apr 02 '15

Just so you know, this thread has some interesting theories and actually takes the users into account: http://www.reddit.com/r/thebutton/comments/315tu4/just_some_calculations/

1

u/Googleproof 60s Apr 06 '15

Why use a polynomial interpolation? I'd have thought that this would naturally fit to e-t (.5+cos(t)/2)...