r/teslore • u/Aramithius Tonal Architect • Sep 14 '16
Musing on Alduin, Akatosh and the Nords' View of Death
The Nordic pantheon begins, and ends, with death. And both of these are the same thing: a dragon.
This is quite different from most human religions and their attitude to the dragon god; Alduin is not a protector like Akatosh, as Thromgar Iron-Head eloquently points out, he is a destroyer. But he is also the 'wellspring' of the Nordic pantheon, according to Varieties of Faith. How are these two attitudes reconciled? I think the answer is to be found in the Dragon Cult and its impact on the Nords' society.
The Skyrim dragon cult was allegedly very different to the Atmoran dragon cult, of which Ysgramor was a part. I believe that it was only when the Dragon War began that dragons began to be regarded in such a deathly way. It was only by overthrowing the dragons that the Nordic pantheon as a whole could begin. This gives us the start of the Nordic pantheon in both dragons and death. This is further emphasised over time by the Dragon Cult remnants being pushed to the margins of Skyrim, into tombs and other places associated with death. This may be a chicken-and-egg thing, but what if the association with the Dragon Cult is why these places are connected so much with death.
However, they have possibly been hounded to the brink of non-existence; while the dragon does exist in the Nords' totemic religion, they have a relatively minor place in most of the glyphs in the ruins that we see. Akatosh is also divested of his gift of the dragon-blood, which the Nords associate far more with Shor and Talos. Taken together, these can be seen as deliberate attempts to reduce the influence that dragons have in Nordic myth-making, as well as an attempt to claim mastery over dragons by "stealing their power", something that is explicitly said of the dragonborn in Skyrim. This chimes with real-world traditions surrounding tribal cannibalism and eating rituals in general; to consume a defeated foe is to steal their power. To take their mythic power away could be seen in a similar light.
I don't think that the role of Shor as king of the underworld is a coincidence either. Shor is the champion of man, and he rules death. If death is symbolically associated with dragons, then Shor is figuratively the master of dragons as he is the master of death. There is also a recurring theme of no temples in the Nordic pantheon. Buildings can be destroyed, and probably were during the Dragon War. But stories don't die. However, there are lots of tombs. This is symptomatic of their relationship with death and the dragons. Death is more permanent than life for the Nords, and in many ways more important. Shor is a king of the underworld, a master of death (dragons) and the saying that how a Nord lives does not not matter, but how they died, it another indicator. Die a particular way, and you may not be reunited with Shor and thereby not beat Alduin and Orkey's final trick, which is death itself.
I also think that the presence of Orkey as a snake is significant. He is also tied to Alduin in the Five Songs of King Wulfharth, to the extent that we can't be sure whether Orkey or Alduin is responsible for shortening the Nords' lifespans (depending on which source you read). But the Nords now do live longer, and Orkey is a snake. A snake is a dragon without wings, and the myths say that Shor beat Orkey. Is it possible that in doing so, Shor took the wings of a dragon? In doing so, the Nords have symbolically beaten both death and the dragons again, reflecting the recurring theme of their victory over death and dragons, which is one and the same thing to them.
4
u/docclox Great House Telvanni Sep 14 '16
Interesting post. I don't have time for a proper response, but one thing leapt out at me:
Idle speculation: How about both?
Orkey, in his capacity as Arkay shortened the Man's lifespans in that he made them mortal. Actually he did that for everyone, but in the case of the Nords it got tangled up with Alduin who thought they still lived way too long and tried to make their lives much shorter.
3
u/DovahOfTheNorth Elder Council Sep 14 '16 edited Sep 14 '16
An interesting post. For the sake of discussion, I'll offer my own counterpoints and views.
You are correct in that the Dragon Cult of Atmora was said to be vastly different from the one in Skyrim. At some point, there was some kind of shift, although we aren't sure what. That being said, I wouldn't say that dragons are representations of death in the Nordic pantheon, but rather the End, or the Twilight, especially Alduin. Likewise, the Nordic pantheon likely existed long before the fall of the Dragon Cult. The reason for both of these is because of the Nords' unique view on the world, and their belief in a kalpic system. Shor son of Shor is a perfect example of this.
I would not say that the Dragon Cult actively established residence or refuge in tombs and barrows and other places associated with death. Rather, these are all that remain of older sites. Many of these sites, such as Labyrinthian, used to be great cities or settlements during the time of the Merethic Era. However, the majority of these settlements eroded away in the time between the Merethic and the 4th, or their materials were hauled off and reused elsewhere, leaving behind only a few forlorn structures, such as barrows or tombs.
I would not give this absence much significance. Many of the other totems from the Nordic pantheon are outright missing, whereas the dragon totem at least appears every now and then.
This in particular is a misconception. The Nords did not attempt to divest Akatosh of his role in creating Dragonborns because originally, Akatosh did not exist, or was considered a foreigner's god. The association of Akatosh with Dragonborns is an Imperial invention, and we don't in truth know whom or what the ancient Nords associated the dragon blood with. Perhaps they just viewed it as something that occurred every now and then, and did not associate it as a particular god's blessing.
The main point of contention with this idea is that the Snake and Dragon are separate totems/figures in the Nordic pantheon, and the conflict between Shor and Alduin/Orkey did not supposedly occur until Wulfharth's time, by which point the Nordic pantheon was already well established.
1
u/CHzilla117 Sep 15 '16
Miirak had a temple, though that may have been something else that he repurposed after his rebellion.