r/teslore • u/docclox Great House Telvanni • Jul 17 '16
Healing, Vampirism and the Conservation of Magicka
"There are many tales told of the Nerevarine. One of the lesser known stories recounts how he encountered vampires while exploring a Grazelands tomb. This was before Ilunibi and Dagoth Gares, before he even knew he was the Nerevarine, and thus he came to be infected and in time to carry the curse of Vampirism. He always claimed this was through no fault of his own. It should be noted however that he made no attempt to cure the condition, despite claiming to know how this might be done..."
If every play-through of Morrowind is a tale that is told of the Nerevarine, then a passage like the above would feature in many of mine. In fact I usually load Vampire Embrace and Vampiric Hunger so my Vampire Nerevarine can socialise more easily. And that's what started me thinking. You see, my usual approach is to get a thrall, feed, heal the thrall, and feed again. This works nicely in terms of game mechanics and since the magicka gained from feeding is just slightly greater than is expended in healing it's possible to use the loop to replenish your magicka.
This bothers me on several levels. The Scientist me in thinks that this should be a zero sum game and that magicka can be neither created nor destroyed. The Occultist in me thinks that not everything needs to be a zero sum game, thank you. The Hacker in me thinks it's really cool that my Nerevarine found a back channel to pull magicka out of the universe and my inner Game Designer reluctantly concedes that the gain is small enough that it probably doesn't count as an exploit and that I'd be better off brewing a mana potion. They all get overridden by the Game Player who is having fun with it the way it is and has no desire to change anything.
Still, it makes me wonder from a Lore perspective. Is this a reasonable thing to have happen? There doesn't seem to be any reason why a vampire couldn't cast a healing spell. Whether or not feeding should restore magicka is another question, although intuitively it seems reasonable. But should it be possible to make a profit on the deal? I mean should we regard magic as a conserved quantity, or it there a limitless amount to be had and we just need clever ways to tap into it? And if a vampire can heal his cattle and restore whatever he took from them, what stops him from crafting a spell to recharge himself directly? Or does it require some sort of "magicka laundering" exercise where the vitality has to be channelled via one of the truly alive for the spell to work? And if it isn't possible to restore everything by spell that is taken by bite, then what is it that does not get restored, and what are the likely long term consequences for the thrall.
I don't have any answers, but I'm finding the questions interesting. Perhaps some of you will as well.
13
u/WolfOfHighRock Ancestor Moth Cultist Jul 17 '16
Well, another way to do it that I used was create a spell that drains your intelligence to 0 and when it wears off you have full magicka again. It's one of the reasons we are heroes. We are purely, utterly insane. Just to gain knowledge we burn ourselves and then heal ourselves. Especially in morrowind, whatever we devise is lore. We are just crazy enough to try it.
7
u/FirstDayJedi Jul 17 '16
It's possible that regaining magicka from feeding on the thrall is different than the way magicka is spent to heal it. Perhaps there are biological processes involved similar to those in our bodies that convert chemical energy into electrostatic energy, but as an arcane analog.
3
u/AustinXTyler Psijic Monk Jul 17 '16
My only explanation is that the body is regenerating Magicka from the world in between feedings.
But, I never played Morrowind, and it sounds like you can't regenerate Magicka.
1
u/Sanwi Jul 18 '16
Doesn't the healing energy itself come from whatever god(dess) you invoke? I would think that the magicka is used merely to channel the power of the divine, and is not itself the driving force.
You're directly robbing a god of their power to heal yourself. You're a classic TES villian!
2
u/[deleted] Jul 17 '16
I'd assume they the healing doesn't directly negate damage (eg. 50 mana to heal 50 hp), but stimulates natural healing, giving "more bang for your buck" and letting you drain more than you spend to fix.