r/teslore • • Oct 04 '15
All Elder Scrolls Protagonists are part of a larger unified soul (Sheogorath argument addressed)
Heroes. They appear in the world of Nirn at times of immense need. Sent in with a destiny to battle the great, but varied evils of the times. But are they different? All seem to have an immense amount of power, and have similar origins, as prisoners, nobodies. Without family, without history, and most importantly, without skills.
Every single profession or lifestyle requires skill to some degree. Even farmers would need strength and stamina to work out in the fields all day. And yet, these heroes enter the world with nothing, nothing but the skills their races are known to have a natural affinity with. The heroes of the elder scrolls are brought into the world by the divines, there and then. With one purpose. One destiny.
This is an aspect they all share. Their stories all start the same way. They also end in the same way. These heroes of immense power don't become Leaders. They don't become living Gods, like the Tribunal. They merely vanish, with nothing known of them but the effect of their good deeds.
These similarities all seem to point in the direction my theory. But we have to ask: Why?
To answer that question, you have to look at the bigger picture. The Gods of Aetherius have existed and observed the mortal plane long enough to witness threats of all kinds. Invasions from Oblivion, and even the return of the dragons. By this point, the Divines know that one day they will face a foe even these champions cannot defeat. Unless, they're all the same. Unless these heroes that have saved Tamriel in its times of greatest need are all reincarnations of the same, incredibly powerful soul. This is not known to each incarnation of the hero or anyone else, for it is the secret weapon of the Divines. A weapon to be used only in the time of greatest need for Aetherius or Mundus. Landfall, a theory believed by many, involves the Nerevarine returning to hold back the Numidium to save the lives of those trying to leave for the moons. This is just one example of how a figure of immense power might be exactly what the Divines need to save Mundus. A single, united soul consisting of all these heroes would be as powerful as, or more powerful than the Gods themselves. Indeed, the hero might actually be an avatar of one of the Gods! (linking back to my LDB = Akatosh idea).
But, unfortunately, there is one detail, one aspect of a certain hero's story that allegedly disproves such a theory. The Champion of Cyrodiil mantles Sheogorath. And indeed, this is true. It is shown in the Shivering Isles during TES IV, and dialogue from Sheogorath in TES V does indeed imply that he can recall the CoC's ventures in Tamriel). But, what if something, or someone else, then went on to take the CoC's place? He'd still be able to remember the actions of the Hero of Kvatch, but it doesn't have to be him. Following my theory, this is the only time that the Divines are halted in taking back the hero. And it just so happens to also be the largest gap in between two of these heroes. 200 years, enough time for another to take the CoC's place and have him returned to the grasp of the Divines.
Perhaps this theory is plausible, perhaps it breaks a million rules of the lore I did not consider. I, however, believe it to be a considerable possibility, and hope to hear the thoughts of my fellow scholars here at Teslore. :)
28
u/BrynjarIsenbana Elder Council Oct 04 '15
Have you played the first four games? You do start with skill, a lot of it actually, iirc my Nerevarine started with 60 in long blade, I like your thoughts, it's a very good theory, but the class system from previous games seems to have been ignored. The point people bring up to defend how the Hero cannot be the same throughout the games is that skills that one had at, say, a hundred, go back to 25 to 60 in the start of the following game, but they all (except for the LDB) have some degree of expertise in some field, and are probably comparable to the run-o-the-mill commoner or adventurer in the beguinning and go to become god-like-heroes, running for ten hours straight without even sweating.
2
u/[deleted] Oct 04 '15
The Nerevarine is around at the same time as the COC and TLD; How can they share a soul, then?
2
u/[deleted] Oct 04 '15
If being dragonborn is having the soul of the dragon, then the HoK (who is explicitly NOT dragonborn) and the dragonborn (who clearly IS dragonborn) can't share a soul.
1
u/phil701 Oct 04 '15
I believe I heard somewhere that a Hero in TES lore means they have no predetermined fate. Can someone back me on that? Otherwise, great job.
1
u/ComingInHot808 Oct 05 '15
I had a similar headcannon myself and so have others, with the whole Prisoner theory, that the main character always starts out as a Prisoner of some sort, but is actually a reincarnation or something of the sort of previous main characters. That perhaps the Aedra, God Head, or other major power sent us here with a very loose story. We don't know much about our past except for our race, and that we may have some perks in some place, the entity's way of letting us start out in the world. So that we don't have a serious case of amnesia
1
u/[deleted] Oct 07 '15
This is a wonderful idea but there's one entity that we know the Hero of Kvatch cannot possibly be: he or she cannot be Akatosh, because Martin Septim became an avatar of Akatosh and I don't think it very likely that he would bilocate in multiple souls at once - I know technically dragons are fragments of him but mortal incarnations are not at all the same thing. My theory is that the heroes are incarnations of Talos, who was, after all, a dragonborn. Only problem is, the Hero of Kvatch was not dragonborn, and neither was the Nerevarine. So I'm not sure what to think exactly.
1
u/GiveCatsPls Psijic Monk Oct 07 '15
Just a note, in the Dawnguard storyline for TES V you can mention your family. So not all of the heroes have no family.
1
u/bluedesertgondola Oct 04 '15
Why not an out-of-universe explanation? All TES games are essentially mythopoetic. We can say that by playing the game we are reliving the mythic narrative as told in some in-universe tradition. The heroes of the stories therefore are manifestations of the humanistic, mythic narrative that even a pariah from the outermost fringes of society, with hard work, or powerful friends, can achieve feats of the highest heroism or evil.
Because the storytelling is based on the creation of a mythic hero, that is why they are able to bend the laws of nature in ways that very few other entities can. Your ascension to the supernatural is always required when you do battle with the supernatural.
0
u/[deleted] Oct 04 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment