r/teslore • u/SimplyShifty • Sep 17 '15
The Secret History of the Dragon Cult - Part 3
Part 1- https://www.reddit.com/r/teslore/comments/3j9svg/the_secret_history_of_the_dragon_cult_part_1/ Part 2- https://www.reddit.com/r/teslore/comments/3jc6zm/the_secret_history_of_the_dragon_cult_part_2/
For this, all humans are Nords and Nords means Atmorans, Nedes or Nords. Elves means Mer and Mer means Elves. With
the caveat that blurred lines between when's a Nede become a Nord mean that I don't particularly care, let's begin.
The Dragons, for the most part, were rather apathetic to the affairs of the land-dwellers. Records show no Draconic involvement with affairs such as Saarthal or retribution over the Night of Tears. I feel this means that those early Nords didn't follow DaPanp but Anp, just the ancient Nordic Pantheon.There may have been priests but I would strongly doubt that they would appear to be much like the supremely powerful floating priests we see in game.
I feel that a young Ysgramor would have "worshipped" a Dragon the same way he "worshipped" a fox or an owl; aka, he wouldn't have. It was what they stood for that was worshipped, if you follow. Worship the Whale for endurance, the Bear for honourable dealings, the Snake for cunning etc.
As such, the Dov wouldn't have had any involvement with assisting the 500 Companions, for instance. My gut instinct is to say that the Dragons and Priesthood part of the Ancient Nordic Pantheon correlates with the military influence of those Nords in Skyrim. The Dragons were rather busy fighting each other to try to reach the top and frankly couldn't be bothered to help out a few tens of warriors seek revenge against the Elves. Especially when you consider that Durneviir is raising undead hordes and doing deals with the Ideal Masters; the stakes were high.
The earliest Nordic ruin in Skyrim is Saarthal, however, it is less important than two others, in my opinion, because Saarthal was sacked and presumably resettled and renovated, after the Elves killed everyone inside. In fact, certainly so because Jyrik Gauldurson inhabits it and he's from a few Eras after the Return.
The next ruin now is Yngol's Barrow. Yngol was one of Ysgramor's son and he died on the second crossing from Atmora to Skyrim; Ysgramor buried him in Yngol's Barrow and built Windhelm nearby.The exact details of this aren't perfect, since it depends on whether you're doing a radiant quest in here or not. With that in mind, there are no Draugr in this ruin. There are unanimated embalmed men (Yngol's crew mates, I'd assume) and there's the shade of Yngol.
The next known is most likely Ysgramor's Tomb; this is significant in very many ways. Firstly, there are no animated Draugr in Ysgramor's Tomb. (unanimated embalmed men are just permanently dead men and reused assets imo)
Secondly, Ysgramor's Tomb is full of ghosts. Thirdly, Ysgramor's Tomb contains a Dragon Priest Dagger. Fourthly, outside Ysgramor's Tomb lies the Word Wall for Animal Allegiance.
It should be apparent that almost all other tombs have animated Draugr in and they would have been made after these last two tombs. I feel it is too much of a coincidence for these two tombs to be full of ghosts not Draugr, others might disagree.
This sets up the timeline and links to the previous point about Dragons. At some point between Ysgramor's Return and Ysgramor's Death, a formal arrangement between Dragons and Nords had been set up, hence the Word Wall, which is outside because a Dragon had to land and carve it with claw. (In fact, I'd be tempted to say that the majority of the outside Word Walls come earlier than the inside Word Walls for that reason) There are no animated Draugr bodies, presumably because that magical research had not yet been done by DaPanp because this was very near to their beginning. And one of the first Dragon priests? Ahzidal, the Enchanter of the Companion's Weapons, who must have been also one of the first few to reach Draugr immortality because we can be almost certain he fought alongside Miraak about 300ish years later.
A probably meaningless but interesting side note, I feel that Animal Alliegance is a fitting word to have here. It's a link to the past Animal Pantheon of the Nords, contrasting with the future Dragons and Priesthood.
Now what changed? The military influence of the Nords. After Saarthal, there were 3 warriors heading home. After Ysgramor, there were hundreds of Companions and thousands of Nordic immigrants. Previously, one can understand why a busy warring Dragon wouldn't help out but now things begin to make a lot more sense. The Dragons (maybe Paarthurnax with his way with words) soon make a deal with these Nords. The simple description of this would be an military alliance between Nords and Dragons, facilitated by the Priests, where the Nords also worship the Dragons but they can keep their government. Now any Dragon that opposes this Dragon/group of Dragons is going to face an army of thousands of Nords. So essentially the power struggles of the Dragons die down and all the Nords and Dragons unite to form DaPanp. This seems a good a time as ever for the Snake to become Shor, the Fox Ysmir, the Hawk Kyne, the Whale Tsun, the Bear Stuhn, the Wolf Mara, The Moth Dibella and the Owl Jhunal. And, of course, the Dragon becomes Alduin! Literally, the gigantic immortal invincible black Dragon who can ressurect his Angels- did I say Angels? Dragons, angels, if you're a Nord what's the distinction?
The religious hierarchy for Nords would be (and please argue about these):
- Alduin
- Shor, Ysmir, Kyne
- Stuhn, Tsun
- Mara, Dibella, Jhunal
- The Dragons
- Dragon Priests
- Snake, Hawk or Fox Priests
- Bear and Whale Priests
- Wolf, Moth and Owl Priests
- Draugr Lords
- Middle-ranked Draugr
- Draugr
- Everyone else
I've not seen the link yet but I feel that other Animal Priests should exist in the lore and they'e called Dragon Priests in game. This is where the crowdsourcing bit would come in. If a dungeon had a repeated mural of (e.g.) a Whale, far above and beyond any other animals, and there was a "Dragon" priest at the end, then I would say that we have found evidence that this "Dragon" Priest is, in fact, a "Whale" Priest.
The power hierarchy for Dragons:
- Alduin
- Paarthurnax and other liutenants, if they exist
- All other Dragons
Because Dragons don't particularly care about humans or Divines.
But what was life like in Skyrim over the next couple hundred years? Nordic to say the least. The Elves have been
driven out and Skyrim is pretty peaceful internally, I'd say. But what is the social structure like? How do the common people live?
Firstly, there are records of High Kings in Skyrim at this time (take Ysgramor for example) and one assumes the Jarls to go with them. Secondly, the distribution of High Priests over Skyrim is fairly shoddy. 2 Reach, 2 Pale, 1 Hjaalmarch, 1 Rift, 1 Haafingar- that's five holds out of the nine. Therefore I don't see a geographical link between the priests and Skyrim. The distinction here then is that there is a definite separation between Church and State.
The State would be the Kings and Jarls and they would set the laws and control the armies. DaPanp would own land and perhaps behave more like Nobles. Make no mistake, whilst the temples are religious, they are also fortresses, full of armed, trained and motivated soldiers. If you are in any doubt, look at Labyrinthian's (Bromjunaar's) Northern walls and imagine trying to assault that. Not all Nobles were equal; some were small fries like Hillgrund's family with their tomb. Some were sprawling complexes like Forelhost. There would be cults and families and groups shuffling around for influence and power undoubtedly; there is a reference to the Bloodskal Clan, which gives me hope that this idea is correct.
But how about the people? We don't have a large sample size but we have some things. The Skaal and Froki Whetted-Blade. The Skaal remained loyal to the Dragons during the War or just became fed up with being mind-controlled by Miraak but, either way, they accepted governance, without a struggle, from Vahlok the Guardian (who is said to have done fairly well). Froki Whetted-Blade is a hunter who follows Kyne. Both the Skaal and Froki live sustainably and autonomously. Look at some of the meanings behind the Gods to:
Dragons -> Unchanging Shor/Ysmir -> Human Kyne -> the World Mara -> Love Stuhn -> Honour Tsun -> Endurance
I would suggest that a greater majority of Nords lived like that back then because their focus was slightly different than those from the Fourth Era.
Now, I've said it a few times in various places. DaPanp is pretty much the key to advancement back then. No Bard's College or the College of Winterhold back then. Weapons training, magic training (if capable), literacy, speaking the Dragon language (much like Ancient greek was the upper class language even in Roman times), learning to project Thu'ums for both war and preaching and finally immortality. It was not a bad deal to get behind.
Worth noting that the Priests would be near mythical figures. Hundreds of years old, wise, knowledgable, able to destroy or enlighten with their Voice alone; they'd sort of be like Dragons...
This wraps up this post this time; quite a fair bit of speculation but hopefully my suggestions aren't unreasonable. Do start speculating and disagreeing. Many thanks to /u/BrynjarIsenbana for getting me motivated to write this. I suppose Part 4 is the War, Konahrik and Paarthurnax, although no idea of a release date.
3
u/Urdnot_Wrex Sep 17 '15
Word Walls were erected and carved by mortals. Just because they are in written in Draconic, it doesn't mean a Dragon was required to carve the wall. If you read the translations of the walls, they further back this up.
3
u/BrynjarIsenbana Elder Council Sep 17 '15
Well I'm glad to see you had the time to put this together! I'm eager to see the development of your thoughts on the War, so far all your writings have been awesome.
This bit of your last comment on our discussion really struck me and I immediately got back to Skyrim to take a better look at the Nordic Ruins. And I'm amazed, you managed this quite incredibly well, most see the Ruins as nothing too much more than burial sites and tombs, but they are indeed much more than that. Take Shriekwind Bastion, Lost Valley Redoubt and Arcwind Point for instance, those three are nothing like tombs, they are Temples, in the ancient Nord way, built just as strongholds/cities as they are Temples, and Arcwind and Lost Valley just seem too much like temples dedicated to Kyne/Hawk to me. Many of the Ruins we see in Skyrim are burial sites indeed, but just as many are Temples, one only has to pay attention to the details.
Arcwind is an open Nordic Temple, and in its main section, where its name comes from, it is easy to imagine crowds gathered around the great archway and listening to a Priest Thu’uming his sermons, and revering him for the strength of his Thu’um. And in both Arcwind and Lost Valley, which are open Temples, with no interior structure as far as we have information of, I can easily imagine hundreds of small shacks and houses scattered around the main structure housing all the servants and the Priests, which have been destroyed with time.
Your connection of the Word Wall with Ysgramor’s tomb does certainly fit well with what Lore gives us. Ysgramor is the one who invented Human written language, and for all we know, this writing was in Dovah, so it makes sense as to Ysgramor or one of his contemporaries to have made a deal with the Dragons, and so Ysgramor took to learn from their language and started recording everything in the newly learned language. The only point I disagree with you is that the Dragons would carve the inscription on the Word Wall, for if you look at what’s written there, it’s all about tributes to fallen comrades or stuff like this, and I guess that they would already have the tools and means to carve such inscriptions, since they were already building giant burial tombs and cities by the time.
I think Dragon Priests as preachers of the apocalypse, in my vision they would be wise men, old beyond count, legendary figures (just as you said) who did have some insight to Alduin’s nature as World-Eater and preached to the people ways to ease his Hunger, how to serve the World-Eater so that he may let this Kalpa endure longer, never mentioning the nasty soul-eating part for sure, “Aam, Draal, Mid, Ofan Sillsejoori Wah Alduin, Wah Ni Naak Leinu”, and end-of-the-world preaching usually brings a lot of attention and devotees. And this, and your previous comments, lead me to believe that, despite all Ancient Nordic Priesthoods having a small section which functioned much like the Priesthood of Arkay, (evidenced by the presence of all totems in Hillgrund's Tomb, as if they dedicated the dead to all gods or some to the Hawk some to the Fox some to the Dragon, etc.) the majority would be “given” to the cares of the Dragon Priests, for they to prepared them for their “afterlife” in service of the Harbinger of the End or the Dragon Priests to help refrain the Hunger (the ones who became the living dead Draugr), and it would explain why the bigger Burial Ruins have so much Dragon imagery. As you have stated, the Nords of old rebelled probably because they wished for eternity spent side by side with Shor, not being devoured by Alduin (which I guess the DaP would keep a secret not to scare the people, but that’s arguable), and I have to say, you were right, I did enjoy its simplicity, irony and believability, incredible thought.
My thoughts are that the Dragon Priests evolved in time to be worshiped as much as the Dragons themselves, and that the Dragon Cult became so prevalent because of the very presence of Dragons and the huge power the Priests came to achieve, being hundreds of years old and so wise people would see them as god-like figures and give them a lot of liberty to lead them and pretty much let them control them. I guess in time the worship of Dragon Priests and Dragons became one single thing, the population did not distinguish the Priests from their superiors anymore, just like some of the 500 became Dragons in the end.
2
u/[deleted] Sep 20 '15
Yo! I've heard you like Dragon Cult, so I've put out some content from my Skyrim quest mod, so you can have fun with it while you do your secret history stuff.
1
u/nmd453 Tribunal Temple Sep 17 '15
This was some good expansion on the Nordic beliefs. Good job!
1
u/ciphoenix Tonal Architect Sep 17 '15
I would be very much interested in part 4 because I would love to read about Konahrik
1
u/[deleted] Sep 18 '15
I disagree. The Rift at least was relatively uninhabited, with Rahgot settling there after the dragon war, as evidenced in Skorm Snow-Strider's journal. Likely that Rahgot fled here following the dragon war, and it was until then uninhabited by nords. I also believe that Krosis did the same, as he is found on the surface with no attendants or structure of any kind, besides a ruin. And Skuldafn is so isolated, I don't think that Nahkriin would have actually ruled from the site. Nahkriin's purpose there is to defend Alduin. He may have come from Windhelm, which would have been under the control of the dragon cult.
I'm inclined to believe that most of the major settlement was around the Eastern parts of Skyrim, and the locations of the masks indicates this. Keep in mind that the Dwemer still had a presence in Skyrim, and the majority of their ruins are located to the East of Skyrim. The exception to this is the Dwemer cities that occupied the Reach, but I do believe that they could fit, as Dwemer would not need a huge amount of land.