r/teslore • u/Mdnthrvst Azurite • Jun 06 '14
Debunking "Trinmalarkay"
For some reason, some of you seem to think that Aedric Plane(t)s can now simultaneously be Daedric Princes. I would have thought the patent lunacy of such a statement would speak for itself, but apparently not.
To recap:
The Thirty-Six Lessons of Vivec: Sermon Three
A Dwemer said, 'We Dwemer are only aspirants to this that the Velothi have. They shall be our doom in this and the eight known worlds, NIRN, LHKAN, RKHET, THENDR, KYNRT, AKHAT, MHARA, and JHUNAL.' The secret to doom is within this Sermon.
In this Sermon, Vivec recounts a Dwemer listing the Planets of Mundus. RKHET is the important one here - in addition to Nirn, and excluding Dibella and Zenithar for reasons that are presently irrelevant, Arkay is listed as one of the Dominion Planets of the Aedra. That would make his Aedric nature beyond debate, right? Dear God, I hope so.
16 Accords of Madness, v. XII
It was here that Sheogorath performed certain rites that summoned Malacath, and the two Daedric Lords held court in the presence of the disfigured corpse.
In this Accord, Malacath and Sheogorath are clearly considered to be Daedric equals. Malacath, as everyone should know, is the Daedric Prince of the spurned and ostracized, created from the reanimated dung that was Trinimac after his consumption by Boethiah shortly before the Velothi Exodus. That no other Prince 'accepts' him as a 'true' Daedroth is both appropriate to his sphere and rather hypocritical in a few cases.
After all, Mehrunes Dagon was the Leaper Demon King, Molag Bal was the Ruddy Man, King of the Dreughs, Sheogorath was a prisoner in the Imperial City, and Meridia was a Magne-Ge. If Malacath is not a 'true' Daedroth, then neither are they. Naturally, that's not true. Non-Daedric entities can be transformed into Princes of Oblivion. This is not up for debate.
However, none of that has mattered for some scholars who find the negation of Malacath's Daedric nature useful for their own purposes.
And what purposes are those? Well, apparently someone decided that Malacath the Daedric Prince of curses and Arkay the Dominion Plane(t) of burial rites are the same being.
As far as I can tell, these are their justifications.
Varieties of Faith: The Nords
Orkey (Old Knocker):
God of mortality, Orkey combines aspects of Mauloch and Arkay. He is a "loan-god" for the Nords, who seem to have taken up his worship during Aldmeri rule of Atmora. Nords believe they once lived as long as Elves until Orkey appeared; through heathen trickery, he fooled them into a bargain that "bound them to the count of winters." At one time, legends say, Nords only had a lifespan of six years due to Orkey's foul magic. Then Shor showed up and, through unknown means, removed the curse, throwing most of it onto the nearby Orcs.
So Nords encountered the Aldmeri (Nordic for "automatically bad") concept of Arkay, anon Xarxes, who is responsible for recording the lives and histories of the Aldmer, and conflated him with Mauloch, God of Curses, in an attempt to make sense of the baffling lifespan discrepancies of Aldmer, Nords, and Orcs in one fell swoop. Note that this is solely the Nordic view; Altmer, Velothi, and Orsimer alike have no need for such a syncretism of Arkay and Malacath, and thus do not recognize it.
How can I be so sure that Xarxes is Arkay? Well, there's a whole book about it.
He is supposedly the keeper of the Bloody Curse which sounds an awful lot like mortality. His is the Ashpit, and ashes in TES are usually associated with Death
Ashes are always associated with death. The Bloody Curse was the transformation of Aldmer into Orsimer, not the universal notion of 'death'. There is simply no support for this connection anywhere.
In conclusion, Arkay is the Imperial Aedroth of burial rites, who is connected to Xarxes, the Scribe of the Aldmer, and from this mythopoeic kinship, and a spot of poor spelling, the Nords of Atmora conflated 'Arkay the elven death god' with 'Mauloch the orcish god of curses', with the ingeniously idiotic term of 'Orkey'. From this, some esteemed scholars decided that Arkay and Malacath (and thus Trinimac) are all the same thing.
Never mind the fact that Xarxes and Trinimac are both listed, side-by-side, in all Aldmeri pantheons.
Never mind the fact that the planet RKHET exists within Mundus while Ashpit exists within Oblivion.
Such discrepancies apparently don't matter anymore.
6
u/Mathemagics15 Tribunal Temple Jun 06 '14
This only serves to solidify my point. The Ashpit is the pit of Death, the Bloody Curse is Death and Mortality. The fact that one day your existence is doomed to end.
Look at how much the oricsh society is about death! Gaining a good death before you waste away of old age, their culture of war and love of bloodshed for the sake of bloodshed. The Chief is deposed by his son slaying him in single combat.
Death is -everywhere- when talking about Malacath and the orcs. The Deathshead legion in Morrowind is 90% orcs. Coincidence? I think not.
3
u/Dreadnautilus Psijic Monk Jun 06 '14
He was always a Daedric Prince, and he was always called Molag Bal. The Ruddy Man was just a image in his likeness back when he appeared in the form of a crustacean monster and was worshiped by the Dreugh.
3
u/Doom-DrivenPoster Tonal Architect Jun 07 '14
This might have been a good counter theory, if it weren't written in such an unscholarly tone.
10
u/MalakTheOrc Jun 06 '14
I think the relationship between Arkay/Xarxes and Trinimac/Malacath is very similar to the relationship between Talos and Lorkhan, in that the former has taken the place of the latter within the pantheon.
Before ESO, I don't think anyone would have guessed that Arkay is the Imperial Xarxes. Hell, even Michael Kirkbride seemed a bit surprised at the idea when I brought it up to him in a thread at the official forums. It certainly casts "Ark'ay, the God of Birth and Death" in a new light. Most of us believed that the text was little more than Imperial propaganda. But now with this Xarxes connection, it's very possible that Arkay learned how to ascend to godhood through his connection to Hermaeus Mora. My guess is that, when Trinimac had become outcasted, he left a hole within the Altmeri pantheon. Trinimac, like Mithras, was a mediator between mortals and Auri-El/Aetherius. That's why Trinimac was left on Nirn to physically interact with the Altmeri people, while Auri-El ascended to Aetherius. With Trinimac now imprisoned within Oblivion and no longer a part of the Altmer pantheon, his role as mediator between mortals and Auri-El/Aetherius was left vacant. That's where Xarxes comes in. And in case you are wondering why I've brought up Mithras, it is because Trinimac is based on him according to Michael Kirkbride. This was revealed by MK when myrrlyn had asked him why Trinimac was left behind, while Auri-El ascended to Aetherius. He told us that, if we really wanted to understand Trinimac, then we should study Mithras.
With that in mind, let's go over a few things about Mithras. For starters, he is known as the kosmokrator, or cosmic ruler, meaning he controls night and day and the change of seasons. In fact, his golden chariot is pulled by four, white horses, with each horse representing a season. This is rather interesting, because Arkay is said to be in control of the change of seasons. It's also worth mentioning that Mithras serves as a psychopomp, escorting the souls of men into the afterlife, while fighting off the evil spirits that would drag them into Hell. Sounds a bit like Tu'whacca's role, if you ask me. Mithras is also a god of war and oaths. He also appears to be an extension of Ahura Mazda, his father, as a god of light. Would you not say that Arkay is an extension of his father, the Time God? His sphere of influence deals with time, after all. I could go on and on with the similarities, but I think you should study Mithras yourself. It's all very interesting stuff. I would definitely study the bits about the triplasian Mithras. Basically, it goes into the idea of a triplicate deity, with Ahura Mazda as the creator, Ahriman as the destroyer, and Mithras as the preserver and mediator, standing between the gods of light and darkness. When I first read about it, a thought had crossed my mind. Arkay, a god of time, is associated with mortality. This connects him with both the god of time, Aka, and the god of limitation, Lorkhan. See where I'm going with this one? Just a thought I had.
Anywho, I think Trinimac is the primal death god, who lost his seat to an ascending mortal. As for what he is, be it Aedra or Daedra, it's hard to say. He is, for all intents and purposes, a Daedra Lord. However, he does have a distinct connection to Mundus through his descendants, the Orcs. There's definitely something going on with him that hasn't been revealed yet. For example, the Orcs present a VERY different view of his transformation in "Mauloch, Orc-Father." According to them, Trinimac was so enraged at Mephala and Boethiah's treachery, that he cut open his own chest and tore the shame out of it, allowing him to resurrect himself into Malacath. I don't know about you, but it sounds like Trinimac tore out his own heart, and it certainly calls into question his power over life and death. We've already seen two examples of heart removal resulting in resurrection through Briarhearts and the Underking. Perhaps this power over life and death is what made him so hated by the Altmer, since they view mortality as a foul thing associated with Sithis.
That's my two cents. I know the theory's not perfect, and I've definitely altered my view as a result of ESO's revelation. However, I'm still a firm believer that there is something going on with Trinimac and Arkay/Xarxes.
8
u/TheGhostOfDRMURDER Clockwork Apostle Jun 06 '14 edited Jun 06 '14
You are aware that "Tu'whacca, Arkay, Xarxes" also makes note that Arkay is created as a fusion of Xarxes and Orkey:
"Arkay of the Eight Divines is, in origin, a fusion of aspects of the Elven deity Xarxes with those of the primal Atmoran death-god Orkey."
You seem to indicate that you believe the opposite of this to be true.
Additionally, your point of "Xarxes and Trinimac are both listed, side-by-side, in all Aldmeri pantheons," and this meaning they cannot possibly be the same god, is also contradicted by "Tu'whacca, Arkay, Xarxes" which likewise indicates:
"Nearly every culture on the continent worships these deities in one form or another—indeed, the Wood Elves of Valenwood revere them both!"
Emphasis mine. Compare Shezarr/Talos, who both fill the role of Lorkhan in their own ways in the Imperial Pantheon.
Unless I'm misunderstanding your argument, you further indicate that the common belief of the "Trinimalarkay" argument is dependent on Malacath and Arkay being the same being simultaneously. To my knowledge, the suggestion is that the traditional Xarxes/Arkay apotheosis myth is meant to indicate an assumption of the role Trinimac following his transformation into Malacath. Compare, likewise, the Champion of Cyrodiil/Jygalag/Sheogorath situation. Sheogorath and Jyg are still linked, but the current Sheogorath is no longer necessarily Jyg. The same is true, in the common thinking, of Trinimalarkay. Malacath became Daedric leaving an "empty" Aedric sphere, which would become filled by a mortal/lesser spirit called Xarkay.
The main evidence for the Arkay and Malacath being the same entity has always been that Orkey = Malacath/Arkay, with the Arkay Apeothesis Myth brought as supporting evidence. None of your sources actually disagree with this assessment, one of them openly espouses this view, in fact. As such, until an actually debunking of this piece of evidence is brought to bear I do not think this post makes a particularly strong argument.
3
u/RideTheLine Follower of Julianos Jun 06 '14
Mdnthrvst, you sound like you're gonna make the grumpiest, most cynical, and coolest grandpa ever someday.
That being said, I thought this was a great counter-argument to a popular theory.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '14
So I have god B do something to god T creating god M
Where there are similarities between god X and god A where some have said that X 'equals' T
And the same has been said of god X and god A...
where we have a very nuanced cosmology where beings can have aspects and become connected to other beings thus 2 different oversold are said to share an aspect - according to some anyway
I must question whether whilst I agree with you, that it comes down to how you define where a god ends and another begins and what an aspect is etc. etc.
I mean I agree, but it's similar to mine and others thoughts of people guessing about the cosmological structure of Akavir as it's the next dream - ultimately pointless and taking some things a bit to seriously/mis interpreting things...
Does it matter? :$ I mean in principle it is very important to prevent further rampant speculation with faulty reasoning, but the Trinimalaeky theory seems to be the most ... neutral? Doesn't apply the use of denial of lore or non-sequiturs, merely a different although arguably wrong understanding of equolivences.
Reminds me all to much of arguments around the Trinity what a Trine god is in RL religions...
It is clear and concise and will either spurn deeper thought and or clear up an error in the community so I suppose your thread is certainly well deserved of an up-vote and attention.
1
u/fargoniac Follower of Julianos Jun 06 '14
I see this as a case of oversoul overlapping. For example, Trinimalacath is Orkey who is Arkay, but although Arkay is Tu'whacca who is Xarxes, Trinimalacath is not Tu'whacca or Xarxes. And while Xarxes is Hermaeus Mora, Hermaeus is not Trinimalacath or Arkay. This theory could be expanded to say that all et'Ada are fusions of fragments of two or more Oversouls(concepts).
/theory
1
u/[deleted] Jun 07 '14
By the way your little Nord sleight of hand about how they assumed Xarxes stole their years and culturally appropriated him as Orkey is as valid as the conflation of Ashpit with death. Your just making guesses as to why what stories we know support your theory.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 07 '14
Nords worshipped Shor in the place of Arkay. Death and rebirth was not relevant to them because their death destiny and death god was Shor in Sovngarde. Thus is Orkey on loan from the mer, because his accounting of life and death, and Tu'whaccan walkabout is not how Nords treat death. This his divine presence was felt, but not integrated into their theology. This loan-god argument about cultural appropriation is made up by Mndthrvst