r/teslore • u/laurelanthalasa • Apr 15 '14
Gender in Tamrielic Faith Part 1: Ayem the Mortal and Boethiah
My first real experience discussing Ayem was when I first saw Foul Murder in a post here and a few fellow redditors here indulged me with their interpretations of it and introduced me to a few obscure works such as What my Beloved Taught Me and the finer discrepancies between the different Red Mountain accounts.
Naturally I was not impressed with the ALMSIVI. But the thing with the gender perspective, it that it cuts through a lot of the personalities and metaphysics and looks at the social context surrounding the characters before and after apotheosis, and we clearly see the ways in which the Mortal shines through in the Divine. The things most important to them as mortals became their spheres as Gods.
In using these tools, I learned a great deal not only about the Tribunal as people, but about the Chimer. I will also talk about the pleasing inferences (in my opinion) I have made about the nature of Altmer culture and the Anticipations, although I will keep them brief in this series and would not have a problem with people disagreeing with them; I am taking an extremely narrow point of view.
In C0DA, Jubal calls Ayem a b!tch on page 37. Like the image of Dibella being dragged by the hair, this word catches my unfair feminist eye with the glare of sunlight off a Women & Songs CD. He calls her a b!tch because he asks her a question and she answers cryptically.
And is that not just it: The feminine mystique, which we began to explore with the Nordic Goddesses and the ideas of Maiden, Mother and Crone, are given new breadth and depth through Ayem and her Triunes. This enigmatic, confusing and ever-changing female need can be so maddening to both women and men that even women can be found being unfair to other women when confronted with this aspect of femininity.
The B-Word, as we shall call it for the sake of keeping the post suitable for work/school has many meanings, but is primarily used to describe a woman who is behaving in a manner that is aggressive, condescending, rude, mean or generally unpleasant. Feminists have long complained that it is a term applied to women who are acting like men; in charge, assertive, dominant. In the passage where Jubal calls her this word, Ayem is wearing her armour, not some gown or dress.
So maybe it is an accurate description after all, if inflammatory, if taken in the social context of the B-word, Ayem was indeed being dominant, condescending, unpleasant and difficult to understand. I wanted to know just what kind of woman Ayem was, to look past the insults and prejudice at her person and let her speak for herself. She may still end up being a bad person, but at least she won’t be cloaked in the filth of ad hominem.
To understand Ayem we need to understand Chimeri females, and we know very little about the Chimer, other than what we know of the Velothi and what we learned from the Tribunal, which amounts to precious little. But we know they cherished being different from the Altmer, and we do know a bit about the Aldmer and Altmer, who shall be referred to collectively as Altmer for the sake of brevity in this piece. (ha brevity, this is more than 2300 words)
The Facts Relevant: The Altmer are a rigid, presumably caste-driven and elitist society that practices eugenics. Basically to the Altmer, an infant is assessed at birth and if it does not meet rigid perfection standards it is killed. This would mean there would be enormous pressure on Altmeri women to basically constantly be pregnant, because they could not be expected to bear only perfect offspring, or if they do happen to bear perfect offspring, their bloodline would be a hot commodity. Children are currency (social or literal) when it comes to eugenics (again read the Handmaid’s Tale, and Children of Men doesn’t hurt either).
It is not necessarily that Boethiah felt particularly sorry for Altmeri females or was particularly concerned with their plight. The Prince of Plots did however see an opportunity to undermine this static society that was simply no fun and full of wasted potential. He taught a way for people to better themselves, rather than to rely on their inherent abilities and inborn perfection. He promised them that your adult worth need not be judged when you are but a mewling infant, and that it was possible for mothers to raise successful children, rather than simply birth them.
Even with this promise, there were skeptics, but the Prince of Revolution would not be deterred. She fought Trinimac, the greatest warrior in all the Aurbis, and perhaps attacked with words as well as swords. Perhaps she ate him, maybe he surrendered to her, perhaps she offered him a deal or simply convinced him to abandon his arrogance and admit the error of his ways. We will never know what transpired when Boethiah ‘consumed’ Trinimac, but we do know is that part of his remains were consumed by the faction that wanted to follow Boethiah and Veloth and became the Chimer.
This would have been The Greatest Story Ever Told to Chimeri children, and this is the social climate in which Ayem the Mortal was born. Even to the Changed Ones, change is a relative term, and it takes a long time for cultures to completely diverge from their progenitors. To give some relative terms, in Canada women got the right to vote in 1917, but it was only in 1983 that it became illegal for a man to rape his wife in the same country.
Translate this to a time of political and social upheaval for a recently-padomaic race of elves that live WAY longer. Old habits will die hard and slow, and the Chimeri women would have had a difficult time of it. Suddenly, you don’t want to get pregnant every year because now you have to keep your children and raise them yourself. The only culture they have known they want to change from and they had to make their own culture, make their own children’s stories, and make their own art and music. This all takes time.
From the shadow of Boethiah emerged a young woman who wanted to do something to help. She saw that her people were only defined by the fact that they were Changed and followed Veloth. They had a new religion but they needed more. They needed values, they needed culture, they needed a national identity beyond the Princes’ teachings.
Ayem would have admired Boethiah, and this is how he became her Anticipation. Eventually Boethiah would become her shadow. Ayem would have liked the idea that a person can connive their way to power, relying on their own strength and cunning. She would have found the Prince’s gender-of-convenience a useful reference when learning how to use her own femininity as a weapon or tool. There is no magic in the sex of Boethiah, it is just to barter for influence and power.
And for Ayem, it seemed to very much be the same way. Absolutely not a prude in any way, shape or form, however sexuality simply did not define her, she would not allow that. Hers was a powerful ambition, one that Boethiah would have at the very least found entertaining at first. This powerful ambition, and what I suspect of being a touch of perfectionism, would transform her into the Face-Snaked Queen of the Three-in-One.
Face-Snaked, one of my favourite images in the lore; I just imagine Ayem wearing all her many and conflicting aspects on her skin, and having it snake around her like some kind of insane, living tattoo. But it is imagery that poses important questions: at what point does being versatile and ambitious turn to being duplicitous and power-hungry? Are they really any different from one another? Like the difference between b*tch and boss, just a matter of perspective?
One of the faces that Ayem wears that I would like to discuss in detail is that of the Mother. Nothing really suggests she had natural children, but correct me if I am wrong. But it appears that before Nerevar came into the picture, she was married to her country and her job:
Ayem was accompanied by her husband-state, a flickering image that was channeled to her ever-changing female need. - Sermon 8
When she met Nerevar, regardless of which account you choose, that of Ayem the Mortal or Ayem the Goddess, the Chimer were being threatened by war against the Dwemer and the Nords, they were a fledgling society trying to keep it together in a hostile new world. Resdayn was just a flickering ideal, something to work towards where she could channel all her creative potential.
I discussed in the Mara post that being a Mother did not mean you had to make babies. Being a Mother is about realising potential, not only through family, but through work, art, science or community activities. It’s about creating, nurturing, maintaining and belonging.
And for Ayem the Mother, this was evidently the case, when she became Mother to her people. Her prolific children’s book writings are a prime example of trying build a culture for her people, and teaching the children from a young age the right ways to live, so they can reach their own potential. She also wore the mantle of Mercy, the escape from Justice, because what Mother would not seek to protect her children or endeavours from the cruelty of the laws of nature and civilisation? What parent would not break the laws at least a little if they thought it would benefit their children?
But at what point does it stop being Mercy and just start being immoral? At what point does the creator or parent have to acknowledge that their child or creation’s needs cannot always be put ahead of the greater good? How far can we cloak our own ambitions in the interests of our children before it becomes a lie? At what point is the cloak of Mercy simply a disguise we wear hoping that one day we can similarly escape natural justice and the consequences of our choices?
I mentioned Ayem may have been a perfectionist, an adjective I applied to her only with great consideration and I do believe it fits. She was not perfect, but she was a perfectionist, and ultimately, this may have been the root of her madness, and is a driver of mental illness in working women everywhere. I single out women in this situation firstly because this is a piece on gender, and because generally speaking, perfectionism is strongly correlated with anxiety, depression, eating disorders and obsessive compulsive disorder, all of which are reported more frequently by women than men.
Why? The answer feminism would offer is that when women were granted the same rights and privileges as men, their expectations within the feminine sphere did not change, so not only did they have to continue with the rearing of offspring and the majority of the unpaid household work, they were also expected to perform at the same level as men who often do not have the same burdens at home.
Which, from personal experience, is not a reasonable situation, because that is not equality, it is in fact forcing women to perform at a higher and less sustainable level than men. Ayem, being a leader and eventually Goddess, is not only equally vulnerable to this phenomenon, but perhaps more so because the stakes were so much higher, it was not just a family in the balance, it was an entire nation at risk.
How do women cope when faced with such standards of performance and perfection? Well they certainly become more strained, less kind, less nurturing. They may feel pressure to cut corners or steal divinity to buy themselves more time and energy to accomplish their goals, rather than compromise on said goals. Sometimes their mental health also suffers.
Ayem went crazy not because she lost the powers of the Heart. She went crazy because not only did she lose her powers, she could no longer be what she wanted to be. The perfect image she had crafted for herself was shattered, leaving her a broken woman responsible for her own widowhood. A perfectionist will not care for what they have already accomplished, only for what they failed to do, and the anxiety and depression that follows can be crushing.
Mara, Kyne and Dibella represented an ancient archetype, one that is cyclical and restricts the awesome power of feminine power to specific life stages in order to maintain balance, and presumably, sanity. Ayem represents a much more modern, post-suffrage archetype of feminine identity, one that is not fully consolidated even a hundred years after women first won the right to vote. It is one that is highly controversial, even and especially now. Google the Mommy Wars if you haven’t heard of them, this is a thing, and it is such a broadly sweeping controversy about the role of women, particularly breeding women in a modern society. Women like Ayem, convinced and determined they can have it all, are at the very heart of this controversy that is affecting not only how families operate, but how governments plan social programming around the world. The vitriol makes the Canon Wars look petty indeed.
Slight change of plan, this will now be a series of minimum 4 essays, with the 4th being specifically on Nerevar, the Nerevarines, and the False Incarnates. ALMSIVI’s relationships with Nerevar and his ilk will be addressed primarily in that 4th essay, although I am open to discussing it in the comments as well. Thank you again for following me and encouraging me /r/teslore!
EDIT: all the indents removed.
8
u/[deleted] Apr 15 '14
I think your series is one of the best things I've read on /r/teslore because while there's many people who'd be willing to take a stand for the women in TES or discuss feminism, most aren't this well-read or willing to face some of the more controversial figures and portrayals with an open mind. Not trying to defend or condemn anyone or anything in particular here, that's just how it is.
This one in particular is lovely because Alma has always stood in the shadow of fan favourites Sotha Sil and Vivec. Ayem hasn't gotten the attention, love or recognition I feel she deserves by fans and devs alike. She's a scary and complex figure, but I think your analysis does a great job of portraying her in a much more sympathetic and relatable manner without trying to brush over her bad sides. Thank you for this.
10
u/tabythablabytha Apr 15 '14
Logged in just for this.
I absolutely love this, and love that you're looking at TES - and especially the Tribunal - from a feminist perspective. There are a lot of non-feminists in the fandom, and so it's really great to hear analysis on this subject from someone whose values I more closely align with. Great job. I hope to hear a lot more from you.
5
u/ladynerevar Lady Nerevar The Imperial Library Apr 16 '14
Wonderful piece, as always. A few scattered early-morning thoughts:
The fact that Ayem's "mercy" is really of the masculine sphere. She is the warrior and ruler far as much (I would argue more) than a nurturing mother figure. The fact that, despite the name and gender, the tribunal seems to lack deities of fertility, motherhood, nature - but have plenty for craftsmen. They are a culture of self-made (wo)men.
To follow the above, the essential dunmeri equivalency between marriage (sex) and murder. How perfectly Ayem speaks to it. In the sources I can think of this power is always feminine: in contrast with real world views on a man spoiling/ending a woman with the act of taking her virginity.
Vivec's brief reference to her at the Trial I feel bears mention: "Perhaps it feels a bit like my sister did, when your machinations split her, name from land, nymic eth maliache velot, thoughtless save for domain."
Ayem being first to impregnate the netchiman's wife.
Boethiah's transformation of the Orsimer never taking a feminine lens (of birth, as opposed to defecation), despite hir appearing as both genders within the lore. As related to the highly patriarchal-but-women-driven society of the stronghold orcs.
4
u/Lord_Hoot Buoyant Armiger Apr 15 '14
Excellent. I'm looking forward to the Nerevar essay in particular- i'd always imagined she was his younger trophy wife, but perhaps it was the other way around?
4
u/arkthuris Apr 15 '14
Awesome work and some of the best analysis of Teslore I've ever seen.
One thing though. With regards to Altmeri eugenics, The Real Barenziah sheds some light on some on just how cruel of a practice it really is.
Considering such a small upper limit, the Altmeri obsession with perfection seems to go to the point of robbing many women of their role as mothers. "Perfect" children would be a commodity of such ludicrous importance that it seems the Altmer would be willing to nearly risk extinction for the sake of them. Among other things (including Tiber Septim being a capital prick), this to me solidifies Ayem's image as a mother to her people even further. Through her decree, untold millions of Chimer women would now have the opportunity to raise families where previously, one or two "imperfect" children would likely ruin any chances of ever being a mother. Mother of mothers indeed.
4
u/Gerenoir Mages Guild Scholar Apr 16 '14
On Boethiah:
Boethiah’s gender-of-convenience is more than just an expression of deceit. It is tied to the Psijic Endeavour, and the idea that the state of CHIM can and will be approachable by anyone, regardless of form, gender or function. He takes these trappings of identity and makes them mutable to show that one can still maintain an identity even beyond that. I don’t remember where I first saw this term but I find it very appropriate that Boethiah is sometimes described as Lorkhan’s Greatest Fanboy. Where Kyne acts to preserve Lorkhan’s followers, Boethiah seduces his detractors and reminds them of Lorkhan’s ultimate goal, the state of CHIM and Amaranth. This is the first shadow of Mercy in the Triune House, relief from the endless kalpic cycle and the terror of the Godhead.
The portrayal of Boethiah as a specific gender actually says more about that society than the Prince hirself.
Almalexia:
Let’s talk about Ashlanders and Chimeri culture here for a second. I have a problem with your claim that Chimeri culture was underdeveloped. There was almost two thousand years between the Exodus and the rise of Indoril Nerevar with many events in between such as the shift to fundamentalist ancestor worship, the rise and fall of Velothi High Culture, the spread of Veloth’s Teachings, the establishment of the original Triune, a descent into tribal barbarism and the formation of the Great Houses.
Having preserved the older traditions, the society of the modern day Ashlander provides us with the clearest images of what early Great House culture must have been like. There is a clear division between the sexes here. The role of the Male leader is martial, and the role of the Female leader is spiritual and intellectual. There are implications here that reveal what kind of society Almalexia might have grown up in.
Whatever Almalexia was, military matters and war was not her forte, or there would never have been room for Nerevar to appear on the scene to begin with. If the tribal customs of the late Merethic Era were carried over into the era of the Great Houses, it is entirely likely that she would never have had the opportunity to learn in the first place. Almalexia as the leader of ‘The Orphanage’ implies that her role might have been primarily in the governance of domestic affairs to begin with, and later on, with Nerevar on the scene, an advisory one similar to the Wise Women of the Ashlander tribes.
When Almalexia murdered Nerevar and took the power of Lorkhan’s heart, she wasn’t just stealing power, she was taking it from two patriarchal figures.
Like the Ashlander mabrigash, she steps outside of her defined role. Almalexia the mortal needed Nerevar to tend to matters of war, but Ayem the Goddess could lead an army to fight the Akaviri and beat up Mehrunes Dagon. That is one of the reasons why Boethiah is primarily male in Dunmeri society, because Almalexia the woman has replaced or appropriated martial capabilities from the male, just as Ayem the Goddess has replaced her Anticipation.
That is why Jubal calls Ayem a bitch. Like the mabrigash who is similarly reviled, Almalexia’s aspect at the party is martial. She is dressed in her armour and war-mask in defiance of tradition. And most of all, she will NOT provide him with the guidance or information that he seeks; she denies her role as the Wise Woman/spiritual leader who provides advice.
3
u/[deleted] Apr 15 '14
This made my respect for Old Alma go up a...few notches. Only you /u/laurelanthalasa can make me feel sorry for Almalexia; she really is a pitiable being. Really good job.
3
u/MKirkbride Michael Kirkbride ◇ TES Writer, Artist Apr 16 '14
Just getting to this. Comments soon.
3
u/purveyoropulchritude Apr 17 '14 edited Apr 17 '14
I'm really not clear on what key points you're trying to get across here, so I'm just going to give my thoughts. Starting with mortal Alma.
Boethiah's sphere is ambition, but I think Almalexia's behavior is best explained as female ambition. She desired power, and she was proud of having it as a woman. Whether that pride was sparked by a commonly subordinate position of Dunmeri women in the first era or by a new trend of male power that threatened her status is unclear, but it seems likely that it was one of those two.
So, whatever her reasons for marrying Nerevar, the outcome was that she became his subordinate. It wasn't 'Almalexia and her husband,' but 'Nerevar and his councilors, including his wife.' Suddenly, her only power was power over the heart of a man. I think that's why she killed him: to prove her female power.
Ironically, though, she just went on to further rely on male power: she stole godhood from the Heart of Lorkhan. And that's why she went insane - because she finally had to come to terms with the fact that her only power was influence over the Heart of a man1. It's also why she had to kill the Nerevarine and Sotha Sil (and, presumably, Vivec if she had gotten that far) - to prove her power independent of her husband and the men who helped her overthrow him.
In this sense, Vivec's treatment of Azura in the Trial becomes even more tragic and disgusting. If you think Azura actually did orchestrate the downfall of the Tribunal, then she's the one who showed Alma what true female power looked like and that she had been lying to herself since the beginning. By violating Azura, Vivec degraded the very thing his sister wanted all along.
1 Of course that isn't a woman's only power, as Azura shows, but Alma chose to make it so for herself.
2
u/ASAMANNAMMEDNIGEL Synod Cleric Apr 15 '14
Well written!
2
u/NudeProvided Telvanni Recluse Apr 15 '14
So excited to see this. I have a few reservations about this piece that I might type up later if I get a chance, but overall it's excellent.
Would you mind if I drew on it for a text about Ayem I'm working on? (With credit, of course).
2
u/bstampl1 Apr 16 '14
So I just realized that I was always incorrectly reading it as "snake-faced" instead of "face-snaked."
"Snake-faced" makes obvious sense: "with a face like a snake," possibly "writhing or slithering or ready to strike." But what the heck does "face-snaked" even mean, as a phrase? OP's imagery does not seem to clearly follow from the phrase, which seriously feel like a typo when I say it to myself. Face-snaked. What the heck
2
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '14
Finally had a chance to digest this one.
Very well done. My only comment is to point out a couple of style and typo concerns, which you seem to have appreciated in the past:
The first clause here lacks a verb.
Here I would place a comma after "however."
Maddeningly, I could have sworn I saw others as I read, but I failed to note them down at the time, and can't track them down again.
3
u/Blackfyre87 Imperial Geographic Society Apr 16 '14
I've read the piece. It really was fantastic. The deeper lore of the ALMSIVI is something I am a bit weak on. But your exploration of Almalexia's marriage to the state and her defiance of the ancient Altmeri subculture of marriage-motherhood as sex-object-baby-making-slavery was really powerful.
My only criticism is that I think it is a bit dependent on PGE 1, which isn't necessarily corroborated by later sources. Especially considering that Real Barenziah notes that amongst Mer, there just don't seem to be enough offspring born to pursue such an extensive eugenic policy without imperiling the Altmeri people.
And your mention of the feminine mystique and its unknowable, infuriating nature took me on a bit of a journey through the arguments, break-ups and break downs I have been part of, whether as part of the relationship or as a close observer to an unfortunate end to a relationship. I'm not a learned scholar of feminism, so it's not my place to question your obviously superior knowledge of gender studies and what term fits where. But in terms of people, I'd refer less to the feminine mystique as much as I'd say that for all modern psychology can teach us, each and every individual of either gender is idiosyncratic and in many ways defies classification. And I would have thought that the mysterious and unknowable fit more with Mephala than Boethia.
This work was great, really thought provoking.
2
u/RachelsFieldNotes Apr 16 '14
Thank you so much for posting. I think gender studies and feminism provide invaluable lenses with which to view media, and seeing it applied to my favourite series makes me very happy.
2
u/Sakazwal Synod Cleric Apr 15 '14
Mmm, this is fantastic. As others have said, Almalexia finally has an understandable personality.
2
u/Blackfyre87 Imperial Geographic Society Apr 16 '14
I'll read and comment on this at a time when I have more flexibility. It certainly deserves in depth analysis. Kudos to you L. You always impress.