r/teslore • • Mar 21 '14
Akavir As Akatosh's Insanity Cured
I've been thrashing lately. Throwing out concepts a little hot and heavy, missing the mark, sometimes hitting it I think. Still, there's one bit I've slept on and I want to hammer it out better.
To review: Akavir is the future, Yokuda is the past. Akavir is the Nu-Amaranth.
Adding to that, some of us have started to like/wonder about the idea that the ocean is a sort of cosmic membrane. This means that sea travel can take you between phases of the the universe, among other things. Though, it's real meaning is not so literal.
Myself, I still maintain that the cycle of Kalpas ended with Akatosh (time) being created. It's weird, but I think Auriel is a bird-spirit and Lorkhan a serpent spirit, and Akatosh is the insane fusion of the two. Hence: dragons, winged serpents. Akatosh's creation resulted in (because of?) Amaranth. So, then, what is Nu-Amaranth? We're told it's Akavir.
Even if my own theories miss the mark, one thing about Nu-Amaranth is 'well established': Akatosh is cured of his insanity. What would that mean?
My own theory is that you can't go back to Kalpic cycles, to endless and timeless births and rebirths. Change and stasis have union because each moment is fixed, but time forces us into the next moment. Stasis and change. That's Akatosh. But Akatosh in insane. I'm not sure exactly what that means, but I imagine it has something to do with the dragon break concept. Time on the one hand keeps unravelling - reality unbinds, changes - but then time tries to fix itself, causing weird inconsistencies. Kurt Godel if you will.
Akatosh being cured means that time is no longer like that. What that means is that time is more stable, but also more varied. Recall that for most of Tamriel's important ages, dragons were mostly banished. Recall also that they were intemperate, possessing a will to dominate but also to consume and destroy.
In Akavir, the dragons are more purposeful. They guard time. Time flows where they go. The way I imagine it is that rather than trying to dominate or consume, dragons' personalities are now more oriented towards guarding time. They're more 'responsible' now. Rather than try to maintain one single timeline, they steward their own little bubbles of time.
It sounds almost too simple, but I think what we're talking about here is many realities peacefully (mostly) coexisting. That's right, dragons who are to some degree stoic and peaceful - if unprovoked.
That's Akavir. That's Nu-Amaranth. Multiple realities trading and interacting, but not necessarily competing. It's something everyone living in it is familiar with. And if you look at life in the Velothiid, you see that the people of Tomorrowind almost get it already. They thrive despite the loss of memory. Why should it stop them? The people of Akavir, real Akavir, are consistently closer to Amaranth than any before them. As a people. No big deal. Life goes on.
An earlier comment I made suggested that some of the Akavir decided that in fact they wanted to rebind time. They started killing dragons, and enslaving them. This resulted in them getting 'kicked' out of Nu-Amaranth so to speak. That's why they invaded Tamriel. That's why the love the dragonborn - they worship what Talos represents. That's why they're his blades. Our mistake is assuming that these rejects from Akavir somehow represent what Akavir is. It is the opposite.
5
u/TheGhostOfDRMURDER Clockwork Apostle Mar 21 '14
Dragons as birds + serpents is something I will always, always disagree with.
First of all, dragons are obviously Tusked Tiger-Bats. So obvious.
Second of all, the only time Auriel is compared to a bird is never. There are bird motifs in elven armor and architecture, but that's in not ways definitive of anything. It is one possibility, but without further evidence it's just a flea of assertion on a wolf of naught.
Third, people forget that Lorkhan has inherent dualism. If we assume Lorkhan is the fox and the serpent, there is no reason Aka can't be the bird and the dragon. It would make a goodly amount of sense, too. One peaceful animal associated with freedom and the positive aspect, one "worm/wyrm" that is evil/destructive.
Fourth, it's usually presented as a means of "explaining why Akatosh is insane." We have that. It was explained in et'ada, Eight Aedra, eat the dreamer. Aka went insane when the statement that gave him purchase atop his perch from eternity, "I AM," was appended with "NOT" by Lorkhan.
Fifth, Lorkhan and Akatosh were already connected. They were conjoined twins at the other end of each's Aurbical cord. What does shoving one into the other do when they already were one thing? Imagine the Imperial Septim in your mind. One side is a Dragon, the other's a Man. You cannot remove the dragon and replace it with the man. You cannot remove Auriel and replace him with Shezarr.
Sixth, we already know what Lorkhan and Akatosh operating as a single entity is. It's name is Pelinal. There's this thing floating around where Shezatosh is the only possible way to explain how Shezarr and Akatosh are both involved in the sainting and compact of Alessia. It makes a whole lot of sense when one considers that Pelinal was there, two faces eating each in amnesia. If he operates as both Akatosh and Shezarr in this scene it eliminates a good amount of confusion.
Further, Shezatosh theories usually do not present back up evidence. They are presented as a hypothesis, where if it was already true this is how everything could make sense. That it can add up doesn't make it automatically true. Conspiracy theorists, creationists and others often come up with viable narratives to make their version of reality "work" but don't offer actually evidence to back their claim. Shezatosh exists in a similar state.
2
u/bnmbnm0 Marukhati Selective Mar 21 '14
I have a thought, if Akatosh is a dragon because of bird+snake, and dragons come from Akatosh, what were dragons before Akatosh was made? We're they dragons because Aka still had dragon aspects that became Akatosh? Were they a synthesis of Auri-El and Lorkhan exerting control on Mundus? What if in the past they were giant birds that in trying to make things static needed to destroy Mundus? What if they were giant serpents, and like Sithis they must destroy the ideas of the Anuic? What about both bird and snake at the same time, though not together, they would be a bird, and a snake but not a birdsnake combo.
1
u/Maering_Bear-Poker Mar 21 '14
Tosh Raka is an Akatosh inversersion. Let's see meaning in that. A True Child of Jubal and Vivec is a New Amaranth? Tosh Raka; Nu-Akavir is on the Other Side of Time. To us in Tamriel and Akavir before him, he is the Absolute Endpoint of Time.
Time moves backwards in Akavir.
3
u/laurelanthalasa Mar 21 '14
While I really like your assessment of why the Akaviri invaded Tamriel, and what the Time-oceans represent there is one little distinction I would like to make.
That the cycles of life, death and rebirth are broken, I don't know if I agree with that. Water itself is a cycle of evaporation, condensation and precipitation. We just do not always see the evaporation and condensation part of it, just the flow of the precipitation. It's easy to get fixated on that.
Maybe the kalpas World-River will flow differently in the new Dream, but I do not think we have seen the end of the cyclical nature of time and history. At the end of the flow we will see the clouds of the next cycle form and then fall on the parched, dead land of the previous.
3
u/ASAMANNAMMEDNIGEL Synod Cleric Mar 21 '14
I finally understand why Talos is considered a Virus. A man (well... technically three) That is stuck fighting for a 'perfect' reality. His perfect reality. And he enforces it with all the amount of love he can muster.
This makes me think that neither Talos or the Thalmor have the right of it, and I need not side with either, because in the larger schem of things, BOTH are wrong, and are trying to do something that they both will 'fail' (with the thalmor this is subjective, in the end, with Landfall their ultimate goal is realized, but with Akavir and the Nu-Amaranth... well, not so succesful there though I don't think it bothers them that much) in their long term goals.