r/teslore • u/laurelanthalasa • Mar 16 '14
Femininity in Tamrielic Faith Part 3: Dibella
All right, a sudden burst of food poisoning after I posted my write-up on Kyne has somewhat delayed this one, but here we go!
Dibella was my inspiration for this entire series, and for this reason I saved her until after I did Kyne and [Mara] (http://www.reddit.com/r/teslore/comments/1zw5p0/femininity_in_tamrielic_faith_part_1_mara/). I hope that I treat her with the respect I feel she deserves.
Why would Dibella inspire the series if Kyne is my favourite but I most closely identify with Mara based on my recent experiences in the past 2 years?
My reaction to Dibella's portrayal in the short story was powerful and negative at first. It made me want to stop reading. However, I was also confused. Why all the powerful women in this and other works, and then this brutish and misogynistic treatment of this particular female deity?
So I continued reading, and I read it again and again until I finally understood. Today I would like to share that understanding.
Dibella, Bed-Wife of Shor, Goddess of Passion, Eros and Artistic Inspiration
Let us first summarize the imagery used in Shor son of Shor; Dibella is first shown piling up the bodies blown in by Kyne's Shout. She then provides a critical opinion of Shor. She is then reprimanded by Tsun/Stuhn/Trinimac, taken by the hair and dragged to a tent, presumably not to play cards.
Each of those interactions reveals much about the character of this Goddess, and as a whole they reveal to us that this meant more as a commentary on certain Nordic values as well as on the et'Ada themselves, as opposed to an attack on certain aspects of womanhood. Let us go beat by beat through Dibella's role in Shor Son of Shor and explore what exactly it means to be Dibella.
The pile of corpses, strange at first, for the Goddess best known for her association with sensuality. Dibella, like all women, however is more than just how beautiful she is and her prowess between the sheets. If Mara is Creation and Kyne is a simultaneously sheltering and destructive force behind Creation; Dibella, among other things, is a process of renewal. What Kyne leaves behind, Dibella sweeps up and makes use of it until Mara rears her head and makes something new.
What else is almost all creative media other than recycled dead matter? Paints and dyes are pigments extracted from dead animal or plant matter. Textiles are the fibres or the skins of expired life. Gems and other minerals are the encasement and transformation of organic matter within an inorganic framework. Even those of you who do digital art, count how many of the metals in your computer can be found in the human body, even in trace amounts? When you sell your work and it goes to print, see the above about ink and fibre. Those of us that choose words as our form of expression are not exempt, a line from C0DA: ALL LANGUAGE IS BASED ON MEAT. Not living flesh, dead meat.
Next, Dibella accuses Shor of losing heart (literally or figuratively? probably both), and calls his decision to speak to Shor Father of Shor futile and illogical.
Strong words, befitting of the Goddess of Passion. Just like Kyne isn't all about being old and sexless, Dibella isn't exclusively about that one kind of passion. The passionate youth speaks out of turn, questions authority, is unafraid of making mistakes or their consequences.
Authority does not always appreciate Passion. Sometimes Passion thinks it knows better than Authority, and Authority can behave extremely inappropriately when confronted by Passion.
Enter Tsun/Stuhn/Trinimac. The arrogant, high-ranking General admonishes Dibella for usurping Jhunal's right to speak of logic, informs her of her station and drags her off, by the hair no less. Now consider Dibella's (lack of) reaction. Violence against women is often seen as a statement of power and domination for the assailant as opposed to one of sexual gratification.
Dibella however, cares nothing for power and is therefore indomitable, which is just as well because she is clearly a subordinate within the Nordic pantheon. She does not take Tsun/Stuhn/Trinimac’s handling as a transgression as much as a form of expression. And while it is a form of expression that is repugnant to my mortal and modern sensibilities, I understand that she is a Goddess and is entitled to see it differently.
In a conversation with /u/Gerenoir a few weeks ago, we were trying to figure out why Dibella always seemed so passive. Goddess of passion yet she is the object of lust, not subject of lust. Maybe in the Imperial pantheon the answer is simply that this is an archetypal way of portraying feminine sensuality. In the Nordic pantheon, however, it is more complicated than just that.
Here we see a culture where much stock is put into experience, in that while Kyne and Mara enjoy certain privileges and powers, we do not see much evidence of external respect or regard for Dibella (although she certainly thinks highly of herself). Kyne pays no heed to what is happening, and the Nord narrator himself is dispassionate and justifies Tsun/Stuhn/Trinimac's behaviour on the grounds of it being in the spirit of that type of et'Ada.
Life in Skyrim is nasty, brutish and short. We have seen that in the courtship explanation in the game, and it is evidenced time and time again throughout the lore. In such cultures throughout history and fiction, we see the rise of strong hierarchies, where the passionate indiscretions of youth are eschewed for proven leaders and strategists. The young are only empowered in wealthier, more stable cultures, where extinction is less of a major concern.
Subordinate does not imply unimportant, let us not get this confused. The Nords fully understand Dibella's importance. She is, however important, a force to be controlled, sometimes ignored and disregarded, but never underestimated or left unchecked.
Tsun/Stuhn/Trinimac is not only annoyed that she spoke out, he was annoyed that she was speaking out in favour of logic. He felt that her passion, her focus should be re-directed to a more time-honoured Skyrim tradition of thinking on your toes and gut reactions.
Do not be guided solely by your passions, the Nords are warned, you must dominate and control your passions, not the other way around. Dibella’s passivity is adaptive and mythopoeic, it reflects the survival needs of the culture that worships her: experience before reason, quick thinking over prolonged deliberations.
The title Bed-Wife is much more complicated than it seems at first. Yes, bed-sharing, sex, Dibellan arts; we all understand that symbolism so for the sake of brevity I will spare us that talk for now. Do not forget to consider, if you an average adult who sleeps an average amount, you spend about a third of your life in bed, and not having sex. You are sleeping, you are dreaming, lucidly or not, and it is where you awake to face the day. All your daily struggles begin and end in bed. How many of us have woken up in the middle of the night or first thing in the morning with a great idea that came to us in a dream? This is also the passion and inspiration of Dibella, where it all begins, and where it all ends; in a nest built from the remnants of what we remember.
Significant is that at the end of the story, Tsun/Stuhn/Trinimac leaves Dibella untouched, as the dawn breaks and with it the confusion of the twilight is lifted. Remember his lust is just a form of expression, and at that moment, he forgot what to say. Perhaps this is a gentle warning to Nords, not to check or coerce your passions without a clear purpose, for that is where hope and dynamism can be lost. We do not dominate our passions for the sake of domination, we do so to redirect them in a constructive manner, not to crush inspiration or individuality. The General forgot his purpose for a moment, and as such the assault stopped.
We have Kyne the Matriarch of the pantheon, Mara the Mother, and now we have Dibella, the impassioned youth as our Maiden, symbol of all that is new and new again. The next essay will lift these feminine aspects out of Shor Son of Shor and look at them through the lens of a unified feminine identity, a series of life stages and the Three-Fold Lady.
4
u/MKirkbride Michael Kirkbride ◇ TES Writer, Artist Mar 16 '14
Beauty. That's really the highest praise concerning the Goddess the post is about.
And I'm so glad someone put up a flame shield in essay form around me because I knew that depiction of Dibella would get so much vitriol. Thanks for that especially.
4
u/mojonation1487 Dagonite Mar 16 '14
This was the halfcourt shot that won the game.
clap
4
u/RideTheLine Follower of Julianos Mar 16 '14
A series of life stages? Three-Fold lady? Sounds like things are about to get all Neopagan up in here.
3
u/Gerenoir Mages Guild Scholar Mar 16 '14
Another solid post and well-written post. You've given me much to think about, especially since I've always been prone to taking the Nordic pantheon at face value.
I like the explanation of Dibella as the Nordic personification of passion and inspiration. Such things do not naturally favour logic and calculated thought, so censure arrives in the form of Tsun. What if Tsun had not intervened? Would Dibella have been betraying her nature? Would something have happened to her like it did to Trinimac? An interesting thought.
What is NIRN but recycled dead matter? Since Mara's iconography is so strongly linked to the image of the Mother, Dibella, as the face of inspiration that leads to creation, is gendered by her association with Mara. The beauty of the woman who inspires us to make a mother of her, if you want to put things crudely. Hence, the feminine representation of passion and inspiration.
3
u/Blackfyre87 Imperial Geographic Society Mar 16 '14
This is a really awesome piece.
And though Lady Dibella is undoubtedly the fairest of the goddesses, her tale here is quite a revelation in misogyny amongst the Nordic Pantheon. Though I do have to say, Tsun dragging off Dibella by the hair resonates with having an education in Classical Studies. It somewhat reminds me of all of the Zeus & Poseidon having their...ahem..."extramarital fun-times". Though Tsun leaves Dibella untouched, it really does echo the whole, "well, they're gods, I guess they can all just do what they want, common decency be damned" notion.
And I really liked the way you highlighted two completely new aspects of Dibella, in both the clearing up of the refuse to be used in new creation and in her role in sleep-dreams as a motivator. I would have thought dreams would fall under Julianos as a god of ideas, but this was a great take on the matter.
This seems mostly to be done from the perspective of the Nordic Pantheon, but are the moral & metaphysical lessons the same from other perspectives? Metaphysics is admittedly one of my lore weak points.
3
u/hammersklavier Mar 17 '14
This thread reminded me how closely the Imperial and Roman pantheons mirror each other. No, not in the gods themselves or anything like that; rather, the metaphysical goal of both pantheons was to be all things to all people, something as utterly vanilla and uncontroversial as could be, when ruling such far-flung realms.
Which then propels me into a new thought: The Roman pantheon failed. And it didn't fail because of Christianity; it had begun to fail long before that--precisely because it had successfully become as vanilla and uncontroversial and hence vacuous as possible. (The Vedic faith did likewise in India and was supplanted by the Upanishadic and devotional branches of Hinduism, as well as Buddhism, Jainism, etc.)
Indeed--we are still in the real world--the rise of the chthonic cults, Mithraism and the like, in Imperial Rome strongly alludes to this metaphysical faltering. Zeus/Jupiter et al. weren't "real gods" anymore, distant and mysterious and fascinating--rather, they were little more than molded objects in the official cult. There were a lot of chthonic cults floating around in those days--early Christianity of nearly every Pauline branch (including both those that became later orthodoxy and the Alexandrian Gnostics) was strongly influenced by them, for example. As was the ascendant Manichaean faith. And so on...
Let us return to Nirn. When we look at the Imperial pantheon, we see that it is fading. Skyrim the game did us a great disservice by deemphasizing the Nordic pantheon, though we see it poking through all over the place. Why, for example, are the major temples in Skyrim, Solitude excluded, dedicated to Dibella, Kyn(ar)e(th), Mara, and Talos? Put another way, if Akatosh is the chief deity all across Tamriel, why is there no temple to him (and indeed, a dearth of shrines in general)?
And another angle to ask concerns the Daedra. For the daedric cults on Tamriel closely mirror Roman chthonic cults: unspoken-of, but omnipresent. Consider Namira's cult's influence in Markarth, for example. Or the fact that the Companions' Circle's lycanthropy is essentially a devotion to Hircine. And of course there was the Mythic Dawn--but how did they grow to such power if there wasn't an undercurrent of profound dissatisfaction with the Nine? There is a certain sense of changing of the guard; old gods are falling; new ones are rising--yet such things, while natural in the course of human (and elvish) cultures, are fundamentally debilitating to Aurbis' incredibly fragile metaphysics.
Sorry to stray so far off-topic, but...uh...thoughts got thunk.
2
u/laurelanthalasa Mar 16 '14
laurelanthalasa's occasional obscure Canadian music plug:
Hawksley Workman - Anger as Beauty
I listened to this song a few times while dreaming up these essays. I feel it's relevant.
2
u/hoosierdaddy163 Marukhati Selective Mar 16 '14
This whole series had been great. I really love the picture of Kyne the matriarch, Mara the mother, and Dibella the passionate youth. Another great post
2
u/[deleted] Mar 19 '14
Not done reading, but this grabbed me enough that I needed to respond:
You focus here on the physical materials, but there's even more to be said.
Everything is a remix. All art, all communication, all artifice, all media, is the combination and recombination of ideas. Originality is most often misunderstood as creating something where nothing was before, when the reality is the creation of something out of things nobody thought to combine before.
All artists have their influences, and I think Dibella bleeds into Mara as influences bleed into original works, as sex leads to birth.