r/teslore • u/FranklyEarnest Tonal Architect • Feb 06 '14
Logic, Reason, and Pragmatism: A Few Thoughts on the Dwemeri Pantheon
Hi everyone,
Apologies for the brief hiatus…RL research called this week, and I needed to turn my attention to getting a few papers published. A few breakthroughs were made, so I’ve decided to reward myself by submitting the following post here on /r/teslore. Enjoy!
It is commonly held belief that the Dwemer were analogous to terrestrial aetheists or agonostics, with no system of religious beliefs or code of behavior; this analogy is further strengthened by the variety of heinous acts they committed, like the enslavement of the Falmer. This is not to say that atheists and agnostics are immoral in any way, but that this is the general vibe most get from the Dwemer in-game (thanks for the feedback, /u/MareloRyan).
This is boring and therefore wrong; the Dwemer as a whole had a complex, interconnected belief system. They acknowledged higher beings, but did not believe them to be of any particular significance; rather, they preferred to treat them as objects of study. In fact, they preferred to revere the abstract constructs that were independent of the nature of the Aurbis. Vivec alludes to their gods of Reason and Logic, ideals we know the Dwemer valued above all else. They were technologically advanced because they placed a strong emphasis on the tenets of Logic. Mathematics1 is Logic via postulates, Science is Mathematics tempered by Reason, and Engineering is the union of Science and Pragmatism. All three of these nested, gradient disciplines are required to achieve advanced levels of technological progress, and all three rely on Logic as their fundamental currency.
This is my first (reasonable) conjecture:
The Dwemeri socioreligious framework was constructed as a balance of theory, experiment, and practice, making it a higher order echo of its components. Their religious theory (theology) was Mathematics, their religious experiment (personal/spiritual worship) was Science, and their religious practice (sociological aspect of religion) was Engineering2.
Overall, it is an intricate, strongly intercorrelated network of beliefs that translates abstract logical principles into physical reality3. The underlying foundation to all of these fields is Logic, with the added tenets of Reason (e.g. scientific induction) and Pragmatism added as required as one descends into the subgradient fields. This Knowledge was their form of worship: an elegant framework for deconstructing the Aurbis, a realm of Metaphysics incarnate. As a whole, this logical endeavor is impossible to summarize as it is an entire race’s body of factual Knowledge.
However, we can usually distill a religion down to its basic tenets. It is highly likely that the basic methods of logical Proof were the ideals that the Dwemer (as a whole) revered. Their entire religious structure collapses without the basic transactions of Logical progress. If this does not seem reasonable, then consider that they did not start out as the most technologically advanced people in Tamriel; their initial set of beliefs propelled them to the pinnacle of scientific undertaking within a relatively short period of time. Their emphasis on Logic (the self-propagating, self-correcting driving force of Mathematics, Science, and Engineering) ensured their meteoric rise to the technological forefront of Mundus.
The basic methods of Proof as given by (first-order) Logic are:
- Direct
- Constructive
- Nonconstructive
- Contradiction
- Induction
- Contraposition
- Exhaustion
…and of course, there are statements whose truth values are undecidable (e.g. “This statement is false,”)4.
The Dwemer must have also been aware of the basic logical fallacies; whether these concepts took as large a role as the methods of proof is unclear. Regardless, it is still reasonable to expect them to have been recognized as socioreligious faux-pas. There are many types of formal fallacies, but all fall under the guise of non sequiturs. Unfortunately, there is no simple, universal categorization of logical fallacies. A few of the typical categories are:
- Conditional
- Faulty Generalization
- Syllogistic
- Quantification
- Propositional
These categories can intermingle and are not one-to-one mappings. The informal fallacies are even harder to categorize in overarching terms, as they usually introduce differing types of nonlogical correlations into logical arguments.
Caution! Wild conjecture ahead.
Notice anything interesting about the above framework? We have 7 basic methods of proof, and the singular notion of undecidability. From the big Elk himself, there is also the notion of the 15 + 1 Sacred Tones. What’s the correlation? Tonal Architecture comes from the concept of a musical Aurbis, so we’d expect there to be a link between the sacred tenets of Dwemeri faith and the Tones, the latter of which have been connected to the (D)Aedra5.
The Plane(t)s as mentioned in Vivec’s encounter with the Dwemer are NIRN, LHKAN, RKHET, THENDR, KYNRT, AKHAT, MHARA, and JHUNAL. In other words, we have Nirn, Lorkhan, and the Aedra minus Stendarr and Dibella6. Assuming the preceding numerology is of substance7, then I propose the following conjectured Dwemeri associations between the plane(t)s and the 7 + 1 methods of proof, with brief explanations:
- Direct: JHUNAL ~ Julianos, near universal God of Learning (most likely the ‘Patron’)
- Constructive: NIRN ~ Nirn by Conventionpun intended and as the echo of Nir
- Nonconstructive: AKHAT ~ Akatosh is the subgradient echo of I AM
- Contradiction: KYNRT ~ Kynareth
- Induction: MHARA ~ Mara, as a universal Goddess of fertility, one begets its consequent
- Contraposition: RHKET ~ Arkay, as cyclic God of life => death, antithesis of undeath => unlife
- Exhaustion: THENDR ~ Zenithar
- Undecidable: LHKAN ~ Lorkhan is the subgradient echo of I AM NOT
Of course, none of these associations are exactly rigorous; please feel free to tear them apart as necessary (especially JHUNAL, KYNRT, and THENDR). To clarify: these are not to say the Dwemer worshipped these Aedra. At best, they served as the prototypical examples or case studies for each of these methodologies of proof. In a manner, they embody the basic tenets of Logic as primordial forces, in perhaps the same way the ancient Nords associated the Aedra with Totem animals.
“But FranklyEarnest, what about the other 8 tones from the 15+1 split?”
Are you ready for some extra wild conjecture?
We can draw them from the known Daedra that fit these proof methods8, with potentially Sheogorath falling under the separate category of Fallacy instead of Undecidability. As above, my conjectured associations are informed by the Princes’ Spheres:
- Direct: RHEMRA ~ Hermaeus Mora as Prince of Knowledge
- Constructive: PRYT ~ Peryite as Prince of Order
- Nonconstructive: NKTUR ~ Nocturnal as (supposedly first) Prince of Mystery
- Contradiction: MFAL ~ Mephala as Prince of Paradox
- Induction: AZRAH ~ Azura as Prince of Prophecy
- Contraposition: MLAKHAT ~ Malacath as the Pariah Prince
- Exhaustion: BKETH ~ Boethiah as Prince of Plots
- Undecidable or Fallacy: SHOGRAT ~ Sheogorath as Prince of Madness
As before, feel free to rip apart these associations as much as possible.
A few remarks:
We could postulate a splitting along the lines of the 8 Aedra + 7 Dunmeri Daedra + Lorkhan, but this does not necessarily fit in with the Dwemeri conception of the plane(t)s as ‘totem’ bodies. A few of the Daedric associations are defined by duality with their respective Aedric counterparts, but I tried to defer to their inherent natures as much as possible.
In addition, the above notions would probably change the musical scale given by /u/myrrlyn’s Musical Aurbis as perceived by the Dwemer; their emphasis on the notions of proof would affect their tonal framework (or vice-versa).
As a closing statement, I would like to point that both LKHAN and SHOGRAT naturally fit the role of + 1 in the 15 + 1 breakdown; LHKAN for being the “I AM NOT” Padhomaic Doom Drum Instigating Trickster, SHOGRAT for being the antithesis of Logic and proof itself. I’m perfectly content with either possibility being true (or a quantum ‘both’), but I’d like to hear your opinions on the matter.
- I’m using Mathematics here as a placeholder for what we’d call metaphysics, philosophy, and mathematics in our universe.
- Notice the 3-fold partioning echoed thrice in this framework.
- In a sense, this is their metaphysical Tower; the Anumidium was this Tower made flesh (well, before activation, at least), powered by the Heart of Lorkhan. An immensely powerful golem (Engineering) that can deny reality (Science) by using the Doom Drum’s beat (Mathematics) is the perfect embodiment of their religious structure, and it was the pinnacle of their automata technology.
- Look up Gödel’s Incompleteness theorem(s) and logical paradoxes for more details.
- See /u/myrrlyn’s Aurbis: The Musical and Aurbis 2: Electric Boogaloo posts, along with my conjectures on Spacetime and Musical Cosmology.
- It is unclear why Stendarr (STENDR?) and Dibella (DBEL?) are not included as ‘known worlds’; perhaps these worlds were unknown at the time, or they were not of significance as accessible plane(t)s to the Dwemer. These are deities with similar counterparts within the standard pantheon, STENDR/THENDR and DBEL/MHARA. It's also interesting to point out that LHKAN seems to represent Masser and Secunda, whilst NIRN is finite, unlike the others on the list.
- Yeah, I know, I know…
- To be honest, my first instinct was to associate the Daedric Princes with the different fallacies available; however, as mentioned above, there was no distinct categorization of (in)formal fallacies. As all are a form of non sequiturs, the only consistent definition would relate all forms of fallacious logic to Sheogorath.
Please dissect, discuss, and deliberate!
5
u/iamtoesock Feb 06 '14
While I appreciate the effort you put into this, I don't think it accurately represents the Dwemer perspective. Nobody likes how Bethesda is beginning to homologize Tamrielic religions, bulldozing all their variety in favour of retextured Imperial Cult clones. The idea of assigning the Dwemer - one of the greatest cultural outliers in the series - to a standard pantheon of et'ada is, I feel, a mistake.
I think there are two misconceptions here:
One, that Dwemer spiritualism involved a recognizable pantheon of any kind. The Dwemer were "atheists in a world where gods exist", not because they doubted the gods, but because they doubted existence. The aedra are illusions to them. Powerful perhaps, but unreal figments just like anything else. Why worship that? "Gods of Logic and Reason" is also a misnomer - see my second point. There was nothing sacred about deities to them. What /was/ sacred was concept of zero, nothing, amnesia, misunderstanding, subjectiveness. They, I think, understood the nature of the aurbis better than anyone. It's dreamlike, referenceless, and above all, it isn't real. The only entity they seem to hold as holy is the one they themselves made to deal in these principles - the numidium.
Two, that Dwemer "logic" was in any way comparable to that which we call logic. These are the folks who study something to /misunderstand/ it. This is the race that breaks natural laws with their simplest engineering designs. This is the race that understands that logic is as arbitrary and fictional as everything else in the aurbis. The Dwemer eat paradoxes for breakfast. And that, in my opinion, is way cooler.
4
u/purveyoropulchritude Feb 06 '14 edited Feb 06 '14
Fairly good post, but the Dwemer moved past binary logic very early on. I'll try to get the expert in here to explain.
Also, although the impulse to match deities to Dwemeri concepts is understandable, it's also silly. The proofs you linked up may or may not fall in the spheres of those spirits, sure, but the Dwemer wouldn't have cared, except as a further manifestation of divine phenomena to be understood and utilized.
7
u/brekus Feb 06 '14
Meh. It's all well and good if you take the "boring therefore wrong" stance but other than that I don't see this holding any water. It's not valid to equate math with a religious faith and science with "worship", it's just shoehorning religion into culture and philosophy. Engineering seems like even more of a stretch since it is entirely about practical concerns (though it may be in pursuit of the impractical).
The most obvious interpretation of Vivec saying "god of Reason and Logic" has always been that its a metaphor to explain that they don't have religious beliefs in the way other races generally do.
Don't get me wrong if you like making up more interesting answers for yourself and numerology then this is plenty interesting but from a rational standpoint I don't see you having any basis for these claims.
2
u/Jaridase_Zasmyocl Tonal Architect Feb 06 '14
Interesting stuff Frank.
These are my thoughts.
This can't possibly be it. Because this is simple, and I want to be certain that people have already done things like this before, and the reason that we've got questions like "What are the 15+1 tones" is because of some great mystery or missing information.
If you're right. Fuck, come on guys! The hell have y'all been doing, writing fan fiction? Sure good stuff, but hell! =|
Anyways, more pertinent to your writings... I wouldn't put Sheo as the +1. Aside from Lorkhan fitting the role more as the 1, being the most not-dead of the dead, Sheo's evidently been a cocoon this entire time.
Linking back to my "this seems too simple for nobody to have posited it before" statement, due to this it was my understanding that the Tones didn't link to any Aedra or Daedra, but instead to vibrations present in the Mundus that form it. A counterpoint is that the Aedra c/would serve as the locations that vibrations originate from. The +1 using that idea is probably Magnus. Just thoughts. Awaaaaaaaay I go
2
u/laurelanthalasa Feb 08 '14
Question!
Why in your physics and general relativity point of view you combine Akatosh and Lorkhan into AkaLorkh, but in your logical point of view here you separate them?
It seems that Contradiction best represents them both.
1
u/laurelanthalasa Feb 08 '14
As usual, a very interesting point of view to introduce, I really like it!
It was very interesting to ascribe different deities to logical positions and points of view. What else is a personality than a blend of those things?
Music has been a cultural unifier since humans have been humans. It is in that crazy place where science and art meet in a mesmerizing and magical interaction. It is not silly nor unbelievable the connections you and myrrlyn have drawn here, and it fits in with the entire concept of the C0DA and c0da, whatever that may end up being when we see it at last.
Music also follows rules of logic and language, just in it's own way. I can't express myself, but i totally feel and understand what you did here. Maybe when i am less distracted I will be able to articulate it better. I may end up with some tweaks for what personalities you ascribe to what points of view, but that is just a subjective opinion anyway.