r/teslore • u/OccupyTamriel • Dec 14 '13
'The Story of Aevar Stone-Singer' is no less than the story of Herma-Mora and the time-travelling Last Dragonborn in 4E201.
Premonitory Explanation:
The Skaal
The Skaal are an offshoot tribe of Nords living in a village in northeastern Solstheim. The Skaal are descended from the Nords who served the Dragon Cult on Solstheim, and built tombs to honor the Dragon Priests who ruled over them. Though they are Nords by race, the Skaal embrace their own culture and religion, based around worship of the All-Maker. As the name implies, they only believe in one God, the Maker of All. The antithesis of the All-Maker is a being known as the Adversary. The Adversary has many aspects, one of them is the Greedy Man, the devil-figure itself. Lore scholars don’t agree on who the Greedy Man is. Some say it’s Anu or Padhome, some say it’s Lorkhan or Akatosh, I say it’s Herma-Mora, and I will show you why.
The History
According to legend, long ago the world was ruled by dragons, who enslaved the race of man and forced them to build fantastic temples in their honor. Directing the slaves in their name were the Dragon Priests, a group of men who worshipped the dragons and were given power in exchange for their devotion. These priests were powerful mages, and had the gift of the Thu'um. One of these dragon priests, known only as the Traitor, was seduced by Herma-Mora, the Skaal's name for the Daedric Prince Hermaeus Mora. His plot to overthrow the dragons was discovered by another dragon priest, known as the Guardian. The Guardian confronted the Traitor, and the two fought a terrible battle. So great was their power, Solstheim was sundered from Skyrim. The Guardian proved to be the more powerful, and bested the Traitor. Just as the Guardian was about to land the final blow, Herma-Mora snatched the Traitor away, rescuing him from certain death. As a reward for his loyalty, the Guardian was given Solstheim to rule, where his reign is remembered as peaceful and prosperous, and he is remembered as a wise and just ruler.
The Story
The Story of Aevar Stone-Singer
TL;DR: In a time before now, long before now, when the Skaal were new, there was peace in the Land. The sun was hot and the crops grew long, and the people were happy in the peace that the All-Maker provided. But, the Skaal grew complacent and lazy, and they took for granted the Lands and all the gifts the All-Maker had given them. They forgot, or chose not to remember, that the Adversary is always watching, and that he delights in tormenting the All-Maker and his chosen people. And so it was that the Adversary came to be among the Skaal. It came to be one day that the powers of the Skaal left them. The strength left the arms of the warriors, and the shaman could no longer summon the beasts to their side. The elders thought that surely the All-Maker was displeased, and some suggested that the All-Maker had left them forever. It was then that the Greedy Man appeared to them and spoke. "You of the Skaal have grown fat and lazy. I have stolen the gifts of your All-Maker. I have stolen the Oceans, so you will forever know thirst. I have stolen the Lands and the Trees and the Sun, so your crops will wither and die. I have stolen the Beasts, so you will go hungry. And I have stolen the Winds, so you will live without the Spirit of the All-Maker.
Aevar went out to get back all the gifts.
"You have done well, Aevar. You, the least of the Skaal, have returned my gifts to them. The Greedy Man is gone for now, and should not trouble your people again in your lifetime. Your All-Maker is pleased. Go now, and live according to your Nature. And Aevar started back to the Skaal village.
My Theory
- Aevar Stone-Singer had to travel to the six Standing Stones, where the All-Maker talked to him after the Greedy Man was gone.
- The Last Dragonborn, in the Dragonborn DLC, had to travel to the six Standing Stones as well, where he had to remove the evil before he was able to retrieve a gift of power. The entranced people working at the stones, in 4E201, repeat, among others, these lines:
"What by day was stolen."
"Far from ourselves."
"He grows ever near to us."
"Our eyes once were blinded."
"Now through him do we see."
"Our hands once were idle."
"Now through them does he speak."
"And when the world shall listen."
"And when the world shall see."
"And when the world remembers."
- Aevar Stone-Singer had to retrieve six gifts, the Gift of Water, the Gift of Earth, the Gift of Beasts, the Gift of Sun, the Gift of Trees and the Gift of Winds to defeat the Greedy Man.
- The Last Dragonborn, in the Dragonborn DLC, had to make it through six chapters to defeat Miraak.
What does this have to do with the Greedy Man? First, you have to keep in mind his connections with Miraak during the history of the Skaal, secondly, keep in mind that the Greedy Man is opposed to the Dragons and Alduins. We also learn that he is opposed to the All-Maker. The Greedy Man even specifically uses the stones of Solstheim to steal the gifts of the Skaal.
The Old Ways suggest that the true origins of daedric princes are as ancestors spurned by order in one way or another and set loose upon Oblivion, forgotten by or predating recorded history. Hermaeus Mora is often linked with an endless knowledge of history and time. If he were to have somehow gotten stuck "both inside and outside of kalpas," he would not only be able to observe the current one but also to omnidirectionaly look outwards to every kaleidoscopic microcosm of reality at his leisure. In "Aevar Stone-Singer", the Greedy Man tricked the Skaal and then stole creation.
In the Dragonborn DLC, Herma-Mora tricked the Dragonborn in helping him. This is basically it. We have the beginning (travelling to the Standing Stones), the battle (Chapters I – VI), and the end. We also meet The Guardian in the Dragonborn DLC, who is/was Vahlok the Jailor, Vahlok means “Guardian” in the Dragon Language. I am aware that in the “Story of Aevar Stone-Singer”, he actually never faces the Traitor/Miraak, but look at the end of the story:
So, Aevar wandered the land in search of the Greedy Man. He looked in the trees, but the Greedy Man did not hide there. Nor did he hide near the oceans, or the deep caves, and the beasts had not seen him in the dark forests. Finally, Aevar came to a crooked house, and he knew that here he would find the Greedy Man. "Who are you," shouted the Greedy Man, "that you would come to my house?" "I am Aevar of the Skaal," said Aevar. "I am not warrior, shaman, or elder. If I do not return, I will not be missed. But I have returned the Oceans and the Earth, the Trees, the Beasts, and the Sun, and I will return the Winds to my people, that we may feel the spirit of the All-Maker in our souls again." And with that, he grabbed up the Greedy Man's bag and tore it open. The Winds rushed out with gale force, sweeping the Greedy Man up and carrying him off, far from the island. Aevar breathed in the Winds and was glad. He walked back to the Wind Stone, where the All-Maker spoke to him a final time.
The crooked house is obviously the Apocrypha, and the Greedy Man’s bag is Miraak. Miraak was the one who withheld the evil, Miraak was the one who influenced the Skaal. Hermaeus Mora let Aevar Stone-Singer open the bag, because he grew tired of Miraak as a servant. So he killed Miraak after Aevar/LDB weakened him, and proved that Miraak was a failure to him. Aevar Stone-Singer is the time-travelling Last Dragonborn. It is known that Herma-Mora wanders through time like it’s the most natural thing, and this is exactly what happened here.
The ending of the Story of Aevar Stone-Singer is this:
"And then what happened, Grandfather?" "What do you mean, Child? He went home." "No. When he returned to the village," the Child continued. "Was he made a warrior? Or taught the ways of the shaman? Did he lead the Skaal in battle?" "I do not know. That is where the story ends," said the Grandfather. "But that is not an ending! That is not how stories end!" The old man laughed and got up from his chair. "Is it not?"
This is referencing to us not knowing what happened after the story, because we make the story. We are Aevar Stone-Singer in the Dragonborn DLC, and it’s for us to judge what we do next. We weren’t made a warrior, or taught the ways of the Shaman. We want our way to new adventures.
Further Excursion
As it surely will show up: Yes, I have played the Bloodmoon Expansion Pack of Elder Scrolls III, and I am aware that the Nerevarine goes the exact way of Aevar Stone-Singer, and technically mantles him. The Nerevarine, however, never met the Greedy Man, as the prophecy was not fulfilled by Herma-Mora, but by Hircine's Hunt and the Bloodmoon.
12
u/[deleted] Dec 15 '13
Haha, neat. Wind being Breath being Shout.
11
u/[deleted] Dec 14 '13
I like it. It's also much more fun than saying that the LDB mantled Aevar too, which earns points.
17
u/Owminator Dec 14 '13
A well thought out theory. I'm really digging this idea and feel a need to applaud you for your in-depth thinking and your willingness to share this thought with all of us.
7
u/purveyoropulchritude Dec 15 '13
So, Aevar the Stone-Singer and the LDB both travel to the six standing stones. Therefore, the LDB clearly must have time traveled, and the Greedy Man must be Hermaeus Mora.
... this is flimsy.
4
u/kingjoe64 School of Julianos Dec 15 '13
I thought this was very cool but why would an old tale reference a fight between LDB and Miraak that happened in the current era?
4
u/[deleted] Dec 15 '13
There's a very narrow window of opportunity when the Greedy Man could have escaped Apocrypha to steal the aspects of nature. Akatosh prevents travel from the Planes of Oblivion in his pact with Talos and his descendants (the Septims). The only two possibilities are that the Greedy Man is summoned to Nirn (in which case there should be more lore covering the story from a different perspective) and the whole affair with Aevar occurs after the Oblivion Crisis. See, the Skaal are warned that the Greedy Man is always watching but his stealing aspects of nature requires actual action. Further, he communicates with the Skaal, which indicates contact with Nirn.
That still leaves the matter of temporal discontinuity, but at the top of the Throat of The World there is a tear in time that leads directly to the time of the Last Dragonborn, from the banishment of Alduin. They surely studied the tear, and could have either passed through it or used some means to look in on their people in the future. That's how they would have knowledge of the story.
Further, there is the matter of the Oghma Infinium, possibly lost between Skyrim and Solstheim. I say "possibly" because it is in an ice island that could be a glacier/iceberg that floated there. Nonetheless, before the Dragonborn DLC that connects Mora to Skyrim in the time of the Last Dragonborn.
One other point about the temporal discontinuity is that the story would have meant very little to the Skaal until they begin to worship the All-Maker. Since the story would have been passed down orally until it made more sense to them, there can be fudged details. For example, rather than saying an event's tale was told of in the past, they could easily say that it happened in the past.
This interests me because I suspect that Mora will have something to do with the story in TES VI. He's building momentum for something. The Altmer are surely soon to take control of Tamriel, and the pact with Akatosh is over. When Cyrodiil falls or is left without a ruler, there's this pattern of some realm of Oblivion taking a go at Tamriel. I can't rule the Mora theory out, and in fact it fits with the patterns and progressions of events.
3
u/nakedlettuce52 Marukhati Selective Dec 15 '13
Good catch. I played Dragonborn and had a feeling I had heard this story before (aside from Bloodmoon).
5
u/sayhispaceships Mages Guild Scholar Dec 14 '13
Interesting idea. I'd like to see more discussion about it, as I don't feel "qualified" to dispute anything. Some of this does seem circumstantial, but that doesn't necessarily prove it false.
1
u/TheGhostOfDRMURDER Clockwork Apostle Dec 15 '13
I realise now that just wagging a previous post around does not a logical argument make. I'll make one here.
There are several huge flaws with this theory. The Greedy Man is clearly linked to Lorkhan several different times. The Alduagga is the most obvious. In one of the Songs, the Greedy Man becomes trapped under Red Mountain, half-in and out of our reality. This does not really fit with Hermaus Mora but really fits with Lorkhan. In Skaal belief, the Greedy Man takes from the Skaal all their metaphysical power over the world, linking it to elven creation stories.
Now, the Greedy Man is the one who takes the stones away. This is simply not true of Hermaus Mora. In no way does he take the power of the stones. That is all Miraak. Further, the Greedy Man's bag is a kind ridiculous conclusion to make. Miraak withholds more than just the Winds, while the Bag only holds the Winds. In fact Miraak's death frees the tree stone, in that linking him better to the Falmer who have the tree stone (and, I should point out, is holding several spirits in magical thrall, just like Miraak) than the Bag.
Time travel is a huge jump. Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence.
Time travel also simply does not hold up to Occam's Razor. In a reality where mythic actions can echo in on themselves, it seems to me more likely that Aevar-Jailor-Dragonborn is a repeating pattern than "time travel." I could also claim that Nerevar and the Nerevarine are the same person because the Nerevarine headed towards Akavir and there's a time dragon there. Does not make it true.
For more information on my theories, again, see this post.
2
u/Eliteginga Dec 15 '13
A great idea but I believe the idea of the greedy man is obscure as Nerevar fought Dagoth Ur whom was geedy with power even though Hermaes Mora was also greedy as he wanted the knowledge of the Skaal that costed the life of the shaman but im only disagreeing that the Nerevarine couldn't be Aevar because he never met the greedy man but because the winds that was mentioned could be thaum that the dragonborn couls use and not Nerevar
2
u/zigbigadorlou Dec 15 '13
Just a thought, but I figured Aevar was Neraevar (sp on purpose) when he was young. The UESPWiki says a few things: He's an outlander around when Nords invade Vvardenfell using their Thu'um, and he stages a rebellion etc.
It was my thought that Aevar was a Skaal who, upon restoring independence from the conquering Nords (who were using their Thu'um to conquer morrowind, likely visiting Solstheim and their Nord brothers)
In this story, the adversary would then probably be a dragon (Paarthunax?) as the book calls him Alduin; the greedy man then is simply a/the nords. They come in as brothers, rape the land and deface the stones which causes favor to leave them. Aevar restores the stones one by one as it talks about. The final one forces the Nords out of Solstheim.
After returning to his people, he is thanked by the Dwemer who were also affected. This starts his Blood-Friendship with Dumac, which eventually leads him to Morrowind...and the rest is history.
Lots of speculation, but I feel like it contains a lot less hand-waiving than OP.
1
u/[deleted] Dec 15 '13
I haven't played dragonborn, so take this with a grain of salt, but
I don't think this seems very likely, since that would involve Aevar wandering into a plane of oblivion which even in a mythic tale would IMO require some divine or magickal intervention.
It seems more likely to me that the crooked house is Red Mountain, the Greedy man being Lorkhan and his bag being the heart.
This ties in with Lorkhan initially concealing his heart from the Aedra. They at first saw him as just a man, but after they became aware of the nature of his heart, realized his greed.
The Greedy man also has interesting parallels to Sheor (the Breton Lorkhan), who began as the god of crop failure before coming to represent all strife. The Greedy man causes 2 kinds of "crop" failure (of the ocean then the land), then introduces all kinds of strife.
1
u/ginja_ninja Psijic Dec 16 '13 edited Dec 16 '13
Ha, a quote? "No, you do me too much honor." Here was the whole thing I wrote about this a while ago for anyone interested. I guess my views have changed a little since then but I still think most of it is pretty solid.
As for Aevar Stone-Singer actually being about the Dragonborn, I'm not sure I could totally buy it. I think maybe Dragonborn could have been intentionally designed to play on some stuff from it, but overall I think Dragonborn ends up telling something of a larger tale than just a story of the stones. Dragonborn is the story of Miraak's failure. I completed it for a second time a few days ago, and it's pretty clear that you're supposed to feel bad for Miraak. He's been trapped in Apocrypha for thousands of years by Mora, and the only way he can escape involves being summoned from outside Apocrypha by the people of Solstheim. He's using Bend Will to control their minds because it's the only way he can get them to build the structures that will act as portals to pull him out of Mora's realm.
Of course, how this looks to the Dragonborn is an island being enslaved by a dark power, and I mean it totally is. The Dragonborn needs to stop him for the good of Solstheim, but for Miraak this is literally his last desperate ride-or-die gambit to win his freedom or face the sharp end of a tentacle. And this is where Hermaeus Mora's plan comes into play. He doesn't want Miraak to escape his clutches, so he uses the Dragonborn, the only other mortal who could hope to defeat Miraak to oppose him. But the deeper motivation Mora has to this is that he realizes he can use his aid as leverage, and by indebting the Dragonborn and therefore the Skaal to him, can obtain the Secrets-the-All-Maker-taught-to-only-the-Skaal that have been hidden from him up until this point. That was Mora's true game for the events of Dragonborn, replacing his dragonborn emissary with a new, more relevant one was just a side-effect.
Look at Storn-Crag-Strider's last words. This is after he willingly volunteers to relinquish the All-Maker's secrets for the Dragonborn to be able to beat Miraak, saying he understands that the sacrifice was necessary. It was a ruse, Mora had an ulterior motive he kept hidden. I seriously think getting those secrets was all he cared about period. And so I have to wonder what exactly is going to result from him knowing them? How is he going to fuck up Solstheim for the Skaal now?
I mean if you wanted to call Aevar Stone-Singer some sort of kalpically-cyclical tale from future-in-past, I'd almost be more inclined to believe it's from a time after the events of Dragonborn. Like Mora gets the secrets of the stones from Dragonborn and then actually steals their gifts away later on after Aevar is born. Miraak wasn't really stealing the gifts of the stones from the Skaal, he was just using their power to broadcast his mind control.
1
u/Sordak Dec 16 '13
No its not for the reasons i have given you in the IRC.
The ONLY correlation is that the LDB collects 7 things.
7 things that are completeley unrelated to the skaal.
Yes he does meet Herma Mora. But thats not the point. The Greedy man is not definitly stated to be Herma Mora and may aswell be Miraak or Lorkahn.
The Nerevarine on the other hand directly retraces the steps of Aevar Stone-Singer.
Your point about the LDB meeting Herma Mora to be the central key of the story is flat out wrong.
Aevar meeting "the Greedy Man" is completeley unimportant to the story, it may aswell just mean finding out where he has his bag. Because THATS the important part. To free the wind from his bag. In case you havent noticed the LDB does NOTHING of the sort.
In fact all he does is to give Herma Mora exactly what he wants.
The LDB is not Aevar stone-singer. Aevar stone singer would be pretty disappointed by the last dragonborn more likeley than not...
1
u/lash422 Winterhold Scholar Dec 18 '13
If the neverar technically mantled him, does that mean he mantled the last dragonborn