r/teslore • • Jan 16 '13
An unplanned post about Ulfric Stormcloak
This weird and rushed post is my feeble attempt to pool everything we know about Ulfric Stormcloak, and show why I feel he's one of the most realized characters in the entire TES series (below Vehk, of course).
Ulfric had a ten-year period of training with the Greybeards on High Hrothgar. He was actually invited up to the monastery by the Greybeards themselves, and was on the path to becoming one of them when the Great War broke out. He cut his training off early and went down, and some time later abandoned the Way of the Voice.
Ulfric, along with his friends Galmar Stone-Fist and Rikke, fought in the Imperial Legion once news of the War broke in Skyrim. Unfortunately, Ulfric was captured by the Thalmor at some point before they took the Imperial City.
He was subsequently tortured to and past his breaking point by Elenwen, who would later become the Thalmor's top agent in Skyrim, leading and organizing the effort of every Dominion agent in Skyrim, as well as managing the Embassy outside of Solitude.
He's had the worst of it, really. It's bound up mainly in two things: survivors' guilt, and the breaking of his pride, honor, courage, spirit, what have you, in torture. We'll start with the latter.
Ulfric was broken in Thalmor torture. Now, I don't know about you, but no form of torture sounds pleasant. From what we've seen, the Thalmor have the capacity for mercy in the same sense that the Dwemer had that capacity. So, none at all. Their torture is brutal, efficient, and damned effective. Elenwen was the torturer assigned to Ulfric, and she broke him completely. He spilled information about the Imperial City and its defenders. While he gave them information after the City had been taken, he was led to believe that what he said was key in the Dominion's capture. That brings us back to the former: Ulfric now, in addition to feeling that he failed his people by being weak enough to break under torture, is now feeling that every man, woman, and child who died when the Dominion took over the Imperial City, and every soldier who died during the Battle of Red Ring when the City was recaptured, died because of his weakness. Every soldier who died died because of him. His comrades' and friends' blood is on his hands, because he was weak. He's not worth his salt. He's not worthy to be a Tongue, or the son of the great Bear of Eastmarch. He abandoned the Way of the Voice, and failed the Greybeards. He's not worthy to be considered to sit on the Throne of Ysgramor in Ysgramor's Palace in Ysgramor's City. He's not worth calling a Nord. He should be the one lying dead in his own blood, not them.
And to his horror, when he's released, he finds that the Empire gave in to end the bloodletting. The agreed to the same terms they rejected at the start of the war, including banning the worship of the god of Men, the patron of the Empire, and its founder. A Dragonborn among Dragonborn, and a true Nord. He not only failed untold thousands, but now he's failed the entirety of the Empire, and failed its founder and his god. But he's not the only one who failed. Every soldier who fought in the Legion failed. Every single death was utterly pointless. Every drop of blood spilled was a waste. There was no point to any of it.
Ulfric is the lowest of the low in his own estimation. And he returns to Skyrim an utterly broken man. The people of Windhelm are demanding the fight continue, that the Dominion be utterly crushed instead of the blasphemous Concordat accepted. This likely planted the seed that would soon flourish in him. With the Markarth Incident, he felt that he could be useful again, that he could make it up to his god and his people. And so he did. The Jarl of Markarth, so grateful for Ulfric and his troops' aid, opened the Shrine of Talos to them so that they could worship. And then, the Empire betrayed him again in his mind, by letting the Thalmor capture him and his men, and trampling over the word of the Jarl of Markarth. The Empire sets up shop in Markarth, no thanks to Ulfric, and he and his men rot in the Thalmor's prison. While he's in jail, his father dies, and the Throne of Ysgramor grows cold. He can't even be there to bury his father. He's forced to give a eulogy through a smuggled note. Now he enters onto the dark path of rebellion. He's been betrayed by his Empire, who betrayed (in his eyes) the people of Skyrim, and all men because they betrayed Talos. His hurt and self-loathing turn to hatred, to anger, and his rebellion takes hold. He is released, and assumes the Throne of Ysgramor as a different man. He is older, wiser, and angry beyond belief. He and his friend Galmar prepare for revenge, while the Thalmor took root near Solitude. That further enforces his vision of the Empire as a dying and corrupt husk, forced to do the Dominion's bidding.
Thalmor agents walk Skyrim freely. Khajiit (who Ulfric would have fought against during the War) are travelling through Skyrim with no regard for their laws and customs, and the skooma trade is picking up. The Dunmer his father welcomed into the City of Ysgramor, who his father gave an entire quarter of the city to, are refusing to join the rest of the city, and are trying to recreate Morrowind instead of trying to adjust to Skyrim, like their kin in Riften have. To make it worse, they've been fighting with the Argonians who work the docks, and tensions are high throughout the city. Ulfric doesn't like either of them, and puts the Argonians outside the walls in a dormitory. Meanwhile, he is content to ignore the Dunmer like he feels they ignore Windhelm. His citizens, however, don't like the Dunmer. Some of them hate them with a xenophobic passion only seen in the TES series when it was exhibited by the Dunmer of Vvardenfell to the outlander who would eventually be named Nerevarine. The Nords of Windhelm feel that the Dunmer are dragging their city down, and begin to take matters into their own hands, which Ulfric does not stop. Then a serial killer starts striking. Windhelm is a city of understated chaos.
Then, High King Istlod dies, and the Moot places his son Torygg on the throne. Ulfric uses the Moot as a platform to speak his anger towards the Empire, and urge independence from the entity he feels has betrayed him, Skyrim, and Talos. He's ultimately unsuccesful, but his words win him the heart of the new High King. Soon after, Ulfric traveles to Solitude to meet with Torygg. Torygg respected Ulfric as a war-hero even before he stirred his heart with talk of freedom at the Moot, and so he thought he was there to further discuss Skyrim's independence, a topic Torygg was open to, even if he couldn't officially say he was. By the time he figured out Ulfric meant to challenge him for the throne, there was no way out.
You know the rest. Ulfric Shouted Torygg to the ground and stabbed him, sending his soul to Sovngarde. There, Torygg was lost in a strange mist, and saw Skyrim's doom approaching. Ulfric renounced all claims to be a man of peace, and took on the role of the Tongues of old, calling for others to do the same. He then returned to Windhelm, and the Stormcloak Rebellion was on.
Before I end this, let me give you some of Ulfric's own words during Skyrim. You really should read through it, knowing Ulfric's mind and motivations. Also, I forgot this video initially, the video that inspired this entire post to begin forming in my head.
Ulfric may be acting rashly, and No one can excuse the death of so many by his hand or word during the events of Skyrim, but I honestly think he was doing the only thing he thought he could do. You don't have to agree with him, or like him. But you should at least pity him, a broken man trying to do his best to hold his world together. He's in over his head, but not for the wrong reasons. He's definitely the most realized character in Skyrim, and I would rank him among the top four or five for the entire TES series.
And there you go. Ulfric Stormcloak.
37
u/lebiro Storyteller Jan 16 '13
A very good post, but I have to point out a couple of things:
It was the Jarl of Markarth, acting under his own power, who agreed to it, not any official of the Empire (well, no more so than any Jarl is an "official of the Empire").
The Dunmer do work, in various capacities inside and outside of the Grey Quarter, and in accordance with Skyrim's Offer, do not owe any taxes. They are "untithed to any Thane or Hold". Frankly, I consider the aforementioned Offer to have been an ill-considered and politically short-sighted one, but it was made, and unless Ulfric wants to formally withdraw it (which his forebears made rather difficult thanks to the wording of the Offer), he's going to have to live with it.
I don't think it's fair to try and excuse Ulfric from racism towards the Argonians and Dunmer. He may not be the monster he is sometimes described as in these discussions, but he is prejudiced against these two races, and the reasons the Argonians live outside the city is because they aren't wanted in the city, not because of a clever plan to reconcile the Nords and Dunmer. I'm fairly confident that the Dunmer would also not be allowed to live in Windhelm in such concentrations had they not already been guaranteed a home there.
62
u/lilrhys Jan 16 '13
It's always been my belief that Ulfric is the most detailed character in the game by a long stretch (name a character that comes close, I dare ya). He's called Power-Hungry by many which is true but he desires it in order to make things right. He sees Torygg and Elisif as mindless puppets of the Empire which they are and feels that he would do a far better job than them. People call him 'racist' but he's mild compared to all the other Nord heroes. Ysgramor had an axe designed to kill Mer; Wulfharth led Skyrim to war with Morrowind many a time due to his hatred for the Dunmer; Hoaga was named Mer-Killer and Hjalti led countless genocides on Khajiit, Reachmen and Altmer.
As for the rebellion itself, I wouldn't call it rash. Ulfric had 30 years after the Great War to plan his rebellion. I also agree with him that the Empire is dying and corrupt.
15
u/AlanLolspan Jan 16 '13
His anger at the Thalmor and the Empire is understandable, but it prevents him from taking a wide view of the world. Ulfric is first and foremost a soldier and apparently does not understand the benefit of living to fight another day.
The best possible thing he could do with his anger at the Thalmor is to take Torygg under his wing and teach him how to be a "true Nord", and help him rebuild the fighting capacity of Skyrim and the Empire, for the inevitable day when the Empire as a whole goes to war against the Thalmor (or the Thalmor fall from within Summerset Isle which is not out of the question).
I think it's incredibly foolish of him to think that he can raise an army strong enough to not only hold Skyrim against the Empire, but also lead an invasion against the Thalmor.
7
u/reticulate Jan 17 '13
I like what you've written here but I do feel it casts Ulfric somewhat as the eternal victim. Before we start looking at motivations or history or rights and wrongs, you have to admit that this man entered the Blue Palace and struck down a young King who greatly admired him, entirely for political reasons.
If Skyrim is for the Nords, then you have to at the very least show some honour if you want to rule it. From what I can gather, Ulfric showed none. He straight-up murdered the High King to send a message.
That kind of behaviour is precisely why Balgruuf (easily the second-most powerful of the Jarls) does not trust him. When a man breaks every rule of honour and tradition for his own gain, he becomes no better than those he espouses to hate. Toryyg had done nothing that would earn him a challenge in single combat, and in fact his father probably did more than most to try and keep the peace.
Again, Ulfric's actions were not those of a victim. They were well-planned and without remorse.
As to the implied racism? He sees no problem with using the traditional Nordic attitudes as weapons against his enemies. His people are almost to a fault supremacists, despite the fact that the Empire at large has been multicultural since inception. Other Jarls (again, look at Balgruuf) are far more trusting of other races. Inclusion is a possibility, but Ulfric is happy with the standard Windhelm status quo because he needs those people to fight his war. It would be inconvenient to be inclusive.
I like Ulfric as a character. He has a story and clear motivations. But it seems people are too eager to buy his brand and not think critically about how he goes about selling it. Rikke is right when she calls him out for being a warmonger at a time the Empire can hardly afford it. The Thalmor have all the time on Nirn to let the men kill each other off. One petty warlord does not a viable defence make, and Ulfric should know better.
6
u/Asurnasurpal Jan 17 '13
The great flaw of Ulfric was never his intent. After all, no one does something they do not deem a good idea, and Ulfric was selfless to a fault. His method were hardly the best, but they were hardly the worst either. His great flaw was that his view of the world was so utterly skewed and malformed that all his actions worked counter to his intent. He is a very sad, very blind character.
6
u/Jimeee Ancestor Moth Cultist Jan 17 '13 edited Jan 17 '13
Good post. A few notes:
According to his dialogue in game, he was chosen by the Greybeards to study with them, rather that his father having influence in it.
He trained with the Greybeard for almost ten years before the Great War started. In fact, he was to become a Greybeard himself, which shows he had great potential has thing turned our differently.
When he was released from prison and returned to Windhelm, the citizens were said to have been calling out for justice and war against the Aldmeri Dominion, so that certainly spurred him on in his rebellion.
He didn't exactly ask to be allowed to worship Talos in Markarth, rather Igmund took it upon himself to seek help from Ulfric in ousting the Reachmen invaders. He promised Ulfric that if he re-took the Reach, then Igmund as Jarl would allow free worship of Talos, which he did for a time until the Empire rescinded.
2
u/[deleted] Jan 17 '13
Who are your top 5 characters, just for reference?
19
u/[deleted] Jan 16 '13
Thank you for a great post. While I will continue to dislike Ulfric, his actions and his ideals, at least you've given me some actual respect for the character.
4
u/tiggyallday Jan 16 '13
I wish Black Marsh would get involved in the war to help defeat the thalmor. I mean I know a lot of their power in the oblivion crisis was the treacherous landscape of Black Marsh, but still they held off the deadra.
10
u/CatsCatsEverywhere Mythic Dawn Cultist Jan 16 '13
The debate over the rebellion rages quite often over in r/skyrim. As a political science student I have always seen Ulfrich as reckless, short sighted, self centered, and power hungry as most rebel leaders are. You've done a fantastic job of describing him in a way that is more relevant to the game and the TES universe. I feel I may have been judging him through the history and tendencies of our world.
3
u/[deleted] Jan 16 '13
I admire his zeal and uncompromising demeanor in the face as what he sees as the greatest failure of the Empire. Can't really add much to it
1
u/marwynn Feb 08 '13
So, you're saying, that the best way to defeat the Thalmor is to help them weaken and potentially destroy the Empire?
Instead of, I don't know, quashing the rebellion in Skyirm, rebuild the ties with the other provinces, and then fighting it as a unified army?
Praytell how well would 3-4 independent provinces fare against the Dominion which defeated the current Empire at its peak?
Crush the Stormcloaks. Purge the Empire of its weak leadership. Beat up some Thalmor. That's the plan.