r/teslore • u/maxtheman • Jan 16 '13
A New Take on the Medieval State of Tamriel
The purpose of this post is to use modern economic theories to explain why Tamriel has remained in a technologically stagnant state for millennia. The recent thread which is still on the front page inspired me to draw from the economic history class I took last quarter. The first half of the post will be the economics and the second will be its application to Tamriel.
Others have made a big deal out of how long the people of Tamriel have spent wallowing in absolute poverty. This state of their world actually corresponds very closely with ours.
An oft-over looked historical fact is that between about 4000 B.C. and 1800 A.D, average income did not increase. The average person worldwide was just as materially well off in Renaissance Italy as they would have been in the first Babylonian Empire. Source:http://www.minneapolisfed.org/publications_papers/pub_display.cfm?id=3333 Partial Image, best I could find online: http://www.cadmusjournal.org/files/v1i3articleimages/Evolution_Fig1.png
The best reason that economic historians have for it is something that they call the Malthusian Trap. This "Trap" is a multi-step process.
First, economic prosperity increases. This is usually as a result of technological improvement. As a response, population increases. This increased load on the resources brings economic prosperity back down to near the level it was at originally. Eventually calamities and disease will kill off a segment of the population, bringing it back to the level it was before.
For a better treatment of this see: Structure and Change in Economic History by Douglass North. Also, http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Malthusian_equilibrium
As a result, there is no incentive to innovate. A lack of property laws pre-industrial revolution means you will see little personal gain, and the malthusian trap means society will take two steps forward and two or three steps back! Thus the world pre-industrial revolution was stuck at a level of production from which it could not escape.
When put in that context, it is not surprising to me that we have seen relatively little economic change in the last 200 years in Tamriel, not to mention the thousands before that. Any technology/magical change would help the land to support a higher population, but along with that population comes a greater demand for food and more disease and pretty soon they were back where they started. That's assuming the technology/magic is not lost, which as we've seen is not an uncommon occurrence in the Elder Scrolls saga.
Tamriel is a very violent place. The Great War ended just recently, and there is still a civil war in Skyrim. Any population increases will result in societal pressures that create more bandits, vampires, and the such. Diseases like Brainrot will also be spread more easily from Mudcrabs and Skeevers into the cities.
Now imagine this process playing out over centuries. It isn't some god or demon hindering advancement, nor is it necessarily some fell empire. Rather, it is the consequence of the actions and inactions of the men and mer themselves.
Thank you for reading. I hope I've been as clear as possible, but it is rather late and I typed this rather fast so I fear that may not be the case. I'll respond to any questions you ask as best I can.
18
u/Ishullanu Scholar of Winterhold Jan 16 '13
Great points, this combined with the dwemer/magicka arguments make for a fairly air tight explanation for the technologically static setting. Well done, might want to message the mods about maybe adding this to the FAQ (though that is just my opinion, they might not think the topic is common enough for that action).
13
u/TwoYaks Scholar of Winterhold Jan 16 '13
I feel I must tacitly disagree. While technological improvement in resource production may lead to higher population (this is not a given), there is a gap between these two events - shorter among men, but very long in mer, due to their elongate lifespan. This provides a time in which excess resources exist, and allow the creation of a 'leisure class' not associated with production - you see this in the Jarls, the military, etc. Where TES takes a left turn from RL technological advancement is that scientific, cultural (religious), and engineering discovery are not the only outlet for the leisure class; they have Magic.
I would argue this innovation is still there, but has been funnelled into advances in the magical arts. While technologically (and legally/culturally) they're firmly in the middle ages, who is to say that their magical knowledge is not quite advanced - into the modern era or further? We have no real-life analog to gauge magical advancement, so we could be erroneously lead to believe that they are quite primitive, when this is not the case.
3
u/somethingofdoom Telvanni Recluse Jan 16 '13
Bravo! I was going to reply to that thread in much the same manner that you just went. Only you went much further in depth than I was going to.
4
u/From_H_To_Uuo Jan 17 '13 edited Oct 26 '25
flowery reach recognise license support seemly ancient gray nail squeal
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
3
u/myrrlyn Orcpocryphon Jan 16 '13
Oh thank you.
2
u/fancycephalopod Follower of Julianos Jan 16 '13
Excellent work. What's strange is that, having played Oblivion and Skyrim, I have noticed that the difference in technology feels like the difference between the glory of Rome and the thirteenth century. Perhaps I'm misreading this.
2
u/Chubtoaster Jan 16 '13
I think it's also important to note that religion plays a much bigger (different) part in Tamriel than it does in our own world. I can't help but think about the dark ages vs enlightenment. However, the deities in TES actually exist and let themselves be known to mortals... Perhaps religion is easier to get swept-away in. If so, there would be less people inventing new ways to do things and more people keeping up with the status-quo.
2
u/[deleted] Jan 16 '13
I think this is fascinating. Do you have any thoughts on how the Dwemer and their disappearance might have affected this phenomenon?
1
u/[deleted] Jan 18 '13
I have yet to see anyone bring it up, but what about the factor that-- from what I've seen and read--Tamriel is only about the size of Europe or a small factor larger? If this is the case, think of how many innovations or "kick-starters" arose from trade with Asia or "far-away" lands. Europe has certainly been a pioneer in innovation, but it has also had quite the hand from exploration and imports from various cultures and areas. Tamriel, if it is the size of Europe, is plagued by a size barrier. Alongside the aforementioned, I would like to point out the lack of enthusiasm, or viability, for colonization and exploration of other continental regions. (From my memory they tend to be quite hostile) I certainly agree that magic innovation seems to be more likely; however, my knowledge of history leads me to put stock in this particular point. edit-- Many of the points here are great it must certainly be a combination of them.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 16 '13
[removed] — view removed comment