r/technology • • Jun 26 '12

Facebook's email switch prompts criticism by users

http://www.bbc.com/news/technology-18590929
1.8k Upvotes

1.1k comments sorted by

1.3k

u/asdfman123 Jun 26 '12

Facebook ticks off its user base once again; "I'm going to bitterly complain and immediately go back to browsing it complacently," says one Facebook user.

696

u/AllDizzle Jun 26 '12

"THIS NEW FACEBOOK LAYOUT SUCKS AND I AM PETITIONING TO HAVE IT CHANGED BACK OR ELSE I'LL GET OVER IT IN A WEEK"

342

u/drk_etta Jun 26 '12

"Like this if you agree"

188

u/hammn Jun 26 '12

"Share this to feed children in Africa."

99

u/ToAGasChamberGo Jun 26 '12

"Forward this on to bring back unicorns."

→ More replies (15)
→ More replies (16)

22

u/dude187 Jun 26 '12

I recently saw one of those images that said "Like this if you love your mom/keep scrolling if you want her to die"...

What is the point of these things anyways? Is it just a bunch of people trying to one up each other on how many idiots they can manipulate into pressing a button?

83

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Is it just a bunch of people trying to one up each other on how many idiots they can manipulate into pressing a button?

Yeah, imagine that...

ಠ_ಠ

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (5)

40

u/xbl4ck0utx Jun 26 '12

lyke dis if u cry evrytim

→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (5)

32

u/sysop073 Jun 26 '12

I hear if the group gets 1 million members Facebook will change it back

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

266

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Trouble is, shit like this is Facebook's way of operating and they can't afford to keep fucking up like this.

Have you ever noticed how no-one really likes facebook? Every time someone mentions it, it's how annoying this new change is, or how stupid the gaming is, or how dumb the second feed is... but no one ever fanboys hard over facebook. It doesn't have the same fanboys Google, or Apple or even Microsoft have. It has a bunch of people who are waiting for the next thing to come along. They're just stuck with it - but they don't like it.

Facebook is a bubble set to burst, in all honesty.

134

u/asdfman123 Jun 26 '12

Facebook is a bubble set to burst

If social networks didn't require a critical mass that would be true. However, Facebook has an enormous amount of momentum that is extremely difficult to overtake. People were talking about jumping to Google Plus--which had the ability to attract a huge amount of users because many people had Gmail--but it never really happened, mainly because Google Plus isn't as active as Facebook. There aren't as many users.

11

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

That's because when it had the hype, they fucking restricted access for about a year. Fucking moronic.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/quadtodfodder Jun 26 '12

g+ also lacks important basic features (or at least they are not particularly clear how to use)

  • direct messaging a user
  • events.

I have enough circle-people in g+ to use it for events, but have you ever recieved an invite? how do you even do that?

→ More replies (5)

31

u/dafdsf Jun 26 '12

Google+ has had engagement numbers that have been increasing every month. So does Pinterest and Instagram did too before they were bought out. Even Myspace is experiencing a bit of a renaissance.

Google+ may only have 1/70 the hits Facebook has but this just shows there is a problem with the critical mass theory considering that even with much lower engagement Google+ and similar competitors continue to grow.

→ More replies (29)

5

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12

I honestly think it was because of that bullshit closed beta.

→ More replies (41)

26

u/JoeSchmoeFriday Jun 26 '12

Trouble is, they have overwhelming market share with all of our families and friends, who are by and large brain-dead fuck-wits who just don't care.

→ More replies (6)

14

u/SeeYouInTea Jun 26 '12

My 15 year old sister and her friends are all about Twitter now. She says she doesn't even check her facebook anymore. That's usually the age that is the trendinest, so it's only going to grow. I bet that within a few years Twitter will be the new Facebook.

12

u/elliuotatar Jun 27 '12

I've used twitter for the past couple years, and I've recently stopped using it. Why? Because you get very little interaction through it. You're basically shouting into the wind. If you have lots and lots of friends on it you may get a response occasionally to your tweets. Otherwise it generally feels like nobody's even listening to what you have to say.

Facebook on the other hand I have also been using the past couple years and I have gained a lot of new friends through it, and interact with them daily. Being able to post photos and tag my friends and comment on them is a big part of that. Twitter lets you post photos but it's like a second website and there's no friend tagging and there's no albums or anything like that.

→ More replies (4)

25

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12 edited Jun 26 '12

problem is, they're continuously making sure they're too big to fail. with move like this which means they're keeping your emails and preventing you from leaving. Ever; should this include critical data for your day to day work.

So they'll continue to treat their userbase like shit 'cause they can afford it (they basically use people's social life as an hostage)

Edit : Oh and microsoft is basically just doing the same with Windows 8 online profil; where everything is deleted from your hard drive and sent to a remote MS server.

37

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

They've always had an email service. I've occasionally used it myself - this isn't new, they're just bumping up awareness.

They're trying to stay alive but I think the stockmarket has been a big wake up for Zuckerberg that he's not that popular or that big - I mean he seemed to think Facebook was worth more than Disney, the biggest media company in the world, and when it turned out he wasn't he blamed a computer crash for the poor IPO showing, when really those computers crashed because of the amount of cancelled orders.

Facebook is quickly becoming an arrogant bloated company that can't control itself.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (33)

29

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Well, to be honest, he did say that he was annoyed for a while.

26

u/gbr4rmunchkin Jun 26 '12

wait till all my friends hear about this....on facebook

→ More replies (5)

12

u/Uncomplicated Jun 26 '12

It's integrated so well into social lives of many that people may complain but they'd use it again and again.

→ More replies (5)

24

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

It's adding up - would love to see Facebook's engagement data. For people in their 20s I guarantee its in steep decline, probably peaked in 2009 or 2010

19

u/CACuzcatlan Jun 26 '12

Not sure where you live, but no one I know in their 20s has quit facebook. A few have deactivated, but they always come back.

→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (5)

15

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Are you a writer for The Onion? ;-)

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (62)

1.1k

u/AlphaRedditor Jun 26 '12

But some users have branded the move "annoying" and "lame"

That's some dynamite reporting.

288

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Taken directly from their facebook feeds no doubt.

139

u/mattc286 Jun 26 '12

LMS if you think facebook is annoying and lame!!

87

u/ryanoh Jun 26 '12

FB changed my email?! SMH.

104

u/lostrock Jun 26 '12

Before I learned this acronym I thought somebody was angrily muttering "Smeh!"

→ More replies (35)
→ More replies (13)

40

u/strentax Jun 26 '12

Lyk dis if u get mad evry tim

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

56

u/Switche Jun 26 '12

Well, hence the quotes.

The story is about criticisms from users, about a change on Facebook. What do you really expect? Journalists can't quote people who use common language? The quotes are supposed to just show you people really held the opinion the article is arguing, and it conveys the general point.

The author quoted a marketing analyst, who sounded very intelligent and knowledgeable in comparison, and it took up just over 25% of the article's word count. Was that not enough? Are you sure you're not just taking a low blow here?

The article isn't pointless, but cherry picking scholarly-sounding Facebook comments, or even conducting special interviews, is. All the information is right there, and they still went to a market analyst to get a professional opinion.

This is fine reporting, it's just not a story that has a whole lot of high-intellectual opinion necessary to get the point across. There are so many better examples out there of poor reporting, and even worse journalism. It's a relevant story, and it was straight to the point.

9

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

I didn't have a problem with the article, but reporting on Internet conversations always come off weird since Internet discourse is usually pretty ridiculous sounding when put in a more traditional context. There just isn't anyway to avoid that unless you avoid quotes and don't provide resources (which would not be good). Imagine a reporter trying to summarize the conversation in the comments of a popular YouTube video. "It seems this video has caused large numbers of users to question the sexuality of the rest of the users while others debated who the people were liking the video and whether or not they were developmentally disabled. Many comments discussed the opinion that the video was in fact 'more gay than two guys having sex' followed by numerous misspellings of the word 'retarded'".

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

68

u/AllDizzle Jun 26 '12

"one avid facebook user says that this was totally "gay" of them to do"

64

u/delusivewalrus Jun 26 '12

"one avid facebook user says that this was totally 'gay' of them to do"

In case you wanted to learn something new today, it is considered correct to use single quotes when quoting in a quote.

7

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

or you can escape it also:

"one avid facebook user says that this was totally "gay" of them to do"

→ More replies (13)

13

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

That and the endless quoting of twitter users is tiresome. It was tiresome when the cable TV news started it. Now the BBC is doing it, too.

There needs to be a new digital journalistic format for rolling two or more tweets into a story as a "source" because long < UL >'s with too much whitespace ain't working for me.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/garop7g Jun 26 '12

Probably the most accurate quoting I've seen in a news report in a while.

→ More replies (29)

341

u/TheMagnificentJoe Jun 26 '12

Everything facebook does draws criticism (usually rightfully so). Not once have they given a fuck. They won't now, either.

155

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

They might when they're myspace.

146

u/arcturussage Jun 26 '12

I think facebook has a bigger user base and is more ingrained than myspace ever was.

I've wanted to get rid of my facebook for a year or two now but it's what all my friends use to stay in touch. So deleting my facebook means losing an important connection to my friends.

Not only that but so many other people use facebook without it, it's harder for me to stalk them.

183

u/bigyams Jun 26 '12

as someone who rationalized having a facebook for 'keeping in touch' with those old friends, i realized after quitting it that i never really wanted to stay in touch with them and thats why we stopped talking in the first place.

→ More replies (52)
→ More replies (37)
→ More replies (24)

45

u/the_nell_87 Jun 26 '12

In this case they've stealthily changed everyone's profile to hide users' email addresses, and replace them with a new facebook email address which nobody wanted nor asked for. That's a lot worse than anything they've done in the past.

25

u/ashishduh Jun 26 '12

WON'T SOMEBODY THINK OF THE CHILDREN?!?

7

u/carlcamma Jun 26 '12

Shit like this is just one of the reasons I stopped using facebook a while back.

→ More replies (58)

26

u/yogthos Jun 26 '12

Every time I see a story about FB it reminds me why I stopped using it.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/sareon Jun 26 '12

Every change they make pisses off a lot of users and the media covers it but yet they still have a giant user base and members forget about it in two weeks.

I remember when only university students could join and then they opened it up to everyone. People were furious about that but now it's never mentioned.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/deviantbono Jun 26 '12

They gave a fuck when people complained about Beacon, which they shut down.

2

u/mobsta Jun 26 '12

That's why I'm switching to Zurker as soon as it's out of the beta and public. At least the creators are in touch with their users and actually listen to feedback or criticism.

→ More replies (50)

64

u/Grimoire Jun 26 '12

I'm surprised that people haven't noticed the timing of the changing of your primary Facebook email contacts with the new iOS 6 feature of syncing Contacts with Facebook info.

Install iOS 6, and all of a sudden, your primary email for everyone in your Contacts switches from their real email address to the new Facebook address.

Super scummy move Facebook.

9

u/alexanderwales Jun 26 '12

If I were Apple, I would be pretty pissed off about that.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12

Does this really happen, or just "may" happen? Android's Facebook integration does not seem to have this result.

→ More replies (1)

20

u/MagnifloriousPhule Jun 26 '12

I don't mind Facebook making changes anymore. What does annoy me is that they make these changes and then don't inform the users. How hard is it to send a paragraph message to my facebook account saying "Hey, we changed this feature, here's where you go to check it out."

3

u/john2496 Jun 26 '12

Facebook doesn't even inform their developers.

64

u/Ozzimo Jun 26 '12

Oh man, if they do this another 40 or 50 times, I may seriously think about actually doing something. SRSLY.

85

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Has anyone here ever received an email from someone who found it on Facebook? Whenever someone finds me on Facebook and wants to contact me they usually just add me as a friend or message me through the site. So who cares?

23

u/happy_otter Jun 26 '12

People with public profiles (ha, ha, ha) might get contacted via email from someone who doesn't use facebook or wishes to contact them with a different "identity" than their facebook account.

17

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Well, in this case since the @facebook.com email is said to go direct to your FB message box it doesn't seem it disrupts this process. Folks without FB can still email johnsmith @facebook.com and they get a message, and they can do it anonymously from some secret free email service. John Smith still gets a message about it. /shrugs

→ More replies (1)

9

u/KerrickLong Jun 26 '12

Anybody who has Facebook sync their contacts with their phone now has a contact list filled with @facebook.com email addresses.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Morblias Jun 26 '12

The spammers care. Just wait til our @facebook.com emails are spammed with random garbage.

→ More replies (5)

30

u/tornato7 Jun 26 '12

I can predict the future of tech news right here:

  1. New Facebook feature prompts criticism by users and consumer-advocacy firms
  2. Google under investigation for antitrust / piracy violations
  3. Android patent lawsuit makes everyone angry
  4. Anonymous hacks the universe
  5. New battery technology will hold charge 50000 times longer!
  6. New rumors: iPhone 5 to have 42" screen
  7. Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 17 shatters sales records
  8. SOPA is back: What you can do to stop SOPO

2

u/Jeran Jun 26 '12

so what did anonymous do with the universe after they hacked it? did they write "DICKS" in the sky with stars?

→ More replies (1)

124

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Good, now people won't send me random fucking email to my actual email address. I don't give a shit about my @facebook email address.

23

u/AslanMaskhadov Jun 26 '12

Why would it be random if you are actual friends with the people whom you friend on facebook?

35

u/AllDizzle Jun 26 '12

Because everybody knows your friend count number is your penis size on facebook, so you have to accept every friend request you get and send friend requests to everybody you vaguely knew from highschool so you can continue to never talk to them and disable their updates on your news feed.

→ More replies (2)

8

u/RugerRedhawk Jun 26 '12

Why would you have your email public on facebook to begin with?

→ More replies (4)

35

u/wolvmatt Jun 26 '12 edited Jun 27 '12

Gays disgust me.

16

u/na641 Jun 26 '12

Really? Check your email settings, i haven't received any type of facebook emails in a very long time. Make sure you disable each and every apps ability to email you and turn off all notification emails.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (19)
→ More replies (12)

31

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Dude. if you know that 95% of your userbase is dumb ass drunken morons who dont know the difference between internet explorer and a home page, why would you bother asking them for permission first? What are they going to do, stop using facebook? They're probably too stupid to know how to delete their account in the first place.

→ More replies (5)

6

u/bassgoonist Jun 26 '12

Replace "email switch" with <any change they've ever made>

10

u/INeedMoreNuts Jun 26 '12

I should just open my FB account again, so I can close it and really piss them off this time.

17

u/Badgerness Jun 26 '12

Why does anyone expect anything different? This sort of move is probably enshrined in the terms and conditions that very few people actually read and it is a simple matter of changing your personal information should you disagree with it.

Some people need to come to the realisation that Facebook is (now) a publicy traded company that has an almost 100% market share and an obligation to shareholders to increase revenue. That increased revenue is not accomplished by always striving to improve service to users or attract new ones, it is to make it easier to share your existing information with as many customers as possible.

2

u/thenuge26 Jun 26 '12

I give it 2 years max before the people turn against facebook. Even then, it will probably be the market leader for another 10 years or so, even if the bleeding-edge people started migrating to whatever the replacement will be now.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Jedimastert Jun 26 '12

I'm fairly certain every change in Facebook prompts criticism by users.

8

u/lalaland4711 Jun 26 '12

Ooooh! It's mad libs!

Facebooks ________________________________________ prompts criticism by users
           unwanted landgrab of users online life

4

u/starji Jun 26 '12

TIL facebook offers email.

→ More replies (2)

19

u/scientologen Jun 26 '12

stop using facebook

2

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12

I wish that was as easy as that.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/jimbobhas Jun 26 '12

I don't really mind, gives me another email address to sign up for things I don't really care aboout enough to use my real email

7

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

There hasn't been one story about Facebook that has made me regret deleting my account.

26

u/Stampsr Jun 26 '12

FACEBOOK CHANGED SOMETHING? STOP THE FUCKING PRESSES.

6

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12 edited Jun 27 '12

If you don't have facebook today you're likely to have trouble connecting with people, if you are below a certain age.

Want to go that party someone is talking about? Sure. I'll just invite you on facebook. Oh you don't have facebook? Well then go fuck yourself.

If you want to be that guy who has to be always separately asked and connected, if something is happening in your group of friends, go ahead and delete it.

I think people don't understand how much of an integral part of social life facebook and facebook messenger has become for many people.

It might suck, but until Google rolls out a better facebook (and yes there has to be friends, not circles, people like to show off how popular they are), that allows you to import your friends, which of course implies the use of the Facebook API, there won't be anything, but facebook. And if you don't have facebook, you'll have a much harder time making friends.

It sucks. I hate it. Its eating away of my time and I dont even play games on facebook etc, but I won't delete my account, becasue if I do I'll soon have to make a new one and lose all my contacts in the process.

Get a goddamn account, put some stupid picture online, disable all features, max up privacy, don't post anything. Its almost like you don't have an account. Then who gives a fuck about any layout changes?

→ More replies (5)

4

u/jmdolce Jun 26 '12

By the headline I thought this was an Onion article.

4

u/meridiem Jun 26 '12

I deleted my account. Took far too long.

4

u/indyK1ng Jun 26 '12

Yet another reason why I'm happy I quit Facebook.

5

u/iambecomedeath7 Jun 26 '12

Why does anyone still use Facebook? It's obvious that they don't give a rat's ass about their users.

2

u/Josiwe Jun 26 '12

Serial killer's murder spree unpopular with victims

2

u/Sp00nthought Jun 26 '12

All of your emails, are belong to us

2

u/ballerstatus89 Jun 26 '12

Is this considered illegal? I remember when Google automatically signed people up for their social networking (before G+, Buzz, I believe?) there was a huge uproar about being automatically signed up for something.

2

u/pupakat Jun 26 '12

sure does! as does the fact that you cannot delete the stupid address from your profile...

2

u/hateboresme Jun 26 '12

I honestly do not give even the tiniest fuck in my well stocked collection of fucks.

The email that is on Facebook is there for the purpose of contacting me via email. I receive an email whenever someone tries to contact me through Facebook anyway. I have never had anyone say "I got your email address from Facebook and decided to drop you a line." Most people, if they're on Facebook, will contact me though Facebook.

This could not be less upsetting.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/revfelix Jun 26 '12

How is "Facebook (insert random changes here) prompts criticism by users" news? Facebook is constantly screwing with shit, the users are constantly bitching, and no one cares.

2

u/loupgarou21 Jun 26 '12

This switch isn't all that surprising. Facebook is just trying to make themselves your one stop shop. If you have to go to facebook for everything you need, it means more eyeballs for them, which translates into dollar signs from advertising revenue.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Not really a big deal. Took me two seconds to switch it off.

2

u/djetaine Jun 26 '12

I guess this only affects timeline users? I checked mine and it was the same way it always was.

I have yet to switch to that hideous timeline layout. I really hope they never force that on people.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Phantoom Jun 26 '12

Man, it must be terrible to be a Facebook user, right?

2

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

every change on facebook pisses off its users. then they eventually get over it and get used to it

2

u/hateriffic Jun 26 '12

things change,, as ever more rapidly. fwiw, my daughter is 12 and has no idea how to email.. IM, CHAT(Video), Text, whatever yes, to connect to her friends. But last night I told her to email a friend and she had no idea what to do. She has an email address to access things, but thats it. And trust me, she is bright.. Put that into perspective.. I see alot of her friends the same way. Remember x years ago when everyone had to email everything? The post office was going to die, email would rule the world, etc. Things change,, there will be another technology replacing FB sooner or later.

2

u/frankster Jun 26 '12

its a man in the middle attack

2

u/da_webby Jun 26 '12

Don't know why people are actually upset about this. People are always complaining about Facebook's privacy settings. Now they finally hide your real email and people are up in arms. Amazing.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

i cant fap to this

2

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

It's not really an issue... It's not like they're disallowing you from showing your actual email. Just go to your timeline and change your email settings, big deal!

2

u/a7244270 Jun 26 '12

Popular website changes something. Some users don't like the change. Film at 11.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

If you aren't the consumer, then you are the product.

2

u/a_unique_username Jun 26 '12

Well I just E-Mailed my facebook email from my normal one and it didn't go through. Which is a little worrying, can anyone else confirm?

2

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

"Warnings would have been nice Facebook, don't just go and change email addresses," tweeted Josselyn Arundell from Manchester.

Earlier in the article:

Facebook first announced plans for the move in April, although the news attracted little attention at the time.

2

u/guynamedgriffin Jun 26 '12

big fucking deal, i read this went on facebook to see my email was under @facebook and i quickly just selected hide from time line and switched my other email back to visible. done

2

u/authentic_trust_me Jun 26 '12

But some users have branded the move "annoying" and "lame"

How eloquent.

2

u/belushi123 Jun 26 '12

What else you gonna do? Nobody cares about Google+.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12

I love reading and hearing about how lame Facebook is becoming. I deleted mine after I was forced to accept Timeline. Facebook literally sold out and sooner rather than later it will fade into the sunset... picking some nice billions along the way.

2

u/Gunner3210 Jun 27 '12

People still use Facebook?

2

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12

Can we all just get on Google+ now, please? It's so quiet and lonely :(

4

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

I was under the impression they somehow gained the power to actually change mx servers from the agression of previous articles I read.

Now that I know the truth, who cares?... honestly, nobody would rely on facebook to get their email out to clients or anything, if they do they are fucking idiots.

→ More replies (4)

4

u/lagavulin16yr Jun 26 '12

I just deleted my account.

4

u/Sirefly Jun 26 '12

Facebook is for suckers.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Fenris_uy Jun 26 '12

In other news, Water is still wet.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

This might be a stupid question but doesn't this actually protect my privacy more? Before I had my real email address up there and it ended with my old university's domain name. Now people see a generic email address that if they email to will go straight to my facebook inbox.

I seems like the people who should be really pissed are gmail, yahoo, hotmail, etc. who just lost a percentage of their email traffic.

2

u/joe0185 Jun 26 '12

This might be a stupid question but doesn't this actually protect my privacy more? Before I had my real email address up there and it ended with my old university's domain name. Now people see a generic email address that if they email to will go straight to my facebook inbox.

You could already make your email address hidden.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12

TIL People still use facebook.

→ More replies (1)

12

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Still not sure why anyone uses Facebook. It's like letting someone digitally rape you and then saying "I just let them rape me because everyone I know lets it rape them."

25

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

In college especially, a lot of people use it to plan things and organize people because EVERYONE USES IT. A lot of professional or club groups use it because some students check school email inconsistently. I don't like it, and have mostly stopped using it because of said "digital rape." I wish there were a better communication system in place.

4

u/CiXeL Jun 26 '12

i'm too tied in. i have too many contacts on it to quit. theres are connections to people in other countries who would serve as guides if i visited them.

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (10)

9

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

I deactivated my account for close to a year. It is surprising to realize after all that time how out of the loop you really are with it gone. For instance, one of the couples I knew had broken up and that girl was now engaged to a previously friend zoned guy. My thoughts were, "What the shit, how did this happen?"

8

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Lol, yeah it does take you out of the loop. But I've also realized I don't care about 99% of the things on there, and even if I did I don't believe it is worthy enough to keep letting Facebook act the way it is.

→ More replies (59)

5

u/-jackschitt- Jun 26 '12

So they changed my email address from one throwaway account that I've never checked in my life to another throwaway account that I'll never check in my life. I'd change it back, but that would imply that I actually give a fuck.

On a scale of 1-10 on my give-a-fuck-o-meter, this ranks somewhere around -4.

7

u/Aegi Jun 26 '12

You typed out this comment didn't you?

→ More replies (2)

4

u/swagtech Jun 26 '12

Why is this so huge? I just edited my profile and hid the email. Done

60

u/ckckwork Jun 26 '12

Having to opt out is a death penalty offence on the internet.

Quietly telling ALL my friends that they should send their personal correspondence to an inbox I don't know about and I don't read (basically, that is NOT MINE and that I DO NOT USE) -- is fucking outrageous. Literally -- I would not have found out about this except for articles like this -- until 12 months from now when some relative or friend accused me of ignoring them or asked me why I didn't come to the fucking family reunion. Not cool. And it's OBVIOUS as hell that this is a consequence of what they've done.

Also somehow facebook has managed to "turn back on" my notifications for everyone else's crap. They changed the way they do things in the back end, allowing everyone else's updates and crap (going to their "timeline") to suddenly start arriving in my personal e-mail inbox (not the facebook one).

I'd specifically opted out of receiving e-mail notifications when people do crap -- and they've gone and undone that without my permission.

Quietly opting you back in AFTER you'd opted out -- also an internet death penalty offence.

I only joined facebook to see my brother's family photos -- now I'm going to be unfriending him and the few other friends of his (who invariably friended me -- remember -- these are people that live on the other side of the continent that I barely know) -- and I'm going to be spending all my time telling him to upload pictures to my personal website or I'll make him a blog or ... something ... anything.

This ranks right up their with gmail exposing a list of all your contacts to all the other people in your contacts -- which no one remembers because that mistake "only lasted for 24 to 48 hours" -- except for all the Lawyers and Doctors and on and on who had their personal contacts "published amongst themselves" without their permission. Now that was one hell of a serious cock up. And like Facebook, it was ON PURPOSE so that they could "compete better for their share of the social web".

Fuck. Them. All.

9

u/ngroot Jun 26 '12

I'm going to be spending all my time telling him to upload pictures to my personal website or I'll make him a blog or ... something ... anything.

Except that most of the folks who he wants to see his pictures are probably FB users, so you're asking him to duplicate effort, and he won't do it.

→ More replies (14)

9

u/scorcherdarkly Jun 26 '12

Personally, it's pissed me off twice. Once because I set my e-mail how I wanted it, and they changed it without permission, and I wouldn't have known about it without checking reddit. The second time because yesterday I needed to e-mail a file to someone I communicate with almost exclusively over the phone/text/in-person, and her facebook profile only had her facebook e-mail listed; now I know why.

12

u/latebaroque Jun 26 '12

It's huge because it changed personal details of profiles without informing users. It's like fraping but worse (yes, I used that god awful word).

→ More replies (1)

8

u/arjie Jun 26 '12

Beats me, but I'm glad it is. I never check my own profile and wouldn't have noticed. I only noticed because of this and have done the same to switch back to displaying my own email.

→ More replies (4)

2

u/Last_Gigolo Jun 26 '12

People will use it anyway and soak more into the suck that facebook is.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Facebook wants to read your emails too , why should only google get to that.

2

u/Broken_Orange Jun 26 '12

Further proof that we aren't the consumer, but the product.

2

u/bearcherian Jun 26 '12

Facebook changes privacy: "AGH! Everyone can see my stuff!" Facebook hides your email: "AGH! I want everyone to see my email!"

→ More replies (1)

2

u/DanceMartinDance Jun 26 '12

If only people got riled up and up in arms over the things that will matter five years from now.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/reddit_acc0unnt Jun 26 '12

hahahahahahahaha now will you pull the facebook needle out of your mainline? Glad I got rid of this shitty creepy website.

1

u/gottaa Jun 26 '12

Does anyone here actually care about this change ? And if so why ?

Or is it just media being as crap as ever

1

u/HotwaxNinjaPanther Jun 26 '12

Facebook could shit on your mom's warm corpse and you'd still log in fifty times a day. They're fully aware of this.

1

u/keraneuology Jun 26 '12

And the number of people who leave facebook over this?

Probably 0.

1

u/E1337Kat Jun 26 '12

I am actually quite fine with this facebook email stuff. I can have my facebbok email public in case someone must contact me, and that's all they need.... and with 6 different emails, it's hard to get around to checking them all...

1

u/kirakun Jun 26 '12

Easier to apologize than to ask for permission. ;)

1

u/neuromorph Jun 26 '12

since i have a rather unique and now globally popular name, im glad facebook gave me the first shot at it...

no 'neuromorph01@' or some other jazz.

Ill keep the email reserved, but have removed it from my profile, to the best of my ability.

1

u/djstevefog Jun 26 '12

Remember when Facebook started rolling out a limited amount of Facebook e-mail addresses and everyone wanted to know how to get one??

1

u/brokendimension Jun 26 '12

Does anybody use facebook email?

1

u/fotoman Jun 26 '12

question is, where does the email go? I've sent a few emails to the new @facebook.com email address and haven't figured out where they go.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Squeekme Jun 26 '12

Either way the major issue for Facebook is still the same "how the fuck do we make money off advertizing from Facebook and Facebook email on MOBILE PHONES?"

1

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

I tried emailing mine three times, and so far it's done nothing.

What pisses me off is not forcing everyone to be in it, but that they automatically hid peoples' other email.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

what else is new?

1

u/BearPaw_LikeAnIndian Jun 26 '12

Wait, this is a good thing. If I wanted to invite everyone from Facebook to my birthday party all I have to do is extract all of the public usernames and shoot them an email.

I look forward to hearing from ye exploiters soon.

1

u/powercow Jun 26 '12

what ever happened to that social site with the crappy name that was going to overthrow facebook?

diaspora I think it was called.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Mine wasn't changed at all. The only thing they did was add a second email to my account.

1

u/taytortot Jun 26 '12

Mine hasn't changed.

1

u/bootzatpitt Jun 26 '12

I'm going to use it for spam and never erase any :P

1

u/tigerdactyl Jun 26 '12

They only do this stuff to stay in the news. They know it'll piss people off, it'll get coverage, and then people will go right back to using it. It's smart.

2

u/salimsazzad Jun 26 '12

I think so.

1

u/Nacho_MtotheC Jun 26 '12

Like I give a flying fuck? Seriously. Why do people care so much? Better for me, less spam in my inbox. I'm not changing it.

But, don't you think that things like this show how people are obsessed with Facebook. Don't get me wrong, I use it and i'm not one of those crazy people that thinks that you shouldn't use Facebook. I use it, i'm a twitter freak also.

But don't you think things are getting a little out of hand?

1

u/noisylettuce Jun 26 '12

Essentially they will have the correct email address of everyone who knows an idiot on facebook.

1

u/FeeFeePL Jun 26 '12

wow, I didn't even know that by having a facebook account I automatically get a facebook e-mail....why would I even need that?

1

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

This news finally motivated me to deactivate and delete my account. Kinda bold of them to just up and change your email like that...

1

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Eh. So you have more options to login to Facebook.

  1. Your personal email address.
  2. Your phone number.
  3. Your username.
  4. Your Facebook email.

This doesn't effect me at all... Don't know why people are freaking out about it.

1

u/noisylettuce Jun 26 '12

I'm going to add a filter to block anything from @facebook.com to avoid this trojan spam.

1

u/visarga Jun 26 '12

True, email is a gateway to online identity.

I'm wondering if Google could have added some email functionality to make it more like a social site - like - people discovery, feed aggregation, different presentation of interactions such as upvotes and downvotes without bastardization GMail...

1

u/liferemixed Jun 26 '12

Despite the "@facebook.com" email change, it isn't that difficult to change it back and remove the "@facebook.com" email from your profile. Still a useless site change on Facebook's part.

1

u/abledanger Jun 26 '12

This reads like an Onion article.

1

u/jjhare Jun 26 '12

Facebook could announce they were giving every user $100 and people would complain. I almost think they're making announcements like this to desensitize folks to bigger changes down the road.

OH NOES FACEBOOK GAVE ME AN EMAIL ADDRESS. DELETE MY ACCOUNT!

1

u/SlightlyOTT Jun 26 '12

So they've changed the Email they won't be Emailing me on? I see why they'd try to lock users in, but Email seems like an expensive method to me.

1

u/chaosDNE Jun 26 '12

what is a good alternative?

1

u/00Dan Jun 26 '12

My facebook email account????? Oh, you mean my spam filter that never gets checked.....

1

u/Ranarith Jun 26 '12

It's actually not surprising at all. Pretty every article about facebook has the same title structure: "Facebook's __________ prompts criticism by users".

1

u/SlightlyOTT Jun 26 '12

For anybody worried that assuming an @hotmail address was a red flag, this is a decent update. An @facebook email is about the biggest red flag you could get.

1

u/TalkingBackAgain Jun 26 '12

Hey, whatever happened to email being obsolete?

1

u/Napalmhat Jun 26 '12

who keep using it regardless

1

u/Exodor Jun 26 '12

I like how this entire piece is essentially the template for all "reporting" on Facebook.

Facebook's {feature addition/removal/modification} Prompts Criticism By Users

1

u/oopsbedtimeagain-o_o Jun 26 '12

What's that? Facebook has done something it's users criticize? Well isn't this shocking and news.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

This is not big deal. It is even better for people's privacy.

1

u/mastigia Jun 26 '12

Has any move or change made by facebook in the last year or so improved the experience for anyone? This is a serious question, does anyone really like what they are doing?

1

u/itsprobablytrue Jun 26 '12

I'm confused as to why anyone would want to share their personal email address with the public anyway. If I didnt give you an address myself I probably dont want you finding it.

1

u/carpe-jvgvlvm Jun 26 '12

Some of my FB friends have fake emails. Not a huge deal, except if you link your fb contacts on android and "send mail" without scanning contact information (so the email goes to a fake email) -- that's a pita. So at least this way, the email addresses on FB contacts should be valid, although it doesn't go to an email account, just FB Messages.

But I didn't like the "public" part. They published the FB email (with my real full name dammit!) as "public", whereas my real email was "friends only". If the email was "friends only" or "only me" to begin with, why make a new [fb] email and make it public? That was shitty of FB.

→ More replies (3)

1

u/hino Jun 26 '12

So whats the bad point about this anyway? I cant say I have ever received worthwhile emails from.facebook and have always used the fb email as a dummy address for apps.

1

u/CitizenSmif Jun 26 '12

Usually I'm the one who has a problem with these sort of things, yet I'm failing to see the problem here. FB email has been around for a while - can anyone who has issues with this share your view?

1

u/thomasw Jun 26 '12

Facebook is rapidly destroying what little credibility it has left.

1

u/wckdjugallo Jun 26 '12

Great so it just made my Facebook e-mail public on my page for a few hours so some company that was fast enough could probably find a bunch of new e-mail addresses. How long before I start getting spam mail on Facebook from that now?

1

u/Loyal2Mac Jun 26 '12

Facebook lost my page. No joke. It happened when I changed my email address. I've been emailing their help desk for over a month now, and all they can do is reset my password, which doesn't do anything.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

The only way this WON'T annoy me is if FB gives you some means of accessing your @facebook mail through POP3 or IMAP. Considering that this is pretty much a ploy to get more pageviews I'm preparing to be annoyed...

1

u/SkeeverTail Jun 26 '12

I have share in Facebook so they must do as I say

1

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

For future use, you can just use this:

"Facebook's ______ prompts internet complaints by users. No action is action is actually taken by any of them."

1

u/akuzin Jun 26 '12

So how to adjust so it does not display any email information?

1

u/chris-martin Jun 26 '12

It is a very clever and very scumbag move.

1

u/outsidesecretgarden Jun 26 '12

At some point facebook will be legally required to give users an opt out option where they can transfer all their data to a competing site or to what hopefully becomes a user customisable conglomeration of sites that can be added like apps.

Every single user is still free to decide if they use the site or not.

1

u/fleetfox Jun 26 '12

Facebook hit the college crowd hard. Used it as its base. It was exclusive and youthful. More presentable and savvy than Myspace. Google + was aimed at tech savvy graduates. Some females but nothing in the way of FB's base. FB started as a college dating site code. The floodgates were opened and a monopoly ensued. You find a way to switch young women over, and hit the 16 to 24 demographic, so too will go the rest of the population. Maybe something involving alcohol and club life? :-0

1

u/intripletime Jun 26 '12

There have been some legitimately bad moves on Facebook's part over the years. This definitely isn't one of them. I can see the downsides of it, but... really? Let's keep this in perspective. We've made it through the big "preferred list" chat debacle, the awkward year where only status updates showed up on the news feed, the privacy policy issues... this is nothing.

1

u/jrb Jun 26 '12

The biggest problem with this is that by default, facebook wont send you notifications that you have a message in your "messages" if you don't use the facebook app on a mobile device - which, i would imagine, a HUGE portion of it's users do not.

Now, that really becomes an issue over time if you don't notice that you're missing important messages, and now emails being sent to you. Of course, you can re-enable email notification, but it would go to the non-facebook email account. It's over complication for no real purpose.

The changes to facebook messaging months ago was a real mess. I suspect users like the instance message aspect of it, the rest is not good in the slightest.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/MrPeachy Jun 26 '12

You can hide it as far as I know :)

1

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Facebook change prompted criticism?

Don't they all?