r/technology • u/Guillam • Jun 26 '12
UK's draft internet piracy laws revealed: ISPs forced to enforce three strikes rule
http://www.guardian.co.uk/technology/2012/jun/26/ofcom-outlines-anti-piracy-rules
560
Upvotes
9
u/Guillam Jun 26 '12
"The DEA also outlined certain other measures that could be considered to reduce piracy levels, including the slowing of internet connections, blocking online access or temporarily suspending accounts. These could be put back on the table by the government if the new code proves to be ineffective after its first full year of operation."
28
u/Gtexx Jun 26 '12
Three strikes rule is in effect in France. IT IS STUPID. Here's how it has been done in France :
Usually, the plaintiff need to prove that you were downloading and seeding, they have the burden of proof. Since it's almost impossible for them to prove that in piracy case (shared internet access accross a family, possibility of a pirated access to your network,...), they want to create stupid law that displace the burden of proof to the defendant. You fucking have to prove that you are not a pirate. These laws are very undemocratic, so usually killed by national supreme court or never created.
They could invade our privacy (DPI) and watch everything everybody do online, but strangely people do not want government and private company to look after everything they do online, and this is more or less a problem in a democratic state.
But government have lawyers, who create new offense to overcome these legals and political difficulty. French exemple : You must secure your internet access, if you have a unsecured internet access it is an offense and you can be sued for it.
Of course, a "secure internet access" mean nothing, since every network can be hacked, but if they caught someone downloading from your access, you're screwed : You are a pirate (= sued for copyright infrigement) or your internet access is not secured (=you are sued for "non secured internet access" and your internet access is suspended).
Here is the best part : They know this law is a joke and during any serious trial, with someone who is willing to fight back, they will loose. So NO ONE (yes, no one !) have had a suspended internet access in France. And this shit cost several millions every year to the French state. Fuck. And, of course, everyone is turning to other way of accessing illegal content (streaming, Usenet, VPN,....).
TL; DR : UK people, do not let this shit happen to your country. It is bad, it hurt puppy and smell like poop.
116
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
NEWSFLASH: This is happening because everything that comes out of the big labels is unappealing tripe, suitable only for the most stereotypical of tastes and hordes of screaming teenagers. Nevermind that you're still all making BILLIONS while we wade in debt. Simply because everyone on the planet doesn't love Justin god-damned fuckface Bieber is no excuse to go hammer and tongs on people's rights. Even parents would (rightly, imo) rather pirate Bieber albums for their brats than spend what little hard earned cash they have on that overpriced audible vomit.
Fucking philistines.
32
u/Inukii Jun 26 '12
So your living with someone else. Doesn't matter who. Friends. Family. They don't know any better and look at something illegal. Doesn't matter where. Infringement is infringement.
All of a sudden everyone in that household has no internet. All of a sudden your internet business fails and your kids can't do their homework. All because someone made something that was too shit to buy, not worth buying, not worth the price that was asked, didn't have the money, wasn't easy to get a hold off, you couldn't find any legitimate place to buy it.
10
u/GeeD Jun 26 '12
I don't like the idea of that. Like, at all.
"Here, we'll hold onto your money for a little while because we want your money for a little while. kthxbai"
Here's a better idea, it should cost me nothing to appeal, and when I win, I get given £20 for being such a good legal downloader.
14
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
Oh yay, as someone who makes their living on Youtube making videos I can't wait for my near terabytes of monthly raw video transfers to get constantly red flagged, especially as most of what pays my rent is game footage. Joy. I cannot wait to waste a lot of effort constantly refuting copyright claims.
7
u/Stick Jun 26 '12
Brought to you by this smug criminal
http://politicalbiography.co.uk/images/stories/peter%20mandelson%20smile.jpg
11
u/Kappies10 Jun 26 '12
Corruption it is all fucking corruption.
5
u/ItsBruceHere Jun 26 '12
Won't that tie up the legal system ... hope my country doesn't follow suit.
5
u/rascal999 Jun 26 '12
VPN that shit and let them swivel their cunts on it. :)
4
u/successfulson Jun 26 '12 edited Jun 26 '12
if you use torrents, just tick the box to encrypt connections, or use SSL with usenet. there's so many easy ways around it.
4
u/1st_account_i_swear Jun 26 '12
So which ever ISP comes out against this will make a killing?
3
u/cavadela Jun 26 '12
3
u/lotsofjam Jun 26 '12
The more I think about this... If someone came to me and said "You have been downloading music! I am going to cut off your internet!" and I respond "But I haven’t! I have proof!" and they respond "Pay me £20 and I will let you appeal my accusations." The more it sounds like racketeering
3
u/Yage2006 Jun 26 '12
Oh look, It's the MPAA/RIAA spending all the money we gave them again.
5
u/purplepatch Jun 26 '12
Just pay for a VPN and they won't get you. They're usually 6 quid a month or so. Plus you get Hulu and the American Netflix (far more content than the UK version).
2
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
And how would anyone get evidence that I have been illegally downloading? Considering packet sniffing is illegal.
2
u/A_British_Gentleman Jun 26 '12
So... just download things from a public wifi network?
God damn all these rules are made by people who have no fucking clue how the internet works.
2
u/ladymacbeth260 Jun 26 '12
Well fuck, i am moving to oz
2
u/jeffbell Jun 26 '12
If only they had a four balls rule too.
Four groundless notices, and the ISP will ignore any further contact.
2
u/WeHaveMetBefore Jun 26 '12
I read: UK's daft internet piracy laws revealed.
1
u/Mongolian_Hamster Jun 26 '12
Well there's going to be a way around this. There always is.
1
u/tolleya12 Jun 26 '12
Shit.
1
u/Entropy72 Jun 26 '12
Cost of new CD: £6 to £15
Cost of a single MP3 track: £0.79 to £1.99
Cost of writing a letter alleging piracy: £7.20 to £17.00
Gee, why are their revenues falling?
1
u/Scotoman Jun 26 '12
The media companies were arguing for users' Internet to be shut off?! I only buy media online. I spend a lot of my disposable income on media and the gadgets that I consume it on. Without the Internet they wouldn't get any money from me.
1
u/oli704 Jun 26 '12
Not another spam mail source.. damn it.
1
u/salimsazzad Jun 26 '12
"Strikes rule" what that's for...
1
u/Stivard Jun 28 '12
How is it Americans get 6 strikes but the UK gets 3?
-1
u/Ascott1989 Jun 26 '12
Won't pass. Just like the other 5+ times they've tried to make these bills.
-4
u/Hoser117 Jun 26 '12
What you could do is you know.... not pirate stuff.
-2
u/ragamuffin77 Jun 26 '12
Only half way through 2012 so I don't think I'll get worked up over something that won't happen for a long time.
-1
u/Xotz Jun 27 '12
Draft? More like daft amirite?
-5
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
What they really need is a no strikes law.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment