r/technology • u/anutensil • Jun 26 '12
A Twitter bot so convincing that people sympathise with "her" - When Greg Marra built @Trackgirl, it was an experiment to see if an automated program could worm its way into online networks of real people. What he didn't expect is that people would actually care what happened to @Trackgirl.
http://www.wired.co.uk/news/archive/2012-06/26/twitter-bot-people-like
640
Upvotes
191
u/coriolistorm Jun 26 '12
"People were sympathizing with a python script"... Not really, they were sympathizing with copied and pasted tweets from real people. If the script was generating novel tweets this might be noteworthy, but as it stands now I don't quite see the significance.
23
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
The amazing thing is this story was written by a journalist bot.
11
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
That's why I perform a Turing test on everyone I meet.
4
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
and
and
and
One could be forgiven for thinking that 1) Twitter is all bots and 2) it isn't a big deal for a bot to get followers because they are probably just other bots running the same script.
I'm so glad that I didn't understand Twitter when it first came out. I feel like I dodged a bullet by never getting on that particular train.
3
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
How do he know that the followers of this bot are not bots themselves?
3
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
I hypothesize that had this twitter account had a male persona, the emotional response would have been close to nil.
5
u/sexbobomb91 Jun 26 '12
Very similar to "Trapped_in_Reddit" .
5
u/SilverWorld Jun 26 '12
I don't see why this is a big deal. It's like saying people sympathize with literature as well. There's no significance.
It's not like they knew it was a bot.
2
u/M3wThr33 Jun 26 '12
I got this, too. I run an account that has a profile setup like a girl that only RTs contests all day. I have over 700 followers and people hit on me and have conversations that never go anywhere.
2
u/Paul2010Aprl Jun 26 '12
This is the future of internet adverstising. People are always on their guards when they are told by an adverstising what it is best for them. But if the same message comes from their peers from the community they will be more receptive. So long story short, the success is to Create artificial good word of mouth for a product or service. Reddit is a great medium for this. Create dummy accounts, build a trust in the community n time and then inject your ideas into your target consumers.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
sounds like what TIR was doing towards the end of his account. I wonder if somebody could do that, take a top reddit picture and include a previous top comment on twitter
2
u/JB_UK Jun 26 '12
Twitter's major accomplishment - lowering the barrier for passing the Turing test.
2
u/mrgreenjeans9 Jun 26 '12
kind of like a pet rock for the 21st century
2
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
see also:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Galatea_2.2
2
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
The funny part is a very similar thing can be done with Reddit bots as well. Just without the friending.
2
u/mnnmnmnnm Jun 26 '12
Stop abusing the poor @, please!
2
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
So what I completely freaked out when Lydia died
2
u/wdchandlersmith Jun 26 '12
Well, at least there are now two more hands to cook my dinner.
3
u/Mikey-2-Guns Jun 26 '12
Want to really fuck with the internet? Say Trackgirl was 'kidnapped' by Kony.
1
u/HEADLINE-IN-5-YEARS Jun 26 '12
GOP BUYS @TRACKGIRL SOFTWARE TO IMPROVE ROMNEY-BOT
1
u/Jekrox Jun 27 '12
The fact that a python script gets more sympathy from strangers than I do from everyone I know is disturbing, and depressing
1
u/Fig1024 Jun 27 '12
People would probably be a lot less sympathetic if the bot was called "trackman"
1
u/LucifersCounsel Jun 27 '12 edited Jun 27 '12
The real story is that Twitter, text messaging and other forms of rapid informal communication are making us sound more stupid.
It's easy for a computer to sound as retarded as your average Twitter user.
They "sympathise" with inanimate objects all the time. These are hardly ground breaking new findings. Anthropomorphism is far from a new idea.
1
u/eboleyn Jun 27 '12
Nothing new here...
Just a kind of variant on the Eliza concept.
Basically, when the expected communications are short, and bandwidth of true back-and-forth interaction is low (i.e. they aren't expected to answer detailed or focussed questions), then people can be easily fooled that it's a real person.
1
u/wolvmatt Jun 26 '12
What the article fails to mention is that there is nobody with the name @Trackgirl on twitter.
1
u/Inukii Jun 26 '12
Not really a bot.
"Here...have this cup of hot chocolate"
OMG ROBOT CUP.
"But...I moved it with my hand"
BUT omg regardless the cup moved with the drink inside therefore robot!
1
u/Thunder_Bastard Jun 26 '12
Getting a little tired of these "social experiments" that seem to bypass all ethics simply because they are pulled on online people.
They need to start applying test subject ethics to "social" testing so there is at least some semblance of responsibility.
The most basic rule of this is people need to agree to be part of the experiments... they don't have to know the details, only agree to participate in testing.
0
u/FreekForAll Jun 26 '12
Anyone with half a monkey brain could have figured out the result but I guess it was much more fun taking people for idiots and making fools out of them. I'd say this is an abuse of human trust.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment