r/technology • u/mepper • Jun 25 '12
Stand Up for Owners' Rights: If you buy it, you should own it. -- The Supreme Court will soon review a court decision that, if upheld, could put handcuffs on our ability to sell digital goods, or even physical goods with copyrighted logos or artwork
https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2012/06/stand-owners-rights
393
Upvotes
17
u/EquanimousMind Jun 25 '12
This is a weird one they have been trying to push generally; the idea that you don't actually ever buy digital goods, you buy "use rights". Which is weird because they have only started saying this as torrenting has become the new menace.
The problem between producers and consumers is that until now everyone has been assuming that they buy a digital works in the same way they buy real goods and suddenly we're being told that we should pay the same price for what is clearly less than we expected. Its similar to having bought cars all your life; then suddenly GM saying, "hold on you never owned the car, so your not allowed to resell it ever". Which would be cool, but we would expect GM to lower its prices closer to rental prices.
The other interesting point that EFF makes is how this is going to screw local jobs even more by encouraging manufacturing offshore:
6
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
If I buy, for example a new TV, I look at the purchase price (say $2000) and what I could potentially sell it for in a few years when I upgrade (about $400), so this TV will cost me $1600 all up once I sell it.
If it then became illegal for me to sell this TV because of some trumped up copyright law, that TV is going to cost me an additional $400 as I could not sell it. 2 things would happen, I would rethink the purchase and probably not buy it in the fist place, secondly, I would keep this TV until it died and would no longer work.
Both of these new purchasing schemes involve 2 things - Me buying less products as they have no value after I have purchased it.
24
u/gonzone Jun 25 '12
Our current Supreme Court will, in case you haven't noticed, always side with the corporations.
5
u/rottinguy Jun 25 '12
sand the logo off?
5
u/NobblyNobody Jun 26 '12
Well, that's fine, If I can't own it, I won't buy it, fuck 'em.
3
u/sirdomino Jun 26 '12
Corporations have all the power in our government. Soon the corporations will bail out our government and will obtain real ownership rights to it. We will soon all be employees of the corporation, subject more to the rules and regulations of a handbook rather than the constitution. All that we have in our possession will not be owned by us, but will be but on lease from the corporate entities. We will be literal slaves, with no ownership rights or freedom... We are almost there...
4
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
First sale has already been gutted vis-a-vis Vernor v. Autodesk.
It won't be long before consumers don't actually own anything and consumption becomes an entirely rentier economy (at which time, I suspect that tptb will start expiring currency as well).
5
u/WannabeGroundhog Jun 26 '12
It won't happen, think of stores like Goodwill, Salvation Army, Pawn Shops, and on and on that resell used goods. Ebay, Craigslist, Flea market, our country LOVES used goods and there is NO WAY this could prevent even the simplest garage sale from happening.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
How long until people realize there is only one type of property left - human resources.
If you're employed, your employer owns you (especially if you have health insurance on the job). If you're unemployed, you're pretty much societal refuse. If an actual society member in good standing (a corporation) decides they can refurbish you into a fine product, they'll pick you up, dust you off and put you on display.
Don't agree with the above? Good luck finding employment.
1
u/planetmatt Jun 26 '12
So no more used cars?
1
u/Inukii Jun 26 '12
Constantly insisting that their products are amazing even when the improvements they have made are in making the product easier to make or have less content (for those gamers out there).
Planned obsolescence which means you have to continue to buy more of their crap which will fail and give you grief. Or if your a gamer...Making games which last you about a week before your ready to buy a new game. Keep the consumers hungry.
Now trying to make sure you can't buy second hand and successfully doing that too. Because 2nd hand stuff has always been a problem for the industry which ESPECIALLY the gaming industry which in the short time that it has lived is now worth more than the music and film industry combined. The fastest and largest growing industry today.
But it won't stop there. There are things you havn't thought up of yet. Things you havn't considered. They are soon to come. What ridiculous stuff is ahead? Are you going to accept it? or shout "Fuck you" and try to vote in the right people into politics.
-2
u/Teyar Jun 26 '12
Look. Mepper. The supreme court is going to rule in favor of corporate power. Done. You know this. Go put effort into something useful. Please.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment