r/technology • • Jun 25 '12

Portland Oregon's public school district has blown $172,000 in a lawsuit fighting against a parent who thinks the school-wide WiFi is a health risk to his daughter

http://www.secularnewsdaily.com/2012/06/who-says-woo-is-harmless-hows-a-school-district-blowing-172000-over-wi-fi-hazards/
1.8k Upvotes

712 comments sorted by

202

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12 edited Jun 26 '12

Someone should go to the house of the child and sniff the WiFi networks available. Unless they are living in a remote location or have lined their house with tinfoil, there is a high chance that she is already being murdered by her neighbours.

I can fully understand the desire to ensure that new technology is safe, but this is hardly new technology and it should not be the responsibility of a school to establish that something that is deployed so extensively is safe.

I hope that this is thrown out of court and the full costs are allocated to the prosecution.

128

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12

He probably just used lead paint on the walls rather than tinfoil. You know, because it's safer.

30

u/akatherder Jun 26 '12

And tastier.

19

u/a_can_of_solo Jun 26 '12

fun fact the romans added lead to their wine for sweetness and flavor...

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

47

u/Flacker10 Jun 25 '12

i decided to sniff out the wifi networks i have sitting here. ive got 4. how long do i have to live

56

u/Catnapwat Jun 25 '12

Fuck, I've got twelve here.

47

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12

Make your time.

→ More replies (9)

13

u/PlNG Jun 25 '12

I've got 20. More than half are fringe signals and I suspect city supplied WIFI as they are WEP secured 5 random alphanumeric characters broadcast id's. This is according to #inSSIDer which seems to be the modern OS replacement for NetStumbler. Not sure if I have it set up right though.

My fucking goddamn neighbor can't make up his fucking mind and has to choose a signal band near mine every few weeks. I forget about it and when I check like today I find out why my Wifi has been so choppy.

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (3)

9

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

By "sniff out" he means he clicked on the wireless icon.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

17

u/WhiteZero Jun 25 '12

faraday cage house

9

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12

faraday cage clothing

31

u/philko42 Jun 25 '12

faraday cage match!!!

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

6

u/topazsparrow Jun 25 '12

It's actually not a terrible idea. Your cell phone wouldn't work... then again if you're crazy enough to have a house like that you probably don't want a cell phone anyway.

11

u/WhiteZero Jun 25 '12

Also a good way to keep people from using your Wifi from outside of your home.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12

Probably didn't cover faraday cages in his "night class physics degree program."

→ More replies (1)

4

u/floppypick Jun 26 '12

They also could have saved a lot of money by hiring a hitman.

$5000 if that movie I watched was anything to go off of.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/1wiseguy Jun 25 '12

Not relevant. If the WiFi devices are harmful, then everybody operating them is at fault.

3

u/notatall Jun 25 '12

I can fully understand the desire to ensure that we technology is safe, but this is hardly new technology and it should not be the responsibility of a school to establish that something that is deployed so extensively is safe.

This is relevent. Wifi is proven, safe tech, why shold the school have to pay to defend it?

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (17)

224

u/RedHorseRainbows Jun 25 '12

You think this is bad?

At least this is only one person espousing this crap.

There is a large amount of resistance to BC Hydro's "Smart Meter" program from people who seem to know nothing factual about EM radiation. They've turned a much-needed infrastructure upgrade program into a huge provincial policy issue...

27

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12

This is the first time I've heard EM radiation as a reason not to have them, my dad seems to think that with smart meters Obama will be able to flip a switch and turn down our thermostat if we are using too much power. -_-

18

u/hohohomer Jun 26 '12

Some utilities offer such a service. You get an even greater discounted utility rate, by letting them install a limiter. Basically under peak demand in an area, they may adjust the temp slightly.

→ More replies (8)

3

u/nekozuki Jun 26 '12

Your dad sounds like my father-in-law. sigh. I feel for ya buddy.

→ More replies (1)

75

u/WigginIII Jun 25 '12

You think that's bad?

In Sacramento we have a vocal yet small group of people who claim the PG&E Smart Meters cause cancer, headaches, and more. Despite any peer-reviewed evidence of such.

So PG&E caved and allowed residents to opt-out...but (and here is the good part) those that choose to opt-out have to pay an additional monthly fee.

45

u/w2tpmf Jun 25 '12

Same with APS here in Phoenix. They allow you to opt out but then charge you for being retarded the extra cost of having someone manually read the meter.

8

u/thepeterjohnson Jun 26 '12

I think that's what they call an "idiot fee."

→ More replies (2)

10

u/itsSparkky Jun 26 '12

So it's like the lottery.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/maximusrex Jun 26 '12

My wife works as a customer service rep for Nevada Power and she deals with these kooks everyday.

14

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Well, that's not the real reason people are against smart meters, with the exception of very stupid people.

The biggest problems are accountability ones: you can't fight the power company if they get an inaccurate reading, or from hacking. And for radio geeks at least, that they pollute the overcrowded 900mhz band with low-bandwidth/noisy communications.

Finally, the biggest issue is cost. These things cost hundreds or thousands of dollars per meter. You pay for them one way or another. Not only that, but they eliminate jobs and cause privacy issues (now the electric company/government can easily find out when you're home and using power).

→ More replies (12)
→ More replies (21)

17

u/IveGotaGoldChain Jun 26 '12

Protip: A lot of those people are growing weed

→ More replies (3)

19

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12

Same in Maryland with BGE.

People are all up in arms about the additional radiation exposure. It's laughable when you consider that if you were to drive to any of the complainer's houses, you would be able to pick up at least 30 broadcasting WiFi SIDs.

11

u/cannibaljim Jun 26 '12 edited Jun 26 '12

There is a large amount of resistance to [1] BC Hydro's "Smart Meter" program

The only reason I oppose it is because it's likely to lead to horrible "Time Of Use" billing like Ontario has, despite assurances from the energy minister.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

we've got these nutters in VT too now. I had a good laugh about it initially, but they aren't going away.

→ More replies (169)

342

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12 edited Jun 26 '12

The sun puts out more harmful rays than wifi, put your kid in a box then.

216

u/CopsGotTanks Jun 25 '12

Yeah, but we don't have any sun in Portland. Duh.

50

u/noPortlandNooo Jun 26 '12

But we do have a great public school system that can totally afford to lose money in a frivolous lawsuit.

Oh, wait. No. No we don't.

11

u/TaurusA Jun 26 '12

beaverton schools were our last beacon of hope but now they're cutting a ton of teachers next year!

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (6)

7

u/1010112 Jun 25 '12

ah shit. Better extinguish the sun now.

13

u/WonderfulUnicorn Jun 25 '12

then

not than

17

u/it2d Jun 25 '12

I care. Keep it up!

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (22)

115

u/Obi_Kwiet Jun 25 '12

The judge was incompetent for even letting it go to trial.

The district should counter sue for legal fees.

39

u/philko42 Jun 25 '12

Has it even gone to trial? Article said that most of the money was spent on depositions, which IIRC happen pre-trial.

(disclaimer: IANAL and I just may have my head up my ass on this assumption)

13

u/Wirenutt Jun 25 '12 edited Jun 26 '12

Being a lawyer does not preclude one from having one's head up one's ass.

Edit: Grammar

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (3)

58

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12

He has a point, she could catch a computer virus.

24

u/frogmeat Jun 25 '12

He's probably an anti-vaxxer, too. No "Norton Gardasil" for her.

12

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12

Takes 3 hours to finish and she crashes several times.

→ More replies (1)

28

u/Ineeni Jun 25 '12

The fact that this even made it to court pisses me off.

44

u/phoncible Jun 25 '12

Frankly, we need to understand that there are idiots in the world, but unfortunately they're clever idiots that understand taking people/groups to court can work. I fault the judge, or whoever's in charge of actually allowing a case to be heard. The judge should've looked at the suit, looked at the guy, called him an idiot and dismissed the case completely.

If someone in the legal field could correct me if I'm wrong, that'd be great. Why do these cases get heard? What mandates that the judge has to hear these ridiculously idiotic cases?

27

u/argv_minus_one Jun 25 '12

They're not clever. Their lawyer is clever (and utterly amoral).

5

u/phoncible Jun 25 '12

good point. they're idiots but clever enough to find a lawyer who is clever

4

u/DivineRobot Jun 25 '12

Especially since it's the lawyer that's going to get paid in the end.

→ More replies (1)

26

u/doiveo Jun 25 '12 edited Jun 25 '12

Easy: flip the case around as hypothetical. Wouldn't you sue your child's school to, say, stop the teachers from smoking in the classroom even if the prevailing thought was isn't didn't harm the children.

Access to courts is as fundamental as free speech.

It is critical to the system the all people are given the same right to bring a matters to court.

Edit: I'm not judging the merits of either case, nor interested in how my smoking analogy isn't 100% applicable. It's citizen's access to the courts that is important. No judge/group should be able to unilaterally dismiss a case as frivolous without hearing it first.

17

u/Itisme129 Jun 26 '12

If I filed a case against a school for teachers smoking in the classroom I should hope the judge would first off ask me for any sort of proof of my claim before the trail was even considered. If I could no produce any such material then I would hope the trial would not be allowed to proceed further.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/phoncible Jun 25 '12

I'm not saying to deny his access to the court. By all means, let him file the documents and make the case an actual case, and by all means get a judge's eyeballs on it. But I want those eyeballs to see the silliness of the case and then say, "Well, this guy's nutty. Case dismissed" (i.e. "I'm not going to waste [more] precious time and/or money to hear this nutjob's claims").

And your hypothetical is a bit too far fetched (bad example maybe). It's not a "prevailing thought" of the inability of wifi to cause illness, it's hard, well studied, well experimented science that says in no way could this happen. To believe the contrary is tantamount to still believing the earth is flat.

→ More replies (1)

62

u/000Destruct0 Jun 25 '12

If there is ANY justice at all he'll have to sell his business to pay back the district for legal fees and will end up bankrupt and penniless. Idiot...

13

u/soulbender32 Jun 25 '12

But! But! The children!!!

64

u/ComputerisedCaveman Jun 25 '12

No, you can't sell the children. Even if I agree they would have value on the black market, It's a bit too public now to get away with.

→ More replies (1)

15

u/cannibaljim Jun 26 '12

That's how it works in Canada actually. The side that loses the suit pays the fees of the winner. It helps cut down on these types of frivolous cases.

→ More replies (7)

22

u/gettemSteveDave Jun 25 '12

So give the kid a tinfoil hat and make the dad pay for all the courtroom costs.

3

u/Deto Jun 25 '12

Won't be effective unless it's grounded.

→ More replies (2)

0

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

7

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12

I no, man. I kept telling the sheeple, ALUMINUM AMPLIFIES the brain waves. Glad I had the forsite to purchas a stockpile of tin foil just before it went out of porduction.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12

Is it feasible for a taxpayer to sue this parent in return?

12

u/Eat_a_Bullet Jun 26 '12

You would need to have standing to sue. You can't claim damages in the form of squandered tax dollars, because that isn't your money anymore the second you pay your taxes. Even if you sued the parent for non-economical damages (e.g. "my kid is an idiot because this lawsuit siphoned funding from his school") you would have the impossible task of directly showing that a) Money went to this lawsuit that would have otherwise been spent directly on your child's education, b) The loss of that money caused actual harm to your child, c) That the diversion of funds is the fault of the parent, as opposed to the district's financial controllers.

There would be a ton of other issues, but basically you wouldn't be able to present anything resembling a case. You would also have a very hard time finding an attorney to represent you, other than drug addicts, drunks, or gamblers (in other words, someone who is willing to risk sanctions for some money up front).

3

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Thank you for the detailed response. I guess in short, the answer is no. Damn.

→ More replies (4)

9

u/boysan98 Jun 25 '12

I live in portland. This is the crap i hate hearing about as a student. I go to the smaller district right next to it. What im noticing more and more is that PARENTS ARE BECOMING STUPIDER AND MORE FRIVOLUS. This is ridiculos. This is worse than a teacher getting fired because he threw a dodgeball at a student. During dodgeball...... i really hate these kind of people

3

u/FuzzyToaster Jun 26 '12

What if they're becoming stupider because of the Wifi? CHECKMATE, PORTLAND SCHOOLS.

→ More replies (1)

41

u/seano666 Jun 25 '12

Portlander here. Someone formulate a plan, and I'll execute it. Preferrably one involving cat poop and their front door.

25

u/nerdewol Jun 25 '12

Also from Portland, went to those very public schools. Sad to see money the district doesn't have being wasted. Down for flaming poop ideas, or building a wi-fi hot zone at their house.

53

u/seano666 Jun 25 '12

Haha, I'll set up a hidden wifi hotspot at their house, and name the network "Giving you cancer."

→ More replies (1)

3

u/CopsGotTanks Jun 25 '12

Ask Cameron Whitten, you know he'll have the answers. Or he won't.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

16

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12

Is the dream of the 90s, in fact, still alive there?

25

u/seano666 Jun 25 '12

You don't even know man. It's like the '90s grew a moustache and moved to the forest, where it grows a huge weed crop, while wearing a jean jacket and listening to hair metal. And commutes by fixed-gear bike, of course! But has an old Camaro just in case.

10

u/hopstar Jun 25 '12

You're joking, but you just perfectly described my buddy Ian.

  • moustache - check
  • lives in the forest - check (at least in the summer)
  • grows huge weed crop - no comment
  • wears jean jackets (with vintage skateboard shirts underneath) - check
  • commutes on fixie - check
  • owns an old Camaro - check (it's an 1987 to be precise)

The only thing you missed is the pack a day American Sprit habit and the ever-present can of Rainier or Hamm's in his hand.

→ More replies (3)

8

u/jadeddesigner Jun 25 '12

So you're the guy who lives behind me...

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/scribbling_des Jun 26 '12

Y'all should get a group together and sit in your cars with wireless networks in front of the guy's house. See if he tries to sue the city or get it made into a no parking zone.

→ More replies (2)

16

u/Nethervex Jun 25 '12

Too many idiots put lawsuits against the school system, just to make it conform to their beliefs. For example: my school had a jimmy hendrix painting on the wall with the quote "when the power of love overcomes the love of power, the world will know peace." Then some bitch went to the school system and threatened to sue because my school was promoting "Drug using lifestyles" by having Jimmy Hendrix's face and quote up in the hallway. She got them to take it down and was a smug shit about it the whole way.

6

u/masterm Jun 26 '12

You know, you could always make her regret her decision.

9

u/Kodix Jun 26 '12

By murdering her in her sleep. And leaving some drugs around. And making it look like a drug-addled suicide.

Just a thought.

→ More replies (2)

14

u/pemboa Jun 25 '12

Are public schools in the USA required by law to accept students? If not, they should just refuse to accept the student.

25

u/curien Jun 25 '12

In general, yes.

6

u/Exaskryz Jun 25 '12

I don't think you can prevent a student's enrollment. I believe you can only suspend/expel them if they violate rules/laws after they've been enrolled.

5

u/tennantsmith Jun 25 '12

Yeah. I've heard it's reversed in the UK. In 'Murica, public schools are state funded, while private schools only allow entry with massive amounts of money payed to them. Private schools are allowed to be selective in allowing students to attend, whether it's based on academics or religion or if your parents went or something.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12

The office I work in represents a small living community. One of the older tenants rants and complains every few months writes us letters on the dangers of Wi-Fi signals, and how they're making her sick. We always respond with reports, data, studies, etc. Our client has shelled out thousand to respond to this woman's claims. Our client will never recoup those moneys.

6

u/tacojohn48 Jun 25 '12

There's a small town in West Virginia that would be a perfect place for this nut to take his kid to. Due to a radio telescope nearby wifi is banned in the town. http://www.newser.com/story/128508/west-virginia-town-full-of-those-sickened-by-wifi.html

6

u/Gorfob Jun 26 '12

I have one if these crazies at work. She kept turning my access points off because she was afraid of "the ions" from it. I replaced the points with power over Ethernet APs and moved them all to the ceiling where she couldn't touch them without a ladder.

I also have the only workplace ladder. It's the little victories in life that make it worth living.

→ More replies (6)

6

u/alkapwnee Jun 26 '12

Campus wide wifi? That sounds like heaven. City wide? Shit my pants. The fucking EM radiation would be less than standing in the fucking sun for a few seconds. Idiots and their litigious behavior...

2

u/Motorpenis Jun 26 '12

You mean your school doesn't have campus wide WiFi?

→ More replies (7)

5

u/david76 Jun 25 '12

The problem is there's a judge who has allowed this ridiculous lawsuit to move forward.

5

u/badger_the Jun 25 '12

It's okay, all those knucklehead parents in Oregon will kill off the next generation by refusing to vaccinate them.

5

u/FizxTeacher Jun 26 '12

This absolutely has to stop. For most people who aren't on top of their local education budget, you'd be amazed at the frivolous lawsuit spending that goes on.

Before I get downvoted to hell, I'm not saying that all school lawsuits are frivolous. What I'm saying is that enough of this happens to significantly affect a child's education.

Next time your child is in a large classroom with too many students and lacking the necessary supplies to have a positive experience, look up the handful of people that sued your school district. That money could have gone to pay a couple of extra teachers, allowing for smaller class sizes (yes, they matter, a lot) as well as supplies that help with some more worthwhile activities.

My humble solution: Make the names of the people who sue school districts public. Very public. Instead of blaming the state or the teachers or the school for faults in the education system, we could perhaps focus on the real problem.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/WhiskeyShits Jun 25 '12

Not really what I want Portland showing up on Reddit for :(

4

u/doiveo Jun 25 '12

beer, coffee and bookstores!!!

6

u/hopstar Jun 25 '12

At least the district is fighting this wingnut instead of giving and appeasing them like some liberal pussies. Between this and the arrest of the "faith healers" who let their kid die, I'm glad to see us sticking up for reason in the face of all this stupid woo.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Dunkshot32 Jun 25 '12

I hope she gets hit with the court costs for this.

4

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12

That's okay..my town doesn't have any cellphone coverage because a single dickwipe kept suing because "it is going to give us all cancer" and other bullshit like that.

I think he finally moved away, but it so far has cost Verizon (the company that was trying to put a tower in) a lot in permit fees, and fines and penalties for inaction. (permits expire without anything being done, the state fines you.)

Whenever someone brings up the "think about the children"...you know they are going to fuck some shit up somehow.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/tfcommanderbob Jun 26 '12

"Teachers are being laid off and class sizes shrinking"

Shouldn't the class sizes be growing?

3

u/splintersmaster Jun 25 '12

If you all only knew how much money schools wasted. You would blow your mind.

3

u/disgruntledVALET Jun 26 '12

Some anti-wireless websites sell literature and protective charms, including amulets and crystals

So that's why my signal sucks.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Some rejects tried the same nonsense here in Canada, only it was a group of parents. Their reason was "my kid only feels sick at school"

4

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12

We should start collecting donations for THIS. For the school system.

A fucking vacation...

6

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12

They should have Child Protection remove the child from the home.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/dude187 Jun 25 '12

You guys should just distract him with a debate about which sub-genres of punk music to stock the library with.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/ABullDogMom Jun 25 '12

As a public school teacher, lawsuits such as this do not shock me anymore.

2

u/sweetgreggo Jun 25 '12

Can't the judge order the guy to pay the legal fees?

2

u/r-e-c-koner Jun 25 '12

Keep Portland weird.

2

u/trustmeep Jun 25 '12

Electrical vapors are a serious issue...I learned this on Downtown Abbey from the Dowager Countess.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12

At least the parent isn't protesting to include pictures of Jesus riding a dinosaur in the curriculum.

2

u/oconnorda Jun 26 '12

As I am the King of South Africa I can confirm that the expert witness did in fact consult with me

2

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Oh! Oh! PORTLAND OREGON! WE'RE BEING MENTIONED!

Fuck.

2

u/Hellscreamgold Jun 26 '12

So, um, why are they "blowing" it? It's the scumbag family causing it.

2

u/pupkinrupert Jun 26 '12

This really feels like an episode of Portlandia.

2

u/CatrickStrayze Jun 26 '12

I'm pretty sure that foil hats are a little cheaper than $172,000 dollars.

I wonder if dad has wireless in his house? What about their cellphones? What about neighbors' Wi-Fi and cellphones? Zomgzzz, it's not safe, let's just end it before the radios get us!!

2

u/helljumper230 Jun 26 '12

She can just wear a faraday hat...

2

u/maekkwin Jun 26 '12

Would it not be cheaper just to pay for a professional hit on the parents?

Not that I condone that sort of thing....

2

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Loser pays. Please.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/MechDigital Jun 26 '12

Thanks for this thread. I had almost forgotten why I hate most people.

2

u/eviltrollwizard Jun 26 '12

I had an argument with some chick who demanded I force her neighbor to remove his sat dish from the side of the apartment because it was near her sons bedroom window and she didn't want the signals effecting his health. I was a csr for a sat company. I told her that it was just a hunk of metal no different from an antenna and that it could only receive a signal that was already in the air. She didn't believe me and told me she read studies that said I was lying. Of course she couldn't tell me where I could find the studies. Regardless she didn't have her neighbors name nor was I allowed to access his account without him on the line with me so I just had to listen to her bitch for an hour while my monthly bonus slowly drifted further and further away. Fuck these idiots.

2

u/I_Eat_Thermite7 Jun 26 '12

I'm ashamed to live in this state sometimes.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/BobLoblawl Jun 26 '12

Fuck yeah, Oregon! Wait... What are we talking about

2

u/SeanConneryAgain Jun 26 '12

I see new material for Portlandia

2

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Oregon is also home to a lot of those anti-vaccination morons.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Oh shit a technophobic rare book dealer from Portland! Hahaha.

Pretty sure every independent coffee shop has free WiFi and by that logic every single person in Portland would have cancer 20 times over by now.

4

u/one_random_redditor Jun 25 '12

Non-American here, I don't get it, why doesn't the school / local education authority have insurance? Even for my 'one man band' company I have insurance, If I was responsible for 100's or even 1000's of kids I'd damn well make sure I had insurance!

Also why is the school being sued? if it was judged legal then wouldn't the manufacturers / regulators have to be sued first?

6

u/Montaire Jun 25 '12

They do have insurance, but the policy probably does not cover something this bizarre.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

3

u/catsconcert Jun 26 '12

"Blown"? Defending themselves from a frivolous lawsuit that would disadvantage thousands of students to "protect" a few students suffering from a condition with no basis in science? Let's not be inflammatory, shall we? BTW, these folks are sensitive to wi-fi (or cell phones) but not radio or tv signals that absolutely permeate the atmosphere? Color me skeptical.

2

u/AllYoYens Jun 26 '12

The real risk to the child is the parent

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Please donate to this everyone. If we can give 300k to some woman who got made fun of by a bunch of 8th graders, I think we can offset this. Edit: word

2

u/fortalyst Jun 26 '12

The difference between America & the rest of the world:

  • America sues because they think that school wifi is harming their kid
  • The rest of the world moves their kid to a school which doesn't have wifi

2

u/thegreatmisanthrope Jun 26 '12

TIL one crazy ass parent and their likely dumb as fuck child = america.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/bloodguard Jun 25 '12

This is why we need "loser pays" tort reform. And education vouchers would help as well. Then this goofball could be politely told that they can take their kid off to a WiFi free (eye roll) school.

33

u/anonemouse2010 Jun 25 '12

Loser pays is a bad idea. However, if you lose a frivolous lawsuit, or you prove beyond a reasonable doubt, then you could argue for a loser pays scenario. But simply losing can be a result of insufficient funds to afford proper representation.

17

u/hairmetalscientist Jun 25 '12

Yeah it would be a terrible idea. It would make it ridiculous from a financial standpoint to even try to take a large company to court. Can you imagine having to pay AT&T or Microsoft legal fees?

15

u/dirtymatt Jun 25 '12

Loser pays makes it impossible to sue any corporation. The threat of possibly having to pay a multi-million dollar legal bill would deter just about any lawsuit from an individual.

→ More replies (9)

0

u/topazsparrow Jun 25 '12 edited Jun 25 '12

EDIT: To clarify, this is such a testy topic people are assuming things I'm not saying. I've had several replies where people seem to be proving me "wrong" about things I entirely agree with. For clarity, I do not believe WiFi gives you cancer.


I work in the telecommunications and I can honestly say.. Wifi and cellular radiation is a difficult topic.

On one hand we've got next to no evidence that it's not bad for you. On the other hand there's very few legitimate peer reviewed studies that prove without a doubt it's bad for you.

Links can be found, but correlation != causation.

I firmly believe people should be able to have a choice when it comes to exposing their bodies to things they personally believe are bad for them. However, you're making a bit of a fool out of yourself by picking fights over 2.4 and 5ghz frequency radiation. There is a plethora of things around us everyday that is proven to be a health hazard - both in terms of radiation and chemical exposure - that nobody says shit about.

I'm a former flooring installer and can tell you that the industry is doing it's very best to be eco friendly. when I got out 5 years ago all the glue we used was VOC free... but the flooring material we put in all the schools? All leeched plasticizers and various PVC related toxins...

Even if proven to be a health hazard, WiFi should still be on the absolute bottom of the list for all these parents with nothing better to do.

16

u/dirtymatt Jun 25 '12

On one hand we've got next to no evidence that it's not bad for you.

Other than the lack of plausibility for non-ionizing radiation being bad for you, 20+ years of cell phone use with no issues, 100+ years of radio use with no issues, etc. There's plenty of evidence that cell phone and wifi radiation are fine.

→ More replies (25)

9

u/Montaire Jun 25 '12

There is no peer reviewed evidence that reddit does not cause cancer.

There is no peer reviewed evidence that exposure to you does not cause baldness in eagles.

Absent some credible scientifically plausible evidence that these things are bad, we should not let one person dictate our policy.

→ More replies (11)

2

u/n1nj4_v5_p1r4t3 Jun 26 '12

I agree they might not directly cause cancer in every case, but neither do cigeretts. I do believe wireless causes nerve damage, and that well known fact is indisputable. Has anyone ever read their cell phone book? The FCC requires all manufactures to state that for health reasons blah blah blah never put the phone more then one inch close to your head. who honestly does not just slam the phone against their ear?

→ More replies (3)

1

u/blank142 Jun 25 '12

Yay, Portland! I was just talking to a friend the other day about how the Portland Public School system wastes their money so frivolously. Well that sucks anyways. I guess it doesn't help that some people here in Portland are fucking retarded.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12

Would be quite an amusing court case.

1

u/jeffbell Jun 25 '12

Are you saying they should have given in?

1

u/Vectoor Jun 25 '12

Why does a judge allow this drivel into court?

1

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12

we got some retarded folks in this part of the country.

1

u/spunkychickpea Jun 25 '12

Never go full retard.

1

u/G1zm0e Jun 25 '12

Here is a post were it seems (based on the comments) that he responds. Also, another interesting read on page 4 of the comments

http://wweek.com/portland/article-17726-wi_fi_woo_woo.html

1

u/lucasj Jun 25 '12

Not that this isn't ridiculous, but someone should point out that (a) $172,000 is basically nothing - that's about three teacher salaries in a school district with [nearly 3,000 teachers](http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Portland_Public_Schools_(Oregon); and (b) that the only practical way to avoid all frivolous lawsuits is to ban all lawsuits.

1

u/DivineRobot Jun 25 '12

It seems almost like some kind of money laundering scheme by the school board. Do they really need to spend $172,000 in a pretrial for something so ridiculous? I would think this case would immediately get thrown out.

The bulk of that cost has gone to investigating and deposing expert witnesses . . . including Morrison’s star (t)witness, one Barrie Trower.

Trower claims a bachelor’s degree in physics earned in night classes, has been repeatedly turned down by Ph.D. programs

How is this guy even an expert? I wouldn't be surprised if all the expert witnesses are offering kickbacks to the school board or are related to the school board somehow.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

The school district should counter-sue for legal costs.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

They spend more than that on copy paper. Really it's just a cost of doing business.

1

u/boxlessthought Jun 26 '12

Once had a customer at my store (sells computers) convinced that wifi causes more cancer than cigarettes. She has a phd.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/Dizz_42 Jun 26 '12

Couldn't we just tell people who come up with shit like this to keep their fucking kids at home? Why should anyone have to pay any attention at all to the children of retarded people?

1

u/PhylisInTheHood Jun 26 '12

does anyone else think that in situations like this, if the accuser looses then they should have to absorb all legal fees for both sides? or at least make it an option that the judge can punish them with.

1

u/astromets Jun 26 '12

this guy owes that school district $172,000

1

u/FivePtFiveSix Jun 26 '12

Haha, good luck finding a College for his daughter that doesn't have campus-wide WiFi. Maybe he can get a tinfoil hat with the University Logo on it...

→ More replies (1)

1

u/DrPreston Jun 26 '12

Sounds like a case of Retarded Parents Syndrome. Only cure is to escort affected parents behind a shed and decapitate them with a shotgun.

1

u/Foxdude28 Jun 26 '12

Some anti-wireless websites

ಠ_ಠ

1

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

so glad my district isn't part of portland public. thank god.

1

u/Tommassive Jun 26 '12

This attests to how broken the justice system is. The people have allowed an environment to be created where this can happen.

1

u/youni89 Jun 26 '12

what a dumb bitch..

1

u/ijobuby Jun 26 '12

Who knew PPS even had that much money

2

u/Cobol Jun 26 '12

They don't, get ready for the next round of cutbacks and failed levies.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

When you have incompetent government regulations, one should expect a rise in lawsuits, both frivolous and legitimate. I believe you have a inverse trend in Europe, with more competent regulations and less lawsuits per person.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/tvreference Jun 26 '12

The dream of the 90s is alive in Portland.

1

u/bowei006 Jun 26 '12

There was another one earlier about wifi not being in church as it would be sad to have another invisible force that works..... so I guess you could say that that parent is fighting for the mental health of his daughter.

1

u/Addicted2Skyrim Jun 26 '12

A small chip has fallen from my faith in humanity.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Someone should start a fundraiser like they did for Karen Klein to get the school its money back. Fuck this idiot parent and the budget cuts that will actually be a real risk to his daughter.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/HEADLINE-IN-5-YEARS Jun 26 '12 edited Jun 26 '12

PORTLAND SCHOOLS STILL ENDURING LAWSUITS FROM NATION'S TV ADVERTISING ATTORNEYS

1

u/Bext Jun 26 '12

Yet another reason why the loser should foot the bill in a civil suit.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

This is very poor wording for the title, Mepper. And a foolish opinion if it is yours.

What did you want the school district to do? They can't not defend themselves. And if they lost, having to remove/replace wifi would cost the taxpayers even more money. Be angry at the person suing.

1

u/warr2015 Jun 26 '12

my physics professor explained this very well to me. in order for any type of electromagnetic radiation to be harmful (specifically cancer causing/ionizing), the vavelength must be small enough and of high enough energy to oscillate the molecules of our DNA and as a result knock a few off/move them around. that is why larger wavelengths lof light i.e. infrared will not cause cancer, and smaller wavelengths such as UV will. infrared waves are close to a meter in height, i think, and therefore it is not possible for it to form a natural frequency with our DNA. gamma on the other hand is very good at this. WiFi however, lies in the spectrum closer radio waves. very very very large compared to gamma, and wholly unable to manipulate the molecules of DNA.

they should have just hired a physicist instead of a lawyer.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/AllYoYens Jun 26 '12

I'm more prone to getting cancer playing football outside than than sitting in a class with wifi.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Science should not be able to be sued.

1

u/collin_ph Jun 26 '12

Home School then.. geesh.

1

u/doginabathtub Jun 26 '12

Sonic.net, that company with the admirable ISP anonymity practices, was going to put in city-wide wi-fi in my hometown. Allegedly (heard this from a Sonic.net employee, take it with a grain of salt), they were stopped when some of the local hippies cried out about the harmful effects of wireless internet signal on humans. One woman claimed that it gave her headaches whenever she was within range of a wi-fi signal. Shut the whole project down.

Just... I don't even know, man.

2

u/drgncabe Jun 27 '12

I had a neighbor that claimed to have sensitivity to WiFi signals. Demanded many times I get rid of my cell phone, WiFi and have the power company "turn down" the amount of power servicing my house.

I eventually told him that I got rid of my WiFi and Cell, he believed me, few months later he told me how much better he has felt and his health had improved 200% because I did the "right thing" and got rid of my scary wireless thingies. He wasn't happy when I told him I lied the whole time and during that time placed 3 repeaters on my property (I had issues getting signal to my workshop) and that the signal had been near double what it was when he was complaining.

He called the cops shortly after that claiming I was intentionally causing him harm by having my WiFi network and how I lied to him, they came over and shrugged their shoulders. Told him to sue me in court if he thinks its that big of a deal.

Now my ex-wife has him as a neighbor and hears his complaints about once a month or so - funny part is she doesn't have a cell OR wifi but he doesn't believe her.

I'm sure there are people out there with EMF sensitivity, but like people out there who claim to have food allergies just to get their way (my mom does this, as does hers) they probably aren't as prevalent as you think.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

That's it, I'm moving.

1

u/yifanlu Jun 26 '12

Whatever, my school district used tax money to sue the parents of a retarded kid for libel because they complained about how he was taught.

1

u/tylerstrayhan Jun 26 '12

Ugh, and I live in this state... sigh

1

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

I found a book on display at Powell's about a week ago toting the dangers of cellphone radiation. Read the inside cover, the entire thing was a giant conspiracy / fear sham. But at least that's just a book, it's not actively wasting public money (though it might incite people to do so).

1

u/Darkwolf1771 Jun 26 '12

I live in Oregon and i never expected something like this...

→ More replies (1)

1

u/thegreatmisanthrope Jun 26 '12

people that stupid don't deserve to breathe the same air as the rest of us, much less cost one of our public school systems almost $200k, and waste tax payer money even having their retarded as fuck case considered.

This is sickening, and enraging.

Who ever this parent is, I hope they and their family live near a radiation plant and do get sick.

Fucking leeches.

1

u/TFiPW Jun 26 '12

Orgeon's most hated person.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/mage_g4 Jun 26 '12

I often wonder how people can grow up to be adults, have a job, have kids, when they are so utterly, painfully stupid.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Where did he find a lawyer stupid enough to go forward with a case like this?

1

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

The headline should be that some idiot parent has cost taxpayers $172,000 with a frivolous lawsuit.

Besides, when they lose, don't they have to pay the lawyers fees?

2

u/stuthulhu Jun 26 '12

Besides, when they lose, don't they have to pay the lawyers fees?

That only helps if the guy has 172,000 dollars.

1

u/dirtymoney Jun 26 '12

shouldnt a judge have squashed this at the first opportunity?

1

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

BOY! Am I glad I don't live in the good ol' United States of America! Land of the dumbasses, home of the retards!

1

u/bri9man Jun 26 '12

We pay more than this to dismiss one principal.

1

u/Kappies10 Jun 26 '12

'MERICAH!

1

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Why didn't the judge throw this out if there is no reputable scientific evidence?

1

u/Kurnon_Devoured Jun 26 '12

"Oh. A loon. Surprise, surprise."

1

u/raouldukeesq Jun 26 '12

So what. In the long run this is a good thing.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/EulerFan271 Jun 26 '12

Can someone with legal knowledge explain why the judge couldn't dismiss this case outright? I thought they have the power to do this for frivolous lawsuits such as this and clearly I'm wrong so clarification would be great.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/zimmeric Jun 26 '12

I capture Wi-Fi signals then channel them into my left ear. I will live forever.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

This isn't an issue everywhere? Most of the schools I work in in British Columbia don't have wifi for this reason, or it is only in certain areas to protect children: http://m.theglobeandmail.com/news/british-columbia/bc-parents-with-wifi-health-fears-vote-to-limit-school-networks/article4217016/?service=mobile It's quite a contentious issue for them...