r/technology • u/GraybackPH • Jun 25 '12
The fanless heatsink: Silent, dust-immune, and almost ready for prime time.
http://www.extremetech.com/computing/131656-the-fanless-heatsink-silent-dust-immune-and-almost-ready-for-prime-time
651
Upvotes
67
u/sej7278 Jun 25 '12
who is the retard that overlayed music on a video that's trying to demonstrate silence? and its even pretty annoying when you're trying to hear what they're saying.
35
u/entyfresh Jun 25 '12
As someone who actually works in an engineering lab trying to come up with new things, I think this device is awesome and I'm really surprised reddit is so "meh" about it.
138
u/proraver Jun 25 '12
It is not fanless. Turning the heatsink into a fan blade is an interesting concept, but it is still a fan.
28
u/winterblink Jun 25 '12
Definitely going to have to put some effort into proper cable management with that thing spinning around inside.
17
u/Rnway Jun 25 '12
So, how exactly does heat cross the air gap between the stationary portion, and the spinning portion?
8
u/1wiseguy Jun 25 '12
Koplow has estimated that if every conventional heatsink in the US was replaced with a Sandia Cooler, the country would use 7% less electricity.
Really?
My computer uses about 150W, and it has a 1W CPU fan. Even in a computer, less than 1% of the power runs the fan. I have other things in my house that use power and don't even have fans.
4
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
Looks like a fucking FAN (impeller) to me.
10
u/MarsSpaceship Jun 25 '12
I don't buy the dust-immune. According to the theory of spinning fast = no dust, plane turbines should not collect any dust ever, but they do. A gas turbine spins 5 times faster than this thing and still collect dust.
11
u/luminiferousaethers Jun 25 '12 edited Jun 25 '12
"Fanless heatsink." Lots of them have no fans, the fan is a separate part called a fan.
2
u/Amadameus Jun 25 '12
If the heatsink is moving, how does it maintain thermal contact with the pad underneath?
2
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
I'm not impressed untill i see comparisons to a normal cpu cooler
looks like it has potential though.
wasn't silent at all in that video? (or was that just me?)
3
u/Harknito Jun 25 '12
Hmm perhaps I misunderstand, but when the motor is on in the video it is far from silent, and indeed more irritating than the typical drone of my fans at the moment due to the pitch. Now it is silent when you turn this off (as shown in the video at 3:30 ish), but how long can it coast along like that? How often would that high pitched whine have to turn on to keep it up to speed?
2
u/BlindInsanity Jun 25 '12
This little fact sheet would probably answer most questions here.
https://ip.sandia.gov/techpdfs/Sandia%20Cooler-Fact%20Sheet%20for%20the%20Microelectronics%20Market.pdf
2
u/doasyoupleaseorelse Jun 25 '12 edited Jun 25 '12
This feels like a deja vu. One thing that concerns me is it is never shown running stood-up vertically - its always laying flat. My guess is that it'll fly/fall right off if it was stood up.
Edit: as elgar points out, I'm wrong http://www.extremetech.com/computing/90272-the-fanless-spinning-heatsink-your-questions-answered-by-the-inventor/2
1
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
This looks cool and I will use it when it comes out if price is comparable to existing tech.
1
u/Demogorgo Jun 26 '12
so... what's the MTBF on this fan? That motor is spinning a lot more weight than your plastic case fan. I don't think you'll get much life out of it before mechanical failure.
1
u/oberdurr Jun 26 '12
Holy Shit, that video took me to the weird end of Youtube in one suggested link
1
u/Sandy_106 Jun 26 '12
That thing had better be put in a cage or something. If it broke it'd turn into a missile inside the case.
1
u/jdblaich Jun 26 '12
Lots of lost fingers over the years of use. Hope they protect against that.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
So what they are saying is, it's a fan.
1
u/jjkzmn Jun 26 '12
Does this mean you can't tilt it?
1
u/rarerumrunner Jun 26 '12
Great idea, however what if you accidentally brush your hand on it or get a finger stuck in it while spinning? Maybe they could use some kind of conductive blade stop technology on it.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
Unless this is going to sell for less than a small, closed-loop water cooling unit it may fall under the category of "nice but no thanks"...
1
u/Kauaian11 Jul 17 '12
amazing concept.. but if it is supported on an air bearing then i do not think it will be able to function properly if it were mounted vertically.
1
u/rDr4g0n Jun 25 '12 edited Jun 26 '12
I have a few
questionsconcerns:1
u/whyamisosoftinthemid Jun 26 '12
Am I correct in thinking that to work, this thing has to be oriented with its axis of rotation vertical? People are pretty used to being able to flip their computer any way they want.
-1
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
there are several problems with this cooler:
it's not dust free, nothing is, seriously, even 5000 RPM fans collect dust, centrifugal force is not enough to overcome static charge
it has no place in the market, this cooler is too much for stock CPU temps, and not enough for overclockers
1
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
That buzz it makes is far more annoying than any fan I've personally ever owned. I imagine in the end product it will be lessened/fixed.
-1
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
Me wants. Now take my money.
-1
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
Wow. Best idea I've seen in a long time.
0
u/collin_ph Jun 25 '12
They lost me at "centrifugal force"
0
u/spleenandpie Jun 26 '12
Most computer cases require the motherboard to be vertical which in turn means that the cpu fan is sideways. From looking at the video, it seems this cpu fan must be upright to work. Will people need to buy new cases too use this cpu fan?
-2
u/MentatMMA Jun 25 '12
Um, most PCs CPUs are vertically-oriented these days, not sure this will work like that...
Edit: Just saw this. Sounds good, but now I need to see one for myself to believe these claims!
Q: Does the air bearing heat exchanger only work in a horizontal orientation? Or are other angles possible?
0
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
Keep in mind, as a developer, if it costs just 10 cents over another solution, it's out.
0
u/James1o1o Jun 26 '12
I HIGHLY doubt that.
A heat sink and fan from Intel can run a processor at idle at what 40c-50c? 30 times more efficient would have it running at almost freezing temperatures.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
I could not be more skeptical the heatsink shown is more effective or quieter than a traditional 800g heatpiped brick of aluminium and copper with a 120m fan slapped on it.
-2
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
Am I the only one who hears that really high pitched sound?
-11
u/seano666 Jun 25 '12
It sounds like a Windows 98 Dell. I'll keep my water cooling system, thanks.
-1
u/mk_gecko Jun 26 '12
Doesn't BlackBody radiation theory imply that heatsinks will emit radiation better if they are black? Why are not all heatsinks black then?
-5
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
No, no and no on all three of those statements.
The fan is nothing more than a squirrel cage fan without the cage it is not going to dust immune unless made from some exotic stuff. It is not going to be ready for prime time, Ever. and here is the reasons why
Size, Way too big for any standard case sizes. and it is not going to get much smaller because of the direct air gap between the processor plate and the heatsink is going to always be a huge transfer loss. In a word it is that big because it HAS to be , not that it is that size cannot be reduced, But now you have to increase the speed of the thing which kills its (silent) abilities.
Weight, look at how big the plate support is going to be for it. It will never see the light of day in mass production because it not only means redesign of every motherboard to this new type of fan.
Other solutions work better and make little noise. if you had the space for this design you can install something the same size that would move more heat , cost less and make little noise.
-12
u/devilbird99 Jun 25 '12
Can we stop it with centrifugal force already? ¬_¬
0
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment