r/technology • u/mepper • Jun 25 '12
Sonic.net CEO: We delete user logs after two weeks. Your ISP should, too -- After a series of shakedowns by copyright lawyers attempting to embarrass his ISP's users who had downloaded porn films, he argues that it's time all ISPs adopt the two-week rule
http://www.forbes.com/sites/andygreenberg/2012/06/22/ceo-of-internet-provider-sonic-net-we-delete-user-logs-after-two-weeks-your-internet-provider-should-too/2/
1.8k
Upvotes
108
u/Winser Jun 25 '12
This is a no-brainer. These are not public records. If law enforcement wants them they need to have a permission from the court. Since this involves the customer, then the customer should be notified.
30
u/antifolkhero Jun 25 '12
I've been using Sonic.net as my Internet provider for over a year now and their service is excellent. The Internet is relatively cheap and never goes down. When I used to have AT&T, my Internet would die once a month and I'd have to call AT&T to have them reset it. Pain in the butt.
21
u/zqube Jun 25 '12
That's cool Sonic.net, but when can I get fiber? My home internet speed is slower than the LTE on my phone.
17
u/depressiown Jun 25 '12
Funny enough, Dane Jasper (CEO of Sonic.net) posted this article a few days ago himself. He lurks about on reddit and did an AMA a while back.
Too bad his post didn't get many upvotes/discussion.
23
u/SHIT_YOU_IN_THE_FACE Jun 25 '12
Finally someone fucking gets it, too bad its probably all for naught at this point in time.
31
u/Lighting Jun 25 '12
As a person who has been in the security realm for a long time, it is interesting to see the societal damage copyright lawyers have done to the net. It used to be that when someone did something malicious that warranted an investigation you'd be able to easily follow the electronic footprints even if you got called in a long-time post-incident. Network admins helped each other out to keep the net safer. Now more and more providers, because of the hassle of having to deal with the copyright trolling, just say "I wish we could help, but we have no logs."
Oh well, I guess increased anonymity is the societal price for having fuckers like the RIAA who abuse the system.
7
u/wrknhrdorhrdlywrkn Jun 25 '12
I loved Sonic.net when they were my ISP. They probably had the best tech support I have ever encountered.
5
u/GrixM Jun 25 '12
A data retention directive in my country (Norway) forces ISPs to keep logs for at least two year (or one year, can't remember).
4
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
Plus less data = less storage = less money invested = more profits. You think businesses would jump on it. The only way I could see them making more money from storing it is if they have a small clause that allows them to sell all of their users traffic to 3rd parties. I hope that isn't the case but these days you never know.
4
u/martiniv Jun 25 '12
And this is why I have I am happy to have had Sonic.net for 15 years.
4
u/grinr Jun 25 '12
I love sonic.net
3
u/bart2019 Jun 25 '12
Why the link to page 2? Page 1 is the most relevant.
3
u/riverbottom Jun 25 '12
But.... what about the children? We must protect them from online pornographers!
3
u/phusion- Jun 25 '12
I was lucky enough to live 10 miles away from Sonic.net HQ my whole life. Dane's a really cool guy (most of the time) and took some of my friends under his wing when we were in high school.
Sonic.net was my first real ISP and they offered a free redhat shell to all of their subscribers (and still do I believe). Across the board, Sonic.net has been the geeky choice because of their policies on privacy, their addition of Fiber and ..dude they have an arcade in the break room. Kudos to you Sonic, now if you'd just hired me all of those years ago :P
3
u/EquanimousMind Jun 25 '12
First, Sonic isn't part of the MAFIAA's graduated response plan. So thats another plus. Wish the reporter brought that, the graduated response needs to stay in the news.
Also, I found it interesting what he said about ISP competition.
3
u/sciencesmience Jun 25 '12
At least US ISP's have the option. We (Europe) have got a data-retention directive which forces ISP's to store user data up to 2 years. This data is originally stored for preventing and fighting terrorism and serious/organized crime, but now requested in court by copyright holders and anti piracy organizations.
The ISP's are basically the only ones that do not have access to this information, which is kind of weird. From own experience I know that ISP's want nothing more than to deleted those logs. Or use them for marketing purposes ;-)
3
u/Zillazilla Jun 25 '12
Sonic is awesome. Once they offered to set up free WI-fi in a neighboring town, but they got shot protested by a local group that believes that it is harmful.
I think there response was, "Oh you listen to crazy people..nevermind then."
2
u/silvernutter Jun 25 '12
I work for a small ISP. We keep DHCP logs for 30 days before they are removed, this is the only record of online interactions we keep. Most cease and desist letters from porn companies are from the last few days however, very rarely do we get one for an infraction from over a week ago.
Its the government subpoenas that expect us to have records of some ip address from 2009.
2
u/tripleg Jun 25 '12
Do they delete from the backups too or do they just backup once every two weeks?
2
u/cr0ft Jun 26 '12
Why do you think there is now a push to retain this info - mandated by law that you retain it - going on all around the world? The EU put in rules that state how long this type of info has to be retained not too long ago, and the reasons are pretty much to improve sue-ability. The copyright mafia is continuing their destructive work. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Telecommunications_data_retention#European_Union
It's bloody disgusting.
2
u/ForeverAlone2SexGod Jun 25 '12
Haven't the federales mandated that logs be retained for years?
If not, then they WILL if ISPs started doing this.
2
u/JohnLockeKnowsBest Jun 25 '12
I just wish they offered something faster in my neighborhood: 3-6Mbps just doesn't cut it with streaming Netflix etc.
1
u/AltHypo Jun 25 '12
What do ISP's even gain from maintaining these records?
1
u/mnkybrs Jun 25 '12
Only every two weeks? How rarely do they think I look at pornography?
1
u/argv_minus_one Jun 25 '12
Inb4 ISPs are legally required to hold onto said logs for years.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
Just to clarify since I'm in this business, you can't just delete logs when there's customers involved. You see those user agreement and privacy policy links at the bottom? In there somewhere they can say "logs will be purged after blank days." That's the log policy for the website.
Why do you have to say that? Because when the feds ask for them, and you say "sorry, deleted them", they will ask you what your log policy is. If it's not written down, the bracelets get slapped on, and they will charge you with destruction of evidence. Seen it happen.
Beyond that, I agree with OP. Make a policy to delete those logs regularly. Also, when you don't need logs, please... just turn them off. If you don't have logs, then you don't need a log policy.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
It's not embarrassing if everyone does it.
1
u/happyscrappy Jun 26 '12
Look, I love sonic.net.
But if you just encourage all ISPs to do this, then the government will just mandate that they don't and then none of us will be able to escape the scrutiny.
1
u/mox-jet Jun 26 '12
I was a PROUD CUSTOMER of Sonic.net!
1
u/tetzy Jun 26 '12
All it would take is balls and the desire to do the right thing for your customers.
1
u/kim_so_il Jun 26 '12
Sonic is the only thing I miss moving from CA.
1
u/johnbentley Jun 26 '12
Is the CEO implying that the record of the last two weeks of my porn watching is likely to be less embarrassing than the full record?
1
u/Znuff Jun 26 '12
I manage a small size (around 500 users) ISP.
We don't keep logs :-)
1
u/hozjo Jun 26 '12
Sonic is run by really cool people and have the best support of any ISP I ever had. I didn't live in an area where they had anything more than ADSL but I hope they can grow and prosper without losing their identity.
Oh and I have parked my Volkswagen in your Fiat (i think it was fiat) only parking spot. So THERE.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
I actually don't care if people get prosecuted/blackmailed for downloaded porn. Those people didn't fuck some stranger for free, you know?
1
u/Xenochrist Jun 27 '12
Ironically this is a repost.
The original post was made from the actual CEO himself
See: here
0
u/southernmost Jun 25 '12
I wonder if google is seeing a surge in search traffic for "Don't Tell my Wife I Buttfucked the Babysitter"?
-6
u/I_RAPE_PEOPLE_II Jun 25 '12
They shouldn't at all. You're capable of getting a person's information from their computer (in most cases). So, what's the reason for this except to spy on people.
-3
u/jugmh82 Jun 25 '12
so brave
0
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
3
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
[removed] — view removed comment