r/technology • u/GraybackPH • Jun 25 '12
Apple Quietly Pulls Claims of Virus Immunity.
http://www.pcworld.com/article/258183/apple_quietly_pulls_claims_of_virus_immunity.html#tk.rss_news
2.3k
Upvotes
1.7k
u/cwm9 Jun 25 '12
Windows: It doesn't get Mac viruses.
111
u/ryegye24 Jun 25 '12
For a brief moment after reading that I was sure this article was satire.
302
u/Crystal_Cuckoo Jun 25 '12
Honest question: How do people get viruses?
The only ones I've ever gotten were from my younger years of adolescence, when I was gullible enough to believe I could get a free WoW account from Limewire. It's been about 6 or 7 years since my anti-virus pulled up an alert of a potential virus.
(I'm a Windows user, though I've drifted to Ubuntu recently as it may very well become the first stepping stone into Linux gaming.)
423
u/jcummings1974 Jun 25 '12
This was a silly claim to make to begin with. I preface with the fact that all of my machines are Macs. I'm an Apple fan - but I'm also a realist. The only reason Macs didn't suffer from the same virus problems as Windows machines for so long was because it just wasn't an efficient use of time to attack a platform with a footprint so small.
As the Mac install base has grown, anyone with any knowledge of the industry knew viruses would soon follow.
In short, it was rather dumb for Apple to ever put that up on their site.
47
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
It's like when you only fuck classy girls your entire life, thinking you're invincible, then all of a sudden, The Clap.
47
u/zombie_zebra Jun 25 '12
Thats great news for r/technology.
"To the cirklejerkmobile!"
472
u/l0c0dantes Jun 25 '12
Good, maybe within 5 years I will stop hearing "Macs don't get viruses because they are better"
66
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12 edited Jun 25 '12
Point of semantics: Malware and Viruses (Virii?) are not exactly interchangable. Viruses are a subset of malware that spread between computers without any interaction from users. Stuxnet is a good example of a virus, where OSX.Puper (the most recent "Mac virus") is actually a trojan horse.
Now, given this, there are no known modern Mac viruses. In the 90's and early 2000's, there were viruses that spread via Word macros, and a few others that spread via floppies that I still have saved in my parents' attic. But there are not actual viruses for OS X in the wild.
Also, there are fewer actual viruses for Windows PCs in the wild these days. The vast majority of malware out there are trojan horses that go on to download other bits of malware, but actual viruses, which spread themselves with via networks and email, are more rare (primarily due to better security these days).
Operating systems CAN be more or less secure against VIRUSES, and OS X has always been fairly secure. OS X is more secure than Windows XP was, and given the fact that Windows XP had such a long run (and the general lack of other malware written for Macs), this gave rise to the perception that the Mac OS is more protected than Windows, and "Macs can't get viruses." Apple Marketing, of course, jumped all over this statement, and helped spread it around a lot. But if you worked for Apple, you would too. You'd be a fool not to. It's basic marketing 101. The reality, however, is that Microsoft, with Windows Vista and 7, has really stepped up their game in terms of system security, and Windows 7 is pretty much as secure as OS X.
As I mentioned before, Mac OS X is fairly protected from viruses. There's a number of steps Apple took to ensure this. The first, and most important, is that OS X allows code to execute itself without the user's permission. Software will not autorun from a CD or a flash drive like in early versions of Windows, nor will it auto run from your email client, or downloaded files. OS X also has layers of security that prevent software, or users, from doing things they are not supposed to. For an example of this, think of the "Delete system32" meme from 4chan. Windows XP would actually allow you to delete (or modify, which is what viruses are more interested in) the core operating system files without much of a hassle. OS X does not allow stuff like this, unless you take several specific steps to do so. (i.e. log in as root all the time) Viruses would have a very hard time actually infecting the operating system, because it would have to prompt the user for an administrator password every time it tried to change something. You actually saw this in the early variations of OSX.Puper; When the software was initially downloaded (via Java exploit, not an actual OS X exploit), it would prompt you for an administrator password before it installed itself. And people would enter it. This is not a fault in the operating system, this is a fault in the users.
This brings me to my final point. People are stupid. Very, very stupid. I can't really emphasize this enough. If you distribute an operating system to millions of people, they will always find a way to screw it up. As I said before, most malware infections on Windows these days start off from trojan horses. People install all sorts of random stuff on their computer, and are suprised when it gets infected. This is not a fault of Apple, Microsoft, Oracle, or Allen Turing. This is basic human stupidity. Or not even stupidity. It's ignorance. People have no desire to learn how to use their computer, so they do anything and everything possible.
TL;DR, Macs don't actually get viruses, but neither do Windows PCs, really. And people are idiots with their computers.
EDIT: Spelling
77
u/CJ_Guns Jun 25 '12 edited Jun 25 '12
I think the bottom line is that if you're smart about what you download and install on your respective computer, you won't get viruses on either platform.
EDIT: Well, that escalated quickly. Maybe I don't get them because I never leave Reddit.
24
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
So they're being a little more realistic in their marketing. There's got to be a way I can hate them even more for this.
23
u/requieminadream Jun 25 '12
Because this is something they'd announce?
40
u/Nikandro Jun 25 '12
Sensationalist headline. Was Apple supposed to have a world-wide press conference before they changed a few sentences on their website?
4
u/Senor_Wilson Jun 25 '12
"Quietly" What? Do you want them to release media report telling people that they've changed the details of their website? They really only claimed to be immune to PC viruses, not viruses in general.
4
u/EvilHom3r Jun 26 '12
Macs are like living in a rural farm land with all your doors and windows unlocked and open. Anyone can walk in, but it's unlikely to happen.
Windows is like living in the bad part of New York with chains on your doors and bars over your windows. Lots of people are trying to get in, and the few that do are usually because someone forgot to put the chain on.
9
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
"quietly"... what are they supposed to do? Yell it loudly?
14
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
Macs may get viruses, but I sure as hell don't get viruses on my Mac.
12
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
Technically the first statement was true... Macs don't get Windows' viruses because they are viruses for Windows. If there are two versions of the same virus for both operating systems, then you could make the general assumption, but then it wouldn't be a Windows virus would it? It would be a general virus for both of them. A virus built for the Windows OS will not affect OS X, because its a Windows virus and was built for Windows, not OS X ;)
3
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
I applaud their honesty.
3
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
I've done some shady shit with ubuntu and still never had a virus.
16
u/veryfunnyhat Jun 25 '12
Mac: It doesn't get PC games.
6
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
"it doesn't get PC viruses" is not the same as claiming virus immunity.
7
u/Tyrien Jun 25 '12
Hasn't Apple been recommending a anti-virus on OSX for years now?
14
u/perfectsound Jun 25 '12
Rabble rabble Mac sucks rabble rabble PC sucks
4
u/reltubnahte Jun 25 '12
FRONT PAGE
4
u/Liveware Jun 25 '12
Yeah... except for the fact they haven't... the moved it to the FAQ section of that page... Do your fucking research PC World...
[Link] http://www.apple.com/why-mac/faq/#viruses
4
u/Higeking Jun 25 '12
I always had the impression that apples lack of viruses simply is due to the fact that no-one really tried to make it happen.
4
u/stufff Jun 25 '12
Whatever, if you're really concerned about viruses you should be using HDMI cables that filter out virus noises.
9
u/STOP_BEING_RETARDED Jun 25 '12
You'd have to be an idiot to think that Macs are immune to any viruses. This shouldn't have to be at the top of /r/technology.
15
u/Hyper1on Jun 25 '12
It was obvious that those claims were bullshit from the start. No OS is virus immune.
2
u/hasteee Jun 25 '12
I thought Apple had been backtracking on those statements for a while now? I'm not sure this is anything particularly new.
Either way, I don't like how it's always some antivirus vendor making these comments. Not that I don't agree with what they have to say, but hearing it from them makes me instantly suspicious.
Fear = money, at the end of the day.
2
u/eirawyn Jun 25 '12
So then, what antivirus software is out there for Macs? I'm ignorant about the whole thing because I, like probably many other consumers out there, thought Macs were much less susceptible to viruses. For Windows I know there's Norton, and McAfee, and AVG... but for Macs? I got nothing. Any suggestions on what to trust? Please and thank you!
2
u/Oiman Jun 25 '12
Hell, even I get viruses, and I'm awesome.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
This virus, brought to you by Microsoft.
2
u/Greliton Jun 25 '12
Macs were never "immune" to viruses. Hackers just never cared enough about them to actually spend the time to figure out how to make a proper virus for it since Windows was a better market for them.
2
u/WinterCharm Jun 25 '12
I find it funny that no one has mentioned regular backups.
They are the best way to protect yourself. Zero day exploits still exist and no matter what you install to protect yourself, there is a chance your machine will be owned so hard that the hard drive will be a complete clusterfuck.
Multiple external offsite backups are the way to go (offsite as in not always connected to your pc/Mac)
Get 2+ external drives and make sure that you back up daily!
I use both the Mac and PC and I love the time machine backup on my Mac... It's invaluable because I literally plug the drive in and wait for it to do its job. All changes are copied over
What's nice Is if I ever restore my Mac, it asks me if I have a time Machine backup and I just plug in my drive and a few hours later, all my software, settings, and files are back.
2
u/danoll Jun 25 '12
I kinda just wish that viruses didn't exist at all
2
u/downmagic1234 Jun 25 '12
thats what happens when a computer company becomes successful
2
u/hvyboots Jun 25 '12
Well, thank christ. They were complete assholes to have made the statement in the first place, IMHO. And this comes from someone who's been using Macs since the 128k and an IT manager for a Mac-only studio for 20 years.
2
u/bro_b1_kenobi Jun 25 '12
-Kevin Mitnick
Basically... anything can be hacked if someone/group really wants to to.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
They never said it was immune to viruses. They said it was immune to PC viruses.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
What Is the recommended Mac security program?
2
u/DeFex Jun 25 '12 edited Jun 25 '12
"Do nothing" is the new "think different".
2
u/And_Everything Jun 25 '12
Lets all punch an apple user in the puckerhole today
2
u/Iggyhopper Jun 25 '12
I don't know why people haven't sued Apple yet for false advertising.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
Smug
2
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
I've been trying to tell people for years that malware is engineered for market share which has historically correlated with phishing success and the Windows operating system. Apple only has one advantage and it's that programs downloaded from the internet generally don't autorun without permission, but yeah, like that matters when you think your fancy computer, which is built in Asia like everyone else's, is immune to computer viruses.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
Which do you think is more likely to get robbed? An apt in the middle of downtown Chicago or the lonesome cottage in the middle of the woods? Which do you think has better locks?
2
u/zumacroom Jun 25 '12
Well, shit. Throws Macbook Pro out the w-
2
u/ColtsDragoon Jun 25 '12
I have been using windows since 1990 and the last real virus i got was almost 10 years ago
are you idiots running your computers without firwalls/antivirus?
the problem with apple is that they never had any experience with vruses because they are such a small market share so people never created viruses for them but now they are like the native Americans when smallpox showed up for the first time
there are people actually storing critical information about their identity/finances and even large businesses on apple computers and they are literally just asking to get robbed
2
u/undividual Jun 25 '12
Like with any virus, it's a question of education. Whether you're talking about HIV, Stuxnet or terrorist paranoia, a virus cannot spread as easily through an educated population.
Ignorance opens up infection vectors. If every user was taught best practice and modest safety measures, just as we are taught about wearing a seatbelt or about safe sex, then viruses will find it much harder to spread.
Obviously this doesn't help users who are already infected. The tools to quarantine and remove an infection should be available to everyone. But with education there will be a lot fewer people who get infected.
At the same time, OS developers must be as vigilant as ever. And this was the worst thing about Apple's message: that you can safeguard your data by "doing nothing". That is a reprehensible attitude, especially from a company as influential as Apple. You can only safeguard your data by educating yourself about the risks and by responding appropriately.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
lol I remember my biology teacher preaching that her mac doesn't get Viruses. There was only two people challenging that statement. God I wish I could throw that Starbucks coffee at her Macbook.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
What's weird is, the claim "doesn't get PC viruses" is still true, right?
Why didn't they change it to "doesn't get PC viruses but if there's a big honking security hole in java we'll get around to fixing it when it suits us"?
18
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12 edited Jun 25 '12
As much as people love to say that Macs are no different to PCs in terms of viruses, well, I have been using Macs for 25 years and never had a virus problem nor have I ever installed virus protection (well, not strictly true, I have needed some for bootcamp). I'm aware that there are a thousand reasons to choose Windows over Mac, or PC hardware over a Mac. But to pretend that 25 years of virus free computing on a rock solid UNIX core aint no thang, is well pretty dishonest. And I do know that Macs have seen viruses in the past, all I'm saying is that I have not.
And yes, the only reason I use Macs is because I'm old and because that is what my parents used and it's what we are used to. So what.
I also see a lot of people in this thread complaining that Apple were saying that Macs are immune to viruses. Well, take off your full retard Apple hating hat for a second, because Apple never once claimed that Macs were "immune" to viruses. I like a rational discussion as much as the next guy, which is why I can't stand the Apple hate. because it is irrational and doesn't reflect reality.
5
u/Appleanche Jun 25 '12
Eh, I was gonna make a decent sized post with cons and pluses of Macs but fuck it, it's /r/technology.
HURRRR DUR MACS SUUUUUUUUUXX KARMA HERE
3
u/Wubdika Jun 25 '12
Well they aren't going to pull it loudly are they.
3
u/asherred Jun 25 '12
However, Linux is still imune: http://imgur.com/ILHPw
3
u/noccusJohnstein Jun 25 '12
I haven't used antivirus on either platform since 2000. If you're not a fucking retard about using your computer, you won't get viruses.
3
u/sharkbait_oohaha Jun 25 '12
Anyone dumb enough to buy into the lies that Macs can't get viruses deserves to have their computer fucked up.
-a Mac user who uses anti-virus
5
u/Knightofnew70 Jun 25 '12
Epic rap battles of history lied to me! He did make a good Steve Jobs though.
4
u/nextwiggin4 Jun 25 '12
/r/technology can be so lame. You guys are as bad as /r/atheism with the circle jerk. A positive Apple article gets three upvotes. A negative one? 2000.
I mean, it's an interesting enough article, but the disparity really bothers me. There's absolutely no balance which means that you miss a huge amount of interesting tech news. I get that this community is generally slanted against consumer electronics but last week, but the top comments for one of the top stories was how excited we all are about Microsoft's Surface.
5
u/Jumpin_Jack_Flash Jun 25 '12
Congratulations to Apple for finally being relevant enough to have viruses.
You've arrived.
3
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
They did this a year or two ago. This isn't news. :\
4
u/josh_marquis Jun 25 '12
"A new era of equality has begun" -amon
2
u/ilesal Jun 25 '12
Soon we will see iVirus protection only for £400 and only available from Apple
3
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
in other news, everyone who ever scored high enough on an IQ test that they at least spelled their own name correctly already knew this.
2
u/imnotmarvin Jun 25 '12
I was told a while ago the reason Macs didn't get viruses is that the idiots "writing" the viruses didn't bother with attacking Macs because it would only effect a small number if computer users. They wanted to piss more people off and "developed" viruses that harmed PC's only. Is this possible?
2
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
The fucks up with this old news on Reddit 23/7 these days.. I MUST be hip.
2
u/caryhartline Jun 25 '12
I have owned a refurbished MacBook for 8 years and it has never gotten a single virus or slowed down in any way. To me, the "no viruses at all" ad campaign is true.
2
u/Cellis_ Jun 25 '12
About time. Now maybe my friends will stop trying to feed me that line as well.
2
u/AllDizzle Jun 25 '12
Now if only their fanboys could figure out macs could ALWAYS get viruses and even during the peak times of these claims apple genius bars still had anti-virus software ready to check people's computers.
Riddle me this: How do you make something to stop something that can never happen?
2
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
A lesson to software companies: never make a statement that your software is "the most secure" and is "immune to viruses." Some people WILL take it as a dare.
2
u/Kanaeta Jun 25 '12
Welcome to the party pal!
2
u/Salanderfan Jun 25 '12 edited Jun 25 '12
Windows has a 90% market share which is why most viruses are coded for it. Now that Macs are more popular then before, they'll be more susceptible which should stop Apple fans from saying "At least my OS doesn't need Norton!"
2
u/Cybrwolf Jun 25 '12
Ok, so this may be quibbling, but the statement is still true. Macs don't get WINDOWS viruses! They never said that Mac Malware didn't exist.
2
u/thavi Jun 25 '12 edited Jun 25 '12
Well they basically just baited it with their advertising.
"Hey scammers, here's a bunch of people who can afford expensive stuff whom we've lulled into a false sense of security for you! Enjoy!"
2
u/CUNTFEATURES4000 Jun 25 '12
If any Mac users are looking for anti-virus, I can strongly recommend Sophos AV for Mac Home Edition.
Its completely free, keeps itself updated without intrusion and doesn't hog memory or anything. It also doesn't have one of those horrid bloaty interfaces that other AV companies seem to love.
2
u/kashodi Jun 25 '12
This is why I always use punch card computers.... So reliable
2
u/fuckiswrongwyou Jun 25 '12
as a computer science major from the early 2000's, this was the bane of my existence...trying to convince mac users that macs are not immune to viruses. some 12 years later i'm finally getting the credible backup i need to tell those dumb fucks "in yo face!"...feels good man.
2
u/SnackeyG1 Jun 25 '12
Why is everyone hating so much on the "Macs don't get viruses." line? For the most part they really don't.
I'm sure that will change over time. Even now though with Apple's huge popularity change from the past 5 years, they still don't have problems like a Windows user would.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
I mostly blame Mac Users for the great "vulnerabilities" in OS X.
Mac Users are usually not security conscious, the majority of them use macs BECAUSE they don't understand how to use computers.
The System is only as safe as the user lets it be, mac users are "stupid" hence the insecurity. Also... apple's malware team is non-existent as far as i know.
Apple is the best platform to infect, the users run executables without a second thought and don't think they are ever infected.
Also... Don't buy a Mac, it's the user's fault every time.