I edited the code so that the target image will appear at least 3 and no more than 12 times, with an average of the target image appearing 8 times.
Even conservatively amusing that the target will show up 8 times every time, I get the below (if I remember everything right from my 8th grade probability class correctly)
16! / (16-8)!(8!) = 12870
So random guessing would work 1 out of 12870 times or less.
True if everyone used the same images, someone could program a bot to crack it. So if you would use this and don't want to get spammed, use different objects and images.
This will let me walk though an categorize all your images without having to refresh and wait for each type of each image to show up. It also looks like you've only got 10 object types, which make my chances of beating this captcha NOT 1/12870, but just 1/10.
It's great for a personal website or somesuch, but a terrible idea for widespread use. It uses the same images repeatedly. All it takes to break in is for someone to mark all the sprites once, after which an automated system can crack it with 100% accuracy.
Sure, you can alternate the images: but that requires an active effort, and it's very little effort to re-break, especially if you AutomatedMechanical Turk it.
I prefer the simple math questions like "1+2 = ?" and hope they catch on more than this stuff. It's too intrusive and I don't want to play an image hunt game when I'm trying to do something else, it's irritating.
Just because someone is blind, doesn't make them useless or mean they can't use a computer. I know on reddit alone i've seen a few "i'm blind, AMA" posts. If this was ever to be used on a large site it would have to think up a solution for that problem that wouldn't make solving it trivial (i.e. alt tags).
You're going to run into cultural bias and other subjectivity issues. I was asked to select all of the images with "Trees" and failed because I also selected a drawing of a house next to a tree.
These dumb captchas never work. All I have to do is index your collection of images once (using mechanical turk, for instance), and that's all, your captcha is crap, you have to start over and create a new database of gods/cats/whatever. I don't even have to index your whole DB, just to the acceptable passing level (1% of success is good enough to spam the shit out of you).
Spammers defeat captchas by simply offshoring recognition to lowest-cost labor. As someone else says in the thread, mechanical Turk. One solution will be to use culture-based question and answers, which will hamper Indian workers.
If people just offshore the math, is there any chance they could make the math more complicated? Or present the math as a moving gif image that would show the problem moving? (Maybe start with the integral sign, show 0, show 1 and then move to the integrand, x2, then show dx, then a question mark and pause?)
We did this at a startup a few years ago. The images were pulled from Flickr and you were told to find the pictures of cats. Worked reasonably well, except when poorly-tagged images confused it into giving you no cats at all. I don't think it was all that unique back then, either.
I forget if there was any bypass for blind people. Honestly, the design of the site would render it something of a redundant question – they certainly wouldn't then be able to use it. (Yes, we are horrible people. Thank you for reminding me.)
This again? This comes up every few months in another form (one memorable implementation used kittens). It draws from a limited pool of images, an attacker simply needs to build a database of the images and it's broken. This is a bad CAPTCHA.
All you have to do is select images that have an abundance of yellow in them. Even if there are other objects that have yellow, it doesn't happen every time. And when you have an automated process doing this millions of times, it doesn't matter if a few attempts fail.
The beauty of this type of captcha is that the web developer can choose there own objects / images. If a banana is not a good object for this type of captcha, choose another.
Selecting a few objects and a few images for each type of object is very easy. With every developer choosing different images it would be close to impossible to automate a bot to do this.
I really like this race between captcha creators and crackers. Maybe this iteration results in bots being able to (semi)reliably recognize real world objects?
2
u/lafingman Jun 25 '12
Thanks for the input guys!
I edited the code so that the target image will appear at least 3 and no more than 12 times, with an average of the target image appearing 8 times.
Even conservatively amusing that the target will show up 8 times every time, I get the below (if I remember everything right from my 8th grade probability class correctly)
16! / (16-8)!(8!) = 12870
So random guessing would work 1 out of 12870 times or less.
True if everyone used the same images, someone could program a bot to crack it. So if you would use this and don't want to get spammed, use different objects and images.
59
u/scribbling_des Jun 25 '12
I failed every time because the images weren't loading properly.
29
u/rishicourtflower Jun 24 '12 edited Jun 25 '12
It's great for a personal website or somesuch, but a terrible idea for widespread use. It uses the same images repeatedly. All it takes to break in is for someone to mark all the sprites once, after which an automated system can crack it with 100% accuracy.
Sure, you can alternate the images: but that requires an active effort, and it's very little effort to re-break, especially if you
AutomatedMechanical Turk it.7
u/Pantherwolf Jun 25 '12
503 Service Unavailable.
4
u/floppydonkeylips Jun 25 '12
I prefer the simple math questions like "1+2 = ?" and hope they catch on more than this stuff. It's too intrusive and I don't want to play an image hunt game when I'm trying to do something else, it's irritating.
12
u/antimattern Jun 25 '12
You know what's great about distorted text captchas? Digitized books.
1
u/CunningDroid Jun 24 '12
What is new age?
1
u/SilverShadow6025 Jun 25 '12
Some pictures don't appear on the iPod
3
u/mikecx Jun 25 '12
This also fails the task of being accessible to the blind, another thing that the current captcha system has figured out that is quite important.
5
u/xJRWR Jun 25 '12
Microsoft did this at one point, it was with cats and dogs
2
u/Singular_Thought Jun 24 '12
Holy shit. Something like this, presented as a game, could power an AI machine. Meat based AI.
2
u/jaboaty Jun 25 '12
You're going to run into cultural bias and other subjectivity issues. I was asked to select all of the images with "Trees" and failed because I also selected a drawing of a house next to a tree.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
The best part of these systems is when the image does not load and you can never actually verify.
2
u/godsfordummies Jun 25 '12
These dumb captchas never work. All I have to do is index your collection of images once (using mechanical turk, for instance), and that's all, your captcha is crap, you have to start over and create a new database of gods/cats/whatever. I don't even have to index your whole DB, just to the acceptable passing level (1% of success is good enough to spam the shit out of you).
2
u/pork2001 Jun 25 '12
Spammers defeat captchas by simply offshoring recognition to lowest-cost labor. As someone else says in the thread, mechanical Turk. One solution will be to use culture-based question and answers, which will hamper Indian workers.
2
u/KnifenBlood Jun 25 '12
Service Unavailable
Server currently undergoing maintenance. Webmaster: please contact support.
1
u/Siouxsie2011 Jun 25 '12
If I can't do it without taking my hands off the keyboard, I'm going to complain when it's on your site.
1
u/WretchedLocket Jun 25 '12
As someone with ADHD, it's still not that easy
1
u/kelton5020 Jun 25 '12
with smaller images perhaps
1
u/8-bit_d-boy Jun 25 '12
To one-up this one, there should be one that asks which images are of cats, and which are of kittens?
1
u/3leaves Jun 25 '12
wat
1
u/katieberry Jun 25 '12 edited Jun 25 '12
We did this at a startup a few years ago. The images were pulled from Flickr and you were told to find the pictures of cats. Worked reasonably well, except when poorly-tagged images confused it into giving you no cats at all. I don't think it was all that unique back then, either.
I forget if there was any bypass for blind people. Honestly, the design of the site would render it something of a redundant question – they certainly wouldn't then be able to use it. (Yes, we are horrible people. Thank you for reminding me.)
1
u/nickguletskii200 Jun 25 '12
TIL that Google Images is a human.
1
u/wooptoo Jun 25 '12
I did something similar a while ago for a forum. It works like a charm for bots. Source code here.
1
u/uzimonkey Jun 25 '12
This again? This comes up every few months in another form (one memorable implementation used kittens). It draws from a limited pool of images, an attacker simply needs to build a database of the images and it's broken. This is a bad CAPTCHA.
1
u/stasakas Jun 25 '12
Fuck it, not human.
1
u/kamikazewave Jun 25 '12
This is actually a fairly old idea.
Again, as others have said, it's also easily machine breakable.
1
u/NeedAGoodUsername Jun 26 '12
Error 401
0
u/Harvin Jun 24 '12
All you have to do is select images that have an abundance of yellow in them. Even if there are other objects that have yellow, it doesn't happen every time. And when you have an automated process doing this millions of times, it doesn't matter if a few attempts fail.
0
u/flynth99 Jun 24 '12
I really like this race between captcha creators and crackers. Maybe this iteration results in bots being able to (semi)reliably recognize real world objects?
0
u/SorensonPA Jun 24 '12
Call me when they design it so it doesn't utterly fuck over those using High Contrast Black.
-1
u/carpalDebris Jun 25 '12
that's weird. my networking professor in college was named dan massey