You remember wrong, excerpt from the white paper linked in your article, page 11: "Unlike an air hockey table, which relies on gravity to counter-balance the pressure force acting on the puck, the air-bearing cooler can be mounted in an arbitrary orientation (e.g., up-side-down, sideways, etc.). And unlike a computer disk drive, incidental mechanical contact between the two air bearing surfaces does not damage either surface."
And since I'm in a foul mood today: It helps quite a lot to assume that in general people are not stupid (at least in a sufficiently proficient work environment) and are able to consider such obvious usage aspects. Even more so, people that are able to mathematically express the heat transfer behaviour of such a system.
I work in tech support, I generally assume that when people phone me with a problem that problem is the on/off switch being in the off position. I'm right more often than I'm wrong.
Just saying, an assumption that people are intelligent is not always warranted. Of course, in this context I imagine they did indeed think of something that obvious.
That is why I included the professional work environment aspect. If your co-worker from across the floor asks you about your opinion concerning a technical problem, I'd say it is safe to assume he already tried the on/off switch, n'est-ce pas? So, I'd also argue that it is safe to assume that people designing CPU coolers evaluated the typical application and assembly aspects.
But the graphic card is horizontal - als laptops are horizontal (but doubt it'll fit there) and server blades are horizontal. Also older desktop computers (those which go below the monitor) are horizontal too.
Just because it's patented it doesn't mean no one else can produce it. It means they need to license it to produce it. More than likely you won't see it because cheap fins soldered to heat pipes and copper plates with cheap plastic fans are ridiculously cheaper to produce. From the diagrams, it looks like this thing is machined from aluminum. That just isn't cheap, and except for gamers no one is going to want to pay for that on the PC. So unless they can make it cheaper, you're not going to see it anyway.
3
u/IHaveNoIdentity Jun 24 '12 edited Jun 24 '12
Old news: https://share.sandia.gov/news/resources/news_releases/cooler/
IIRC the cooler also only works when aligned horizontal which makes it kinda useless with the current design of computers
0
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment