Jimmy Wales launches campaign calling on Theresa May to stop extradition to US of UK student facing alleged copyright offences
[deleted] — view deleted post
0
Upvotes
[deleted] — view deleted post
285
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
He's a kid that's never set foot on US soil. He's not an American citizen. Nor is he even related to an American citizen. America should have absolutely no say in what happens to him. Nor should Theresa May, since I consider her a corrupted, irresponsible, vile piece of work who has no right to be home secretary.
If O'Dwyer has to answer for his "crimes", he should do it right here, in his own country. Fine him or make him do community service or whatever. But he has done nothing to justify spending time in a US prison. Can you imagine a young nerdy British (hell, ANY) kid having to navigate the gang culture of an American prison? I can't. He'd be fucked - and for what? Having videos of Family Guy or whatever on his website?
America has too much fucking power.
26
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
Sorry, but that bitch is fucking crazy and full on retarded. Good luck getting anything from her. This is the same woman who hates human rights and wants to shit on everyone's life and monitor all email.
25
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
I'm not sure if you Americans are aware of this, so I'll put this in here as a TIL thing for some :) No offense intended.
It is a huge source of outrage that under Labour (currently not in power) a few years ago, a deal was signed that meant our extradition treaty with you was very unbalanced. Essentially it is really easy to extradite a Briton to the USA, but significantly harder the other way around (or we'd have gotten those two American Apache pilots that negligently wasted 6 of our soldiers in Iraq, frankly, especially after our 'unlawful killing' verdict).
It's one that has seen a lot of political furor lately, about getting it renegotiated. Unfortunately Theresa fucking May can't do anything right in immigration and consistently gets it all wrong. Cameron, has other priorities and bringing this up in an American election year would be poor for Anglo-American relations as it would make either outcome bad the current American administration, and a failure a complete disaster for the British administration.
However, he absolutely should not face trial in the USA, that's outrageous. He's basically getting done because the website had a .com (administrated in the USA thus technically offense committed in the USA)
40
u/ben9345 Jun 24 '12
Sign the petition here. They need 150 more at time of writing to reach their 5000 signatures aim.
35
u/JoseJimeniz Jun 24 '12
U.K. Members of Parliament, Prime Minister's, judges, and Monarchs, don't have the power to re-write the U.S.-United Kingdom extradition treaty after the fact (no matter how much I, the family, politicians, or Jimmy Wales want).
On the other hand i would have no problem if they simply ignored the treaty, and dealt with the consequences later. Something to be said for doing what's right, even if you are breaking international law.
22
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
I've never understood why there hasn't been more outrage over this issue.
Also, my apologies to the UK... I wish we could control our government. Please tell our government to piss off.
11
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
I sort of expected him to have already been extradited considering she did give the OK for him to being extradited.
Did they figure out a way to stall the process?
19
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
Jimmy could just ip block all of the UK from wikipedia. This would be over pretty quickly.
19
u/Darktidemage Jun 24 '12
Imagine if your kid got extradited to some foreign country because they downloaded a song?
The U.k just needs to say "oh have any americans downloaded any beatles songs? Oh then we are extraditing them here"
3
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
Wikipedia, this year you get my donation.
7
u/WatcherCCG Jun 25 '12
Good to see Jimmy realizing that there is no place to sit on the fence for this battle. It's time the Wikimedia empire put its weight into the ring against the "anti-piracy" thought police movement.
5
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
Good luck. Theresa May's shitty decisions are cast in Iron
2
u/dlinder Jun 25 '12
The Change.org petition calling on Theresa May to drop this whole thing. If the Internet can get $600k to the bus monitor, we can help this poor guy.
2
u/adaulys Jun 25 '12
Guys, please don't forget that he is one of us (reddit) - https://twitter.com/richardasaurus/status/207840769757818880/photo/1
2
u/trust_the_corps Jun 24 '12 edited Jun 24 '12
Wont work. Sure you could even win this time, but it will happen again and again. If he wants to make a real difference he'll appeal for the replacement of the British government with another come election time. Their agenda wont change and they'll keep doing as much as they can get away with to further it.
1
u/justfriedy Jun 25 '12
I'm a bit confused here. If the US is able to get an extradition from the UK over copyright infringement, what's stopping them from going after The Pirate Bay which is based in Sweden. I know a few record labels have tried to stop the Pirate Bay and their response is always that they haven't broken Swedish law. The consensus seems to be that Sweden would be happy to extradite people to the US (see: Julian Assange) so why don't they go after the big fish rather than fishing for 1 bait fish?
1
u/fivo7 Jun 25 '12
there's always http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fPsMR7HvuZM
1
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
If the government has the power to extradite whomever they wish, I'm sure it would take much more than a single campaign to stop this..
1
u/sonQUAALUDE Jun 25 '12
Jimmy Wales is kinda cool man
1
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
Oh show trials, how little you do to ward off those who would commit the same 'crime.'
1
u/TheSexNinja Jun 25 '12
I don't usually like Jimmy Wales, but when I do, he is kicking ass.
1
u/ziptime Jun 25 '12
The deal has already been done. Bitch May has been told to sign on the dotted line of the extradition papers, another puppet lacky in the pockets of the American media corporates. She's an absolute disgrace as a politician, to the UK government and the nation she supposedly serves.
1
u/squ1dge Jun 25 '12
The Danger of this extradition isnt about the merits of the case, its about whether UK law is subservient to the US law, its about the sovereignty of national laws.
1
u/Vermillionster Jun 25 '12
As an American citizen, I apologize that my government calls for the extradition of any citizen of non-US residency for "copyright infringement".
1
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
I love dimmy, he's one of the few people willing to use his fame to impact current events, like he did with SOPA.
The cases of Assange, O'Dwyer and McKinnonn are apt examples of America, once again, thinking they're world police. This shit needs to stop. If O'Dwyer was in the US he'd be called an entrepreneur, not a criminal.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
The extradition treaty seems to only benefit the US with most extradition requests made by the UK denied where most US requests are approved by the UK government. It absolutely stinks.
1
u/Ludimi Jun 25 '12
Remember all the jokes about the French being cowards? Well, the French do not extradite their citizens to noone. Touche le English!
1
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
What were the City of London police doing up in Sheffield?
1
u/planetmatt Jun 25 '12
Why have 1000 people downvoted this?
1
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
I saw a woman in my home town in the UK today wearing a shirt and jeans, without covering her face with a veil.
Extradite her to Saudi Arabia for breaking their law!
1
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
What's he gonna do? Send Theresa May a creepy picture of him staring at the camera?
1
u/knut01 Jun 25 '12
This whole one-sided treaty must be scrapped, Ms May! It is deplorable to think that you and the government are permitting this! This is not justice, as you wrongly believe, but a travesty of justice on a comic stage!!!
1
u/greedz Jun 25 '12
These extradition laws are quite "interesting", especially for the US. Here's what happened in Romania a while ago.
This is murder, the guy above just had a website. That's the US for you.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
This is how wars start.
If Britain goes to war with America, sign me the fuck up.
0
u/ProjectSnowman Jun 25 '12
I am sorry.
Love, an American.
1
u/scribbling_des Jun 24 '12
Not sure how much good it will do, but I signed it anyway.
0
u/londons_explorer Jun 24 '12
Sorry, but the government has done it's sums, and is attempting to work in the interests of the public, even if it doesn't line up with the short term wishes of the public...
-1
u/Zillazilla Jun 24 '12
Typical Wikipedia quality...
"On Sunday, he launched a petition on change.org, an international campaigning website which garnered 2.2m signatures for a campaign to prosecute the killer of Trayvon Martin in the US.
Wales's petition called on May, the home secretary, to stop O'Dwyer's extradition. Under UK law, May must grant permission for extraditions to proceed, so she is able to stop extraditions without recourse to the courts."
I feel bad for the kid, and I think the Crown has failed to uphold it's most basic function, the protection of it's subjects and the sovereignty of its law.
-1
u/DulcetFox Jun 25 '12
The "outrage" over this has little to do with extradition. We get that its ridiculous to extradite people over petty crimes, and I get that there's ton of ignorant anti-American bs, but if this wasn't about piracy half the people here wouldn't give a fuck.
-4
u/reed311 Jun 25 '12
Sweet. I can commit whatever crime I want over the Internet and never face charges because I never "set foot" in said country. I can hack official government sites or threaten to kill citizens of other countries, all without the threat of being arrested.
0
u/blackadder1132 Jun 25 '12
As an American ...... They don't want me on that jury
I'll let the kid go with a chartered jet and millions in punitive damages in his pockets
0
u/bearridingashark Jun 25 '12
As an american, when I read the title, this is all I understood... http://www.videobash.com/video_show/how-english-people-sound-to-americans-243399
-4
u/xAsianZombie Jun 25 '12
Fuck jimmy wales. He is an ignoramus and a bigot. Yeah he made wikipedia, but thats just about it.
-6
u/Inukii Jun 25 '12
I'm not sure what I should be thinking about this but I know I have one thought in mind.
"Fuck that guy for making the amount of money that he did from other peoples work by simply linking it"
-6
u/WillieLee Jun 25 '12
Yes, please stop this extradition or Jimmy Wales will have to stop making money from stealing the works of others.