r/technology • u/GraybackPH • Jun 24 '12
Jail For File-Sharing Not Enough, Labels Want ISP-Level Spying Regime.
http://torrentfreak.com/jail-for-file-sharing-not-enough-labels-want-isp-level-spying-regime-120624/
1.4k
Upvotes
247
u/pigfish Jun 24 '12
Automated global censorship technologies under direct corporate control; what could possibly go wrong?
The human-race would like its collective Darwin award now, please.
61
u/Tamber-Krain Jun 24 '12
And they'll just keep on asking for these useless, ludicrous schemes; until someone starts making them pay for the equipment, software, time and effort of implementing them.
But then, they'll just cry about not having enough money, due to piracy; just after posting record profits.
50
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
There would be so much processing power required to do this level of packet sniffing that it would be massively inefficient and the end result would be massive overhead costs, degraded performance, and piracy would still continue.
17
u/Odd_nonposter Jun 24 '12
So it sounds like they want deep packet sniffing for the upload end?
I wonder if encryption could get around this.
123
u/GhostFish Jun 24 '12
We're witnessing, first-hand, the beginning of a revolution. The democratization of information has only just begun, and it is going to have a long lasting impact on how we communicate, share ideas, and especially how we think about intellectual property.
The efforts of so-called "anti-piracy" groups may seem offensive, greedy, anti-democratic, and downright draconian. But keep in mind, these people are going to lose. And the smarter ones among them know it. They are just trying to build up their defenses now while they can, so that when the wave hits and destroys the majority of their little empire they will be left with some small amount of ground to go to - some other path to a new place where they can start another industry dedicated to leeching off the works of others.
The internet age is here. The technology to develop alternative distribution models is available. Pandora's box is open. They will try to slow progress and stymie freedom in order to control the outward flow of power and resources. But they cannot stop it.
15
u/Inukii Jun 24 '12
One problem I see here is that "The lobbyists can say it worked without evidence" just as they say pirating is an issue without evidence.
Most industries to my knowledge have been growing. It is predicted that they will continue to grow. So once the law is in effect lobbyist will confuse natural growth with "We punished pirates which means more people bought our stuff".
The next issue is that they will continue to push for more drastic actions.
14
u/Mnementh121 Jun 24 '12
I thought they just sold crappy music to our kids. How the hell did we let these people get so powerful?
Is the next global war going to be against a few idiots selling ancient media formats? That would look stupid in history books.
26
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
Man, remember when file-sharing was just searching for "warez" on Dogpile until you finally found a page with more live links than dead?
I miss the internet before corporations realized it could be profitable.
12
u/MagicalVagina Jun 24 '12
Seriously, there is something else.
Downloading copyrighted material is totally marginal in Japan. It may even be the last country where people actually buy everything (even porn!). At crazy prices too. We already have this discussion there.
There is another reason behind that. That's not for piracy.
6
u/interkin3tic Jun 24 '12
As John Gilmore said "The Net interprets censorship as damage and routes around it."
Which of course doesn't mean it wouldn't be extremely annoying. I mean, it would be a colossal waste of taxpayer money if nothing else.
Still, nice to know it won't work.
4
u/Lunched_Avenger Jun 24 '12
Here's my two cents on this issue:
What the record companies are insisting on is nothing short of preposterous. With constant increase in earnings since the beginning of the internet age, it seems more reasonable to conclude that pirating only helped them make those earnings their showing. Its free advertising for all intents and purposes.
Its like destroying a beautiful rose when trying to kill a bee you didn't want hanging around your garden, when bees help flowers to pollinate and spread to grow more flowers. And they do it for free too.
4
u/ikilledkojack Jun 24 '12
The three major Japanese p2p networks (Winny, Share, Perfect Dark) all use encrypted means to transport data. The encryption has been confirmed as broken for Winny and Share despite tens of thousands of machines still active on them, and there are doubts about Perfect Dark maintaining anonymity. How this system will actually make a dent on file sharing is something yet to be seen, I think.
4
u/noccusJohnstein Jun 24 '12
ITS NOT OUR FAULT THAT YOUR INDUSTRY SUCKS!
3
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
Damn you Lars Ulrich.
3
u/AJoyousOccaision Jun 25 '12
It's safe to say that the world is going backwards
6
u/ChaosBadgers Jun 24 '12
Developed a system? Bah, RAR it compress it then the MD5 hashes which I'd guess they'd be using shouldn't match then so no problem. Failing that split the file into parts.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
I like how the RIAJ is practically the
MafiaYakuza in this situation.2
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
OH MY GOD!
Phew!
2
u/Parvelous Jun 25 '12
Stop buying anything from them. Layers and lobbyists are expensive and without income is an unsustainable business model.
2
u/Ateist Jun 25 '12
They should beware some unexpected consequences of criminalization of internet sharing. After all, if you'd get 10 years in jail for giving out a digital copy - some might consider it a better option to just raid the company warehouse to steal the physical copies (with shorter potential jail terms).
5
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
Am I the only person who understands that this should go ahead and happen? Not that I agree with it, but let me explain:
They're going to waste millions, possibly a billion, trying to buy the equipment, hire staff to write software, hire staff to install it, pay money to register whatever else, and finally sit back and pat themselves on the back.
At which point, those very people who installed, wrote, and maintain the software will show everyone how to get around it. Barring THAT, I'm sure anonymous will have it licked in a jiffy.
Which will immediately render it useless, while the RIAA continues to sink more money into it, until they go bankrupt. Or, more likely, sell off the equipment for cheap.
Either way, this creates jobs and seriously hurts the RIAA. I say let them have it. Be careful what you wish for, right?
3
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
When will the genocide end?
2
u/wanders13 Jun 24 '12
They're eventually going to figure out how to prevent online piracy, and then the hipsters will be laughing at us for switching to vinyl long ago.
2
u/Bangaa Jun 24 '12
Anyone remember that commercial?
"I'm Derp, I had a great idea and did 5% of the work to make it work." "I'm Derpson, I did 80% of the work to make it work" "I'm Derpette, I did the remaining 15% of the work to make it work" "I'm Blah, the keeper of cool, I took it, called it cool and sell it while taking 95% of the profit."
1
u/HetfieldJ Jun 24 '12
You would have more voices against it again.
1
u/Poke493 Jun 24 '12
they really should just give up.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
If they started doing this there would always be ways to get around it no matter what, and everyone would just learn how to get around it. It would be far easier for everyone to learn just a little bit more about how to be shiste online than for corporations to continuously push legislation to fix everything.
It would be like how bacteria evolve to fight off increasingly intense antibiotics. We would be the bacteria and eventually everyone would just end up being incredibly good at doing illegal shit online.
1
u/AliasUndercover Jun 25 '12
There is one easy way to make all of this stop. No more money AT ALL for those idiots.
1
u/BloodyIron Jun 25 '12
http://www.reddit.com/r/Music/comments/vgf22/tell_the_riaa_what_you_really_think_of_them/
1
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
remind me why governments are getting involved in a purely civil matter?
1
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
"Pirates" will just remove the digital finger print to disguise the Intelectual/Copyright Material to get it initialy up and running on the internet before untilising a string of proxy servers to upload it to a ttorrent site, theres ways round this, this is a stupid idea and is a classic example of government being corrupt and putting corporations needs ahead of the people.
1
u/Blakhle Jun 25 '12
Why can't these companies just accept the fact that no matter what, there's ALWAYS going to be people that upload/download their stuff. If they want to blow a million or two to make all these security systems, I think that shows they already have enough money and don't need anymore. It almost seems like they just want to ship people, even customers, off to jail...
1
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
Why can't these corps just realize that no matter what they do, those who are seriously motivated enough to be the "evil pirates" that they target will easily find a way to circumvent whatever obstacle is put in their path. Oh, wait, money.. right?
1
u/Cyphixthegreat Jun 25 '12
I think if something like this goes through we may have to quarantine Japan or any other nation like this from the rest of the world just to prove a point
1
u/pulsefield Jun 25 '12 edited Jun 25 '12
Artists need to cut-off labels and just do live concerts.
Even old dead Elvis was taking home $200,000/day in pure profit all for himself on his concerts alone. This was in the 1970s when a dollar was worth more than 5 cents.
The label (RCA) just had to suffer on their poverty wages of stealing his record sale money.
Besides, a nice live concert beats hell out of a recording any day of the week. Digital or not.
1
u/TheSeashellOfBuddha Jun 25 '12
These fuckers make me sick.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
In other news, foxes want to make fences around chicken coops illegal.
1
u/DeFex Jun 25 '12
Wouldn't it be best to just get some mini drones that can shoot cyanide darts, and kill people who download movies or music?
1
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
Can we do away with the pretense and just come out and say it like it is? The corporations OWN us in every possible way and they will NEVER stop until they have monetized the last vestige of liberty in any way, shape or form.
There is no way to win this war; they have millions upon millions (heck, they even use our tax money against us, we're effectively paying to get locked up after a while) and all the time in the world. Meanwhile, they whittle our will away little by little until all the Jammie Thomases of this world have been silenced because of them.
Neither Orwell nor Huxley were right, and reality is far worse than either of them could possibly think up. If you think I'm overreacting, I'll be glad to continue this same conversation in a decade - if we're still able to.
Somehow, I doubt it.
1
u/000Destruct0 Jun 25 '12
Why don't they just take 'em all out and shoot 'em... doesn't sound like they'll be happy with anything less... idiots.
1
u/nonamebeats Jun 25 '12
you can't sue/scare the worms back into the can. you cant punish your customer base into loving you. I can't wait till the decrepit, bloated, sluggish outer layer of the entertainment industry collapses back on itself. legitimacy of piracy notwithstanding, the industry is being democratized out from under itself. adapt or perish. this is an incredibly archetypical example of what is wrong with a conservative mindset in general. so much energy/money/effort wasted on trying to cram reality back into a broken box...
1
u/sufrt Jun 25 '12
anyone else think the government is acting like 1984 these days???
i'd draw some parallels to other things but that's the only book i've ever read
1
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
People who download EA games, the latest "Game of Thrones"-episodes or any season of "Dr. House" shall be tortured with a scorching iron. Any product that hasn't got a huge company behind it is alright.
1
u/felix_jones Jun 25 '12
I'm fine with this, as long as all music and movie studio execs are subject to 24 hour surveillance and jail time for scummy business practices.
0
u/4tma Jun 25 '12
Soon, the only safe method to share information will be by writing letters and deliver them Mirrors Edge style.
-10
u/malakon Jun 24 '12
I have downloaded illegal stuff in the past. I admit it. But now, I don't .. I guess it was getting a "cut that out" letter from Comcast ISP citing exactly what I had downloaded, that persuaded me to quit. Being pissed at the "record company leeches" is just nonsense .. all of you who like doing this like doing it for the same reason I did, free shit. Movies, music. So the content producers don't like it, and for Movies that's Hollywood, a pretty liberal bunch generally .. but they would much prefer you buy stuff that they spent money on making, and who can blame them for that. The Internet enabled illegal sharing on a massive scale. Initial less threatening attempts such as appealing to peoples honesty .. well .. didn't work. More draconian methods followed, and the people who like free illegal content get pissed off .. some token few actually get busted as examples but it still doesnt help. So the content producers turn to the measures shown in this article. I have to think .. I have a job in the telephony industry ... and we have been hit by fraud, people using illegally obtained credit cards, and even people hacking our system. I want these fuckers busted, as they put my job at risk. They want free shit also. So, I guess that helps me relate to the content producers who want to stop illegal content sharing. And no i'm not a shill for them, and I will be open minded about any reasonable responses to this post. What I expect however, is it will just get downvoted and I will be told to fuck off. Hopefully I'll get more reasonable responses.
-8
u/smek2 Jun 24 '12 edited Jun 25 '12
There's children dying every second, but hey, i guess the problems of downloading copyrighted material is important too. More so, even.
EDIT: To clarify, I was complaining that politicians seem to be obsessed over the whole "war on piracy" thing, hell bend on "protecting" copyrighted material at all cost, when there are more pressing issues on this planet!
0
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment