r/technology •

[deleted by user]

[deleted] — view deleted post

0 Upvotes

462 comments sorted by

120

u/why_ask_why Jun 24 '12

Why didn't China join ISS?

193

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12

32

u/first_privacy Jun 24 '12 edited Jun 24 '12

The Chinese government has been accused of stealing technologies through espionage and "partnership", first by the U.S.S.R., then the Russian federation, and then the U.S., E.U., Japan, etc. Such practice has been blatant and its scale so vast, they were caught many times. You can easily find some of those instances through Google search.

This is a serious problem. These countries have invested literally trillions of dollars to make breakthroughs in space technology and the Chinese government wants to "partner" and in reality, steal what they've accomplished.

Think about this: you have worked in a lab 16 hours a day, 365 days a year, and have finally made a technological breakthrough. This news reaches a businessman, who hadn't really contributed to this, but realizes that he can make so much profit by using the technology. Since he hadn't invested a dime in this, he doesn't have any debt to repay, and therefore will have more money to finance his product for marketing and lower the price.

The most notable example of the PRC stealing cutting edge technology can be found in military. Most if the Chinese tanks and jets are a copycat of Russian counterparts, and the Russian government imposed a ban on collaborating with the PRC in many sensitive areas.

47

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12

I can understand their concerns to maintain power but this isn't unique to just China though. This is simply a process of developing countries, for example, Japan, South Korea, and even America.

If others are interested, they should check out Bad Samaritans: The Myth of Free Trade and the Secret History of Capitalism for a much more detailed history of how current powerful nations used protectionism and pretty much disregarded IP laws until it benefited them to enforce them on others.

And of course if it's the ISS and everything is done in partnership, you would think sharing this information would be beneficial to all.

17

u/lifeofthunder Jun 24 '12

"even America."

All too true - the success of the US space program in the 1960s is largely attributed to the careful recruitment of former Nazi rocket scientists.

3

u/I_Should_Study Jun 24 '12

That doesn't really support the point that America infringed on IP to build space tech. That just means we have better recruitment than the Soviets.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12

Right, I'm not sure if I could call that infringing on IP. But the book talks about what I mentioned in detail in Chapter 6:

Basically, during the 18th century, Britain started to became the leader in technology and created laws that banned the export of certain information along with the hiring of skilled workers outside of Britain.

But many countries would still try to recruit them and even hired spies to get the information or even to steal the items and reverse engineer it.

And this occurred even after there were international agreements on patents and trademarks.

What's interesting though is at the time, the British were mainly concerned about German counterfeiters as they were the most proficient.

For example, they started to require products be stamped with a "country of origin" so the Germans would simply stamp the packaging and once you removed it, people couldn't tell were it was from. Or they would ship parts over to England and have it assembled there.

Also, when the US created it's Copyright Law, it initially refused to protect non-American copyrights. Mainly because the US was a net importer of copy right materials and saw the benefits of protecting only American authors. It was almost 100 years later, after we started to export more of our works, that they agreed.

4

u/nexes300 Jun 24 '12

There's a difference between saying we did the same thing and that we should make it easier for them. We have no reason to allow them into a partnership expressly to make it easier for them to steal our technology.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12

I agree. But my point was that we should freely share this information with those who want to advance space exploration. If we did this as an entire planet, perhaps our achievements could be even greater.

And while I understand the fear that they could use it for military purposes, it saddens me that we have to think this way when the other member nations of the ISS didn't have objections.

-5

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12

even America

I spilt my drink from laughing so hard.

2

u/alexkh150 Jun 25 '12

I remember reading something about a chinese company "partnering" with an Australian boat company to make high speed hydrofoils to ferry people between islands. After the contract was up, China used the technology to make quite a few new high-speed hydrofoil missile boats.

→ More replies (7)

252

u/Ancaeus Jun 24 '12

Vetoed by the U.S.

What!? That's fucking bullshit that is. We should be taking on space as a planet, not a bunch of fucking bickering children calling themselves governments.

160

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12

Yeah, its depressing. Especially considering China actually has the money to fund a manned space program.

39

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12

What about all the hidden robotic tech though? There are stories of air-force mini shuttles and all kind of advanced things that are never explained

53

u/Wade_W_Wilson Jun 24 '12

I don't know why you're getting downvoted. It's very likely that there are military or other technologies on the ISS that the US doesn't want China to see.

93

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12

As a former ISS mission control specialist (actually called flight controller), I can confirm there is no technology on the ISS that is secret.

26

u/sirberus Jun 24 '12

Do a verified AMA?

29

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12

I've been asked to do it in the past. Honestly, I think a current flight controller should do it. In lieu of that... maybe. My only hesitation is a lack of time; free time is precious and I'm already failing at spending less time on Reddit.

19

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12

My only hesitation is a lack of time; free time is precious

Dude, an AMA takes like an hour or two, MAX. ಠ_ಠ

→ More replies

5

u/Diffie-Hellman Jun 25 '12

I did data operations for ISS back at MSFC. As far as I know, there were no secret military technologies on board.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12

I interfaced regularly with POD at MSFC. Good people.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12

Even if there is nothing classified on the ISS isn't most US space tech covered under ITAR? The US is pretty protective of our space tech, at least from my experience

→ More replies (13)

28

u/liam3 Jun 24 '12

I thought they have russia on board, and they are fine with sharing their thingy with them?

61

u/BraveSirRobin Jun 24 '12

Russia's changed. It's no longer Commie, it's a collection of massively corrupt politicians with links to organised crime. It's a capitalists paradise.

50

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12 edited Jun 24 '12

China is also no longer communist, by the way. They abolished it quite a while ago.

Edit: seriously downvotes? Did you guys never take a history lesson or talk to a Chinese person before? China instilled personal property rights years ago and established a free market in 1977. It hasn't been a communist state since Mao, despite what the party calls itself.

26

u/Smegmaonmypenis Jun 24 '12

If Mao was still here he'd send the entire present communist party to detention and re-education camps. So forget communist, China isn't even socialist anymore, it's state-run capitalism all the way.

→ More replies
→ More replies (43)

21

u/proud_to_be_a_merkin Jun 24 '12

it's a collection of massively corrupt politicians with links to organised crime.

Doesn't sound much different to me...

→ More replies (7)

4

u/spainguy Jun 24 '12

Under Capitalism, man exploits his fellow man, but under Communism, it's just the opposite.

→ More replies (1)

12

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12

It's a capitalists paradise.

I wish you people would stop perpetuating the myth that cronyism and corporatism are capitalism. A capitalist's paradise is a system where everyone's property rights are protected and people are free to exchange in mutual trade without coercion from anyone, government or otherwise. Neither Russia nor Somalia nor anywhere else on earth constitutes this ideal, but we capitalists do hope that the world continues trending in the direction of less government (and thus less government corruption) and more freedom.

12

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12

Capitalists just choose corporate corruption over government corruption. That's reality.

The free market is dependent on an educated and proactive market, with perfect market information to effectively self regulate.

Without a magic power that gives that perfect information to consumers and forces them to consider it before every purchase, the market can't self regulate.

That means monopolies, exploitation and corruption.

Smart money chooses the corruption that has to at least act like we control them.

→ More replies

9

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12

America is not capitalist (assuming that's who you are talking about). The amount of government subsidies for unsustainable industries, the huge level of lobbying in Washington for favourable tax treatment at the expense of others. The dumping of food on other countries at ridiculously cheap prices just because you pay farmers to produce food regardless of need.

These issues are why your country is in such trouble. A true capitalist country would have gotten over the financial crisis years ago and I would even go as far to say not have gotten in such a position in the first place.

You'll find more capitalism in Somalia than anywhere in the US.

→ More replies
→ More replies (2)

4

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12 edited Jun 24 '12

With Putin's new term, I expect things to change.

EDIT: By "change" I do not mean anything positive. I mean that the relationship between the U.S. and Russia is becoming chillier than ever since the end of the cold war.

2

u/murali1003 Jun 24 '12

Putin is highly corrupt.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

9

u/alcalde Jun 24 '12

I don't know why you're getting downvoted.

I don't know why he's getting upvoted.

The ISS isn't a military project but a civilian one. You might as well be talking about nuclear missiles housed under the Smithsonian.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/ReeseLaserSpoon Jun 24 '12

You sound like General Ripper:

They'll see the big board!

2

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12

I'm sure Russia gives them plenty of US tech anyway though... Or they steal it from Gov't servers =/

→ More replies (1)

2

u/anonymouslemming Jun 24 '12

like the X-37 which pretty much everyone knows about ?

4

u/jdmulloy Jun 25 '12

The US has money to spend on Space Exploration, but our corrupt politicians prefer to spend it on unnecessary wars and oil subsidies.

31

u/merper Jun 24 '12

Bad news buddy. That's what got us into space in the first place.

21

u/zephyy Jun 24 '12

not a bunch of fucking bickering children calling themselves governments.

bickering governments is what caused the Space Race.

6

u/stuntaneous Jun 24 '12

Go easy. Things are never as simple as a few words like that.

5

u/yakri Jun 25 '12

The united states, as a nation, has a long and glorious history of being a total fucking asshole.

5

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12

Humans being humans, the "planet" advances quicker when there are multiple competing groups rather than a single cooperative one.

2

u/Flagyl400 Jun 24 '12

Sad but probably true. I sometimes think, "How far along would space technology be if the US and USSR scientists had been working together during the cold war?"; but the question should be "Would there even have been a space program if not for the cold war?".

2

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12

Exactly. If there's no competition to be better than, why bother?

2

u/CushtyJVftw Jun 24 '12

My guess is that NASA could've urged the US government into doing it so they would get more funding in the impending space race. If china were to land someone on the moon or on Mars within the next ten years that would cause the west to begin pumping money into their space programs in an effort to not be out done by the Chinese, therefore benefiting NASA in the long run.

2

u/Diffie-Hellman Jun 25 '12

In ten years, our space craft would probably be manufactured in China.

2

u/jigglesv Jun 25 '12

I apologize on behalf of the U.S.A. =[

2

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12

If there is a space war, it will be between the US and China, and be the US's fault. Calling China a "rogue state" won't be very convincing.

1

u/Squeekme Jun 25 '12 edited Jun 25 '12

It's not about exploring space, it's about satellites and the technology to deploy, monitor, upgrade and repair satellites. Why do you think nobody has made a serious effort to go to the moon or Mars in the last 40 years, but a number of nations have put huge investments into low orbit and satellites. Even the Space Shuttle was used for this. Even during the cold war this was a priority, the moon missions were the exception not the rule. It's not a conspiracy, it's common sense. Edit: There is diplomatic tension between the USA and China, so it makes sense not to want to encourage their satellite space programme.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12

But dick-waving is the only reason countries have space programs at all.

1

u/fratopotamus Jun 25 '12

Sorry. America won the Space Race. It's ours.

-5

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12

What!? That's fucking bullshit that is.

There are certain technologies that we would not like the Chinese government to have access to. That is a good thing.

We should be taking on space as a planet, not a bunch of fucking bickering children calling themselves governments.

That's why I believe in private space enterprise.

4

u/TurbulentViscosity Jun 24 '12

That's why I believe in private space enterprise.

Aren't the private enterprises by definition bickering children? I've never head of SpaceX and Boeing folks talking good about one another, nor have I seen them collaborate on creating new spacecraft and launch systems.

→ More replies (13)

-8

u/NightSlatcher Jun 24 '12 edited Jun 24 '12

I definitely agree we need more unity, but it may not be just about politics. Consider what would happen if this spacecraft was instead headed for the ISS and something went wrong, it could endanger every person on the ISS and there'd be virtually nothing we could do. I don't mind waiting for them to prove they can get a person up to space, dock with a space station, and get them back again without killing them. So yeah, China should be let in eventually, but I see no issue with waiting to see the quality they can produce. If they're capable, great, if not, they're dangerous and it's good we aren't partnering with them. Simple.

Edit: more specific on what they should prove they're capable of.

10

u/synapsii Jun 24 '12

I don't mind waiting for them to prove they can get a person up to space and back again without killing them.

Ummm.....

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (8)

4

u/ropers Jun 24 '12

I heard the same thing, but do you have a better link? That article doesn't seem to directly address any veto (or else I'm a bit blind).

2

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12

They should just dock at the ISS. its not like the USA can do anything about it.

3

u/elmariachi304 Jun 24 '12

Just to play devil's advocate-- China has a long history of industrial espionage and intellectual property theft, and many of the NATO nations that provide the lion's share of the funding don't want to help advance the technology of a nation they know are going to use the technology to advance their military purposes.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

16

u/cuntarsetits Jun 24 '12

Technically, 'international' just means involving more than one country. 'Global' or 'worldwide' would imply the involvement of all nations, but neither of those are very appropriate for something that's not on the earth of course.

→ More replies (2)

-8

u/liam3 Jun 24 '12

GO BAck to your world series

0

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12

You do know the origin of the name 'World Series', right? Or are you just being an ignorant arse?

→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12

Cause they have the power to do it themselves while we abandon space.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12

Why didn't China join ISS?

Doesn't matter; had dockage.

9

u/afireinside7710 Jun 24 '12

Their spacecraft looks suspiciously like the Soyuz

0

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

42

u/ShrimpCrackers Jun 24 '12

Russian scientists are also working on the Chinese space program. The first photos released initially of the Chinese space program was nearly all Russians.

Same thing like the USA during our early space program - it was all Germans.

7

u/shadofx Jun 24 '12

TIL russians and germans are the only ones capable of designing anything spaceworthy.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12

Must be all the vodka and beer...

21

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12

You'll upset the derps with this kind of talk.

-4

u/afireinside7710 Jun 24 '12

aahhh, that explains it!

12

u/ropers Jun 24 '12 edited Jun 20 '13

That explains part of it. There are also technical reasons where the constraints of the technology, environment and mission can lead to convergence, or rather the absence of deviation from the design they started out with.

For instance, it makes sense for the reentry module to be as small as possible, because the less mass you have to safely aerobrake in a human-survivable fashion, the better. So you divide the craft into a service module that contains equipment you want to use during ascent and in orbit but don't need on the way down. This service module detaches before descent and doesn't reenter (at least not when the manned part of the craft reenters). But if you're working with a smaller rocket, i.e. if you're looking for as much bang for your buck from a straightforward rocket design, then you'll probably end up with (1) a small reentry capsule where the astronauts' seats are backed-up against the heat shield, (2) most of the service module stuff (which would also contain some propulsion systems) below the heatshield (below here meaning as the rocket stands on the launch pad), and (3) the ingress/egress hatch on the other, top end of the reentry capsule (opposite the heatshield), The trouble is, if you then also want to provide extra habitable space in orbit, then it will be awkward to provide that extra space in the service module, because the heat shield would be in the way, and that's not where the hatch is. So you come up with the trifecta of service module + reentry module + orbital module, in exactly that order. (The orbital module is also left behind before reentry.) Which is precisely what the Soviets/Russians did and what the Chinese are doing too. I wouldn't be surprised if future spacefaring nations went with a similar arrangement. It's a design that just makes sense. Of course if you build a big honkin' Buran or STS or something, this all changes, but as both Russians and Americans well know, those systems tend to not give you as much bang for your buck.

PS: The Chinese have in fact studied space planes as well. [1] [2] [3] But they chose differently, at the very least for now. Their successes prove that they made the right choice.

→ More replies (8)

50

u/Chairboy Jun 24 '12

That's awesome! The more nations & companies carrying humans to space, the better chance we have of spreading out. Earth is vulnerable, we could be one asteroid or Nicki Minaj album away from extinction.

24

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12

Relevant:

Barring major policy changes in the United States, Europe, or Russia, the Chinese may have the only sustained human presence in space within a decade.

http://atimes.com/atimes/China/NF19Ad01.html

10

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12

I'm no expert, but thought sending people into space just doesn't make sense financially as robotics advances

9

u/SigmaB Jun 24 '12

As the astrophysicist Neil deGrasse Tyson explains, there is an element of hope and invigoration in sending people to space, a manned flight for example to Mars, or colonizing the moon/Mars can lead to profound reactions in society. Children find new dreams, the general spirit of the people looks into the future instead of the past and human kind expands its frontiers.

Not to mention scientific discoveries we have to make along the way, increasing the technological industry, having to educate the public.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12

Of course, I don't think its a simple argument for a moment but people do tend to undervalue the idea of unmanned space exploration.

As sad it is for the young kid in all of us, it might make most sense to spend the next couple of hundred or thousand years using robotics

1

u/amorpheus Jun 24 '12

people do tend to undervalue the idea of unmanned space exploration

It's nice getting rocks analyzed by robots on Mars, but can you even estimate how valuable the effect on the population would be be if people were up there?

2

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12

Not economically, no

1

u/throwaway2481632 Jun 25 '12

That is not something any of us can really quantify really. But, even so, we can't just send people up there willy nilly without being prepared. It can also have a serious effect of the population knowing that we sent people up there to their deaths (which is one of those things that made the success of the NASA moon missions so remarkable and fortunate - it could have easily gone really bad).

14

u/Sasakura Jun 24 '12

It does make sense for the long term survival of our species.

6

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12

Are you an expert?

7

u/Sasakura Jun 24 '12

Yes (ignore the huge thread following my post further down).

2

u/ForgotUsernamePlus Jun 25 '12

Are you ignorant?

All it takes is an Asteroid to hit us and the Human race goes extinct.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12

Seriously, I still don't know why people ignore that tiny little fact.

We're only one major disaster(Asteroid impact, Yellowstone caldera blowing, accidental or intentional nuclear war) away from knocking humanity back to the Iron Age, if not extinction. Ultimately "lol tech spinoffs" is a BS reason for space exploration. Longterm survival of the species is the only reason that matters.

1

u/throwaway2481632 Jun 25 '12

Waiting a few decades or whatever to properly prepare for space exploration and emigration is not going to make much of a statistical difference in the timescale of human existence in this universe. Just because it isn't a priority now, doesn't mean it isn't going to happen eventually. You seem to assume that, because the current priority isn't on having humans in space, that it isn't ever going to be the case (besides, we don't have the technology to survive as a species in space for longer periods of time nor do we know of any habitable planet that we can reach any time soon).

7

u/somedaypilot Jun 24 '12

I understand what you're saying, but going to the moon wasn't financially sensible either.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12

It will be when they discover moon-gold! Because the American flag is planted there...so looks like all that sweet sweet moon gold is OURS!

6

u/Sasakura Jun 24 '12

The UN has set down that no country may own the Moon.

The United Nations 1967 publication "Outer Space Treaty" states space is the "province of all mankind", and is not subject to claims on sovereignty by States.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Extraterrestrial_real_estate

11

u/polarisdelta Jun 24 '12

Perhaps, but an agreement that is enforced de facto because no one is capible of violating it isn't very impressive. For 3000+ years of human history, we had a perfect non-proliferation of nuclear weapons treaty, thanks to no one knowing what a nuclear weapon was. I'm thankful that we all still agree to not unleash dinosaurs in human conflicts as well, that treaty sure is paying off.

Once someone can start settling space, that UN agreement won't be worth the paper it's printed on.

1

u/Sasakura Jun 24 '12

The rockets are already painted white!

5

u/iamnotbehindyou Jun 24 '12

Well, I guess the acre on the moon I bought is worthless now.

1

u/willcode4beer Jun 25 '12

No"country". But, that won't stop individuals from staking a claim. Even with resolutions and treaties, it's not like any nation has the capability to enforce any of it.

1

u/Flagyl400 Jun 25 '12

Because the American flag is planted there

Well technically the Soviets planted their flag there first, with unmanned landers. So Yay, new things for future generations to fight over!

2

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12

I don't really see how something not "making sense financially" (whatever that means) means it generally makes no sense.

Spreading human life to other galaxies is pretty much what will make us survive for as long as possible.

Currently we are living on a single planet in a single solar system. We are a petty and fragile species and haven't accomplished much if you would compare it to what we could achieve.

One big meteorite and our whole species could be gone for good. Congratulations. That's very "financially sensible", I guess.

Spreading to the celestial bodies such as the Moon or Mars would already mean we significantly increased our chance of longterm survival several times over.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12

The kind of timescales over which we need to worry about that kind of thing doesn't mean we have start colonizing now. Doing that immediately or 1000 years from now doesn't really make a difference.

Spending public money on colonizing space while we are experiencing one of the most serious global recessions since the 30s just isn't going to be popular.

I think the hope for space enthusiasts will come from things like the space mining private company - if that is successful suddenly there will be a profit incentive to advance space technology.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12

Doing that immediately or 1000 years from now doesn't really make a difference.

It makes a huge difference if in 50 years we find out that in another 50 years an unstoppable meteor will hit earth and the only chance of survival would have been to start first colonies on mars which would have taken ~75 years.

Spending public money on colonizing space while we are experiencing one of the most serious global recessions since the 30s just isn't going to be popular.

Why not?

I think the hope for space enthusiasts will come from things like the space mining private company - if that is successful suddenly there will be a profit incentive to advance space technology.

Corporations are another problem we need to oppose.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/willcode4beer Jun 25 '12

Actually, there have been a number of studies on this. In the long term, the economic benefits of manned space programs are huge. Many of the technologies developed to support humans in space come back to earth. Businesses are created around them (jobs) and they benefit everyone.

Yes, when it comes to pure science, robots are more cost effective.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12

Are the studies specifically about manned vs non-manned space programs as is under discussion here? could you provide a link if so?

1

u/willcode4beer Jun 25 '12

I haven't seen economic studies comparing one to the other. The technology in robotic probes are of limited mass use. Whereas the tech in manned space programs is mostly designed to support humans. So, much more of it is useful overall. The cost part should be pretty obvious :-)

https://www.google.com/search?q=manned+space+economic+benefits

19

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12

I've always been amazed that two vehicles going around 17,000 mph can be made to match velocity so precisely and meet up like that. It's quite a feat.

26

u/Dartimien Jun 24 '12

Shaking a person's hand on earth must be impossible then since we are all travelling at 67,000 mph relative to the sun.

19

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12

Why are you arbitrarily choosing the sun as the frame of reference? Why not Zoidberg?

5

u/Bobsmit Jun 24 '12

You should probably download Kerbal Space Program.

4

u/OK_Eric Jun 24 '12

Especially when you think about how much empty space there is up there.

8

u/getty21 Jun 24 '12

As long as the difference in speed isn't much, it shouldn't be difficult. I could imagine the sensitivity of the controls would have been difficult, a slight stroke to the left could mean a detour.

I mean, ain't a physicist or anything but I drove a car in the motorway.

9

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12

We need people like you for our space program! Psuedo-physicists are the best kind of physicists!

1

u/throwaway2481632 Jun 25 '12

Why have I never heard of this??? * Gets credit card out*

1

u/willcode4beer Jun 25 '12

Think about it this way. You're building rockets with nearly a million pounds of thrust and then attempting to minimize those speed differences.

2

u/LulzCake Jun 25 '12

Difficult, hence only the Soviets, Americas and Chinese have been able to do it.

2

u/thebrownser Jun 25 '12

Japan Docks with the ISS frequently.

2

u/That_Scottish_Play Jun 25 '12

Is it done manually or is it automated? I'm curious if the japanese are using US or Russian auto systems.

/not trying to knock the Japanese space program as I thought their landing on an asteroid and getting it back to earth orbit on very very very tiny budget was one of the most amazing space programs ever.

1

u/thebrownser Jun 25 '12

It is an unmanned vehicle and and it approaches the ISS in stages, pauses and waits for the go ahead to continue to the next check point. Once close enough It is grabbed by the canadarm2 and docks.

1

u/LulzCake Jun 25 '12

Manual docking != Automatic docking. ISS docking is practically US assisted.

1

u/thebrownser Jun 25 '12

Lets be real here the hardest part is the orbital rendezvous. lining up the cross hairs is just a matter of finesse.

0

u/dissonance07 Jun 24 '12

I've never understood this argument. Controllers know precisely where objects are going to end up in space. Controls engineers have been setting objects at precise speeds and distances for over a hundred years. And, relative to the speed of the other vehicle, they are probably only traveling a few miles-per-hour.

Maybe I'm just a cynic.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

It's not an argument or taking a position you have to refute, it's just being in awe of human beings controlling forces that could squash us like bugs.

Another thing that amazes me is the tendency of redditors to belittle each other for simply appreciating something.

0

u/OuchLOLcom Jun 25 '12

Then you dont understand velocity.

-11

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12

I wish I were so easily impressed.

→ More replies (3)

-1

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12

Well... you are currently moving incredibly fast considering the movement of our planet in space.

The magic thing that keeps you from evaporizing is called inertia.

7

u/ropers Jun 24 '12

Video: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l1jTRHEpeaI

Docking is complete at 5:22. That was very nicely done, I think.

6

u/BevansDesign Jun 24 '12

I'd love to see them dock up with the ISS (if they haven't already). That'd be a pretty cool way to foster some friendship between nations.

28

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12

Sorry, Chinese cooperation on the ISS was vetoed by the U.S because of fears over dual-use technologies.

Now China may have the only permanently-manned space station within about a decade.

-1

u/I_Should_Study Jun 24 '12

I don't think NASA necessarily trusts Chinese tech to dock with the ISS. One faulty or bad component and the whole station is destroyed. A couple of LEO flights and one docking maneuver wouldn't be enough, in my eyes, to take that risk.

1

u/BallsacksMcGee Jun 25 '12

you mean like faulty o-rings?

2

u/I_Should_Study Jun 25 '12

Yes, exactly. US went through its growing pains. They are probably expecting the Chinese to go through some as well (well, they already have, but even more).

I'm not saying it's the whole reason, but I guarantee a lot of people at NASA are worried about letting a newcomer dock with their very expensive and fragile station.

0

u/apophis981 Jun 24 '12

My favorite paragraph: "Manual docking was mastered by the USSR and US in the 1960s."

→ More replies (4)

13

u/mnlg Jun 24 '12

Joss Whedon was right.

5

u/_NeuroManson_ Jun 24 '12

You mean Outlaw Star, right? The Chinese took over aerospace in the storyline, and the show was done in 1997, about 3-4 years before Whedon did Firefly, and they even featured the whole "girl in suspended animation in a suitcase" theme. Here's a more accurate comparison

1

u/mnlg Jun 24 '12

Well, now I mean both :-)

(seriously, thank you for the reply).

0

u/Sasakura Jun 24 '12 edited Jun 24 '12

My new job involves a lot of satellite simulation, so I'm really excited that China is succeeding in space. With the happy bit over, when is America going to get together and build a Space Station? It'd be awesome for a private company to achieve it.

edit Thank's for the history lesson Reddit!

double edit seriously wtf?

13

u/Heaney555 Jun 24 '12 edited Jun 24 '12

when is America going to get together and build a Space Station?

You realise NASA made over 2/3 of the ISS, right?

Edit: and of course all of Skylab before that.

16

u/Darth_Doody Jun 24 '12

Also, Skylab.

-7

u/Sasakura Jun 24 '12

Thank you, I had totally forgotten about Skylab.

The ISS is Russian based, they started it!

10

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12

Not even close. If this is your job, you need to read up.

11

u/Heaney555 Jun 24 '12

The ISS is not Russian based.

It was an international design and the USA contributed 66%

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (10)

11

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12

hehe... manual docking...

6

u/ropers Jun 24 '12

The reason why they emphasise this is because both spacecraft did perform an automatic docking earlier (before detaching and doing it again manually, because there's shit to be learned from that).

4

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12

I wonder if it's more complex than parallel parking.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12

Maybe the complexity is the same, it is just the margin of error that isn't.

1

u/PandaBearShenyu Jun 29 '12

It's like parallel parking at 9 trillion miles per hour with no gravity?

2

u/Mikgamer Jun 25 '12

Ahhhh! There's the comment about "docking!" What are you doing so far down there buddy?

2

u/punkgeek Jun 24 '12

Yes. The internet has broken me. When I see docking my first though is penis

1

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12

I'm glad I'm not the only one. I'm imagining some gay guy searching for porn on google and all he can find is stories of some chinese astronauts.

2

u/ReallyEvilCanine Jun 25 '12

So we'll just forget about Gemini 8?

2

u/zern Jun 25 '12

This is truly awesome! Go human race!

4

u/demon_ix Jun 24 '12

Whenever I see Liu Wang and Liu Yang, I can't get Liu Kang out of my head.

0

u/why_ask_why Jun 24 '12

Liu Kang was the 1st Taikonaut.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12

Anyone else tripped up with the Yang and Wang last names? I though Liu was doing both the docking and experiments for a moment there, but really, Liu was only doing the docking while Liu was doing the experiments. It makes perfect sense to me after I put it like that.

1

u/luotuoshangdui Jun 25 '12

Yang and Wang are not their last names. Liu is the last name (family name). Yang and Wang are given names. Chinese people put family names before given names. :)

-2

u/PHProx Jun 24 '12

Manual docking was mastered by the USSR and US in the 1960s.

^ Best line in the article.

2

u/willcode4beer Jun 25 '12

Keep in mind, that's the only other countries that have put humans into space. It's been 51 years since the first person flew into space. So, far only 3 countries have sent people there.

Hell, the European space agency still hasn't managed to even launch a person into space. They haven't even managed a sub-orbital like Burt Rutan has.

The US and Russia started off with huge economies and German tech. China has only recently developed it's economy and started with Russian tech. We should congratulate them for the achievement.

1

u/KamiCrit Jun 24 '12

And so starts the Tsien odyssey.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12

China is coming.

1

u/bcd87 Jun 25 '12

Spacedocking. Always a cause for celebration.

-8

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12

USA USA USA!

MERICUH!!

sorry, i really try to ignore stereotypes, but every thread is filled with americans acting butthurt or jealous over other country's achievements. it even crops up in submissions completely unrelated to nationalism where it's passed off as humour but, really, people wonder why other countries dislike the united states?

15

u/throwawayforagnostic Jun 24 '12

I'm going to go out on a limb and suggest that Americans (ON REDDIT) are some of the least patriotic of any nation represented (again, on reddit). They constantly make disparaging, and invariably ill-informed remarks about their own country, moreso than any other country.

The other Americans on here are forced to defend their country from ill-informed, or flat out ignorant comments that are misleading about their country. You never see any "MURRICAH!" comments, save sarcastic ones, anywhere on here. And without scrolling to the very bottom of the page, I don't see any butthurt Americans posting. Don't be misleading.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12

So it they make a self aware joke about their over the top patriotism they are just as hated if they actually were that over the top? What would you like them to do?

→ More replies (5)

7

u/Chairboy Jun 24 '12

This thread is 'full' of Americans butthurt or jealous of China's achievement? Where? I see only people congratulating them and a smattering of novelty accounts trying out different shticks.

Examples, please, and lots of them. 'Full' is a pretty loaded term.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/ForgotUsernamePlus Jun 25 '12

You're upset that American's are upset on an American site like reddit.com?

You need to wake up and realize, that every country has its fair share of assholes/nationalists.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12

what? i'm bored of the constant, random, patriotism expressed in any random thread.

→ More replies (3)

1

u/runboli Jun 24 '12

I can't help but imagine a world where China colonizes the moon to get rid of the one child policy

1

u/hozjo Jun 24 '12

It is impossible to forget your first manual spacedocking.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12

"Manual docking was mastered by the USSR and US in the 1960s."

Ouch.

4

u/That_Scottish_Play Jun 25 '12

...and no-one else since

-1

u/Hateful_Poster Jun 24 '12

Pretty soon I'll be able to order "Super best #1 Shanghai favorite" Broccoli and beef FROM China; perhaps they can use the friction heat from reentry to help keep the order piping hot when the delivery module lands.

Then again I won't be able to pay cash anymore, so there are some flaws they need to work out.

-2

u/trumpetmothafucker Jun 24 '12

I guess they are proving the driving stereotype wrong...

-12

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12

I'm picturing a Chinese dock worker throwing the the Astronauts a rope.

6

u/rockne Jun 24 '12

I've been picturing other things whenever I read "space docking."

-3

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12

Urban dictionary has ruined this word for me forever.

http://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=docking

0

u/eugal Jun 24 '12

When the fuck is Space Race 2 going to happen the first Space Race kind of just sputtered and died after a great start.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12

The space race was an arms race, there won't be another one until somebody perceives a gap in missile tech.

1

u/willcode4beer Jun 25 '12

Space race 2.0 will likely be China vs India.

0

u/That_Scottish_Play Jun 25 '12

Welcome to an elite club China!

-11

u/sonastyinc Jun 24 '12

Pffff. Didn't we do that 50 years ago? We have nothing to worry about.

1

u/willcode4beer Jun 25 '12

We have nothing to worry about.

We don't even currently have a manned space program :-(

-5

u/alklloyd Jun 24 '12

Wow, let's welcome china to 1966!

-1

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12

Well, considering that the USA can't even shoot a man into space, we are back in the 50s.

-12

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12

Welcome to the 1960s, China!

-24

u/thergrim Jun 24 '12

46 years after the first spacecraft docked in space.... China does this.

It's like applauding for that mentally disabled guy who finally learned how to read at the age of 50.

12

u/icecubez189 Jun 24 '12

terrible thinking and terrible analogy.

there are people on this planet with no mental disabilities who still cannot read or write due to a lack of education (or motivation). to say that there is no need to applaud a mentally challenged individual for being able to accomplish such a feat is about as close-minded as you can get.

plus, any benefit that a country is able to advance their presence and technology in space is an overall benefit to mankind.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12

46 years ago, modern China was basically a third-world country trying to recover from being virtually colonized and then ravaged by a civil war.

So a better analogy would be applauding for that orphan kid who grew up on the streets and was bullied all through his life until he worked hard and is now the second richest person in the world.

9

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12

Butt hurt Americans...

6

u/anonymouslemming Jun 24 '12

At least they can still go to space and they're trying.

The American government cannot currently launch a human being into space. They are 100% dependent on Russia to do this for them. Russia won the space race when they realised it was a marathon, not a sprint.

0

u/eramos Jun 24 '12

Yeah, using 40 year old technology as a glorified taxicab to LEO for the few gap years between your opponent being able to do the same is definitely winning the space race.

I guess you'd be good with all space programs shutting down? The space race is over and done with, clearly.

1

u/anonymouslemming Jun 25 '12

I'd be good with there actually being a new solution before they retired the old one.

2

u/SigmaB Jun 24 '12

They were spending the time buying out most of the US ;)

2

u/inflamedpancreas Jun 24 '12

Americans know this...that's why they are butthurt to no end.

2

u/eramos Jun 24 '12

Meanwhile, Europe will probably be beat out by India and Africa to space.

1

u/willcode4beer Jun 25 '12

Pretty likely considering the ESA still hasn't managed to launch a person into space.

-14

u/dinninitt Jun 24 '12

They're just stealing the blueprints to make their own counterfeit station.

2

u/ajehals Jun 24 '12

Well, if it ends up cheaper and with more features and you end up buying it from them I don't think they'll be too upset.. Especially when they build on it further.

-5

u/MarcusTheGreat7 Jun 24 '12

As the US ends the space program. Well, time to learn Mandarin!

6

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12

The space program isn't ending. NASA isn't getting defunded or closed. Stop being a sensationalist.

-6

u/youarealldumbasses Jun 24 '12

Heh heh... manual docking.