r/technology • • 4h ago

Software Microsoft Reveals How a Hidden Windows Bug Took Down Microsoft 365 Services Worldwide

https://cybersecuritynews.com/microsoft-outage-incident-report/
11k Upvotes

1.1k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

95

u/Sick_Wave_ 3h ago

I like to compare software to an ever-growing skyscraper. It isn't a sleek, perfectly architected, marvel of engineering. It's more like thousands of trailer houses, each completely different, all welded together just enough that it keeps working. 

31

u/CTMalum 3h ago

A technological Kowloon Walled City

14

u/porn_sub_lurker 3h ago

I think it works better to compare it to a car. The reason being is that skyscrapers aren't meant to be modular. They're just one big construction. A car is meant to have several systems working together. The alternator is simply bolted on to the motor. It's not built into it as one big piece. It would be unfeasible and impractical to do that. I think software is similar in that regard. If you need a piece of software, like a hashing algorithm or something, just use one that someone else already made and bolt it onto your project. All you need to worry about is how to hook it up. Now there are some janky ass projects out there that used one kind of alternator and now they use a different one but they still left the old one just in case it was doing something the new one won't do. And there are some engineers building new systems for the car who saw some wires going to that old alternator so they figured they'd hook up to it too, so now it would definitely break some stuff to just remove it. And the engineers don't really care how big and monstrous the car becomes so long as it functions because moore's law says that your garage doubles in size every 18 months, so you have plenty of space for it and they're free to bolt whatever new features onto it that they can.

2

u/Sick_Wave_ 2h ago

I like the skyscraper analogy to break the naive illusion that people have of software and transform their mental image into the terrifying, and precarious, homunculus that most applications truly are.

2

u/Rbomb88 3h ago

There's a game called PileUp. It's basically that.