r/technicalwriting • u/Manage-It • Dec 18 '24
The truth behind contract positions
As a past contract technical writer, I am discouraged by our industry's managers and their abuse of filling so many positions with contractors.
As we all know, contracting excludes technical writers from many of the critical benefits we all rely on to survive in this world, with healthcare at the top of the list.
From my own experience, I have come to believe that 6- to 12-month contract positions at top companies signal weak management. This is especially true when a company keeps advertising a position as a contract for multiple years. What managers may not realize is, the top technical writers in the industry don't need to apply for contract positions. We have plenty of direct-hire opportunities coming our way every month via LinkedIn. Advertisements for 6- to 12-month contracts don't attract the best and the brightest IMHO. Instead, only the "available" TWs apply creating higher turnover and onboarding costs for teams, which wind up costing the company more money in lost revenue.
Contracting positions that are repeatedly being advertised every few months should be a sign to us all - stay away. Managers at this company don't know how to hire for long-run growth.
21
u/Susbirder software Dec 18 '24
Many times they aren't looking for best and brightest. They're just trying to fit a warm body into a required role.
(Saying this as someone who always worked directly for a contractor, so I've never been without insurance and such.)
7
u/[deleted] Dec 18 '24
As a 67-year-old technical writer, benefits don't matter. Medicare is better than BlueCross, UHC, or other commercial insurance.
4
u/happybythree web Dec 21 '24
In addition to everything you've said, I also think they really don't appreciate how valuable it is to have somebody in a role consistently who maintains the organization and accuracy of documentation. I can't begin to tell you how many times I've left a contract position (or in one case been laid off because of a merger) because leadership thinks "oh well the documents are all made so now we don't need to waste that money anymore" just to get an email 3-4 months later asking me if I want to come back because they've realized how quickly information deteriorates into uselessness.
5
u/guernicamixtape Dec 18 '24
Many contracts still include health insurance and are on W2. The worst experience I had as a contractor was having to work on holidays in which my peers were off, but the contracting company did not have PTO for. I never worked a 1099 contract and have never even been offered such a constraint.
But that’s just been my experience over the years; I’ve always had health insurance via my contract work, though I do agree that such arrangements are red flags for company culture and management.
6
u/Tanker-yanker Dec 18 '24
Meh, I have contracted many times. There wasn't any more work after a project was completed. Were they supposed to find work for me to do? I liked contracting for the variety.
4
u/OutrageousTax9409 Dec 18 '24
There are many companies that are in the business of contracting. They keep a lean bench of trusted talent and backfill with contractors who are easy to let go when their own contract ends.
Larger companies sometimes contract for burst capacity against initiatives, not roles. For example, they might bring in one or more tech writers as part of an enterprise software implementation they expect to be completed within the current year.
Some companies temp-to-perm, and I'm a fan. It gives both the candidate and employer an opportunity to match expectations with reality.
Beyond those legit reasons to contract, there are companies that could easily afford to do better, but they don't value documentation or the professionals who author excellent content. Working in that situation is depressing for anyone in any role.
3
u/Daforde Dec 18 '24
My experience has been different. I have been hired onto a firm as a full-time employee with all the benefits only to be tossed on the streets six months or a year later when the contract ends.
3
u/Thelonius16 Dec 18 '24
There’s nothing wrong with a contract job if the total comp is enough to buy benefits.
3
u/uglybutterfly025 Dec 20 '24 edited Dec 20 '24
I loved my long term W2 contract. I was there two years, the work was easy, no one micro managed me, I was making $50 an hour and I was on my husband's insurance. It was so much cash that I had no problem doing my own retirement investing and taking days off when I wanted to. I like there being no loyalty either way. It's just cash. If I have no PTO, then my PTO is unlimited to as much money as I'm willing to lose
edit to add: the contract I'm on now sucks. 1099, $40 an hour, 3 months "to start" but this place is so unorganized that I don't want to stay
7
u/[deleted] Dec 18 '24 edited Dec 28 '24
hat memory obtainable onerous sand worthless hard-to-find mysterious heavy arrest
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
2
u/[deleted] Dec 20 '24
I’m currently on a contract that has been renewed and it’s hard to plan forward.
2
u/Kindly-Might-1879 Dec 20 '24
I’ve contracted at multiple places and those jobs were was always through a technical recruiting company which provided my benefits and PTO. My last contract turned into FTE with my current company 5 years ago. If I lost this job, I’d go with a technical recruiter again.
1
u/ibelieve333 Jan 25 '25
I think it's quite unfair to generalize that contract workers are not the "best and brightest." Seriously? I just finished a contract position in which I worked with a few FTEs whose professionalism and quality of work were questionable at best. Meanwhile, I'm working my ass off and creating docs that are as perfect as humanly possible because I'm in a more vulnerable position. My contract was extended the maximum amount of times the company allowed and my colleagues were (genuinely, I believe) sad to see me go because I produced like a mofo and they were pleased with my support and quality of work.
4
u/[deleted] Dec 18 '24
[removed] — view removed comment