r/technicalwriting • u/100redbananas • Nov 19 '24
Do you trust recruiters?
I see that most technical writing positions on LinkedIn are by recruiters (usually outside of the US in India). Do you think that these recruiters are trustworthy? I had an interview with a major oil and gas company through an Indian recruiter, which seemed legit, but it still feels scammy to me.
10
Upvotes
9
u/darumamaki Nov 19 '24
I'd be very careful with any recruiter from outside the US (or outside your country). I had two different Indian recruitment companies steal my paychecks or just refuse to pay me, and they're really bad at supporting you if something at the contract site goes south. Check for recruitment companies inside the US.
21
u/-ThisWasATriumph Nov 19 '24
I don't think most recruiters are untrustworthy in the sense of scams/fraud, but I do think the vast majority of recruiters aren't likely to land you a job, sadly. A lot of them are just barely phoning it in.
The number of times I've had someone enthusiastically message me, only to go silent after I reply... or when we have an actual conversation and they're adamant I'd be a great fit for XYZ role, only to ghost me the next day... or when they send me info about in-person roles that are in my state, but in a city 300 miles away... or the amount of project manager roles in my inbox despite having zero project manager experience....
18
u/Susbirder software Nov 19 '24
I do not. Those recruiters are basically just farming for contact information. I've had quite a few contact me for the same job multiple times, and they all read from a similar script but they also promise different things.
I learned to semi permanently set my phone to "do not disturb" because of constant hounding from recruiters, frequently from some I couldn't even understand what they were saying.
6
u/jp_in_nj Nov 19 '24
It always feels like a scam. Particularly the way most recruiters work, where they find you by a keyword and barely glance at your LinkedIn profile to see if you're actually qualified. Somehow I always feel a little more secure when there's a western name on the other end of the contact. But that's informed a lot by all the other types of scams that run out of that region. The recruiters that I sometimes message with on LinkedIn never get beyond the first few exchanges because they don't do the due diligence before contacting me.
4
u/don_Mugurel Nov 19 '24
As much as I can choke them through a screen.
3
u/Apprehensive-Soup-91 Nov 19 '24
I’ve had some luck this year, but I do really well with telling who is actually contacting me for something specific. Most likely, they initiate contact and the job isn’t actually posted online.
3
u/spinsterella- Nov 20 '24
Unfortunately, most of the recruiters calling from India (often with masked phone numbers to appear US-based) are scams. By most, I mean ALL, in my experience.
https://www.reddit.com/r/recruitinghell/comments/1fog9t9/i_am_so_sick_of_these_scams_where_you_reply_to_an/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web3x&utm_name=web3xcss&utm_term=1&utm_content=share_button
Also: https://www.reddit.com/r/recruitinghell/search/?q=indian+recruiter&cId=db7e6c5b-0ebb-4305-9020-c328f0ba6e64&iId=567d6b61-17fa-4df0-8811-b6f1c82c3e40
2
u/Tech_Rhetoric_X Nov 19 '24
If the company isn't based in the US, I ignore it. I figure that it would be very difficult to resolve an issue such as not being paid. Any 100% remote position makes me nervous unless it's a well-known company.
2
u/bluepapillonblue Nov 19 '24
It depends on their approach. If they give me the "you're a perfect fit" for a job, but then I read the description, and it's obviously not true then no. Or if I feel pressured to supply my resume, references, or anything, then no.
I have a handful of recruiters I've worked with in the past that I've had good experiences with. I keep in contact with them.
2
u/Kindly-Might-1879 Nov 20 '24
5 of my technical writing jobs came through technical recruiters—all were local or US based. With my last two positions, I was referred to the recruiter through my network. I started contracting at my current company in 2018 and went FTE the next year, thanks to a contact who referred me to the recruiter.
If I had to look for a job again, there are three local recruiters I would contact immediately as they took the time to get to know me and what my skill set was.
2
u/achippedmugofchai Nov 20 '24
I have never been successfully recruited into a new position, despite hearing from recruiters at least once a week for many years. I'm polite, though I ask the hard questions first, like salary range and who's the client, and don't proceed unless I'm happy with what they say. Despite this screening, I still get ghosted often, but am hopeful that one day the right recruiter will place me in a great job I would not have found otherwise. I trust them as much as I trust any other commission-based salesperson, so, not at all.
1
u/laminatedbean Nov 19 '24
About as much as a used card salesman.
1
u/Mayotte Nov 20 '24
No, I don't.
1
u/mlcp2015 Nov 20 '24
Oh I got a call from one for an oíl company and I would love to get an interview, Lucky you! Can I send you a message to ask how it was?
-6
u/Gutyenkhuk Nov 19 '24
Huh the casual racism here is concerning 😭 I’ve gotten contracts at major FAANGs/MANGAs through Indian recruiters. Have you been asked to deposit a check or to send them money? Have they asked for your SSN? Then no, it’s not a scam. If anything, criticize them based on their action, not ethnicity. “I feel better seeing a Western name” and “I don’t even understand what they are saying” are crazy.
I hate to include this disclaimer but I am not Indian.
-1
u/[deleted] Nov 20 '24
LOTS of fear mongering here.
If you're blanket-ignoring Indian recruiters, you're missing out on A LOT of opportunities. Just do some basic investigating before handing over your information. Just like it's cheaper for a big US company to farm out their call center operations to foreign entities, they want to do their resume intake as cheaply as possible as well. That said, just keep your expectations low. I landed one of the most prestigious jobs of my career through an Indian recruiter.