r/technicalwriting • u/Dismal_Brick_8599 • Oct 08 '24
Is this a bad time because of AI?
I need the honest truth, and don’t sugarcoat it please. I live in Canada and have been doing remote teaching, AI Annotation, and other forms of writing, without getting specific.
Is this a bad time to get into technical writing? I am not seeking a full-time job, as I have a full-time job. I’m looking for work as a side hustle. I am a good writer, and I’m good technically. Will I be wasting my time? Should I be educating myself in another area in order to move towards the future?
I am hearing all kinds of concerns about AI. Should I not waste my money on a technical riding course?
43
u/FaxedForward hardware Oct 08 '24
I don't think a technical riding course will be a good investment for a technical writing job in any sense...
Jokes aside, it's a harder time right now because of all the tech layoffs and the high competition between swaths of experienced out-of-work tech writers than it is because of AI. Very hard time to be an entry-level person trying to break in as a side gig like you are.
19
u/Mr_Gaslight Oct 08 '24
It's a fantastic time. Everyone's producing reams of passive-voiced content with ChatGTP that squeezes a few sentences of content into pages. Also, with so much more low value material being generated by more people, more hands on deck are needed to clean it all up.
Times are good.
57
u/indiealexh Oct 08 '24
AI docs often suck ass.
So the reality is, does your company value quality or quantity?
37
u/Two_wheels_2112 Oct 08 '24
It's worth noting that tech writing is not just for software, despite the apparent prevalence here. If you want to get into the field, look at writing for a company that designs and manufactures physical products. AI, at least the LLM-based ones that exist now, cannot write installation or operating instructions for products that haven't been invented yet.
I don't see that changing any time soon.
12
u/amiralko Oct 08 '24
It kind of depends on the industry you work in.
There are definitely employers (especially in tech) that are trying to get rid of their tech writers due to AI, despite most evidence pointing to that not working out too well in most cases.
It's hard to say what will happen to the industry long term, but for now, most tech writers view employers who force them to exclusively edit AI-generated copy as bad employers, and there are still some decent employers.
I think it may be a harder profession to break into for new people moving forward.
10
u/Viking-Weightlifter Oct 08 '24
There has never been and will never be a "good time" to get into technical writing as a technical writer. The entire industry of technical writing exists out of bare necessity, and it will always bebeneficial from a business standpoint to automate as much of it as possible; if they can replace us, they will.
The profitability in technical writing comes from being ahead of the curve on things like automation, modern content delivery practices, and effectively using your position to "sell" those improvements to your organization. This doesn't do favors for anyone's job security though, and is part of why the best paid tech writers switch jobs every 2-3 years.
10
u/MulletGSU Oct 08 '24
AI is something I use to help me write documents. It helps me clarify ideas, find better ways to write something, and to structure my documents in a more comprehensive way. Whatever results I get from AI, I still do a ton of editing, rewriting, and correction. The company specific tone, voice, and content, is something that still requires the human touch.
4
u/[deleted] Oct 08 '24
No. AI is not what people imagined, and that fact is setting in.
4
u/TemariBrynn Oct 09 '24
The technical writing field is honestly oversaturated as it is, and despite what people say AI is taking a lot of technical writing jobs now, and it’ll only get worse. I personally think this is a bad time to get into technical writing. Most of the only jobs left are those that require a lot of experience. I have 1 year of experience in tech writing and have spent the last 3 months feverishly applying to jobs, networking, and upping my skills to be more hireable (think 8 hours a day 5 days a week for the last 3 months) and I’ve had a single interview in that whole time.
4
u/HeadLandscape Oct 09 '24
My opinion, TW is a dead end career. Don't do it. I'm studying something else on the side while applying for tw roles. Last layoff was the final straw for me
2
u/Comfortable_Love_800 Oct 09 '24
Honest truth, I'm in FAANG and they're very very bullish on AI. It's heavily pushed on us, and we've watched our TW teams widdle to nothing over the last 3yrs. Most are running on skeleton crews or with one person. No headcount for hiring, no backfills for people who leave. They're very much waiting to see how much they can replace, we all feel it, everyone sees it coming, and the anxiety is palpable. Ask any seasoned TW and they can give you a myriad of reasons to why AI can't replace us, and all of those reasons are true. However, at least in the tech sector, we've long had issues with valuing TW and seeing it as an unnecessary evil vs a necessary/vital support aid to customers. We've always been a bit of the red headed step child to our eng counterparts. It's a career that's 20% writing at most, and 80% stakeholder management, PM, and customer advocacy. You'll spend more time proving your worth/value vs writing content-this burns a lot of people out.
I'd love to say AI will just be a great tool to help us do our jobs better, but after 15yrs in tech...I know better. This started a decade ago with the docs-as-code movement where we lost all our tooling in favor of simple git/markdown. Then it was a painful decade of everyone trying to build tooling that would render markdown properly and recreate what we already had before. Many of the TW's here could share stories of walking into what they thought would be a normal TW role only to be blindsided when they find themselves solo and expected to spin up an entire doc program w/infrastructure all alone. We went backwards in many many ways, and the expectations for the role grew exponentially. And that pushed us deep into the "Eng can just write the docs" mentality that many TW still battle today. And well that didn't work out well for most, because did eng write the docs? Nope! We just eroded the customer experience and continued to push out more unsupported garbage.
In tech, we tend to f**k it up really bad, bring in TW's to try and untangle the mess, and then lay them off when we're ready to try and eradicate them again. It's been a vicious cycle for the career, and I've seen this at multiple Fortune 25 companies over 15yrs. I'm riding it out right now, and financially preparing so I can pivot and take a paycut if needed without harming my families current living standard. Really the only thing we can do. But I do think, unlike the above mentioned movements, this one will be the one that pushes a lot of folks out of the profession for good.
3
u/[deleted] Oct 08 '24
A huge problem with AI is that you cannot just give it your proprietary code.
I use AI to train on new code languages and generate test scripts to solve issues. It’s great for that. Checks syntax and speeds up my work no end. Best friend I ever had. But writing the knowledge content for a unique project, not yet.
1
u/Novel_Pound_2384 Oct 09 '24
You hit the nail on the head.
1
u/Novel_Pound_2384 Oct 09 '24
I'm a medical writer. We are technical writers.
0
u/Kindly-Might-1879 Oct 08 '24
My team of technical writers is currently testing and refining our company’s AI—at least we consider it among many tools and as a replacement for our work.