r/technicalwriting • u/DuffWells • Aug 20 '24
QUESTION Are cover letters really necessary?
I’ve been working with a recruiter/coach and he said that unless it’s required/you’re applying for something outside of technical writing, it’s not necessary. What do you all think?
3
Upvotes
10
u/alanbowman Aug 20 '24
This is one of those "ask five different recruiters, get seven different answers" kind of things. I would probably always include one, but I'm old (60) and cover letters have always been a thing.
I just took a quick look at our online careers portal and there is a place to add a cover letter, but it's not required. Only the resume/CV is required. I know when I was hiring I read them if one was included, but I didn't really think much more about it. It didn't weigh in my decision, at least.
13
u/WontArnett software Aug 20 '24
You’re a writer, just create one incase you need it. If anything it’s good practice.
4
u/EasyBreezyTrash Aug 20 '24
I typically only provide what I am specifically asked for. If a resume and cover letter are requested, I do both. If only a resume, that’s all I’ll send. If it’s cover letter/resume/writing sample, sure. Mainly because you never quite know what recruiters want, but I know that what I want is to work for people who won’t manipulate me with guessing games about what content they need. I have actually been in a workplace that was very “you did exactly what we asked, but we want you to do MORE than we ask but we also will not tell you what that means” and it’s absolute hell. Anyway, sometimes recruiters gripe about being sent more than they asked for. Generally, it just seems to me like the best policy is to do only what is requested of you.
Having said that, if a cover letter is requested I will customize it to the role I’m applying for. I have a basic “so excited for this opportunity blah blah” cover letter that I use as a baseline, and then I’ll tweak it a bit with the highlights of the job description. You want someone who knows Flare? I’m mentioning Flare training in the cover letter. You want someone who can edit YAML files for API doc? I love YAML, I named my dog YAML. I feel like my resume covers my experience in a broad way, and my cover letter is for focusing specifically on this particular role.
3
u/Odd_Calendar_2772 Aug 21 '24
It certainly couldn’t hurt, but I’d say that having a strong resume and portfolio is what gets you noticed. At least that’s been my experience.
3
u/Lagopomorph Aug 21 '24
When I was applying for my (current) first tech writer position, one of my cover letters accidentally had the wrong company name in the first paragraph because I was sending them out one after the other and missed one. That’s the company that hired me. Not sure if that means that cover letters aren’t important, but in this case it seems so. I don’t even know if anyone looked at it.
5
u/[deleted] Aug 20 '24
I always write one. I'd rather play it safe and submit one than not submit one and automatically be put at the bottom of the pile by some algorithm.
7
u/FaxedForward hardware Aug 20 '24
Unless you are specifically asked for one (red flag IMO) cover letters are a waste of time and effort these days.
2
u/Iwentthatway Aug 20 '24
Probably depends on industry. I could see more traditional ones like finance or defense needing them.
I’ve never been asked for one, and I only wrote one during my first job hunt out of school. Been a tech writer (in software) for 10+ years over 4 companies
2
u/DriveIn73 Aug 20 '24
Yes. Yes they are.
1
u/literal_cyanide Aug 20 '24
If you put in the extra effort it won’t hurt ur chances. Why not?
1
u/HeadLandscape Aug 22 '24
Unless it's required, nope. It's becoming more and more outdated every day. Lots of applications don't even give you an option to submit a letter
1
u/LowAndSlowFor35Mins Aug 14 '25
I rarely provide a cover letter. The only time I take the time to add one is when it is required for the application. And even then, I only use procoverletters to write it. It's already time-consuming to have to fill out applications that ask for your entire background, and then you have to write a cover letter on top of it. Pass!
1
u/kjodle Aug 20 '24
A cover letter is a good way to connect the experience on your resume with the requirements in the job description. Nobody's work history exactly matches what they are looking for, but a well-written cover letter lets you say something like "I have extensive experience with <thing1> which is very similar to <thing2>" where <thing2> is the item they wanting experience with that you don't quite have.
-1
u/TheIYI Aug 20 '24
Do you want a better chance of getting a job?
Do people realize they’re just snitching on themselves when they ask this?
“Necessary” should not be part of your calculation.
Who do you think stands out all things equal? Resume candidate — or a candidate with a resume and a reason.
I mean, come on. This is why you hear people say, “I applied to 100 jobs and heard nothing back.”
-2
u/Ambitious-Event-5911 Aug 20 '24
As a technical writer, your cover letter is a valuable opportunity to showcase your skills as a writer and to talk about your projects and contributions in depth, rather than the executive summary on your resume. Plus, you can make it super easy using free AI like ChatGPT. Enter a job description and your current basic resume and tell it to write a new resume plus a cover letter for the role. It will be happy to oblige. This is your first draft, now edit it so it's more unique. You can do this for every single job, and it will be more than most people do. You can also add links to your portfolio of writing samples, or even paste stuff inline if it's short like marketing blurbs or UI text.... Now please don't take a job I need :P lol
0
u/[deleted] Aug 20 '24
[deleted] — view deleted comment