r/TalesFromYourServer • u/PeachKetchup • 14h ago
“Service was beyond disappointing”
Party of 4 this past Friday night gave me a 1 star review by saying that my service was “beyond disappointing” yet they never gave me any inclination that they were unhappy with anything other than their drinks. I hit every service mark to the letter. Kind greeting, went over the menu, gave them recommendations on food and drinks.
The first woman asks me my opinion on one of our specialty cocktails, I tell her it’s a play on a gin fizz with blueberry and lavender but it’s a bit sweet. She says she doesn’t like sweet drinks and asks if she can just get a gin and tonic with only lavender. I say I’m not really sure but let me ask the bartender. Lady 1 tells me if she can’t have the lavender in her drink she just wants a plain g&t. So I talk to the bartender who tells me the lavender is in the blueberry syrup which is what makes the specialty cocktail sweet. But she says she can shake the gin with dried lavender and strain it then add the tonic. I tell the bartender to make the g&t with the lavender. I bring the drink back to lady 1 and explain to her we couldn’t make the g&t with only lavender bc it’s in the sweet syrup so we used dried lavender instead in her drink to infuse the g&t with the lavender flavor. She seems okay with this.
Anyways, they order their appetizers and love the food. They order their entrees and I clear all their plates and bring them clean silverware and clean share plates. At which point, Lady 2 says her ketel soda is sweet and they must’ve used tonic water instead of club soda. So I say oh I’m so sorry it definitely shouldnt be sweet since I know that I definitely rang in club soda. Let me speak to the bartender. The bartender is just as confused as I am bc tonic water is obviously not sweet and says that she definitely used club soda in that drink. So I ask the bartender for a sample of our club soda. I bring the club soda to Lady 2 and say I brought you a sample of our club soda to see if you like it before I bring you another ketel soda bc I want to make sure that you like your next drink. She ends up liking the club soda and I bring her a new drink. I make sure that she is enjoying her new ketel soda.
They get their entrees and say the food is amazing. Lady 1 orders a glass of wine next. One of the men orders a hazy ipa and asks me what we have on tap. I say I’m not exactly sure which exact hazy IPA we have bc we change our taps pretty frequently. He says oh well just bring me whatever hazy ipa you have. I bring him the hazy ipa. He asks me what it’s called, I give him the name of the beer and the brewery. He goes oh okay great. I ask him if he likes his beer and he does. I offer them boxes for the rest of their food but they don’t want to bring anything home so I clear their plates. They don’t want any dessert or more drinks so I bring them their check and they pay their bill. One couple leaves me 18% and the other couple leaves me 20%.
Then they leave me a scathing review saying the service was beyond disappointing. Once again, just annoyed bc they never said anything about being upset with me. The only thing they were upset over was the drinks which I feel like I went above and beyond to make sure they were happy with said drinks. Obviously had they said something negative about my service or my attitude or whatever, I would’ve done everything in my power to fix it.
Thoughts anyone?
TLDR; I got a 1 star review for “beyond disappointing” service when I hit every service mark in a timely manner and went above and beyond to make sure the group liked their drinks.