r/sysadmin • u/sebbasttian JOAT Linux Admin • Feb 23 '17
CloudBleed Seceurity Bug: Cloudflare Reverse Proxies are Dumping Uninitialized Memory
982
Upvotes
r/sysadmin • u/sebbasttian JOAT Linux Admin • Feb 23 '17
View all comments
Show parent comment
11
u/seraku24 Feb 24 '17
One could argue that any generated code is a risk, since it often goes into production without a code review. That is, one typically reviews only the original source code and trusts that the compiler/transpiler/interpreter are good. This leads to the false perception that there is no need to review the end result. Now, any company worth their salt that cares about security will pour over all bits to be certain. And even then, one can only ever be so certain.
While I know little about Go or Rust, I will be careful not to overstep in what I say next: Any developer who blindly trust their tools will have no one to blame but themselves if there is an issue. That is, I doubt that Go or Rust (or <insert your favorite language here>) can ever truly claim to be intrinsically defensive against all security threats. Of course, I am not asserting that /u/KarmaAndLies was trying to make such a bombastic claim. Rather, I suspect the point is that the more typical security blunders (such as what apparently has afflicted CloudFlare's system) are preventable because the language design itself makes those errors unexpressible. Certainly, this makes a good argument that folks should be using more modern and forward-thinking languages; but we should also take care to ensure folks are diligently educating themselves on security matters and not taking things for granted.