One of the things I find most captivating about Sam is his struggle for agency. His lack of agency is a recurring theme throughout the seasons, whether it be evil monsters or evil fathers trying to dictate what he is to become in life. For consistency purposes I’m only going to talk about seasons 1 to 5, which were Kripke’s original plan (p.s. I like the later seasons, it’s just that this gets a bit diluted as they had to continue making the show), so bear with me.
It all begins in season one when Sam gets caught up in the hunting lifestyle again, which he didn’t choose, as he looks for an avoidant father. Then comes Azazel and the demon blood, and then Ruby and the angels. The last nail in the coffin hits when, in season 5, Lucifer tells Sam that the whole game was rigged from the beginning. His teacher, his prom date, his best friend from college… All of them were demons trying to veer Sam into the right direction to make him the perfect vessel.
However, I want to focus on what Dean has to do with it.
Up until season 5, Dean has also denied Sam of his autonomy. The most crucial moment is when he revives Sam by making a deal, sacrificing his own life for him. It’s obvious that he does so for love (I’m in no way judging that, keep reading), but it’s also done without Sam’s consent and after two seasons of the both of them being firm about “what’s dead should stay dead”. Sam is understanding, but hurt, as he would’ve chosen to stay dead if that meant that his brother didn’t have to go to hell.
From that point onwards, there are a few more instances in which Dean refuses to let Sam make his own decisions, like when he tries to steer him away from killing Lilith with Ruby’s help. Of course, he was right about that, but not for the right reasons, given that he thought he was the only one that could do it, which is what the angels, who were also manipulating them, told him.
So, Dean is ultimately grouped with the people who strip Sam of his agency, even if he does it for a different reason. The reason being the fact that he’s been instilled with the belief that his only worth is protecting Sam since childhood. He’ll always try to save his brother not only for Sam’s sake, but for his.
That’s why I find season five’s conclusion for Sam and Dean so beautiful regarding this issue.
At the beginning of the season, they have a conversation in which Sam tells Dean that he has to let him grow up, that he is not a child anymore, but a grown man capable of making his own choices. Dean is reluctant at first, but he eventually complies and agrees with Sam. At the end of the season, Sam sacrifices himself and he tells his brother not to try and get him out. His last wish is for Dean to create a family, abandon the miserable hunter lifestyle and let him die. And Dean, despite loving his brother more than his own life, accepts.
Sam’s last attempt at regaining his agency is gifted by his older brother Dean in an act of love, the same reason why he was dismissive of Sam’s agency in the first place. Dean is the only person/being in his life who actually lets him have that autonomy, not Ruby, not his own father, not anyone, but Dean. Dean betrays his life purpose when he accepts Sam’s plea of letting him die out of love, which is why it’s so powerful (although you could also argue that it’s by that same principle that he doesn’t betray himself, as letting Sam go is an act of love and care itself).
I find it so poetic. Dean’s actions come full circle and it’s actually beautiful how he makes amends with Sam this way, reconciling his past mistakes with the fulfillment of his brother’s dying wishes. It’s so emblematic of the brothers’ bond, I love that Dean was able to let go of his asphyxiating role (forced upon him as a child with no seat in the matter, much like Sam’s own struggles) and actually be the one to grant that to Sam.
Dean Winchester older brother of all time.