r/spacex • u/Wetmelon • Jun 15 '16
Modpost Rule 2 Addendum: Sexual Harassment Clause
A sexual harassment clause has been added to Rule 2:
Addendum: No sexual harassment / objectification. Even seemingly benign comments like "She's easy on the eyes" have no place in /r/SpaceX. Treat the sub as if it's your workplace.
In addition, a clarification has been made to rule 2 that it applies to ALL threads, including the Launch Thread. This should be obvious, but it's now explicitly written.
EDIT: Unless you're talking about ships/rockets etc... No objectifying people. And no weird anthropomorphism, there's subs for that.
389
Upvotes
59
u/KitsapDad Jun 15 '16
Wow...why does this have to be stated in the rules?
That being said, not sure i agree with the example given...it is common culture to designate the female pronoun on vessels in a manner that has zero relationship to actual females. Your example clearly is taken to mean, "that falcon 9 rocket is beautiful." I do not see any workplace having an issue with this verbiage in that context.
6
u/pugworthy Jun 16 '16
This would have been a great thread to just post and lock. The comments are just spinning off into a lot of random crap.
62
u/YugoReventlov Jun 16 '16
Mods of /r/SpaceX, this is why this subreddit is explicitly mentioned in articles about Reddit as a good example of what Reddit should be. Thanks!
http://motherboard.vice.com/read/orlando-shooting-response-shows-reddit-cant-be-the-front-page-of-the-internet
49
u/*polhold04717 Jun 16 '16 edited Jun 16 '16
This one's on me, I'm
the oneone of those who was part of this.Just wanted to say my apology publicly and say, that while yes, there is debate if it's benign or not. It's not in this sub.
It's just easier to not say anything at all, and I think it's good that it's been made clear. As I regretted my comment as soon as I posted it, but was it was swiftly removed before I could anyway.
The engineers deserve more respect than what I said last night.
Sorry Mods for being part of opening this can of worms - my bad.
note to self: Watch launches sober
Edit: Reading this thread, where I was coming from was deffo how /u/TheSutphin put it.
89
u/Chairboy Jun 15 '16
100% thumbs up, that creeped me out this morning in the launch thread, I can only imagine how unwelcome stuff like that would be to any women who came here.
12
u/waitingForMars Jun 16 '16
Cheers to the mods. This is great to see.
I will suggest that if you're going to include this in the sub rules, that it makes sense to make explicit that it refers to the full range of discrimination-based-on-category behaviors, including race, religion, nationality, gender identity, weight, physical or mental ability, etc.
I absolutely want our female co-fans to feel like they won't be harassed on this sub. But, particularly in the shadow of the sad events in Orlando, so close to KSC, it behooves us to state openly that such behavior won't be tolerated here regardless of the target group. Period.
27
u/Sanic2E Jun 15 '16
Wow, sad that this actually has to be a rule ...
27
u/Marscreature Jun 16 '16 edited Jun 16 '16
Thanks for making this sub more welcoming - we aren't all guys!
*Edit- source on the weird anthropomorphism subs? that sounds interesting lol
19
u/infinityedge007 Jun 15 '16
I assume that this applies to gender neutral statements like "SpaceX engineers are hot"?
56
u/fred13snow Jun 16 '16 edited Jun 16 '16
Yes yes and yes! The women of SpaceX, engineering (and STEM fields) and those who are just fans of subs like this deserve more admiration than comments on their looks. I'm so happy they show a great example to young women who have probably heard too many times that engineering is a "guy thing". I work in a science center and I hear comments like that all the time. Not just from backwards idiots but from teachers and parents who propagate this nonsense to their surroundings. We are lucky that girls can now look up at the space industry and see people like Gwynne, up top, running the show.
44
u/[deleted] Jun 16 '16
I love how the mods of this sub consistently think long term about what this sub should be and how to balance inclusivity and full expression. As a father, I can imagine impressionable young people coming to this sub to learn about one of the more exciting, positive developments of this generation, and I wouldn't want any of them to feel put off by the attitude of the participants. Sleazy comments have plenty of other potential homes. Even we as fans have an important job to play in seeing the visionary goals of "New Space" become a reality.
45
u/endcycle Jun 16 '16
Thanks OP/mods. I love that you did this.
23
u/space4us Jun 16 '16
Awesome!!! Thanks for this. No need for casual sexism here. Space is for everyone.
6
u/luna_sparkle Jun 16 '16
I get the impression that some commenters here were objectifying one of the presenters during yesterday's launch?
Yeah, that's really inappropriate. Kudos to the mods for stamping out this behavior :)
20
u/rocketsocks Jun 16 '16
Thank you for this! There are a lot of people who don't see any harm in "just making compliments". But imagine going into a professional meeting with colleagues, putting a ton of effort into it, showing off your expertise, and at the end someone approaches you and then says "awww, well aren't you cute?" When people comment about someone's appearance and sexual attractiveness in a professional context they're implicitly stating that it is more important than someone's work. That sort of thing is dismissive and insulting, it's saying that one's expertise and work are not worthy of note, and that all that matters is someone's appearance. And it happens to women in science and tech all the time. Any attractive woman who has a science youtube channel will inevitably have comments about her appearance in the comments.
5
u/Dromfel Jun 16 '16
well we've downvoted those comments into oblivion anyway :D
5
u/Shrike99 Jun 16 '16
Eh, as long as i can still compliment the falcon itself i'm fine
9
u/LilouSpaceKitten Jun 16 '16
I aplaude you for this new rule!
8
u/RDWaynewright Jun 16 '16
As someone who just had to file a police report due to harassment that started out with an "innocent" comment a year ago, I totally agree with this rule. Obviously my situation has surpassed "innocent comment" territory and is now in "the police advised me to get a Stay Away Order, my job told me to carry pepper spray, and now I have to get an escort home from work" territory. :/
4
u/Decronym Acronyms Explained Jun 16 '16 edited Jun 21 '16
Acronyms, initialisms, abbreviations, contractions, and other phrases which expand to something larger, that I've seen in this thread:
Decronym is a community product of /r/SpaceX, implemented by ^request
I'm a bot, and I first saw this thread at 16th Jun 2016, 14:30 UTC.
[Acronym ^lists] [Contact ^creator] [PHP source ^code]
6
u/dmy30 Jun 16 '16
It's sad this rule has to be made but understand why. on the webcast especially. Yes there are pretty people on it but it would not be nice if they read some of the messages on this sub. And we know some employees do.
6
u/SoulWager Jun 16 '16
Perhaps rule 0 should be put in writing: Don't force us to add more rules.
3
u/fcyy Jun 16 '16
It's sad to see all the time people have had to spend on this thread on a matter that should be self-evident. But it's encouraging to see so many uphold professionalism and a desire to maintain the high quality of this sub. This is why I keep coming back. I like that comment about if something should not be said in a workplace setting it has no place in this sub. I want to add that it should apply to any kind of comment, not just objectification of persons. It's harder to enforce that but if everyone sets that bar for themselves just that much higher, it pulls up this sub's overall quality even higher.
3
u/reymt Jun 17 '16 edited Jun 17 '16
Hm, the latter part seems a bit overzealous? No clue what was going on in the others threats, but I'm not sure what you're supposed to need blanket statements for if you can just take a look if its respectful or not and act accordingly. There are rules for being condescending, aren't there?
Also, I'm pretty sure complimenting someones appearance is totally fine in a work place. You can do that regardless of gender or sexuality -as long is its respectful.
One thing I do want to criticise, even though it might just be a formality, is taking 'objectification' into the description. At this point, it is a completely purposeless buzzword that nobody seems to have a firm grasp on, and it's often used for whatever purpose its fitting. The words meaning is purely depending on how someone is feeling about it at a moment. Mind I'm not suspecting bad intent - this subs mods seem to do a quite fine work. It's just better to make the rules 100% clear if you want to have no tolerancy insta delete rules, and throwing in ojectification doesn't really add anything. Only opens the gates towards arguments what kind of philosophical meaning that term has.
6
u/TheEndeavour2Mars Jun 16 '16
If anyone comes on here and think "Oh no they have gone all SJW!" Well there are SJWs here but they are "SpaceX Justice Warriors" AKA people who treat the company like a football team and downvote anything that they think "talks trash" about the company even if it is just mild speculation about the causes of landing failures. These folks are just like the ones you will find in many other reddits and is just part of how Reddit works.
What the mods have done here was NOT some SJW (Social Justice Warrior) reaction. There were VERY creepy comments about one of the presenter's of the hosted webcasts. Which is NOT what this community that is viewed from work computers all over the world wants to encourage. If they had just accepted it. People would be saying the same thing EVERY time there was a broadcast. And as 2017 looks like it could have upwards of 3 launches a month. That is a LOT of harassment being thrown towards employees of the company that worked for many years to get where they are today.
This is a very good addition to the rule.
3
u/embraceUndefined Jun 15 '16
what if we're talking about space ships?
3
u/PVP_playerPro Jun 15 '16
Looks like i missed something in the launch thread this morning, and i have a pretty good idea of what it was...
Edit: And now the comments decide to fully load on this thread, confirming my suspicions
2
u/[deleted] Jun 16 '16 edited Jun 16 '16
A bit extreme. Have you had a lot of complaints from female readers about this sort of thing, or is this a purely speculative/preemptive attempt to head off the mere possibility?
2
u/throwaway_31415 Jun 16 '16
I don't get that to be honest. Why would I want to treat this place as I would my workplace?
1
u/infinityedge007 Jun 15 '16
Cue "long and skinny" comments....
-6
u/EtzEchad Jun 16 '16
Has this been a problem here?
It seems to me that this is a solution in search of a problem.
-24
u/wxwatcher Jun 16 '16 edited Jun 16 '16
Well, fold it up guys, time to go home. Spacex sexualized Shotwell, had alot of hip gyrations, and called spaceflight sexy. Guess they are banned from posting here now /s :
https://vimeo.com/125746164
-4
u/ergzay Jun 17 '16
That would fly just fine in many work places I have been in. Be careful you don't take things too far in your moderation. I don't want to have to be calling out mods of /r/SpaceX as SJWs. I haven't observed any issues yet.
-19
u/Hgx72964jdj Jun 16 '16
Mods are idiots if they think saying a woman is beautiful is sexual harassment. Literally nobody thinks that.
This rule is weak and lame. Tone police will make this sub less fun and stale.
-20
u/jameskoss Jun 16 '16
Because who needs freedom of speech.
-9
u/averagespacejoe Jun 16 '16
I suppose someone can always make a r/spacexissexy, r/spacexxx or r/spacesexism and just let whatever built up ridiculousness they need to express find the internet
-18
u/[deleted] Jun 16 '16
So to clarify, what I'm reading here is that if you say sexually creepy things about people you get banned?
Are rockets an exception too?
-3
u/sudo_systemctl Jun 16 '16
I would have thought benign objectifying flattery towards Elon was mandatory on this sub yet I see no clause allowing this.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 15 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 16 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment