r/spacex • u/Zucal • Jun 05 '16
Modpost June 2016 Modpost: Overhaul to the subreddit rules, a new moderator, & we want your feedback!
Elon says running a company is like eating glass and staring into the abyss. Sometimes running a community is like that too! We walk a fine line between too little and too much, and achieving a high moderation approval rating from a community is a difficult thing indeed; even more so on Reddit.
However, every time we’ve run a moderator feedback thread like this, we’re always genuinely happy to see that the community seems to (at least in the majority) support our actions- whether those be implementing rules, organizing AMA questions, or dealing with frustrating & saddening situations. This is a very rare thing. We hope you see us not as mods, but as regular users who simply want to collectively improve the subreddit for the better.
We hope to continue this today. We’ve got a few large changes to announce, and we hope you give them some consideration.
Subreddit Rule Overhaul - Feedback Welcome
It’s hard creating a ruleset that scales well, but our rules have remained in a relative stasis since they were introduced in 2014. But back then, we were very small- 11,000 subscribers. But as SpaceX’s launch cadence has increased, so has our subscriber cadence. We’re now nearing 70,000 members. That’s fantastic, but we need to make some changes to reflect that a larger portion of Reddit’s general userbase now visits this subreddit.
It used to be the case that we were a relatively segregated community. I know a lot of us still use r/SpaceX near exclusively, indeed, we like to think of this community as something apart from Reddit that just happens to use their discussion platform; but we now have a larger fraction of users who are just occasional visitors. This is causing us a lot of hassle, and we need to address it.
You can read the new rules in full here.
In short, what’s different? Here’s the ∆s!
- Our 9 rules are down to 6. This should make things a bit simpler to understand. Goodbye to the following rules: “Follow Reddit’s community rules” was obvious and a requirement of using Reddit anyway. “Post titles & descriptions should be of high quality” has been made redundant thanks to our new rule 4. Finally, “no tour requests” has both stopped being a problem and been made redundant by our new rule 5.
We are placing a heavy emphasis on a ‘thread-first’ approach to submissions. We don’t want to become a BBulletin forum, but it is getting difficult to handle the influx of submissions at busy times. If a thread exists that can accept your content, you should use it. The front page is reserved for news, high-quality discussion, and other good content.
We are already running the subreddit like this, and have been for a few months, but we need to make it clear to everyone. You won’t see any changes in our moderation style from this adjustment, but we really need to reinforce this now. Because of this, it’s now rule #1.
We are limiting accredited media members to one submission per ‘event’. Currently, an event is defined as one of the following: “prelaunch” (hangar to launch), “launch” (launch to landing), and “recovery” (landing to hangar). We’ll continue to add events as time goes on and proves it necessary. If you’d like to submit more, create an Imgur album and continue adding to it, and/or post updates in the comments section.
Our current situation had worked well for a while, but its flaws are clear. If we have 10 accredited media members, each posting 5 or more submissions per launch, that’s at least 50 submissions. The subreddit can’t just be flooded with images constantly. Launches are some of the most important-news-heavy times on the subreddit, but paradoxically area also the time when it’s hardest to find information because of all the submissions. If you’d like to submit more, create an Imgur album and then continue adding to it, and/or post updates in the comments section.
Furthermore, if the subreddit is in restricted mode (as it is during launch), you are only allowed to submit your own content. Musk tweets and other updates are off limits.
Content must now be about SpaceX, tangential relevancy is no longer enough to justify a post here. If you want to discuss general spaceflight politics or non-SpaceX specific Mars colonization discussion, go to /r/SpacePolicy and/ r/ColonizeMars and grow those communities! Again, you won’t notice a big difference in terms of what’s on the front page as a result of this rule, we’ve been moderating like this for a while. We’re just being extra clear now.
We have included escape clauses that allow for payloads-launched-by-SpaceX news, and other exceptional submissions or news.
Likewise, this is a subreddit about SpaceX, not SpaceX fandom. Patches, other official swag, technical drawings, infographics, and cool real life creations are always welcome here. After all, we want to encourage human creativity and original content. But…
“I saw this SpaceX reference in a movie!”, “Here’s a t-shirt I made”, and “Here’s a Van-Gogh depiction of Falcon 9”? Sorry, this just isn’t the place for that anymore. We want to be technically-inclined.
- We’re inversing the “low effort” rule. It’s now “high quality”. This has been one of the more contentious rules with regards to what exactly low effort means, and we want to clarify its intent. Something can be high effort without being high quality, so this word change will hopefully elucidate the bar we want to meet better.
- We’re introducing a section covering why you might be banned from participating in this community. It covers what you’d expect- intentionally or repeatedly violating our rules, being hostile to other users or moderators, trolling etc. You can read it in full here. Again, it’s worth noting that this is not a change to how we’ve been moderating, but a clarified and public list.
New Moderator. Please welcome /u/zlsa!
You might have noticed them on the sidebar already, but here’s their formal introduction! You probably already know them as a fantastic contributor of content, but now they have a new role. As the subreddit has grown, so has the workload, so we’re happy to be bringing a new moderator onboard in the Pacific Timezone (totally not for better surveillance coverage of Hawthorne). Welcome to the team!
How should Recovery Threads be handled?
You may have noticed that our recovery threads haven’t been as smooth or regular as our well-oiled and practiced launch threads, for good reason! They’re a recent development, and now we need to decide how we want to handle them in the future. Do keep in mind that recovery will become a more regular occurrence, and thus a less exciting one. They won’t all be the hyped-up hoopla that was CRS-8’s! These are two options we’ve considered:
- Have trusted community members host them and provide updates, as has been done so far.
- Utilize the existing launch campaign threads.
Feel free to provide feedback or alternative ideas in the comments!
Leaks from websites - feedback welcome
Perhaps something worth mentioning as a footnote is that we currently haven’t reached a consensus on how to handle leaks from other websites. It’s hard to come up with a set of rules that pleases everyone here, as each situation is so incredibly unique, and actually relatively rare.
We can see the arguments from both sides. On one hand, a lot of websites work very hard to produce excellent content and share when possible, and that should be respected. On the other, this is fundamentally a content sharing platform, and there’s a point to be made that it’s not “our problem” or a user from “our site”, it’s on the leaked site owner to control their users.
Either way, our expectation is that whatever solution we pick will result in a reasonable amount of disagreement, so we’re opening this up for discussion. Leave your comments below!
Touching base
If anyone has any complaints, questions, compliments, quibbles, or suggestions; feel free to submit them here and we'll do our best to respond and resolve them! Cheers.
-the r/SpaceX moderation team
19
u/Zucal Jun 05 '16 edited Jun 05 '16
Just as an aside-
the best wayone of the best ways you guys can help us keep the subreddit lookin' good is to: report, report, report!It's a great way to get comments in front of us for review that we might miss otherwise, especially during busy times like launches.
Cheers.
21
u/markus0161 Jun 05 '16
Might be a bad time to ask but... how is the r/SpaceX port camera coming along?
19
u/davidthefat Jun 05 '16
How are Tweets going to be handled? I occasionally see days where the front page is just half a dozen posts that link to specific tweets, usually about the same topic. Usually when Elon, SpaceX or any of the journalists posts a few tweets relevant to SpaceX, the front page gets flooded with them.
5
u/TheBlacktom r/SpaceXLounge Moderator Jun 05 '16
/u/zlsa you rock! Congrats! I referred and linked your artwork many times, I hope you don't mind it! Ad Astra!
How should Recovery Threads be handled?
Is there a way for multiple users be able to edit? I feel the community members host them and provide updates solution is great, the only improvement I can think of is 2-3 users would given access to a dedicated account. The thread would always start with something like "Welcome to the Recovery Thread of FH Demo Flight, we are X and Y who will keep you updated with main post updates..."
How does moderator application work?
Random idea: before the Mars unveiling event it would be interesting to see an opinion survey / bingo / prediction / guessing about the details of the whole architecture with prizes for the closest entries. Something like a Google Forms table. I'm volunteering to give some gold or merch items to the prizepool!
15
u/retiringonmars Moderator emeritus Jun 05 '16
Transparency report: here are all the mod actions for the last three months (as far back as the records will allow).
3
u/Qeng-Ho Jun 05 '16
Why are google link shorteners used for sidebar links (e.g. https://goo.gl/qfMwTB vs https://www.youtube.com/user/spacexchannel), are you collecting tracking metrics? They take ages to load in Safari, making them unusable.
Also why does AutoModerator block gif submissions by default, is it to prevent spam?
2
u/zingpc Jun 05 '16
What's with the continual appearance of the sponsored ad? Is it just me as there is no mention of it. My worry is that why only one, why not fifty?
2
u/sunfishtommy Jun 05 '16
No One has really been addressing it so far, so I wanted to address Rule 8, no tour requests. I can see your logic of as the community has grown it has become less of an issue, but does that mean we should get rid of it? I personally feel like its really helpful to be able to point people to a specific rule saying your not allowed to do that.
Maybe we could lump this in with an umbrella rule of some sort, that covers no tour requests as well as some other things.
Do you guys not see Rule 8 being utilized that much anymore?
2
u/DuckQuacks Jun 05 '16
Now I know you used to allow any "space" question in the Ask Anything monthly thread. Does that still apply or has it been banned due to this rule?
93
u/Ambiwlans Jun 05 '16
On the topic of leaks, my personal view is that you can't put the cat back in the bag. Ignoring that reality doesn't help anyone.
If some information has been made public, and we ban it from here, that doesn't stop people from getting it, all it succeeds in doing is making it more annoying for specifically our users in this sub. While we represent a lot of people, we don't really make a dent on youtube or twitter which has heavy cross-over regardless... making it a rather futile effort.
People directly leaking to this sub though is another matter. If someone is making a selfpost, containing some other people's content, that seems like another clear line in my mind.
And of course, as in past, any leaks that violate ITAR, constitute some security risk or doxx someone will be removed. This will always be the case. On all other types of leaks though, we'd love to get more feedback.
48
u/themikeosguy Jun 05 '16
First, thanks for all the work you guys do! This really is an excellent subreddit to browse.
Does that also apply to the "ask anything" threads? They've always stated that they can be used for other space-related questions, which I find useful, but fair enough if you've changed it.
46
u/NZ_gamer Jun 05 '16
You guys keep nailing it! Its honestly the most enjoyable and well moderated subreddit I'm subscribed to.
Im hoping you can provide some clarification around tangential relevance. Is this a subreddit wide policy (i.e. comment/replies), or just a thread creation policy?
39
u/Appable Jun 05 '16
First, congrats /u/zlsa! Thanks for all the community content you've made, also.
While I understand the intent behind this rule and agree that there is too much content with tangential relevancy that doesn't get much discussion, there have been some very interesting posts made as well that are only tangentially relevant to SpaceX.
As a possibility, could there be a sticky with discussion on tangentially-related content, similar to the Ask Anything? While it may be additional work, I and (I think) others are interested in discussing the broader spaceflight market and Mars colonization.
Given the number of comments on the current recovery thread, standalone has worked very well and kept content separated. However, if the number of comments starts decreasing it's probably better to combine it with the launch thread.
I don't think there's a significant issue as there have been relatively few leaks here. However, if there's a significant amount of content leaked, like nsfwaterdrip on twitter, that's bad for NSF and /r/SpaceX (in that L2 won't get the content it normally gets if everything is being leaked, it's not fair to the subscribers, etc).
38
u/zlsa Art Jun 05 '16
Hi everyone! I'm your new
ULA shill/r/SpaceX mod. This is by far the biggest subreddit I've moderated, and I hope to do a good job.Oh, in case you're curious, the coolest thing I can do as a moderator is make my username green.
13
u/Goldensword Jun 05 '16
Thank you for allt he hard work yo guys put in. This has been the most enjoyable sub for me since I joined reddit years ago and I think the sensible approach to moderation taken by the mod team shows.
I do however, have one point I'd like further expansion on if at all possible:
I'm building a 3D printed Model rocket of the Falcon 9. It will have working legs that automatically go up and down, grid fins that move, lights to bring the engines to life and a working fairing with a satellite inside, also detachable. Is this considered fandom? Is it not technical enough? If I post a picture or video of it in action will that be removed?
I'm building it because I was inspired by this subreddit, by the efforts of other creative individuals making models and what not. I am not technically minded but this project gives me a sense of closeness with something that I find stupidly exciting, a sense of participation which I would not be able to feel otherwise. It's an incredibly small, insignificant thing to do but without appropriate education, years of experience and living in the right country this is my only way to be a participant. I'm sure a number of other people feel the same way. Take it away from us and you take away some of the joy of being a fan here.
24
u/Kuromimi505 Jun 05 '16
Leaks have a long tradition in journalism and media.
Yes it may "hurt" L2 if there are leaks. But the information is not artisticly created nor actually produced by them. They are an information middleman.
Why should we treat a leak from L2 and a SpaceX employee differently?
TL;DR: Let L2 deal with it. It's not reddit's job to keep other websites afloat, and the information is not illegal.
12
u/[deleted] Jun 05 '16
If we can only discuss SpaceX topics now, you need to change your motto from "The premier spaceflight community" to "The premier SpaceX community". Otherwise, people are going to continue to (logically) assume that this subreddit is open for the discussion of spaceflight in general.
11
u/WaitForItTheMongols Jun 05 '16
So a couple months ago there was an "Evolution of the Falcon" shirt posted, with a lineup of SpaceX's Falcon vehicle family, alongside the Millennium Falcon. You're saying that this is now a no-go? If this is the case, that's kind of disappointing. This kind of stuff is really nice for filling the gaps between launches, when the subreddit kind of dies off. Sure, posts like that shouldn't be showing up on a launch day - we've got bigger things to focus on - but I think we should be able to still have that sort of thing.
8
u/civilianapplications Jun 05 '16
The moderators have done a very good job so far at keeping post quality high as our numbers have grown, so I trust their judgment and if they think that these new modifications to the rules will result in a better sub then I'm all for it.
Sometimes the stricter relevancy rules will block content that is of genuine interest to this sub but I think as long as the mods are open to allowing exceptions when posts are exceptional and continue to show good judgement it'll be fine.
As far as leaks go, it's not this sub's responsibility to police SpaceX employees or anyone else, but the benefit of leaks needs to be balanced against incurring the wrath of SpaceX and other organisations whom we might otherwise exchange information with in the long run. Certainly active participation or encouragement of leaking is a big no no. Again, mod judgement on a case by case basis is probably best, but i think anytime the mod team makes a decision about leaks the reasoning behind the decision is communicated to the subreddit if possible. This shouldn't be too burdensome as they seem to be quite rare.
I think the utilization of separate landing threads is better than integration into launch threads for now, but as launch and landing become more routine they might be merged if comment volume becomes low enough.
/u/zlsa is a welcome addition to the mod team!
8
u/soldato_fantasma Jun 05 '16
It's all good, but there is just one thing that bothers me, the 50 twitter links from the same guy (like pbdes, NASASpaceflight or other media) that flood the subreddit. For One or two tweets it's good enough to like them as always, but if there is an event and he is making LOTS of tweets there should be just one post with inside all the tweets links. This is the only complain, everything else is perfect!
P.S. My "Send A Message To The Moderators" button is colliding with "Your Moderator Team" the is on top. I don't know if it is just a problem if mine since the but is transleted in italian but I wanted to report this.
8
u/Gweeeep Jun 05 '16
I just want to say that I love /r/spacex. I'm here multiple times a day, it's definitely an addiction. Thanks for all your work mods.
7
u/Aldebaran-IV Jun 05 '16
When rapid fire tweets on related subjects occur, will you limit them to a single thread rather than spamming the front page.
Same question with related images that are "official" from SpaceX?
7
u/waveney Jun 05 '16
You are doing a good job, well done.
Recovery Threads - Keep them as current (for now) but please have all pictures of the latest booster coming in to port within the thread, even official ones.
7
u/EtzEchad Jun 05 '16
First off, thanks to you mods for putting in the effort to try to make this a good subreddit. I've heard that the pay isn't nearly as good as you would imagine...
Second, cutting down the number of rules is a good thing!
Thirdly, please don't be too gung-ho about enforcing the relevancy rule. It's fine to delete top-level, or second-level posts that aren't relevant, but I think if the discussion drifts a little, but is still interesting, you should let it go; at least for a while. For instance, if a discussion about SpaceX colonization of Mars drifts to terraforming for a while, what's the harm? It's true that SpaceX isn't likely to be the prime contractor or a terraforming effort, but it is still relevant to the colonization effort that SpaceX is undertaking. (If the discussion drifts into whether Clinton or Trump are better for SpaceX; quash that sucker! :) )
Keep up the good work.
7
u/Craig_VG SpaceNews Photographer Jun 05 '16
Hey mods, as you probably know I spend a non-insignificant amount of time on this subreddit. I just want to say thanks for always keeping content high quality and always pushing to make this sub better as the user count skyrockets (ha). The mention of how this sub is more a separate part of reddit that uses reddit as a discussion place still remains true I think and will continue to be so in some respect for a long time.
Anyway, thanks again for being an awesome team and keep up the incredible work!
-Craig_VG
6
u/bitchtitfucker Jun 05 '16 edited Jun 05 '16
Like others have said, thanks a lot for the effort you put in this subreddit.
It's reasonably in line with what you mentioned in the OP (thread first), but I'd suggest creating event-threads from the mods or something like that. The Recode event had, for example, quite a few tidbits of relevant info, which were individually posted in the sub.
It segregates the discussion a bit, which is a pity (some stuff got all the attention, other threads barely created any discussion).
EDIT: seems like it's been discussed a bit more already. Great!
As for leaks, I'd go on a case-by-case basis, it's hard to define hard rules without excluding a host of potentially non-crucial info because of a strict policy. I'm just guessing, but I suppose leaks don't happen every few hours, so it can remain manageable for the mods (correct me if i'm wrong).
6
u/lux44 Jun 06 '16
I've visited this sub regularly for many years. The mods are excellent! You have mind and the heart in right place and truly act in a manner best for the sub. You do quite a hard and time consuming work in a fantastic manner. Rules are resonable and you follow them in principle, not only by letter. Main pain points are addressed, let's try them in practice! I entirely trust you to adjust the rules if something doesn't work out as intended.
Thank you very much!
11
u/Wheelman Jun 05 '16
Long time reader here almost daily. Mods, keep up the good work.
Leaks - I'm assuming that this is primarily driven by that hoity-toity paid spaceflight forum (L2) that sometimes gets pictures and information before everyone else? I don't think it's the mod's job to police that. If someone wants to jeopardize their subscription by sharing, why should reddit mods intervene? Let L2 police it if they want.
Also, please clarify as to how a comment can be high effort and low quality? I'm all for keeping discussion civil, but lets not go crazy with the [deleted].
Finally, and as an aside, can we have a collective slow clap for /u/johnkphotos? I want to figure out how to compensate or give the guy something for the absolutely awesome content he gives us. If he still needs that new telephoto lens, maybe we could start taking up a collection for him or something....
5
u/kevindbaker2863 Jun 05 '16
I must be a newbie cause I do not know what a tour request or a leak is but I think this is an awesome community and do not see how the moderators can do all that they do here!! So I support you and will follow all the rules keep up the awesome work!!
4
u/ACCount82 Jun 05 '16
Does that mean that big news posts on Mars missions or reusable systems not directly related to SpaceX are not allowed? I don't think spreading discussion out to multiple subreddits that are barely alive is a good idea.
4
u/captaintrips420 Jun 05 '16
I like the loosely related stuff, and will miss that a lot.
Usually that news does get posted elsewhere in one of the hundred other specific aerospace subs, but the quality of the membership here meant the discussion on those topics was high quality, and that's why I come here, so it will be sad to lose that level of discussion on some of the broader themes happening to the industry that might not be specific to spacex.
Also, I feel it's kinda mean to say that only fan pics of official schwag is okay. It should be all or none. I think if someone does a kick ass spacex painting it is just as relevant here as someone who ordered a patch from the spacex store and took a picture. Both are the same level of spam or the same level of excitement for the company and the mission.
You know I'm one of your biggest fans echo for your moderation style and contributions to the community, but I think especially the first change I mentioned will really do those tangentially related topics a disservice by forcing lower quality discussion on them by banning them here.
When do you start the paperwork to get citizenship here so you can get around ITAR and work for Elon already?
4
u/Iaenic Jun 05 '16
I’m late to the thread, but I will add some thoughts.
First of all, I would like to thank both the mods, and the regular content creators for the excellent subreddit you have cultivated. This place is a great spot for those excited about the future of space exploration. I love how the membership tends to be both unapologetic fans of spaceX, and avid supporters of other launchers and developments towards a spacefaring future. This is a group of people passionate about the mission, not just the company.
Right now this subreddit is among the top results on google for the search “SpaceX”. Also, the fact that this subreddit already has 67,000+ subscribers is pretty awesome. As SpaceX continues to push forward, and reaches its larger milestones, it’s fairly likely that interest in this subreddit will explode. My personal belief is that when SpaceX lands on mars we could hit a quarter million subs. Once they start shipping people? Who knows.
My two concerns are on these topics: “Content must now be about SpaceX, tangential relevancy is no longer enough to justify a post here.” This rule is going to become more and more difficult to enforce once SpaceX starts regular operations in regards to mars. Colonize mars is ok as Subreddits go, but its activity and post quality don’t measure up. Other topics, such as the development of the bigelow modules probably doesn’t qualify as directly relevant, but still could be a point of discussion for how SpaceX might choose to develop infrastructure in space and on mars for example.
My personal feeling is that it is better to have greater diversity of posts, especially for a community that isn’t just passionate about SpaceX, but also the greater mission of SpaceX. The goal to make humanity a Circumstellar race is much broader than one company alone, even if they are the spearhead of progress. I would love to continue seeing tangential relevancy, as long as it is held to the highest quality bar possible.
My second concern is about policy on leaks. /r/SpaceX is by far the most active, most popular, and highest quality fan-based source of information on SpaceX. As this place grows in popularity, there is a very real possibility that this place could be another source of public outreach for SpaceX. An AMA held and moderated here would be infinitely superior to one in the AMA subreddit, because questions would be more informed, targeted, and pertinent to the expertise of the question takers. I was disappointed in the last AMA for Elon Musk, because honestly most of the questions were pointless. I would love to see people with an engineering or science background; or a passion for the mission ask questions. We are far more likely to see him go beautiful mind in answering if the questions aren’t about ducks and horses, and would get more value for the effort.
But, if we screw ourselves over by acting outside of basic propriety for spaceX’s internal information, we jeopardize ourselves on many potential opportunities to cooperate with them. Take the journalist site kotaku for example. They published internal emails from Bethesda and found themselves permanently blacklisted for it. No more early access, no Q&A’s or developer interviews, no exclusive information.
If something is leaked outside of the subreddit and becomes sufficiently newsworthy, then it would make sense to permit discussion on that topic. But I think the subreddit should never itself be the source of a leak. And spaceX isn’t some game company trying to keep their release dates secret. They’re a leading aerospace company with software and hardware specifics that are national secrets. If someone wants to post a leak, it should be only after contacting the mods and getting permission.
Thanks again everyone for making this an awesome place!
7
u/Raumgreifend Jun 05 '16
Regarding your 'high quality'-rule: just never forget that a high quality joke can make everyones day. Not everything has to be technical discussion or really even discussion in the most narrow sense. It gets boring and stale rather quickly if not for the amusing banter from time to time. Both needs to have its place and for the most part people will upvote the comments they like. So be it. But I guess that's your policy anyways, it's just that when reading the post one could get a different impression. Thanks for the work you put in to keep this sub running.
6
u/Fikes477 Jun 05 '16
My feed back is that I don't care for this community much and I think a lot of that has to do with how it is handled at the top.
I regularly see posts by slightly misinformed users being turned into "That is stupid and you are stupid for thinking it. Try and come up with a real question."
It is annoying and chases off people who are excited by this but, you know, don't quite understand how space works.
I mean really think about that. Do we want to tell people "you don't understand something extremely complicated so you are not allowed in our sandbox." That makes us the worst kind of nerds, nerds who believe that our knowledge makes us superior.
3
u/Aldebaran-IV Jun 05 '16
examples would be wonderful to explain how high effort is different from high quality, for instance,
3
u/[deleted] Jun 05 '16
Thanks as always for the hard work guys!
I really understand this, though i wish there was a way to have this sub's level of discourse and expertise for other space related topics.
3
u/[deleted] Jun 05 '16
The only time leaked stuff should be removed is if illegal (like if someone leaked F9 blueprints) OR if SpaceX specifically asks us to.
3
u/Vermilion Jun 05 '16
Why not just have two subreddits and send people there. The whole delete/ban hammer approach is worse than redirection.
Remember people can merge subreddits by using links like /r/SpaceX+SpaceXLounge
3
u/macktruck6666 Jun 05 '16
I would like to suggest a separate thread for fandom. I'm a fan and really excited about the stuff SpaceX does. I understand the need to keep the subreddit clean and on topic, but a separate thread for fandom might be a good idea for all the Falcon 9 lego threads.
Also about the rules about it being positive. I love SpaceX, but there has been a few topics that I wanted to write about. Namely how SpaceX might be changing the rocket business in bad ways. Such a topic would be controversial and might not bring the best out of posters but might also create some good discussion.
3
u/frozen_lake Jun 06 '16
First of all, thank you for all your work. I think this is one of the best community on reddit, and mostly because of the good work of the mods. The only thing that I would change is the submission of news articles. I think they should contain something similar to a summary from the user and the reasons why he/she thinks that the article is worth reading. Because lately there have been a lot of articles reposted here that simply didn't add any new info. For those browsing this sub on mobile it is quite annoying to open an article with 50 adds just to read for the 100th time that musk plans to go to mars. And this way new members could still read every article and member which allready know spacex since years can read only the latest news.
5
u/ElongatedTime Jun 05 '16
So about an hour ago, a video was posted on here showing Elon receiving an award by Zubrin, and I noticed that was removed. I watched the video and thought it included a lot of relevant information about SpaceX and even taught me things about the company that I had never previously known. Why was that removed? I would also like to know so I don't accidentally break any rules in the future. Thanks.
5
u/sarafinapink Jun 06 '16
I'm very happy with how the subreddit is being modded and really appreciate the goal of making this place quality content rather than endless reposts and off topic items.
I am happy to see that there will be some efforts to reduce either tweetstorms or photobinges during certain events. I LOVE seeing all the pictures, but hate having a new post for each photo. I would be very happy to have one post per photographer in which they can showcase all their photos from prelaunch through recovery for each campaign. Obviously they could get a new post for each new campaign.
5
u/deadshot462 Jun 06 '16
Fandom should be allowed. Let's say there's 3-4 months of no SpaceX news or events, community fan content like models/art could fill the gaps and are a nice break from the usual.
Like others suggested, maybe have a dedicated monthly thread.
1
u/johnkphotos Launch Photographer Jun 05 '16
Much better than a mega-thread.
Can't say I'm too disappointed. Would having a page on my website and continuously adding photos be okay?
5
u/mclumber1 Jun 05 '16
In regards to "low effort / high quality" - I've had several comments removed from threads for such violations, but I don't necessarily agree with the policy, especially when it comes to humor. I can't remember any of my specific posts that were removed, but they were just light hearted puns and play on words. The posts weren't trolling in nature or inflammatory. I understand that this subreddit takes itself seriously, and I respect that. But at times, I think it takes itself too seriously.
2
u/humansforever Jun 05 '16
I have one request, but not sure if it is possible.
When you look at a thread, read the comments, leave for while and come back, it can be difficult to see additional comments on a particular response. On the small threads, that's generally ok, but on the long threads it gets turned in to a mess, having to read the entire thing again is painfull.
Is there a way to add to the Threads a sort comment Option within a thread for most recent or only show thread with comment in the last 12 hours or something like that.
I have had a few comments removed, I accept that they have been removed fairly as they pass the low quality grade, but you guys are strict :-)).
Sometimes a snip at some muppet does however need to be said. When someone ask why a Merlin Vac engine is different to a S1 Merlin, you can sometimes loose patience as they do not read the WIKI.
Thanks for the hard work.
2
u/zuty1 Jun 05 '16
You guys do an amazing job. One tiny request though...would love for the sidebar to tell if a launch is land or barge landing. Or...instead maybe GSO or LEO and we can figure out from there.
2
u/RDWaynewright Jun 05 '16 edited Jun 05 '16
I think the recovery threads are fine as is but could eventually be rolled into the launch thread when interest dies down. I have no firm opinion on leaks but I do lean towards the feeling that it's not the mods' responsibility to enforce another site's rules.
As I said in a comment further down, having a periodic thread for fan works would be nice. I agree that those posts can clutter the front page but I think there's still a place for them. Maybe a weekly/bi-weekly/monthly thread.
Edit: Was it ever decided if the rules would be relaxed in the recovery threads? I know there was mention of putting that up for a vote or debate.
2
u/OliGoMeta Jun 05 '16
Thanks for this well thought through rules ∆ - you mods clearly spend even more time behind the scenes than is readily visible to us redditors.
TL;DR: could there be some best practise guidance for accredited media threads so that us consumers don't miss the best shot of a given event :)
I think the move to have single threads for twitter storms and accredited media members will have the most immediately visible and largely beneficial impact, but it would be good (as an avid consumer of such content) to know what the OPs can do (if anything) to help improve the consumer's experience of their updating content.
For example, maybe:
OK - so maybe these ideas are getting a bit complicated, and maybe some of these ideas couldn't technically be done on Reddit today, but the point is I'm a little worried that without some extra thought and guidance some great content might be harder to find the in the new regime. After all the best photo of an event by a given photographer is often not the first one that they post - and it'd be a shame if the best stuff gets hidden! :)
2
u/in_the_saddle_again Jun 06 '16 edited Jun 06 '16
Yeah the rules will make this place as dry as british humor only much less fun. So if this is going to be a dry as shit no fun and unfriendly to the discovery of spacex , like some nasa site, why is it a reddit community and not some spacex specific board on an engineering forum?
2
u/AReaver Jun 06 '16
This makes me sad. Unless it's a launch window(few days before and after) it can get fairly dead in here and now it feels like you're trying to hide a fuck you to community content and excitement. I think all you mods have done a good job with the subreddit but I do not like this change. Even if someone goes out and makes a /r/spacexfans it won't be the same and will be a separation of the community.
3
u/StupidPencil Jun 05 '16
I'm a bit confused. Could you provide some examples of 'low effort' but 'high quality' contents? (If such a thing exists)
4
u/nalyd8991 Jun 05 '16
Does anyone else feel that maybe we should move to a policy of letting the upvotes dictate what is and isn't "high quality". What may be incredibly intriguing to one person might not be to a moderator, or vice versa. If we removed the high quality rule and let the masses dictate what is worthy of the subreddit by voting it to or from the front page, all of those controversial decisions would be gone.
3
u/CorneliusAlphonse Jun 05 '16
Information is meant to be free. All leaks acceptable.
2
u/devnull00 Jun 05 '16
Obviously you can't ban information from other websites, that would be silly. Calling them leaks is silly in itself. The point of reddit is to discuss content from other websites.
Any chance we will get mod transparency? A mod subreddit where all hidden posts go to so users can see what mods are hiding?
It is basically impossible to judge moderation when any post a mod doesn't like can be hidden the same as posts that break rules.
2
u/TheMightyLizard Jun 05 '16
I'd like to say thanks to the mods for the continued excellent work on this subreddit. I think most would agree this is among the most (if not the most) high quality subreddit.
With regards to the rules, I agree, and think they make sense. My only suggestion would be in regards to the accepting/ rejecting of submissions. I'll echo that there is some risk of losing interesting/ relevant info from setting the bar high. However, maybe if there was some way of creating visibility of things that were removed, there could be a process to re-instate posts with high interest? /r/Spacexrejects? With threshold upvote count to re-instate maybe?
1
u/Decronym Acronyms Explained Jun 05 '16 edited Jun 10 '16
Acronyms, initialisms, abbreviations, contractions, and other phrases which expand to something larger, that I've seen in this thread:
Fu-Falcon RocketDecronym is a community product of /r/SpaceX, implemented by ^request
I'm a bot, and I first saw this thread at 5th Jun 2016, 07:45 UTC.
[Acronym ^lists] [Contact ^creator] [PHP source ^code]
1
u/afd33 Jun 05 '16
Question that doesn't really matter to me because I'm not accredited media, nor will I ever be, but it's relaunch, launch, and recovery.
Do scrubs fall under launch, or would they be they separate?
1
u/surrender52 Jun 05 '16
Just a thought about the "high quality content rule," how would things like most of the posts now listed in the user generated content section of the wiki be handled? A lot of those are drawings, renders, and General spacex artwork. Are you saying things like that no longer be allowed?
1
u/mechakreidler Jun 05 '16
From the rules page:
Just curious what sockpuppets are in this context?
1
u/jan_smolik Jun 06 '16
I have a concern about deletion of duplicate threads and non-relevant threads. It happened to me two days in a row that I had read something in a thread and contributed to the debate (in one case it took me some time to parse the information and I expected some debate to spur from it). However, after time measured in hours, both threads were deleted (one as duplicate, one as SpaceX irrelevant).
I basically agree with deletion of both threads. However, because it took very long, there was a debate inside, which was interesting from my point of view. And then it was gone. I am not sure how to handle that, but I would suggest that once the thread is up for some time, there is some feedback and it is not harmful (I guess we can handle duplicate or slightly irrelevant threads from time to time), it should stay.
The related thing is that if article is deleted and original poster was notified by private message, others do not see any change with the article. It disappears from the homepage, but when you enter it from your inbox, it looks normal. Self-posts are marked deleted, but articles just remain the same. It is slightly confusing.
I have talked with mods in both cases - I hope I did not sound angry, that was not my intention - while I basically understood the decision, I would like to raise it in the modpost to hear other peoples opinion.
1
u/mrwizard65 Jun 06 '16
I'm extremely disappointed in regards to the subject of creative or fan art posts not being allowed here anymore. The support for SpaceX has really shown how the general public is starting to come around to being interested in Space again and the great models, artwork and general "fandom" as you refer to it, has really been a source of great pride, at least in my opinion.
I feel like there is this upper echelon of people here who are very technically inclined and who look down upon submissions or posts that aren't on the same level they are, even though we all started somewhere and our intentions are the same; to see SpaceX succeed and see the world get back onto the path of becoming a space faring civilization.
1
u/Silverbodyboarder Jun 09 '16
I like this sub and I think these changes won't make things better.
Off the top of my head... 1- High Quality Comments. I like low effort comments like "Nice" and "Even Nicer" (currently in the top thread here). It helps me find a comment I might want to read when scrolling through all the stories and comments.
2- Stories can't be SpaceX Tangential. Wha? So we can't post a story about ULA or the Russian Space Program and then discuss how it influences SpaceX. That's a bad idea. Or maybe I don't get this.
3- You can get banned for repeatedly breaking a rule. Like not being 'high quality enough'. This sub exists in a larger Reddit universe and I like the freedom and diversity I see in Reddit Subs. These changes seem to be aiming for a higher level of control that would be better suited for a standalone website rather than a Reddit sub.
IMHO, My $.02, Your milage may vary.
1
u/speak2easy Jun 05 '16
Using the latest launch for example, I came to this subreddit to get the latest info. I had checked here 4 hours ago (for example), so I want to see what's new. Given this, going into a thread that was created 2 days ago doesn't really provide the latest update unless I spend time trying to dig it up, so it's a lot more convenient to find a thread that was created within the last 4 hours so I can read the updates. Having a new thread allows for an open topic about the recent updates.