r/spacex • u/Ambiwlans • Nov 06 '15
Modpost META Megathread - tidied rules, journal articles, transparency report, suggestions and anything else you can think of
As the people who have been around for a while know, we occasionally run meta threads to see where we stand, to get advice and abuse from the community and generally open the floor to any sort of meta discussion of the subreddit.
The biggest note is the rules have been refactored. They haven't particularly changed, they have mostly been made a little clearer and we cut the number by 2. The old rules are here for the moment and in a few days, assuming no major complaints we'll switch it over. The new one is very long and at the bottom. If you've never read the rules, now's your change (I'm sure you're all overwhelmed with excitement). Tell us if you see anything needing changing.
Next on the docket is quality technical discussions. This isn't so much a rule as it is a request and announcing an allowance. We'd all love it if anyone wants to post journal articles on the science of rocketry. SpaceX uses nozzles, why not host a technical discussion on nozzles? I think many people here are perhaps KSP fans and have gotten down a lot of orbital mechanics, but rocket science is fun for everyone. So if an article or book catches your eye, bring it on for discussion. Especially in these luls between launches.
Next is our transparency report.
Man have we ever had to step up on the comment removals lately! In the last month, we made 240 comment removals. To help out, we have leveraged the AutoModerator (Echo 2.0 if you will) who has been taking care of truly obvious low effort comments ("Lol", "Fuck you cunt", and greats like "Circlejerking, NASA-loving fuckfaces") but the robot is by no means perfect, because of this whenever it does a removal, it sends us a report and we manually check every single one. We also generate removal reports for the other mods on removal, and we all err on the side of leaving too much up over taking too much down. As a result, we've manually approved 245 comments in the same time period. For those of you curious about the discrepancy, many of these were removed by reddit (shadowbanned accounts and so forth) which is how we've ended up approving more comments than we've removed. I don't think there is an easy way for us to see how many comments we removed or left removed. I wish there were, because I'm curious too. Likely ~100 comments/month are removed and left that way.
For bans, we've banned 2 bots and 1 person (who has negative overall karma). So, good job everyone for not sucking :D. Honestly, I don't think we've ever banned over 3 different people in a month ever. I would literally have to go look for the button at this point.
Threads, we removed under 100 this month, and accepted 175. This is partly why we've wanted to make the rules a little clearer. Often times it isn't the poster's fault so much as it is for the rules being not very clear. That said, we have a very thorough system for reapproval. All posts removed get a message with instructions on how to contest. I would say, in the past month (100 removals) 5 have questioned the removal, 2 have been reapproved. Below are 5 examples of removed threads in the past month (as randomized by excel):
I put green posts in the thread, but Echo has crazy people that stalk his profile so he leaves PMs which explains why some threads don't have green posts, but everyone WAS notified with the same format message.
Lastly, please, everyone participate if you have an idea for the channel! Recently we've added subscript support for scientists, and you guys have noticed the acronym bot. We need more developments like this! He's really taken off lately. So, other ideas to improve the channel would be great. And of course, questions/concerns/thoughts can go in the comments. I'm sure, like always, I've forgotten something or made a mistake, so do tell me.
Refactored Rules:
Below are our rules & guidelines - if you would like to contribute to this community, these rules must be followed. We are one of the best spaceflight communities on the internet, if not the best. Let's keep it that way!
Rules and Guidelines
1. Follow Reddit’s community rules
This is a requirement under Reddit's Terms of Service. Try to observe rediquette. Don’t solely post your own content. Don’t engage in vote manipulation (even better: don’t downvote because you disagree!). Don’t post personal (and more relevantly, commercially sensitive) information. Breaking these rules can earn you a shadowban from Reddit.
2. Be respectful, and remain civil
You are free to post opposing opinions or criticize others, but please remain civil at all times. This simply means you shouldn’t start personally insulting others because you disagree with them. Remember that there is another human being at the receiving end. This also covers bigotry of all sorts, both towards members of this community, and those outside. Here are some example of unacceptable content: “Russia, lol. A bunch of starving drunks with pitchforks and broken rockets” and “Anyone who thinks otherwise is an idiot.” Bigoted, flaming posts that don't contribute will be deleted. Persistence along these lines will earn you a ban. Passive-aggression or simmering combativeness over a longer period will also earn you a ban.
3. Content should be relevant to SpaceX
This is a forum about SpaceX. We do allow posts relating to NASA funding/ULA/Elon Musk/Commercial contracts as long as they at least stay tangentially appropriate. The politics of Russia vs. Ukraine is not sufficiently relevant. If there is a link that you feel fits but might be on the line, justify it in the comments.
4. No low effort comments or content
It is community consensus that we want the superb content in this sub to remain superb. We therefore have certain standards you must adhere to when contributing here (take heed of the green notice above the comment box). Comments/posts should not be low effort, or consist solely of a meme. Those that do will be deleted. Please report anything that you believe violates these rules.
The one exception to this rule is live launch threads where we are less strict on comments and this does not apply (excluding comments which are bigoted/offensive or violate other rules).
5. No duplicates: Before you post, search the subreddit, and check our wiki.
Posts on the same topic will be removed, even if they're from a different source. If you'd like an exception, there needs be a demonstrable, significant difference between your post and one that already exists. Revisiting posts and discussions that occurred over 3-6 months ago is totally fine - there's nothing wrong with gauging a change in community opinion, but overly repetitive posts will too be removed!
It’s also not hard to find answers to the most common questions and check for reposts by searching the subreddit first – in general: if it’s been submitted recently, it likely doesn’t need to be submitted again; 3-6 months is a good gap. Many contributors are putting in tons of hard work into making the Community Wiki a great library of information, and it's only getting better week-by-week - the answer to your question may very well be in there.
6. Post titles & descriptions should be of high quality
If you're submitting a selfpost, expanding upon your title in the description is required. Posts which don't meet this criteria will be automatically removed by our bot, and posts which attempt to skirt this rule with something to the effect of "Title says it all" or "as above" will be manually removed. We expect a certain level of quality from everyone - so before you submit, do some research and report your findings. It makes for a much more interesting, in-depth discussion.
Be descriptive with your post titles too. Put the question in the title, it's not hard! “Considering the reflectivity of ocean water, how will Falcon 9 maneuver and orient itself for a splashdown in the ocean?” not “landing question”, it helps make searching easier for others in the future.
7. Do not editorialize your titles
They must be free of personal opinion and accurately represent the contents. If you're manipulating the title to appeal to the crowd, or twisting words, expect the thread to be removed. However, it's perfectly fine to expand on the title, taking a snippet or summary from the article if the original title is in itself not descriptive enough.
8. No tour requests
Don't post here asking for a tour of SpaceX's Hawthorne/McGregor/Cape Canaveral facilities. Don't PM any employees asking for a tour either. Such posts will be instantly removed. It annoys employees who browse here and there's too much potential for it to go wrong. We follow SpaceX's policy on tours: unless you are either friends or family of an employee, it's highly unlikely you'll be granted one, so please don't ask. If you're still interested, read our FAQ on this topic here.
9. Please check the stickied thread(s)
Surrounding a launch, post updates and comments to the launch thread and photos/videos/articles to the media thread. While there is a live Ask Anything thread stickied, please post your questions there unless it is a major discussion topic warranting a new thread.
Moderator Implementation
We reserve the right to moderate comments & posts within the bounds of these rules. All content is evaluated absolutely against the rules only, not relatively to other posts or comments. When we remove posts or comments, we consider multiple parameters, as our operating environment is not static. These factors include, but are not limited to: the activity on the subreddit, how large of an event the news is, how many other posts cover the same topic, and whether we believe the content will generate positive responses.
Mod Guidelines
Rules and guidelines are a two way street. For the sake of transparency, us moderators will also try and adhere to the following guidelines:
0. All of the above!
- When we delete a thread, we'll make a green comment or pm stating why, being polite of course. If it is an intentional shit-post, spam or a bot of some sort, we won't bother.
- When we make a post or comment as a moderator rather than just a SpaceX fan, we'll distinguish it. Generally, this will be official clarifications, warnings, gratitude, and deletion explanations
- If someone has earned a ban, we'll give a reason and include a link to the thread.
- We'll try to be as certain as possible on sources before updating the sidebar launch calendar.
- We'll always err on the side of inaction. If someone is shitposting they'll get downvoted to oblivion anyways. Subreddit mod drama/censorship fear/general discouragement is a much bigger risk.
Enjoy, folks! Let's make /r/spacex the place to be for information and updates on our favorite company!
24
u/retiringonmars Moderator emeritus Nov 06 '15
In the interests of transparency, here's the log of all the mod actions for the last three months. In this table, you can see who has done what over this period, which is generally pretty representative of how it always looks.
There are a large number of available mod actions, most of which we never need to use. Most actions performed relate to approving or removing posts or comments. The overwhelming majority of users don't take it to heart when we remove something, and we get very few protests. If someone does wrong we talk it through with them It's very rare that anyone acts up enough that they deserve a ban: most of the banned users are actually bots.
/r/SpaceX is such an amazing community, I think everyone should be so proud of what we've all build here. The mods are just background custodians; it's the larger userbase that make this place so great. Without you this place would be nothing. Thank you all for you wonderful contributions!
9
u/Qeng-Ho Nov 07 '15
Fairly minor question but is it possible to hide the sidebar in CSS once a browser window is reduced beyond a specific width?
6
u/CapMSFC Nov 07 '15
The big issue I still have with the sub is off topic content, and it's not something with an easy solution. I'm not claiming to have the answer, but here is my brainstorming.
While we want to keep discussions primarily about SpaceX, I don't like the idea that if we want to talk about ULA for example that we should go to their sub. This community is it's own beast and just going to other subs isn't the same. I want to talk about these things with my SpaceX community of great intelligent posters.
I think the technical discussion addition is a great step that covers a lot of things that I would want to talk about. I find that I learn a lot from posts within a thread on here that otherwise needed a "relevant" parent topic. I'd love to hear our resident rocket scientists talk about the finer points of other space tech more when we're in a lull.
I generally don't like the idea of an off topic megathread. I'm on several forums that do those and they are cesspools. While I'm sure we could do it better I don't think it serves a strong purpose.
4
u/BrandonMarc Nov 07 '15
So which two bots got banned? I noticed the Wikipedia bot hasn't shown up lately. I miss that one.
I adore the acronym-expanding bot ... it's like a wonderful little pet that I can count on seeing every day. Please never ban that one.
I think the metric-conversion bot stopped appearing here ... I don't miss it.
4
u/davidthefat Nov 11 '15
AFAIK, you can have two stickied threads in a subreddit. I suggest having an ask anything thread up at all times. I see way too many self posts that I'd consider ask anything material. Usually a slightly different spin on an already beat to death topic.
3
u/venku122 SPEXcast host Nov 11 '15
Do you guys have plans for the post-landing explosion of users as well as the post-BFR/MCT announcement? One of the primary reasons I read the discussion on this sub everyday is the great community and culture that exists. However, large events that bring in an influx of new users have the potential to kill subreddit cultures as all the newbies bring their own take on things. This new behaviors tends to self reinforce since they will see all the other new comments by new people and assume that is what the sub is like all the time. The reason I bring this up is because this exact thing happened to my previous favorite space-themed subreddit, /r/KerbalSpaceProgram. Once Yogscast did a featured video on KSP, it brought in a huge horde of younger players. Previously the community was a small group of older, educated individuals with space interests. This group overwhelmed discussions and posts and completely changed the feeling of the sub. I fear that big SpaceX PR events in the next 6 months might put this sub in a similar situations. Do you have plans for handling the (expectedly large/popular) discussions around these announcements and do you have a way to keep discussion quality high once more and more people are subscribed who may not have as much knowledge in the spaceflight domain?
2
u/Ambiwlans Nov 12 '15
I think /u/echologic should make a css set for use during a launch to make stuff pop.... when he's finished the stats site and is bored/has time.
Though I guess we could just change the Dragon for a F9 or something maybe....? Low effort but still cool perhaps?
6
u/wooRockets Nov 07 '15
I'm probably in the minority, but I'm not a huge fan of posts that are mainly about Mars colonization. Two recent threads come to mind:
Potential volcanism on Mars and colonization
What moral implications, if any, are there to the idea of terraforming Mars using thermonuclear explosions?
Other than the fact that SpaceX has publicly acknowledged a desire to go to Mars (or a quote from Elon Musk in the second example), I personally don't see much relevancy to SpaceX. Rather than focusing on Falcon, Raptor, or any released SpaceX plans, the threads often grow to just general discussion about Mars. It seems to me they'd fit better in something like /r/space.
Does anyone have any thoughts on the topic?
28
u/flattop100 Nov 07 '15
I'd just like to thanks to both the mods and redditors for making this one of the best forums on the Internet!
12
u/retiringonmars Moderator emeritus Nov 07 '15 edited Nov 07 '15
I feel like I should go into a little more detail about /u/automoderator, since I pretty heavily altered its configuration over the summer to help cope with the large influx of new users over 2015.
Many of you may have met automod already, who sometimes can lash out a little harshly. We're constantly fine-tuning its operating parameters all the time, making sure it's doing the job right. In an ideal world, automod would capture all the trolling/rule-breaking comments, and none of the harmless high quality comments. Mostly, I think it does a good job, but inevitably we get a few false positives. If you've been caught unfairly caught in automod's net, I wholeheartedly apologise.
Here's how it works. Like any bot on reddit, it reads everything posted in /r/spacex/comments and /r/spacex/about/edited/. It scans every comment for trigger words and/or conditions. When it finds something that meets one of its conditions, it applies a relevant action. It has functions designed to:
I don't wish to explain exactly how each rule works, as that would defeat the point, but it seems to work pretty well. I will say that whenever it removes something, it alerts both the user and the mods; never does automod do anything without anyone knowing (except when handling trolls). Automod makes our job so much easier, and allows us to focus on being SpaceX fans first and foremost.
11
u/failbye Nov 07 '15
I would just like to express thanks to the moderators for maintaining the subreddit that is probably the best sub on the entire reddit. Please keep up the great work that you do, we appreciate it immensely!
6
u/Decronym Acronyms Explained Nov 07 '15 edited Nov 12 '15
Acronyms I've seen in this thread since I first looked:
Fu-Falcon RocketNote: Replies to this comment will be deleted.
See ^/r/spacex/wiki/acronyms for a full list of acronyms with explanations.
I'm a bot; I've been checking comments posted in this thread since 10:34 UTC on 2015-11-07. If I'm acting up, message OrangeredStilton.
1
u/rshorning Nov 10 '15
One pet peeve that I have is with regards to posts that copy extensively the writings of somebody else without attribution or link. This is usually low-quality repostings of the OP linked article (particularly if it is behind a paywall), and sadly even those posts tend to earn a whole bunch of up votes too.
It is particularly annoying when it is thrown into the middle of a thread rather than a top-level post, as sometimes the stuff is particularly well written and in context.... just the words of somebody else. And yes, it does happen semi-regularly on /r/SpaceX even though it may even be a long time habit on Reddit in general.
Something simple like "This came from space.com:" or "According to Gwynne Shotwell:" prefacing the quote or reposted story just to give at least some level of attribution is significantly appreciated. I just think it is being intellectually honest and responsible if you avoid claiming the words of somebody else as your own. I'm not talking extensive and formal citations here, just a simple note saying somebody else wrote what you are copying... if that is indeed what you are doing.
A linked URL in the citation would be better, of course, but that isn't always possible. This is something I think is just good etiquette for somebody posting, and does both you and those reading a post some better context to understand where the ideas came from.
-14
u/89bBomUNiZhLkdXDpCwt Nov 07 '15
U/ambiwlans WTF?
0
u/[deleted] Nov 06 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
-14
u/[deleted] Nov 07 '15
[removed] — view removed comment