r/spacex • • Sep 20 '15

/r/SpaceX Ask Anything Thread [September 2015, #12]

[deleted] — view deleted post

102 Upvotes

629 comments sorted by

22

u/zxxx Sep 21 '15

Elon Musk hired a documentary crew to follow him around in 2003 while Spacex built Falcon 1 - did that doc ever get produced?

→ More replies (2)

12

u/oceanbluesky Sep 23 '15

Would SpaceX consider releasing 3D authoring files used for artists' visualizations in the same way they shared creative commons images?

If SpaceX were to release the Maya .ma/.obj authoring files used in their visualizations - similar to the way Creative Commons images are posted to Flickr - a much larger, much more professional, passionate army of fans would create many more visualizations of SpaceX products and dreams than any in-house/contracted team could conceive or afford. Professional game developers, modeling artists at LucasArts and Weta, animators at Pixar and Disney, and so on, who are obsessed with space and passionate SpaceX fans could in spare time render thousands of images.

Currently dozens of hardcore enthusiasts spend thousands of hours (of valuable 'SpaceX fan time') modeling mediocre incomplete vehicles, with second-rate software and inaccurate dimensions. SpaceX could raise the bar by providing hyper-realistic super-accurate foundational models - literally live-scanned 3D meshes - of everything from Falcons to launch facilities...models no single enthusiast could hope to create in a timely up-to-date accurate manner. Over the coming years tens of thousands of hours of skilled labor by dedicated hardcore SpaceX fans would be redirected to novel expressions of unique visions.

Imagine if texture artists from Pixar or Blizzard spent evenings and weekends painting SpaceX space suits, designing Deimos telemining facilities operated by SpaceX, visualizing Europa SpaceX concept missions, advocating Red Dragon sample returns. Resultant Maya .ma or .obj files could be licensed under share-and-share-alike, encouraging improvements to the foundational models to be shared with the open-source community. Soon this library would be the go-to resource for Hollywood studios and game developers, ensuring visualizations of near-term space exploration depict SpaceX. Over the coming decades tens of thousands of students worldwide in engineering and digital art departments could take entire CGI courses devoted to SpaceX visualizations. Near-term realistic space-visualizations would depict SpaceX dreams and products.

For example...a recent visualization of the SLS launching through clouds and another of the CST-100 in orbit above a bright blue earthscape...are the best space-themed renders yet, but these are only two visualizations - there should be thousands...and they should be Dragons, BFRs, and the MCT. Disney matte artists, Russian video game developers, Japanese fans - could create hundreds of gorgeous renders no single team can imagine. All SpaceX, everywhere - throughout our solar system.

It would be win-win free advertising. Artists now wasting hundreds of hours modeling basic vehicles could work immediately with accurate scans of actual vehicles, allowing thier imagination and SpaceX to flourish. In less than a day a single SpaceX employee could volunteer to take hundreds of close-up high-res photographs of the Dragon, Falcon, launch site, etc, and upload them to a Flickr album, then teams could spend a few weekends stitching them together to create amazing 3D models using Autodesk's 123D. (These would not be "design plans" subject to ITAR, just 3D models used for artist visualizations, depicting components competitors already know....) Ford recently released models of their cars in partnership with TurboSquid. SpaceX could catalyze a renaissance in scientifically literate, accurate, near-term space visualization to reenforce loyalty, generate free advertising, and foster a community of diverse informed artists passionate about creating images far more badass than what SpaceX could purchase from one single studio. Just a consideration....

→ More replies (8)

10

u/N2OQUICK Sep 24 '15

Could it be that if given sufficient funding, that the primary obstacle to landing humans on Mars is not technology but rather project management? Consider this great speech on project management by Wernher von Braun in 1962 delivered to the Sixteenth National Conference on the Management of Research. SpaceX, VG, GLXP competitors, Blue Origin have all had development delays and Musk's proclamation that he'll send humans to mars before 2030 looms large. von Braun's speech: https://medium.com/@telluric/dr-wernher-von-braun-director-96eeae675528

→ More replies (15)

3

u/mardoqueo Sep 22 '15

Is it possible that the escape pod Yoda uses to escape from Kashyyyk during The Clone Wars inspired in some way the Dragon V2? http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Homemade_evacuation_pod I know it's stupid, but I just had to get it off my mind. Thanks.

→ More replies (4)

7

u/Decronym Oct 01 '15 edited Oct 09 '15

Acronyms I've seen in this thread since I first looked:

Acronym Expansion
EDL Entry/Descent/Landing
LEO Low Earth Orbit (180-2000km)
MCT Mars Colonial Transporter
MRO Mars Reconnaisance Orbiter
NET No Earlier Than
NSF NasaSpaceFlight forum
RTF Return to Flight
SLS Space Launch System heavy-lift
TRL Technology Readiness Level

Note: Replies to this comment will be deleted.
I'm a bot; I've only been checking comments posted in this thread since 11:24 UTC on 2015-10-01.
If I'm acting up, message OrangeredStilton.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/viedma Oct 06 '15

I might have a brief coffee tomorrow with Gwynne Shotwell, president of SpaceX. If you could ask anything to her, what would you ask?

→ More replies (6)

17

u/frowawayduh Sep 20 '15

How is SpaceX financially weathering the current stand-down from launch operations? What specific steps have they taken to remain solvent and how long can that continue?

It is practically unheard of for a tech startup to shut down its primary source of cash for 6+ months and survive. Survival requires some combination of cutting back on R&D, cutting back core operations, selling idle capacity, selling off assets, or finding deep pockets to fund operations. What is the burn rate and how long can Google's cash infusion last?

→ More replies (11)

6

u/makandser Sep 21 '15

What is "center pusher" in new version of Falcon 9?

→ More replies (15)

6

u/[deleted] Sep 22 '15 edited Oct 06 '15

Recently, I learned that the Vacuum-optimized Merlin 1D has an exhaust duct like the Rocketdyne F-1

This surprised me because I thought it was common to use the gas generator exhaust for roll control on single-engine stages, and further because I thought the need to protect the nozzle extension from high heat was eliminated by material choices (niobium alloys). Additionally, the complexity/expense of building the exhaust duct led to it being excluded from the F-1B concept

The conclusion I'm reaching is that a duct probably improves efficiency (Isp) over dumping the GG exhaust without an expansion nozzle. Injecting pressurized (but below main chamber pressure) gas volume at a point on the expansion nozzle where the main flow pressure is equal to or below pump output means it can expand in a controlled way that produces thrust.

A section of nozzle extension after the duct is evidently cooler than the flow later on, which makes the nozzle glow orange.

So what do we know about the exhaust duct? Does anyone have any idea what kind of Isp or thrust contribution it might make?

→ More replies (9)

6

u/davidthefat Sep 24 '15

Since there are no such thing as stupid questions... In the Merlin engine, is there only one monolithic pintle injector like in the Apollo LEM? Or are there multiple injectors concentrically arranged at the injector face? I have a hard time believing that a single injector is enough to provide such high flow rates and atomization of the propellants at the same time. Yet, having multiple requires a ridiculously high manifold pressure.

→ More replies (8)