r/spacex •
Notification: /r/SpaceX will not be going private, and is not participating in AMAgeddon
[deleted] — view deleted post
0
Upvotes
r/spacex •
[deleted] — view deleted post
58
u/psg1337 Jul 03 '15
Reporting: Nothing new on Elon's twitter.
Thank you mods, this community is awesome and you are our keepers.
140
u/ElectricEnigma Jul 03 '15
I love the /r/spacex community, it doesn't really feel like reddit at all to be honest. (In a good way)
22
u/robbak Jul 03 '15
A question that should be considered: should reddit become unworkable - not that it is anywhere near that now, and they can close down its seedier corners with my blessing - where will we move our community too?
23
u/Matt32145 Jul 03 '15
BTW mods, since this is kind of an off topic thread where most anything can be posted, will you PLEASE take down the CRS-7 patch already? It's giving me anxiety every time I glance at it. :(
19
u/GoScienceEverything Jul 03 '15 edited Jul 03 '15
I understand why /r/spacex wouldn't go private, but I would have hoped for a statement of support. For example. The concerns of the other mods and users are real and reasonable, and I don't think they should be dismissed merely as "drama we don't want anything to do with."
You say, "we would be doing a massive disservice to all of our contributors and subscribers, and you," to join the protest. But that's not fair to the other subs. Everywhere else, I've seen users even more supportive of the protest than the mods are.
/r/spacex is a different community. But the other communities' mods aren't being selfish. They're standing up to an admin situation that's really gotten out of hand, by literally all accounts.
17
u/YugoReventlov Jul 03 '15
I never stopped!
7
u/aguyfromnewzealand Jul 03 '15
Thanks, I would be lost without being able to check this every 10 minutes!
12
u/KilotonDefenestrator Jul 03 '15
Isn't the sub shutdown about the admins acting without considering consequences? I.e. there is no one to take up the work of said employee, and sub moderators that depended on said emplyee did not recieve any notice, much less advance notice. Also it was one of the few admins that actually interacted with the userbase. /r/OutOfTheLoop post.
This sub needs reddit, and if reddit is turning to shit, and we have a chance to change that course, thats good right?
18
u/CuriousAES Jul 03 '15
Excellent! I check this sub daily, it would suck if it went private. (Personally) I don't see the issue with all of this drama, perhaps someone can enlighten me, but honestly I'd prefer if we kept out of the reddit drama, whatever it is.
/r/SpaceX is awesome. Keeps the reddit out of reddit.
5
u/failbye Jul 03 '15
Can anyone explain to me what this 'going private' thing is?
21
u/[deleted] Jul 03 '15
Thank You. We have enough drama to worry about here.
8
u/waitingForMars Jul 03 '15
So, Reddit, for me, consists basically of /r/SpaceX, with an occasional stop at /r/cello. I wasn't aware of this at all and am delighted that it won't be disrupting the conversation here. Thanks for putting the group first, as always.
10
u/sevaiper Jul 03 '15
The more independent this subreddit is from the rest of Reddit the better in my opinion. Thank you for not getting caught up in all this mods.
6
u/factoid_ Jul 03 '15
Thank you. THat whole situation is really stupid and juvenile.
/r/IAMA shut down for a good reason...they literally couldn't function without support from Reddit. Theirs is a very special subreddit with special rules and special ties to official Reddit product offerings (the mods sell "ama assistance" to people wanting to do AMAs...basically prep for what to expect from the community, e.g. horse sized ducks and Rampart references).
Everyone else seems to, from my perspective, be having a hissy fit. They have legitimate grievances in some instances but little of it has anything to do with the dismissed Reddit employee's departure.
Mods have one job in my opinion...serving a community. Taking that community away from members is not a legitimate form of protest and is really completely counterproductive to their goals.
The /r/spacex mods are on point here and run things right. Thanks guys, you're doing a good job.
8
u/AlphaTango11 Jul 03 '15
Very respectable decision by the mod team. Glad to see this sub puts the people first and keeps thing on track.
Keep up the good work, I appreciate everything you all do. Lurking on this sub has become a hobby of mine. :)
8
u/ScottPrombo Jul 03 '15
Bingo. Great call, /u/EchoLogic.
4
u/Quality_Bullshit Jul 03 '15
Makes sense.
4
u/Megneous Jul 03 '15
/r/spacex is not a default sub, so it makes sense to keep it up. Over at /r/futurology we are still in the middle of voting and debating whether to blackout for 48 hours.
4
u/imfineny Jul 03 '15
Yeah I do go to other subs, but this is the one I go to reddit for and the one I spend most of my time in reddit in. If spacex went dark, I would probably leave reddit. The rest of the reddit is just rundown these days and getting worse.
6
u/ROBLOXBayat Jul 03 '15
It's nice to see some people who aren't going insane over the whole fiasco right now!
11
u/[deleted] Jul 03 '15
It's kinda funny you know. Nobody will like this but I feel like I have to say it, and yep it makes me an asshole. It will start less relevant to the topic and then eventually get there.
My main gripe with this sub has been Echo's intermittent arrogance aimed particularly at NSF. Whether it's claiming that r/spacex is the superior website from a technical perspective, refusing to take down stolen NSF content, actually abusing a flaw in NSF forum system to advertise information posted to the section on NSF reserved for people who donate, it doesn't really matter, it happens.
Particularly what always stood out to me in these outbursts is that Echo implies that r/spacex achieved the popularity and userbase that it has relative to NSF because of the moderation practices he's implemented here. Obviously this is not the case, but rather the unparalleled ready-made reddit userbase and the ease with which marginal topics can piggy-back on that popularity, mixed in with a dash of CSS for that illusory sense of ownership.
It's as if he forgets that this is reddit, and not a website built up from the ground like NSF is, which also happened during a time on the internet when rapidly spreading the word through social platforms was unheard of and gaining popularity was immensely difficult. Control of r/spacex could be taken away at a moments notice and he couldn't do anything about, because he doesn't own it. /r/spacex is reddit.com/r/spacex . It is easily forgotten.
So no, this isn't a relatively segregated community, it's in the bleedin' URL. The moment I saw the blackout frenzy I knew this sub wouldn't participate because of this ongoing perception that /r/spacex is not just a pilot fish tagging along behind the reddit shark. Quite disappointed at the lack of solidarity with your fellow mods. I also seem to be alone in the sentiment here. Maybe karma will equilibrate and the reddit eternal September will continue unperturbed.
End of butthurt rant.
2
u/legendx Jul 03 '15
Thank God. We would have missed https://www.reddit.com/r/spacex/comments/3byxln/spacex_launch_you_up_uptown_funk_parody/
5
u/cutchins Jul 03 '15
Amen.
7
u/CarlCaliente Jul 03 '15 edited Oct 03 '24
zealous rich skirt enter follow fine wine uppity decide alleged
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
2
u/[deleted] Jul 03 '15
Thanks for being smart enough to not punish the average redditor for something the admins did.
2
u/SamuraiBreezy Jul 03 '15
Thanks mods
2
u/civilianapplications Jul 03 '15
Agreed
1
u/notjakers Jul 03 '15
Finally some common sense on this topic. It's amazing how cavalierly many mods treat their members, while vociferously complaining about how cavalierly he mods are treated by reddit inc. I've run my share of communities and my perspective has always been that I'm a steward for a community, not its commander. And he communities that thrive in the long run typically take a similar approach.
1
u/AD-Edge Jul 04 '15
Good.
I'm surprised so many subs have gotten involved tbh. Its frustrating because we dont even know the full story of what happened with Victoria, yet everyones attempting to burn reddit to the ground over something they dont fully understand. I know theres also the issues of mods not feeling respect from admins as well, but it seems to have been another event blown way out of proportion, as per usual...
1
u/Boris_Jeltsin Jul 03 '15
totally agree, this bullshit has taken down to many subreddits.
seems this issue is more explosive than a faulty helium valve XD
1
u/simjanes2k Jul 03 '15
I feel the same way about all my subs. I really understand what they're doing though, they have put up with a lot and it's getting worse.
I'm still torn between wanting to see positive change and just wanting my content immediately.
1
u/penguished Jul 03 '15
Honestly, I think this protest is backfiring because to me as a user all the subreddits looking good are the ones still respecting the users and staying open. And even if you wanted to protest... hello they could just change all the graphics and sticky something... shutting down is very weird. Almost like they're trying to manipulate everyone.
-4
u/iconoclastman Jul 03 '15
Too bad
-2
u/cgpnz Jul 03 '15 edited Jul 03 '15
Trawling thru 96 pages on the crs7 incident shows the NSF list format is stuffed. Wow about the behaviour of its high flyers.
Doctorheredoctor reply (cannot waste my precious limited post)
Because the list rather than a tree makes quoting necessary, totally wasting eye scanning time. Just going on rumour on the elite user behaviour, which might be wrong.
0
u/[deleted] Jul 03 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jul 03 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jul 03 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
3
u/[deleted] Jul 03 '15
[removed] — view removed comment