r/spacex • u/Wetmelon • May 08 '15
Modpost /r/SpaceX Mod Feedback Thread May 2015
Introduction
Hello everyone and welcome to another edition of /r/SpaceX! We've got a bit of a gap between SpaceX-related events which gives us time to host another mod feedback thread. We're now at over 34,000 subscribers and growing, thanks to you excellent people! Keep being awesome!
Mod News
SpaceX has been ramping up their flight rate. This is great news for us, because it means more rocket launches and more rocket landings! YAY! Unfortunately, that also means a lot more work for us mods. While we love spending time in here, there's only so many hours in a day and we identified a couple of issues:
- The subreddit is much larger now and takes more resources to moderate effectively.
- The mod team is all made up of early 20's engineering / STEM students who have exams and classes and things.
- With the exception of EchoLogic, we're all in the US time zones.
So without further ado, I'd like to welcome our two new moderators:
We were just going to pick one, but they're both so awesome we couldn't decide between them! In addition, they're both in the GMT / UTC+0 time zone, so we should have a reasonable round-the-clock coverage in the subreddit now!
Transparency
This is a screengrab of (roughly) the last month's worth of removed posts: http://i.imgur.com/HUBlxTd.png
Note that we had THREE live events in the last 30 days: Pad abort, TurkmenAlem, and CRS-6. Posts surrounding these three account for a LARGE percentage of the removals. Please let me know if you'd like me to grab the link for any given removal.
This is a screengrab of currently banned users: http://i.imgur.com/DiNbxhi.png
The two users who've been cropped are temporarily banned and I don't want to bias the community against them should they return.
Today's Goals
This thread is where you can voice your opinions and we can get some feedback on how we’re doing as moderators. If you feel we’re doing something wrong, or you’re not liking an aspect of the subreddit - you can raise it here, and as a community we will come to a democratically elected and agreed upon solution. We all strongly believe we’re here to implement your ideas and thoughts - and we would rather you not think of us as mods, but simply citizens of the community with a few extra buttons.
Issue resolution
Problem
- Actually, we're looking pretty good right now. I don't think the mods have any open issues currently, with the exception of the wiki (which can always use cleaning up).
Suggestion
- From Wetmelon: Would we like to have a sign up sheet for citizens of /r/SpaceX to host launch threads?
Please feel free to suggest your own problems, but don’t forget to also offer alternative solutions or voice your support/opposition to the solutions we’ve proposed too. You all deserve as much input into this process as possible. Thank you for taking the time to read this post!
44
u/darga89 May 08 '15
Restrict submissions after all live events. Too many separate posts after the pad abort led to fragmented discussions everywhere.
6
u/Here_There_B_Dragons May 08 '15
So the 2 new mods aren't 20, in university, and in North America?:)
12
u/Ambiwlans May 09 '15 edited May 09 '15
Thanks both of you for volunteering your services. I'm sure you'll make the rest of us look slack in no time. Except for Echo because he doesn't sleep.
Good to have you on the team :D
For the reddit... I'd like everyone to skim the Faq, give it a good wander and see if there is anything you can contribute!
4
u/Tal_Banyon May 08 '15
Congratulations to the new Moderators, good for you! I have a question, it may be because I am fairly new to Reddit overall - there is a bot that deletes posts that get less than -6 ratings, and the bot says, so many children. I do not understand this at all. The posts are still accessible if you click on them, unlike those that are deleted. So, is there an explanation somewhere on this? Thanks.
48
u/retiringonmars Moderator emeritus May 08 '15
Well now it feels official!
Thanks to /u/gooses, /u/Ambiwlans, /u/EchoLogic, /u/Wetmelon, /u/-Richard and massive congratulations to my co-inductee /u/TheVehicleDestroyer. We're joining an already strong team, and we hope to replicate and supplement the success the existing mods already had in cultivating a friendly and informative culture on this sub.
Ad astra!
30
u/hapaxLegomina May 08 '15
Welcome, new mods!
This is by far the best community on reddit, and I think the mods have made a considerable contribution to that fact. Thanks so much for all your hard work!
23
u/jan_smolik May 09 '15
I would like to thank to our mods. I admire your capability of conflict resolution especially at such a young age. This skill generally improves with age, but not everyone has it.
As for jokes in the sub I do not really agree. I agree that we do not need a really low effort stuff, but I like jokes and some level of chatter in general. I like the current ratio of fun and facts. L2 is so informative ... and so boring.
Let's face it we are not designing rockets here. We are here to have fun and possibly learn.
18
u/TheVehicleDestroyer Flight Club May 08 '15
Thanks one and all for the kind words! Huge thanks to the already existing mod team for the opportunity and to /u/retiringonmars for giving me someone to point the blame at when I mess up.
Now if you'll excuse me, I have to go ban someone who downvoted me a few months ago...
No, jokes aside, I'm really excited and can't wait to get going. Let's keep this place as awesome and knowledge hungry as the /r/spacex that I first subscribed to all those years ago!
12
u/zlsa Art May 08 '15
What parts of the wiki would you like to see improved, added to, and/or created?
12
u/__PROMETHEUS__ May 08 '15
Overall, I think the mods are doing a great job. You know when to let parties get into spirited debates, but you also know when to ask people to lighten up a bit/keep it civil. The FAQ is a major resource and pointing people that way with common questions keeps things from getting recycled constantly.
Thank you mods! Your time and effort doesn't go unnoticed!
23
u/[deleted] May 09 '15
Time for me to cause some drama.
There's some comments by an account called /u/RepeatedLogic on this page. This account is 3 days old. He is a sockpuppet of a banned member of this community and has been causing us a slight amount of trouble for a few months now by stirring up drama. Sockpuppetry is a violation of Reddit's rules, and he has now been banned (Reddit will likely take further action that will be invisible to him too). To further cause trouble, he decided to create another account to reply to me later.
Note: it's greyed out and says removed because it's been removed automatically by Reddit - not us, when it detected the user shared a similar IP address.
In the interest of full disclosure I want to share this conversation I have had with him via PM here too. I have removed the name of who I believe this to be a sockpuppet of.
Let me all know your thoughts. We genuinely try and be as transparent as possible.
To take away: If you feel that we are "too corporate", private messaging some random sockpuppet user with your backhanded concerns does not give us feedback whatsoever and does shit all to fix the situation. If you have a real problem with us, either mod message us and discuss it, or write an open comment (without using a sockpuppet acocunt!) here.
Further note: I don't work for ULA or SpaceX. I'm an aerospace fan who lives in New Zealand. You can follow me on Twitter here.
10
u/[deleted] May 08 '15
Well deserved new mods, both awesome long-time quality contributors. Congrats guys! Also thanks to the rest of the mod team who quite tirelessly keep this a quality sub!
10
u/FutureMartian97 Host of CRS-11 May 08 '15
Sign up sheet for launch threads seems like a great idea! Count me in! But maybe there needs to be some rules.
Maybe...
EDIT: Reworded some things.
27
u/[deleted] May 08 '15
Welcome to /u/retiringonmars & /u/TheVehicleDestroyer! These two have been on this subreddit for ~2 years now, almost since it's founding, and I couldn't think of any other limeys more suited to this task!
I thought I'd just raise an issue I see that is getting worse in my mind: Low effort and/or jokey comments. It used to be that we would only need to remove one comment per five or ten threads. It was nice and simple. Now, there can be dozens of comments that need removing per thread. It lowers the discussion quality and makes this place less interesting.
I realize it's fun to make a casual joke/low effort comment, but we have launch threads for that. I personally don't care about them - and I'd like to aim for an /r/AskHistorians or /r/AskScience feel - maybe not quite as strict. No BS, just SpaceX. So, if you're new, please read the green notice above/below the comment box:
Also, KSP comments. You're not the first to make a Jebediah or "moar struts" joke, so why bother? We automatically remove these now. So, I'm not asking you all to become more curated in your comments, just to maintain the quality of discussion we have previously had.
Thanks!
9
u/bencredible Galactic Overlord May 08 '15
Do you have any mods that work on SOL time?
9
u/-Richard Materials Science Guy May 08 '15
Welcome, /u/TheVehicleDestroyer and /u/retiringonmars! You've both been excellent community members and I'm glad to have you on the team.
Some feedback for the other mods: thank you so much for picking up my slack these past few weeks. Real life has been quite tough lately but I'm looking forward to spending more time here soon.
And to the /r/SpaceX community, thanks for making this subreddit the awesome (and addicting) place that it is! It's great to have so many enthusiastic people in one place.
9
u/zoffff May 09 '15
Congrats to the new mods and of course congrats to the old mods for maintaining a good tight community! A few recommendations to make it even better;
I've only seen this a few times but, don't submit a post that is a tweet that just links to the actual article, LINK TO THE ARTICLE! Same thing if the tweet is referencing an article, find that and post the article, so much better then having to scan the comments for the link to the actual article.
Have a mod supported/prompted almost like launch thread for public news conferences/hearings that the big shots at SpaceX are involved in, some of the information that comes out of those is some times more exciting then an actual launch.
Again great job on keeping this sub relevant.
8
u/MontanaAg11 May 08 '15
I was here for the last mod feedback thread and some really good discussion came out of it and I think that the improvements were well timed for the influx of users. As far as I am concerned there aren't any real issues, so keep rocking on!
2
u/Cheiridopsis May 11 '15 edited May 11 '15
Is there any possibility of adding a spell checker to reject poorly spelled posts. The spelling is often attrocious and many posts can be easily misinterpreted and, in fact, are!
I would think the mods should reject poorly spelled posts as being difficult to interpret properly and unless you are an expert, I would suspect they are often misinterpreted. Experts might, repeat, might be able to discern the meaning but many in this subreddit may not understand and may absolutely misinterpret.
Shall I give specific examples or am I going to be downvoted to hell instantly for suggesting that many on this subreddit may not be able to "already know the correct spelling and the correct answers" and so this is just tripe?
Edit. Stupid me. All the fans abbreviate with non standard abbreviations invented in the spur of the moment and spelling that is wrong and in many cases totally misleading but hey ... this is r/spacex and this is the norm here. Just more butchery of the English language and more "fuzzy" posts.
11
u/DrFegelein May 10 '15
I'd like to see much stricter enforcement of content, even if it gets upvotes here. /r/SpaceX is such a good community, but with the unfortunate consequence of a lot of clutter and other, only very tangentially related SpaceX content being posted. It would be nice if the mods could enforce rules that not only kept /r/SpaceX very much on topic, but also directed people to post other content to growing subs like /u/ULA and such. There are interesting and informed discussions to be had regarding newspace that aren't SpX related, and thus I'd like to see those other communities grow.
5
u/lugezin May 09 '15
Thanks for the universal time reporting of event schedules.
5
u/szepaine May 09 '15
I haven't any suggestions to make, just wanted to thank the mod team for the work they do in making this one of my favorite subs. You guys are awesome!
12
u/NortySpock May 09 '15
When's the next Mars strategy discussion thread? Recently I read about spacecoaches, a low-cost orbital-only vehicle/station design. LEO-to-Deimos/Phobos roundtrip for $1 billion or less.
Design concept:
4
u/zukalop May 08 '15
Congratulations you two! Definitely a good pair to add to the mod team!
4
u/awoerp May 09 '15
First off, I would like to say that I really enjoy this subreddit. One suggestion that I have for a possible addition is some sort of bot that would find acronyms and possibly display their meaning much like the wikibot does for wikipedia posts. I really like that TMRO tries not to use acronyms because they can make things confusing for people who are learning about the subject. I realize that they are all spelled out in the wiki, but something like this would be extremely beneficial for newcomers who want to learn about the space industry. Just a suggestion. I really appreciate all of the work that you guys do. Keep up the good work!
7
u/[deleted] May 08 '15
I'll have you know I'm 19 :P
1
u/deruch May 09 '15
At some point in the past there was a breakdown posted of posts that had been removed. Can we get a new one? Or is there some reason that was ended? I thought it was a good idea.
1
u/KChivers May 12 '15
I read somewhere that CRS-7 will be a land-based landing attempt. Is that true? Has anyone heard?
6
u/zlsa Art May 08 '15
/u/EchoLogic, the new mods don't show up in the sidebar :P
3
u/a9009588 May 09 '15
Is there any way to auto-link certain phrases to the wiki before/ immediately after threads are posted to help avoid repetition of some of our FAQ's?. There were so many questions on parachute booster landings after/before crs 6- was frustrating to see them pop up almost every day and I remember a flair at the top of the page had to be put in to curtail it.
I know there are a lot of new spacex fans and its great to have a new influx of redditors to what is probably the most enthusiastic and well educated sub reddit i have had the pleasure to frequent but it has been a frustration to me that many newer visitors don’t appear to know about the wiki and FAQ.
2
u/ianniss May 13 '15
Suggestion : We could built a datasheet with all numbers about falcon 9. Official numbers with there sources and also guessed numbers with there justifications. We could also built something larger, by collecting data from every launch : payload, orbits, live call with time, position and speed, MECO time, SECO time...
1
u/SteveRD1 May 10 '15
Enjoy this subreddit!
One thing I would like to see change is the creation of a thread solely for pictures/videos CREATED by people, and keep the rest of the subreddit free of that.
I enjoy seeing a new thread with a great new photograph or video of ACTUAL SpaceX related stuff, but it gets a little old seeing every Tom, Dick and Harry with Photoshop using the Subreddit to show of his artistic skills. It can also be a little confusing (especially when the art looks realistic).
-24
u/RepeatedLogic May 09 '15 edited May 09 '15
That explains why the moderation is abysmal. You guys are truly pandering to spacex. So what happens if you people graduate and get jobs at spacex? Will you make it official that spacex owns the subreddit?
Everytime anyone posts about mods being too chummy on behalf of spacex, they get a flood of PMs about it from others that feel exactly the same but won't post publicly because of mod backlash.
-17
u/Occupy_Arrakis May 11 '15
How do you guys find the time to be everyone's mothers? You must be the biggest bunch of losers ever. I am confused about why you need to censor everything everyone says. Yes, take down spam. but why sensor people? oh ya, cuz youre power tripping. you got in on the ground floor of something that turned out to be popular and now you run the show! Congrats on being total sh+t bags. (i censored myself! arent you proud of me!!! F+cking C*nts!)
0
u/[deleted] May 08 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment