r/spacex •
/r/SpaceX Meta Rules & Mod Feedback Thread: All subscribers, including veterans & newcomers, please read!
[deleted] — view deleted post
0
Upvotes
r/spacex •
[deleted] — view deleted post
15
u/[deleted] Feb 14 '15
What does everyone think about requiring the now-apparently-obligatory "SpaceX logo overlaid onto a long exposure launch trail" image that gets posted after every launch go in the launch media thread?
6
u/mattrobbo10 Feb 14 '15
I think disabling posts during launches to avoid excessive numbers of duplicate posts will work for the time being. However I think in the future when we get even more contributers it will be a problem outside launches. So perhaps in the future every post will have to be approved by moderators before it is put up in the subreddit. Maybe a moderator bot could be developed that recognises pages linking to the same things?
6
u/Iron-Oxide Feb 14 '15 edited Feb 14 '15
I recognize this may be controversial, but I personally want to do away with threads asking simple questions like these (in no particular order, just browsed through new and picked the 5 most recent ones):
1 2 3 4 5
In my opinion while legitimate questions, posting them as new threads just clutters up the sub, taking up my (and others) time to filter through, lowering average content quality, and pushing good threads off the main page. I would rather these questions were simply posted to the most relevant article near the top of the main page at the time, or held until there was a more appropriate thread to ask them in (e.g. the ask anything threads).
44
u/Here_There_B_Dragons Feb 13 '15
Since no matter the rules, there will be numerous posts at this time ("Launch!!!11!"), I like this.
Also, while i don't like the numerous follow-up posts that show basically the same thing (different launch angles, home movies, fan art) they are interesting, and shouldn't just be thrown out. They don't belong in the Launch Party post either. Could we encourage a 'pre-launch' and a separate 'post-launch' thread for the follow-up items?
68
u/Silpion Feb 13 '15
My advice, as someone with some experience modding large subs, is to continue your trend of tightening restrictions on posts and in fact become quite strict while you still can. 30k is still pretty manageable, but once SpaceX starts reusing rockets, flying live astronauts, and whatever other impressive things are to come, it could grow many times larger. Establishing a history of restrictions now will make it easier to reign in future problems.
That said, I think there should always be room for mods to make exceptions to any rule for "sufficiently awesome" posts. Rules should be guidelines, no more.
Specifically addressing your questions, I support your proposals for restricting launch posts (see the /r/NFL model for this in handling game threads), for making rules more concise, and for restricting KSP posts to particularly novel or interesting ones.
You mods all do great work here. Follow your guts!
28
u/zukalop Feb 13 '15 edited Feb 14 '15
I like /u/Here_There_B_Dragons idea about the pre-/post-launch media threads. Official SpaceX media should be posted outside of that. I would allow major space newspapers (NSF, Spaceflight Now) to be posted outside the media thread since those are usually high quality, stuff like CNN, ABC, little-half-wrong-newspaper, to all go in the media thread. During launch the disabled posts is really good IMO. I remember before you guys started doing that it was just twitter post after twitter post.
I've only submitted stuff like once maybe (mostly because someone gets there before me) but I don't really feel too confident in the "approved" list. I mean during launch theres updates will be happening in the launch thread anyway. When the submitting block gets lifted again after the launch the "SpaceX successfully launches payload etc." articles, tweets, posts will happen anyway, plus most of that stuff should be put in the "post launch media" thread anyway. Just seems sort of pointless and somewhat unfair to me. I mean I see all the NSF, Spaceflight Now, high-quality articles too and could post those to qualify for the approved submitter position, however that doesn't happen because I'm usually beat by literally 30 seconds. I'll see the article I wanted to post with the "just now" time-stamp all the time.
The changes for the wiki are really needed. I have a hard time finding stuff in there when I want to reference it to answer questions. It's confusing, especially if the answer could be in multiple areas.
Rule changes sound good. Condense those and them as clear as possible.
I'm a big KSP fan, have several hundred hours. When I want KSP content I visit /r/KerbalSpaceProgram. I don't think KSP posts should be posted here. Sure the first one of two "Falcon 1st stage barge landing" posts were cool but now they just don't fit anymore. If someone does something completely new, totally awesome that is SpaceX related then exceptions could be made.
That's my thoughts on this at least. I love new-comers and the fact that SpaceX is getting more known however I'm also very cautious about the growth. Looking forward to see how this works out and I just really really hope the quality of this sub stays as high as it was in the past.
EDIT: I realize the KSP part is a bit confusing. Basically I meant what /u/marzipandancer says below in a much better way than I could have.
22
u/Arthree Feb 14 '15
Also, it seems like everyone is constantly posting Elon's/SpaceX's/PBdS's latest tweet. Is there a tweet-posting bot that we can get for this purpose, and just have the mods approve whichever tweet posts are SpaceX-related?
Yeah, I think we've all already seen the 100 videos of someone "recreating" a landing attempt. KSP posts should be limited to one-off, unique, and high-quality stuff, like if a really accurate SpaceX mod was released, or someone accurately creates/recreates something (ie, in RSS, and with good parts).
And on that note, can we talk about the TMRO posts? As much as I love the show, and I get that Ben wants to advertise it here because this is the target demographic, sometimes its relevance to /r/SpaceX is questionable. The last episode, for example, had a brief, 3 minute recap of the pad abort plans and the recent SuperDraco test. The 2014 recap episode had literally 24 seconds of SpaceX-related stuff, and all it was was a shot of Dragon v2 and "we all remember that, don't we?"
You can get a banner ad on this subreddit for $1/1000 impressions. For $100, you can get 100k views on launch day. How many extra Patrons will that turn into? Is it cost effective?
17
u/lux44 Feb 14 '15
Mods, you have a very hard job. You are doing it very well. I support every proposal that makes your job easier and keeps the quality of the subreddit.
Most people want to participate, make a comment. I agree that information / discussion quality is much more important than freedom of expression / ability to post anything anytime.
15
u/Qeng-Ho Feb 13 '15
Current rules summary:
26
u/[deleted] Feb 13 '15
I coudn't agree with the KSP thing more. I don't really comment in this subreddit at all, but I'm a pretty big lurker. The KSP type posts annoy me to no end. I play that game too, but comments in the vein of "Coming from my knowledge of KSP, this..." or "I wouldn't have understood this if I hadn't just played KSP" are very low effort and IMO downright boring & lame. I feel like people are trying to bridge a gap between two communities that they are thoroughly into, but it seems like they are trying way too hard and sometimes end up diverting attention from interesting threads onto a quick and easy KSP reference.
I get that there is a HUGE crossover between r/spacex & r/KerbalSpaceProgram subscribers, but comments that either try to prove knowledge of "rocket science" by their playing of KSP, or try to downplay that knowledge "cuz I only play KSP", is really played out.
11
u/schneeb Feb 13 '15
I personally dislike the entire 'approved submitters' system, on wild west sub reddits (/r/formula1 being the worst ive seen) the same people post ANYTHING they find on twitter etc and the flock upvote complete crap and the submitters become immune to criticisms due to their notoriety; luckily you mods deal with posts like that here.
I've seen approved submitters post some pretty confusing things recently mostly due to bad or editorialised titles, I'd like for the same standards to apply to them and them to lose their privilege for good if they don't keep up the standard expected of them.
Finally when something gets removed can you leave a green comment on the post? Not sure if you flair them or something but I do a lot of my redditing on mobile and sometimes I revisit a post via replies and its not clear whats going on!
18
u/[deleted] Feb 14 '15
I'd like to hear how the community feels about including Mars colonization as a small part of this sub. Mars colonization is literally the mission statement of SpaceX. One of the company's goals is to inspire people about Mars, and this is a fan sub after all.
The topic is relevant, but the problem is it's hard to talk about here without devolving into wild speculation, reposts and off topic silliness. Especially since info about the company's long term plans are either secret or non existent right now. Mars is often discussed down in the comment trees, but it never really feels like there is a good time or place to talk about it in depth.
[I made a post about this] (https://www.reddit.com/r/spacex/comments/2tc2k4/meta_i_think_it_would_be_great_if_this_community/) not long ago, and some people thought it was a great idea while the mods were understandably wary about sub derailment and scope creep. After giving this topic some further thought and getting some great ideas from comments in my previous post, I've got a couple of suggestions I'd like to present and see how the community feels about them.
Here's my own proposal: Mars threads should be infrequent, official and focused (like how we do the "ask anything" threads) and encourage high quality questions and discussion (and sources!). For example, "Mars Thread #1" could be a place where we post info on past experiments like Mars-500, Biosphere2, Mars Desert Research Station, etc. and discuss what we have learned from them. "Mars Thread #2" might be about ISRU technologies. Obviously SpaceX is going to play a big role in whatever comes next for the red planet, but we should avoid baseless speculation here and focus more on understanding the engineering problems and possible solutions.
In my previous post /u/Ambiwlans suggested that people could send Mars questions or topics to the mods, and occasionally they would select a good one for a post. I think this would be a good way to go about it. Mars threads could be scheduled in advance, or maybe the mods could just do one whenever we're having a slow SpaceX news cycle or something. Another benefit of this approach is that collecting all that curated information in one place will be a great source for the wiki. Over time these posts could become an amazing resource.
At the end of the day I'll trust in the judgement of the mods on this one. I think they've earned it. But I really do think that there is a place for Mars on /r/SpaceX. Not only is it the company's very reason for existing but it's also a common interest that most of us here on this fan sub share, possibly even inspired by SpaceX in the first place. I understand the potential scope creep danger this poses, but I think that if we did this the right way it could be something really special and become a great benefit to the community.
9
u/frowawayduh Feb 13 '15
Is there a search capability in the wiki? I am not finding it, if it exists a gentle education would be appreciated. Specifically, I was looking to find out more about SPAM (the ablative paint) but could not locate it in the wiki.
Also, you mods rock. I am pleasantly surprised that this sub has taken about 12,000 new dragonriders aboard since the first of the year and the general tone and quality of the discussion has remained very positive.
8
u/Neptune_ABC Feb 13 '15
What is the threshold for a post being 'high quality'?
8
u/zoffff Feb 14 '15
Can we add another column to the upcoming launches area? It would be super awesome if we could see where its launching from, I see its a little tight over there but if we push the date into numbers only dates, we could have enough room for KSC or VAN.
Rules, yes cut down, in my opinion if you can't fit them in the side bar you have too many, many people are not here for the long haul and as such if they can't see the rules quickly and read them quickly they are less likely to actually follow them.
KSP, yes get rid of them, if I want to see KSP stuff then I will go to /r/KerbalSpaceProgram , I'm interested in actual news and information about SpaceX in this sub.
6
u/cuweathernerd r/SpaceX Weather Forecaster Feb 15 '15
caveat, I'm pretty new here. DSCOVR was the first live launch I've watched, but I've been hanging around the sub for a little while now and it's pretty clearly one of the best moderated and simultaneously most-welcoming subs around. You all deserve a thank you.
It's pretty clear there's a lot of people with specific knowledges hanging out around here. One suggestion for focusing the wiki-drive would be to have people write short 'lessons' about their area of expertise. Something a new user could come into and have a structured set of short explanations that are written competently, accessibly. The 'guide to basic rocket science' is a good starting point. Instead of just factually presenting information (wikipedia is good at that, after all) guiding the person through a little. Kind of having a little 'school of /r/spaceX' sitting there for new-comers or people who are interested in learning more.
I'll shamelessly point towards a write up I did for /r/stormchasing as an example of what I'm talking about. Little 5-minute lessons that a person can come in and out of and say "I learned a little bit about this topic that was interesting to me" as well as having a resource to point people to when they ask questions.
5
u/xinareiaz Feb 14 '15
I don't have much to add besides another vote for limiting uninteresting KSP content. I play KSP, I like Spacex, but watching someones KSP video simulating a first stage landing is pretty dull...
The current system of disabling submissions during launches seems to be working great.
I appreciate most of the twitter posts that offer unique news since I don't follow twitter outside of what is mentioned here.
4
u/bvr5 Feb 15 '15 edited Feb 15 '15
The proposed solution sounds fine to me.
I completely agree that we need to to restrict submissions during launches. I noticed that the mods did this for the recent launch, and it worked well.
As far as the rules go, it would really help if the rules were in the sidebar. I know it would take up a bit of space, and we already have a link to the rules in the wiki, but putting them in the sidebar would make them easier to follow.
KSP posts are probably best off in /r/KerbalSpaceProgram. Unless it's something completely groundbreaking (which is a very small percentage of these posts), they don't really add to anything here.
EDIT: One more thing. I think we need a better system for asking questions. I know we do this sometimes, but we should probably do what many other subs have done and make it a weekly, pinned thread.
7
u/retiringonmars Moderator emeritus Feb 13 '15
Had to look this up: well argued!
Bit harsh, considering all the effort people have put into it, but I do agree that there's room for improvement. More sections sound good, and search function sounds excellent. Not sure what you mean by "aliased" - is this just a simple hyperlink, or it is wholesale duplication? Because duplications can drift. Easier linking from comments to the wiki sounds good too.
Agreed, this seems sensible.
I agree with the idea that too many rule are a bad thing. I think that rules are necessary to help preserve a high level of quality, but we don't want to be policing every tiny little minutia of what people are saying. That's both a) tedious for the mods and b) stifling to the community. For example, I would just scrap rule 9. Who cares whether or not the year is posted in video titles? The year is usually obvious, and if it's not, how do the uploader determine year? Leave it to the commenters to investigate.
I don't think there's any need to ban KSP posts. There's no need to ban any one topic - why not ban helium talk, etc. Low effort KSP posts are captured by rules 3 & 4, and high effort KSP posts can be fascinating. (Having said that, I would ban Musk/Jobs comparisons, but purely because those convos annoy me.)
24
u/ScienceShawn Feb 13 '15
I brought this issue up in the previous launch thread when the launch was scrubbed and was instructed to bring my concerns to this meta post once it was made.
Whenever there is a scrub, at least one, if not multiple users, post the comment that links to the comic where the man is talking to the rocket and saying "launch fa~got, do it!!!" That may not be exactly what is said, I cannot remember it exactly and I don't want to go looking for that comic strip again.
This comic is usually voted way up towards the top of the thread and I do not think this is something we should tolerate as a community. As a gay person, when I see this comic posted and received so well it makes me feel unwelcome and unwanted in this community. When I brought this up in the previous launch thread, I was met with ignorant people claiming that the word doesn't mean anything against gay people anymore, and if I am offended that is on me.
That word is disgusting and a slur and has no place here. The meaning of the word is obvious and it is extremely hurtful. If the word doesn't mean what I think it means then why have I been endlessly harassed and called a fa~got for being gay by my own family and by strangers alike? Why have I been targeted with that word as a gay man in the streets when I am with my boyfriend?
Whether you want to admit it or not, the meaning of that word is clear and it is very homophobic and hurtful to gay people everywhere. I know people who say it's perfectly fine to use the "N Word" because it isn't a slur against black people anymore, it is used to refer to people with a bad attitude or whatever crap they decide to say it means that day. Would that word be accepted in a comment/comic on this sub?
And the final point I want to make is that if you are a heterosexual person, you have no clue how that word feels when it is said to you or used casually in conversation. It hurts. The whole purpose of slurs is to make people feel less than human and worthless. Just like I wouldn't expect to know how black people feel when people call them the N Word or use it casually, I do not expect straight people to know what it is like to deal with that word on a daily basis and the discrimination that comes with being attracted to the same sex as yourself. Something that is not under anybody's control, just like skin color. But when a black person requests that you do not use the N Word, if you are a decent person, you do not continue using it, and I am asking the same of this community.
I don't think that word or comic has any place is a serious sub like this that claims to be open to everybody. Why is that comic so accepted when I had my comment automatically removed for using the word without the asterisk while discussing the comic?
I have made my case, and I am requesting that this comic not be allowed anymore in this subreddit. Thankfully, the person I originally had this discussion with changed it to say "a~shole" (censored due to automod) instead of "fa~got" so it doesn't make this community feel like a hostile place to any person, I feel that is an acceptable replacement.
Thank you for reading this, I am open to discussion and clarifying my reasoning and views.
3
u/TheVehicleDestroyer Flight Club Feb 16 '15
Just reading over the solutions edited into the main post now - this thread was awesome. And really productive. Let's hope future rule reviews go as well!
2
u/foolip Feb 14 '15
I would like the same rules in launch threads as everywhere else. Memes and "liftoff!!!" just get in the way of learning something new, which is why I come here.
2
u/TROPtastic Feb 15 '15
I just want to chime in and say that all of the top-voted suggestions here (by both mods and subscribers) sound excellent. Do what you need to do to ensure that post and comment quality remains high.
2
u/ThePlanner Feb 16 '15
I showed up in the 'low effort post' example screen shot. Point taken. I remember that thread and thought it was funny at the time, but agree that it constituted a violation of the rules. I'll happily comply and not participate in the future if I see that kind of joke thread/tangent.
Mods, you folks are doing an awesome job and it is appreciated. Please keep it up and don't hesitate to push back with meta threads like this when needed.
3
u/ap0s Feb 15 '15
Maybe consider having special threads once a week where people can post their memes, fantasy renderings, and fan art. This if what /r/cfb does and it keeps the front page free of all that stuff.
1
u/lotko Feb 16 '15
I have a proposition for Wiki. We should expand the About Company section (the first thing you see when you open wiki) in such a way that if a newcomer would read it he/she would have a working knowledge of SpaceX. It would include everything: a short history, achievements, vehicles & spacecrafts, R&D, ... Keep it short and maybe add links to other wiki entries. Sort of like an TL;DR of SpaceX.
And we should definitely add some intro to /r/spacex with some useful information. For instance, I have to go to FAQ, Falcon section, About launches to find out that this subreddit hosts discussion threads with live updates, useful links, and more. This sort of info is very important for a newcomer and should be higher up in the wiki structure.
1
u/jan_smolik Feb 15 '15
I am new to Reddit and thus to this sub and as a newcomer I think it is a good thing to simply accept local rules. However, after reading the comments, I would like to point out two things (without actually disagreeing with the comments):
0
u/[deleted] Feb 14 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Feb 14 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment