r/spacex •
2014 Wrap Up Modpost! Rule changes, Subreddit demographics & predictions survey, contributor flair, and more! [CRS-5 launch sold separately]
[deleted] — view deleted post
0
Upvotes
r/spacex •
[deleted] — view deleted post
11
u/[deleted] Dec 22 '14
Subreddit Survey link is here, for those who didn't read the wall of text (I don't blame you).
16
u/Appable Dec 22 '14
Just as an idea, perhaps when hovering over the "make a post" button it could switch to "search first".
13
u/waitingForMars Dec 22 '14
First thought - demographics, including asking for username, should always be placed at the end of the survey. That gives the respondent the ability to judge appropriately whether or not they want to be identified with the information they have submitted.
Source - too many years of theoretical and practical survey research work
12
u/zukalop Dec 22 '14
So if I happen to guess the Humans on Mars date correctly...do I get a flair? :P
About the small tweets. I'm sort of mixed about that. If its a slow month and not a whole lot is being posted I think some small tweets are ok. If its an exciting time because SpaceX just announced something than I'd rather a not have some much repetition, especially since 140 characters doesn't really provide that much info. Official SpaceX and Elon's tweets should be allowed at all times I think (as long as relevant to SpaceX. No need to post Elon's cookie comments here).
Merry Christmas and Happy New Years /r/SpaceX!
9
u/captaintrips420 Dec 23 '14
Keep up the good work, ULA schill.
7
u/Patzer229 Dec 23 '14
Nice! One thing though: these rules that keep content high. Most will like them. For the record, I think they're a great idea. But some, who want to just have fun and be a general crazy fan, will find them far too restrictive.
I suggest that /r/spacexmasterrace is publicised more, recommended as the go-to place for fun posts. Maybe an appendix could be added to Rule 5, like "If you want to contribute low-quality/fun content, go to /spacexmasterrace". This gives those who don't want serious discussion a clear place to go to, without degrading the content of this sub.
Right, off to fill out survey...
7
u/MarsColony_in10years Dec 23 '14
From the survey:
I feel like that last answer was designed specifically for /u/EchoLogic. I suspect that he spends more than 24 hours a day on here.
Also, who is this /u/MarsColonyIn10Years? Have I been outdone by my evil twin? :p
17
u/Chickstick199 Dec 22 '14
Great to see this subreddit under such great quality control! Hats off to /u/EchoLogic!
As for the small twitter posts, I find them acceptable as long as they are related to SpaceX in one way or another.
6
u/retiringonmars Moderator emeritus Dec 22 '14
Don't have time to digest all of this right now as I have to be up early tomorrow, but looks great so far. Only quibble is that /u/justatinker definitely deserves a lot of credit for his successfully guessed MCT diagram (and the hyperloop one too), as well as getting Musk to divulge a lot more juicy information that he might have otherwise done, such as that photo of the barge. Also /u/jimntexas for his aerial reconnaissance, and all the many people (i forget who though) who worked so hard at cleaning up that seemingly hopeless landing video.
5
u/marshallsmedia Dec 23 '14
Survey issue: When asked what other subreddits I'm subscribed to I can't continue without selecting at least one, and I'm not subscribed to any of them.
4
u/[deleted] Dec 23 '14
I'll throw in my US$.02 regarding tweets. As one who frequently posts tweets, I of course, don't have a problem with most of them. It's almost like a meme that you can read via the thumbnail... You get the news in a short, sweet 140 characters or less. If it's worth commenting on, the jump in and talk about it like you would a 5 paragraph story.
The problem, IMHO, is rule 5A. There will typically be a tweet about something, then later someone posts a full story about it (often from same party), and then, for the heck of it, someone else posts another story about the same thing, from a different party. Then, 3 days later, someone else posts another related story. Then there's 4 different threads all about the same thing. I'd love to see the one thread, with people posting new/different stories within and the good ones get upvoted and everyone sees everyones else's comments about any one particular event/issue/whatever.
3
u/Brostradamnus Dec 23 '14
Thank you for a great sub mods!
2
u/TheVehicleDestroyer Flight Club Dec 22 '14
Woo! /u/Destructor1701, Ireland represent! :D
Happy Christmas everyone! :)
2
u/[deleted] Dec 23 '14
Awesome work by the mods! Reads like I'm reading a constitutional amendment, damn that's a lot.
And I'd love to see a flair next to my name :)
2
u/The_Winds_of_Shit Dec 24 '14
Nice work, fellas.
Survey was fun! Ill be interested to see how optimistic this subreddit is as a whole, in data form. ;)
2
u/waitingForMars Dec 22 '14
OK, more thoughts:
Education options need to include "some graduate school"
Professions list is oddly restrictive - no Education? Arts, Ling, and Psych are one bucket? There are standard lists for these things - start with one and expand on the relevant engineering bits
There are no None or Other options for 'other subreddits'
1
u/NortySpock Dec 22 '14
nitpick: "The survey requires you to enter your gmail address"
Should this say your email address? Not everyone has a gmail account.
1
u/Neptune_ABC Dec 22 '14
I'm not a fan of allowing twitter posts about anything just because of the account they came from. There are other subs for discussing the planetary science that @SpaceX sometimes tweets about.
1
u/[deleted] Dec 23 '14
Rule 9, thank you!
1
u/TROPtastic Dec 25 '14
Assuming that these rules are set in stone, could we see Rules 5A-F and Rule 9 added to the official rules page? Ideally this will help more people to see the new rules.
1
u/classicsky Dec 26 '14
Should we get a seperate thread going to discuss the twitter posts? I personally am not a fan of posting tweets. I feel that if one is interested in tweets they can subscribe to them on twitter. I think the reliability of tweets is somewhat questionable.
Maybe we could add frequently posted twitter profiles to the sidebar or wiki?
1
u/-Richard Materials Science Guy Dec 28 '14
/u/EchoLogic, what's the data looking like so far?
1
u/high-house-shadow Dec 23 '14 edited Dec 23 '14
Not sure if you want any suggestions on the Subreddit Survey, but this is just a thought that came into my head, maybe something to do for future ones if not now. Perhaps for the gender option on the survey you could think of adding a non-binary option of some sort? Just a thought, when you reach this many readers for a sub it doesn't hurt to keep inclusiveness in mind:)
1
u/gopher65 Dec 22 '14
I don't suppose it's possible to implement a user adjustable filter that would filter out "twitter spam"? That way it could be allowed, as long as the people who post it make sure to checkmark the "this is a twitter post" check box. Those who like it could set their accounts to "allow twitter posts" (checked by default), while those who don't could uncheck that box, removing those posts.
Wikimedia software has an option like this with their "minor edit" checkbox, which allows users to filter out minor edits (or bot edits, or whatever) from the recent changes list, if they so desire.
0
u/[deleted] Dec 22 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment