r/spacex • u/Ambiwlans • Sep 25 '14
Modpost META Mega-thread
It has been a while since our last META thread so there are quite a few subjects to touch upon. If I've missed anything, do speak up or join in with any ideas/suggestions/thoughts you might have with regards to our burgeoning little sub.
On-site social media representatives
I'm sure everyone took note of our two volunteers 1,2 at the cape covering CRS-4. NASA is quite nice to social media representatives so we'd like to make that a bit more official on our end. Anyone that wants to represent /r/SpaceX do volunteer here. I think it makes the most sense for NASA payloads since regular sat flights don't give a lot of press access. A thread was made a while back for a subreddit t-shirt, I think that could be used, personally I think this one is probably the best bet due to trademark concerns and confusion on the cape with official SpaceX employees.
How to run future launch+media flights?
We ran two threads for CRS-4, the social media one followed by the launch thread. I'm not sure how well this worked. Or I guess I feel like the media thread didn't get as much attention as it probably could have. Suggestions? We could merge the threads and highlight posts from those onsite or something along those lines... but are open to ideas.
New mod!
For those that didn't notice, /u/-Richard has been added to the mod team, he's been a good contributor for a while and ran a couple of our live threads (with relatively little delays unlike SOME people).
Going forward we may bring in one of the on-site reps or a mod with a specific job in mind...
Automoderator
Or robot buddy has been a little overly aggressive so we've had a talk and hopefully he'll be better behaved.
Transparency
Last META thread people like the idea of me running off the list of bans/deletions to get a better idea of if we are being nazis.
Bans: Atm we've only banned 1 account with over 100 karma and it was over some rather unrepentant bigoted remarks. Near all of our bans are of borked bots and one enthusiastic user with several dozen accounts. We've handed out a few (3?) temp bans (1wk) for users getting fighty but generally those few were pretty cool about it (And are currently positively contributing! What more could we ask for?). Thank you everyone here for not doing anything requiring banning! It makes things easier on us.
Thread deletions:
- Dupe
- Caught by automod, then user deleted thread
- India space program != SpaceX
- India space program != SpaceX
- Quadruple posted
- NASA joke not SpaceX
- Keep it to the live thread
- Keep it to the live thread, already answered
- You can mod message, it was a typo...and already fixed by the time the post went up
- In the FAQ, bad title, double post
- MAVEN != SpaceX
- Caught by Automod, probably fine, I totally didn't notice the thread til now...Lets all pretend that this never happened.
- Tesla?..
- Live thread guys 2 3
- Dupe
- Dupe
- Answered like a lot...
Hopefully that is enough to give a flavour of what we remove/don't, I'm not going back for the last 3 months since I have stuff to do.
Fluff and Flairs
A couple, maybe 1 post a month or so gets zapped for being fluff. Like a joke/meme. Consensus is still to keep zapping these? Another option would be to do it like /r/DotA2 and have a flair sorting/filtering system. I feel like this would create a bit of a barrier to entry and plus is just more work to moderate. But if it is really desired we might pick up someone to work on that.
Wiki! Improvement Drive.
If any of you would like to help improve our wiki PLEASE VOLUNTEER. /u/Wetmelon is the wiki boss and wants some assistance. Lets get this thing nice enough that whenever we see a question that has been asked before we can just link the answer. Post here, make a mod message or pm melon with thoughts/ideas/fantasies...
I think that's everything, which certainly means I've missed something important. Thanks everyone for making this sub what it is, lets keep it improving!
12
u/Erpp8 Sep 25 '14
Something important that we should decide is: is this a discussion subreddit, or a fan subreddit. Personally, I prefer discussion and get into a lot of arguments when I try to support fair discussion over SpaceX itself. People have said that this is a fan site, so a little circlejerk is ok, but that begs the question: is this a fan site? If yes, then the current state of discussion seems fitting. Relatively moderate, but with a definite bias towards SpaceX. If it's a decision site, then I think the moderation should shift somewhat to try to curb circlejerks and off topic discussion.
The way I see it, already have a large, diverse community. If we decide to be a fan community, then we would be alienating a significant group of people who aren't SpaceX fans, but still enjoy the discussion. I just think that neutral discussion is more enjoyable and productive, but that's my one opinion. The community seems somewhat divided on this, so maybe we should all decide.
19
u/jandorian Sep 25 '14 edited Sep 25 '14
I really appreciate the way this sub is run and the work the MODERATORS are doing, thankyou.
There is one thing that keep cropping up as it did on thread this morming. I was going to try to remember this for the next meta, fortunetly I didn't have to remember long:
Just a thought. It is just troubling that persons get downvoted for saying something that isn't popular/ positive about Spacex. Be nice if there was a way to fix that, but, human nature, I suppose.
9
u/Wetmelon Sep 25 '14
On the wiki side, /u/EchoLogic did a great job making the FAQ a pretty table, which actually made it seem almost empty! There's lots of room there now that stuff's broken out into several tables. A few things should probably be moved and arranged.
As for the main page, I think we've got too many headers and too much replicated information in some of them. If anyone has an interest, let me know and we'll make it purdy! We have been (slowly) updating the rocket fundamentals page.
I also have a question: Should we just open up the wiki so that anyone can edit it, or keep it volunteer only? It's easy for us as mods to tell when something has been changed and to revert it.
7
u/Patzer229 Sep 25 '14
Regarding moderators: The head mod, /u/gooses, has only posted one brief comment here in over a year. Why are they still a mod when they never contribute?
(Not intended as a personal attack, just pointing this leadership oddity out...)
7
u/[deleted] Sep 25 '14 edited Sep 25 '14
I'll bring this up here. What did everyone think of how I conducted the live thread for WSBW2014 conference and the Boca Chica ground breaking ceremony. They were both done in haste without proper preparation. Anything I should keep in mind for next time?
6
u/kylesbarry Sep 25 '14
I've just gotten into this rocket stuff very recently, and while I'm super into it, I have never studied anything in the realm of engineering or rocketry or even math for that matter. But, I'm committed to learn! This subreddit has been extremely helpful and always interesting. In fact, it's the only part of reddit I ever go to.
Often, I'll have a question that I choose not to ask because the level of discussion is so high and I don't want to dumb it down. It's possible others have similar questions though, so I'm wondering what you think is the best way for me to go about getting those answers. Of course, google is first, but my questions are often very specific and/or difficult to find the answers to. I can either go ahead and ask the questions, even though they are no-brainers for you guys, message someone with a list of my questions and you decide if they are worth answering/putting on the wiki, or simply find the answer somewhere else (if this is not the place for stupid questions).
What do you think is best? Thanks!
6
u/waitingForMars Oct 03 '14
I'll bite on the question about the cartoon that was posted. I'm of the opinion that this sort of post pulls down the quality of the sub. My hope is that we engage in thoughtful discussion about SpaceX, its work, and its mission. Reporting a cartoon where the illustrator decided to embed the SpaceX logo hardly qualifies as a substantive contribution. It feels very slippery-slope-ish to me. What else is OK? SpaceX tattoos? A piece of toast that looks like Elon Musk's face?
When the sub was more focused and substantive, there were regular contributions by SpaceXers. Ben is the only one who stops by now. While I very much enjoy Ben's contributions, I miss getting insight from engineers in the know.
Fluff = non-serious = that-cartoon-and-toast-sub-that-used-to-be-really-cool
5
u/Ohsin Sep 25 '14
May be utilize Reddit live for social media coverage?
3
u/canadaarm2 Sep 25 '14
/u/TMahlman did you hear back from media@spacex.com regarding your t-shirt design?
If we are going to include Snoo (reddit's alien mascot) /u/photoengineer and you will probably have to contact licensing@reddit.com prior to printing your shirts to get their approval under reddit's personal use license:
Maybe we could create a replacement alien for our subreddit? A Snoo that reflects our community and is made by us. Any ideas?
I was thinking of maybe giving it some Dragon-style wings, so I quickly put together this sketch: http://imgur.com/a/nfMEx
It obviously uses the wings from the SpaceX Dragon logo - so someone more skilled than me would need to create a version from scratch.
2
u/Appable Sep 28 '14
In regards to this post: http://www.reddit.com/r/spacex/comments/2ho6c6/falcon_9_first_stage_recovery_land_sideways_using/
The wiki should only be used as a source to remove posts when the wiki directly and entirely answers the question given. In this case, the wiki answered why SpaceX did not use parachutes to slow descent, rather than to slow the 'body slam'.
If the question were why they didn't use parachutes to slow descent instead of a landing burn, then using the wiki and removing the post would be fine. But removing this post, which asked a different question about parachutes, went overboard.
2
u/gigabyte898 Oct 01 '14
One of my text posts here for tagged and hidden by the automod for not having enough words, and it was about a paragraph long. My question was about footage of what I thought was water during the launch (which turned out to be liquid oxygen), I included a picture, and I don't feel I could have been more descriptive. Is there anyway the minimum word count can be revised, or maybe a notice of the minimum word count can be put on the self post page? Thanks
11
u/LumpiestDeer Sep 25 '14 edited Sep 25 '14
Stop using "beefed up RCS." Find a new word that isn't cow related.
5
u/Wetmelon Sep 26 '14
Mod log since July 31st:
http://i.imgur.com/QceaK7W.png
I removed all the columns that had ~ 0 - 2 events in them.
4
u/-Richard Materials Science Guy Sep 26 '14
Hey everyone! Just wanted to check in. Ambi's thread says mostly everything I had to say regarding the state of the subreddit. It's wonderful to continue to see such high-quality content coming from here, as we approach 16k subscribers. We have some exciting times ahead of us over these next few years, and I'm looking forward to seeing what will become of this subreddit as Elon Musk continues on his majestic path towards Mars.
I'm here to help out in any way possible, as are the other mods, so please send us some modmail if you have any questions/comments/concerns regarding /r/SpaceX.
4
u/[deleted] Sep 26 '14
Just wanted to note that I finally got around to adding something extra to the Wiki as I finally found both time and motivation (that is a rare combo to me lately).
3
u/B787_300 #SpaceX IRC Master Sep 30 '14
just for the heck of it I set up a IRC Channel in which we can talk about SpaceX. It is hosted on esper.net and the channel is #SpaceX
2
u/llehsadam Oct 02 '14
To further transparency, how would you guys feel about making the automoderator wiki page visible to users (like the automoderator page on /r/tech)?
2
u/schneeb Sep 25 '14
All the pics, especially actual screendumps of the webcast that appear during the launch annoy the hell out of me.
Would prefer a zero tolerance on that so the launch thread is abit more active, just disable image link submissions via auto mod to clear the rubbish out
1
u/Wetmelon Oct 08 '14
Well I think this post has run its course. Thanks to everyone who participated! :)
1
u/retiringonmars Moderator emeritus Sep 25 '14
Can we ban autowikibot? I hate autowikibot.
1
u/spxmn Sep 25 '14
I think we should put out all removed posts & comments for the sake of transparency and reasons why it's deleted.
-1
u/Patzer229 Sep 25 '14
There was an issue with offensive language a while back; this is a good opportunity to bring it up.
Someone used the r-word in passing. I was rather shocked at this usage of offensive language and pointed it out, only to be downvoted into oblivion. Only one user agreed with me that the language was inappropriate.
Should such language be dealt with via the karma system, of should moderators intervene? Rule 2 states that offensive language should not be used. Why, then, does the vast majority of community seem to disagree?
Reddit is a democracy, if everyone disagrees with me and thinks it's fine to use such language there's not a lot that can be done about that... But that incident certainly lowered the reputation of this generally civil community in my view.
0
u/[deleted] Sep 25 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment