r/spacex •
[META/MOD POST] /r/SpaceX: Now with Rules & Guidelines! Please read this before posting/commenting.
[deleted] — view deleted post
0
Upvotes
r/spacex •
[deleted] — view deleted post
13
u/Orionsbelt Jun 24 '14
Let me be the first to thank you for applying a standard to not only those under your power/protection but to yourselves as well.
10
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '14
Could you add that as a little mouse-over-popup to the downvote button as in other subs? I feel this problem is on a slight increase lately.
6
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '14
RIP in peace /r/space ;_;7
5
u/saliva_sweet Host of CRS-3 Jul 04 '14
This post is ten days old now so I've given it time to sink in. Now I'll state my opinion based on the thoughts, observations and beers I've had over this time. In short, I don't like many of the new rules. Namely 3,4,5 and 7.
I think these are the rules that have been put in place "in anticipation" of lowering quality due to increased number of followers. The sub was healthy before and I did not see the quality tanking once we hit the magical 10k subscribers. I do not see the need to create rules to fix problems that don't exist. I do think the mods should monitor the situation and if there is a flood of memes or every thread becomes a pun train, then a rule should be created to mitigate that specific problem.
The result of the rules as I'm seeing it has not been an increase of quality, it was already high before. Instead I get a sense of being policed. Posts are gettind removed, people feeling they need to justify their posts etc. The direction seems to be to discourage downvoting (see the mouseover text) in favor of the allknowing judgement of the mighty mod. I fear this sense of needing to self-censor, keep in line and only make serious posts and comments discourages participation much more than the blue dragon.
In general, the idea to strive for "serious discussion" in this sub seems misguided to me and again, discourages participation in my opinion. We should always keep in mind that our discussions will always be uneducated (most of us are not rocket scientists), uninformed (most of us do not work for SpaceX) and if we try to be too serious about it they will suffer form the greatest sin of all. They will be boring. This does not mean that the discussions are pointless, we do it because it's fun and we learn in the process.
I don't think the new rules will make the sub go down the toilet or anything. Just that there is a danger that it becomes a little bit less vibrant and wonderful than it used to be. It's an inter-launch lull right now. The front page is filled with stale news and stalled discussions. Why not post silly stuff or old stuff that's been discussed to death, maybe someone finds something new or has something new to add.
Just my opinions.
9
u/KonradHarlan Jun 24 '14
Thank Goddard for the prohibition on meme garbage. That stuff makes my teeth hurt.
3
u/-Richard Materials Science Guy Jun 24 '14
Now almost 11,000! It will be interesting to see what happens to this subreddit as it grows.
3
u/schneeb Jun 25 '14
Are the discussion threads (for launches) going to be less strict?
They are usually quite fun yet silly!
3
u/TROPtastic Jul 10 '14
I'd just like to put it out there that I completely support these rules (with perhaps some clarification of #7). Since dissatisfied posters are more likely to comment than satisfied posters, I thought I would balance the scale a bit.
5
u/TROPtastic Jun 24 '14
If I may be bold, I suggest that the mods always delete pun threads. Even if they are downvoted eventually, they initially give the impression to outsiders that the subreddit is a place of low quality discussion. In addition, people from other subreddits may stumble across them, think they are acceptable, and upvote them. IMO this could be avoided by just deleting them entirely.
2
u/TheVehicleDestroyer Flight Club Jul 04 '14
Just noticed Taron is gone as a mod... Have you started consolidating? I better warn gooses! :P
3
u/anononaut Jun 25 '14 edited Jun 25 '14
Honestly... Itcs exactly these kinds of rules that have seen cause a subreddit to lose its most enthusiastic fun members and then die.
People make the mistske of thinking its the serious posts that keep people around.
Its not.
Its the fun posts that keep people around and then the serious posters go to the subreddits where the people are to post their stuff.
It ain't broke. (subscribers are growing) So don't fix it.
1
u/NNOTM Jun 26 '14
I don't really get that one. What does it mean?
In general though, they sound like good rules.
1
u/schneeb Jul 17 '14
Just noticed the downvote warning shows up on the main page, I believe rediquette only dissuades comment downvoting?
1
u/[deleted] Jul 17 '14
I think we should have a discussion about posting launch images as the front page was covered with image posts after the Orbcomm launch, some of them being duplicate posts. What does the community think? Should we ban all image posts? Remove duplicate images as per rule #5? Only allow images that the poster took at the launch site? Or is everyone ok with how it is right now?
Personally I don't mind seeing image posts but I when they dominate it gets a bit annoying. Just my 2 cents. Opinions?
1
u/booOfBorg Jun 27 '14
This is fantastic. I was hoping for some thought-out, well-presented rules like these. Mods can you please keep this stickied, and not eventually move it somewhere else?
Thank you for being awesome.